In the matter of GZW

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

MENTAL HEALTH COURT

CITATION:

In the matter of GZW [2024] QMHC 2

PROCEEDING:

Reference

DELIVERED ON:

26 June 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

14 May 2024, 15 May 2024 and 7 June 2024

JUDGE:

Wilson J

ASSISTING CLINICIANS:

Dr S Harden and
Dr H Till

DETERMINATION:

1.   In relation to charges 11 and 14, there is a substantial dispute of fact and the court may not make a decision about unsoundness of mind.

2.   In relation to charges 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 12 and 13, GZW was not of unsound mind.

3.   GZW is permanently unfit for trial.

4.   GZW is subject to a forensic order (disability) – inpatient category.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – PROCEDURE – FITNESS TO PLEAD OR BE TRIED – DETERMINATION OF ISSUES – where the defendant was charged with 13 offences as a teenager – where the defendant has an intellectual impairment and neurocognitive deficits likely caused by fetal alcohol spectrum disorder – where the defendant is currently remanded in custody – where the parties accept the defendant was not of unsound mind at the time of the alleged offences – where the Crown submits adjustments could be made to the trial process to support the defendant – whether the defendant is fit for trial – whether the unfitness for trial is permanent or temporary

Mental Health Act 2016 (Qld), s 118, s 685

Berg v Director of Public Prosecutions [2016] 2 Qd R 248; [2015] QCA 196
Kesavarajah v The Queen
(1994) 181 CLR 230
Ngatayi v The Queen
(1980) 147 CLR 1
R v Hayles
(2018) 131 SASR 186
R v House
[1986] 2 Qd R 415
R v M
[2002] QCA 464
R v Podola
[1960] 1 QB 325
R v Presser
[1958] VR 45
R v Pritchard
(1836) 7 C & P 303
R v Rivkin
(2004) 59 NSWLR 284
Re T
(2000) 109 A Crim R 559
YE v Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) (Qld) [2019] QCA 247

COUNSEL:

K McArthur for the defendant
S J Hamlyn-Harris for the Chief Psychiatrist
G J Cummings for the Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for the defendant
Office of the Chief Psychiatrist
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)

Background

  1. This is a reference under the Mental Health Act 2016 (Qld) (‘the Act’) brought by the defendant’s legal representatives in relation to GZW born on [redacted].

  2. I was assisted in this matter by Dr Harden and Dr Till.  

  3. The reference relates to 13 offences alleged to have been committed between 21 January 2021 and 9 January 2023 (when GZW would have been a child aged between 15 and 17 years old). 

  4. The alleged offences include armed robbery, robbery and attempted robbery, unlawful use of a motor vehicle and entering dwellings with intent.  

    Summary of offences

  5. Dr Gupta, psychiatrist, interviewed GZW twice; once on 2 May 2023 and again on 19 February 2024. In his addendum report dated 22 April 2024, Dr Gupta helpfully…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the matter of GZW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QMHC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of GZW, the defendant, the court was required to determine whether he was fit to stand trial for 13 offences he was charged with as a teenager. GZW has an intellectual impairment and neurocognitive deficits likely caused by fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, and he is currently remanded in custody. The court needed to decide if GZW was fit for trial, and if his unfitness was permanent or temporary.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether GZW was fit to stand trial, considering his intellectual impairment and neurocognitive deficits. The court was required to apply the criteria established in the seminal Australian case of R v Presser, which sets out the minimum standards an accused must meet to be considered fit for trial. These criteria include the ability to understand the charges, plead to the charge, exercise the right of challenge, understand the nature of the proceedings, follow the course of the proceedings, understand the substantial effect of evidence, and make a defence or answer to the charge.

The court considered the evidence provided by three experts: Dr Zeeman, Dr Perkins, and Dr Gupta. Both Dr Zeeman and Dr Perkins, psychologists, found that GZW was not fit for trial, while Dr Gupta, a psychiatrist, found that GZW was fit for trial after two interviews. The court found that GZW suffered from cognitive deficits and at least a moderate intellectual impairment, but the extent to which this impacted his fitness for trial was finely balanced. Ultimately, the court found that GZW was permanently unfit for trial.

The court's decision was based on the balance of probabilities, and it found that GZW did not meet the minimum Presser standards for fitness to stand trial. The court accepted Dr Zeeman's expert opinion, which was based on her comprehensive assessment of GZW's cognitive abilities, lifespan assessment, mental status examination, clinical history, and verified previous psychological assessments. The court found that GZW's unfitness for trial was permanent, and it made no order as to GZW's fitness for trial.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

He was able to draw a basic, and spatially correct diagram of the court room. Understanding of the substantial effect of evidence GZW had a sound understanding of evidence that could be submitted in court, including:(a)witness statements; (b)police documentation; and (c)media evidence (clothing, photos, videos, fingerprints). He stated a “witness” was “a victim” and then stated, “a person who is dobbing on you”. His responses were confused and naïve. Capacity to make a defence, instruct counsel, inform the court of their version of the facts and decide on what defence they will reply upon and to make their version of the facts known to the court and counsel GZW was not able to identify all relevant information that would be important to discuss with his solicitor when questioned during his interview with Dr Zeeman. He was able to produce an account of the events relating to some but not all charges. Ultimately, Dr Zeeman found that GZW did not meet the minimum Presser standards for fitness. At the hearing, Dr Zeeman gave evidence and maintained her view that GZW is permanently unfit for trial. Dr Zeeman’s testing showed that GZW’s:(a)expressive and receptive language were below the third percentile, which is extremely low; and (b)sentence memory was below the third percentile. Dr Zeeman stated that based on the functional testing, she determined that GZW was actually quite impaired, despite his seemingly intact social façade and knowledge, or at least his ability to recite his charges. She was not able to say with any certainty what the aetiology of GZW’s deficits might be, other than that there is consistent and verified reporting over the lifespan assessment. Dr Zeeman noted GZW was fully engaged in the assessment on the day she saw him so there was no question as to withdrawal or intoxication. She felt that GZW was giving his best effort on the day. Dr Zeeman also noted that GZW had multiple breaks during his assessment with her. Dr Zeeman accepted GZW understands the nature of the charges and can give a personal account of the charges against him. However, Dr Zeeman did not think GZW met the other Presser criteria, such as the ability plead and exercise the right of challenge, understand the nature of proceedings and follow the course of proceedings, understand the substantial effect of the evidence or have the capacity to make a defence and instruct counsel. She had doubts that GZW would be able to understand concepts such as the ability to plead and exercise the right of challenge. Dr Zeeman stated that during her interview with GZW, she broke things down very simply and gave GZW multiple choice questions to test the Presser criteria because she knew GZW’s vocabulary was extremely low. However, even after Dr Zeeman provided low level explanations of court concepts such as oaths, verdicts and juries, GZW was unable to answer Dr Zeeman’s questions which suggested to Dr Zeeman he is not going to be able to retain the explanations of those terms regardless of his level of education.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 118 of the Act sets out the circumstances of when the Mental Health Court decides whether a person is fit for trial:“118 Decision about fitness for trial(1)This section applies if—(a) the Mental Health Court decides the person was not of unsound mind when the offence was allegedly committed; or(b) because of section 117 or 117A, the court may not decide whether the person was of unsound mind when the offence was allegedly committed.(2)The court must decide whether the person is fit for trial.(3)If the court decides the person is unfit for trial, the court must also decide whether the unfitness for trial is permanent.(4)This section does not apply if, under section 117(4), the proceeding against the person for the offence is discontinued.” Pursuant to s 118 (2) of the Act, I am obliged to decide “whether the person is fit for trial”. Section 685 of the Act provides that no party to the proceeding bears the onus of proof of any matter and that the matter must be decided on the balance of probabilities. Although “fit for trial” is not defined in the Act, the criteria to be applied is based on R v Presser (‘Presser’),[1] the seminal Australian case on fitness to plead and be tried. [1][1958] VR 45. In Presser, the trial judge was concerned that the defendant might not be fit for trial and, based on the jury direction of Alderson B in R vPritchard (‘Pritchard’),[2] considered the issue of fitness in this way:“[The test] needs, I think, to be applied in a reasonable and commonsense fashion. And the question, I consider, is whether the accused, because of mental defect, fails to come up to certain minimum standards which he needs to equal before he can be tried without unfairness or injustice to him.He needs, I think, to be able to understand what it is that he is charged with. He needs to be able to plead to the charge and to exercise his right of challenge. He needs to understand generally the nature of the proceeding, namely, that it is an inquiry as to whether he did what he is charged with. He needs to be able to follow the course of the proceedings so as to understand what is going on in court in a general sense, though he need not, of course, understand the purpose of all the various court formalities. He needs to be able to understand, I think, the substantial effect of any evidence that may be given against him; and he needs to be able to make his defence or answer to the charge. Where he has counsel he needs to be able to do this through his counsel by giving any necessary instructions and by letting his counsel know what his version of the facts is and, if necessary, telling the court what it is. He need not, of course, be conversant with court procedure and he need not have the mental capacity to make an able defence; but he must, I think, have sufficient capacity to be able to decide what defence he will rely upon and to make his defence and his version of the facts known to the court and to his counsel, if any.” [3] (emphasis added)[2](1836) 7 C & P 303.[3]R v Presser [1958] VR 45, 48.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As already stated, Dr Till’s view was that if GZW was found unfit for trial, then it should be permanent unfitness. Consideration In relation to this matter, GZW disputes charges 11 and 14. Therefore, in relation to these charges, I find that there is a substantial dispute about whether he committed these offences. I am satisfied that this dispute does not exist only because of GZW’s mental condition. Accordingly, I may not make a decision about whether GZW was of unsound mind when the offences were allegedly committed. In any event, there is no evidence to support that he was of unsound mind in relation to any of the charges. In relation to the remaining offences subject to this reference, I find GZW was not of unsound mind when these offences were allegedly committed. The next issue I must determine is whether GZW is fit for trial. To make such a finding, I must be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that he is fit for trial. Mr Cummings for the Crown frames the issue in this way: “My submission is, it should – as a matter of fairness, once the issue is raised, it needs to be determined. And, your Honour, I’d also steer against the notice of proof, because that can operate danger – unfairly to a person in [GZW]’s circumstances, rather, it should be – well, it’s an open inquiry and once the issue is raised, that would lead – in my submission, logically, to a circumstance where once it’s issued – once the issue’s raised, unless it can be eliminated, then un – fitness hasn’t been – hasn’t been shown.” GZW is a young man and has been subject to cognitive assessments since 2010 which demonstrate a number of developmental disabilities. Dr Zeeman notes the pattern of symptoms and results of current psychometric testing together with his lifespan assessment, mental status examination, clinical history and verified previous psychological assessments appear consistent with the DSM-5 diagnostic criteria for the following: (a)Unspecified Neurocognitive Disorder (FASD related); (b)Intellectual Developmental Disorder (moderate – severe); (c)Specific Learning Disorder (reading, written expression, arithmetic); (d)Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (hyperactive) Severe; and (e)Complex Childhood Trauma (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder). Whilst Dr Gupta disagreed with Dr Perkins and Dr Zeeman about whether GZW is fit for trial, there is consensus between all of the reporting experts that he does suffer from an intellectual impairment. There has been some reference to GZW’s neurocognitive disorder being as a result of FASD. However, as Dr Gupta stated, in relation to the determination of GZW’s fitness for trial, it does not matter whether GZW’s cognitive deficits are as a result of FASD or his alcohol and substance misuse. The undeniable fact is that he suffers from cognitive deficits and has at least a moderate intellectual impairment. The question is how much this impacts on his fitness for trial. This matter is very finely balanced. Dr Perkins and Dr Zeeman, psychologists, have performed cognitive assessments upon GZW and both strongly hold the opinion that he is not fit for trial. Dr Gupta, psychiatrist, did not perform any cognitive assessments, but had two interviews with GZW, where he assessed GZW’s performance in each as being fit for trial. Notably, GZW in the second interview, remembered Dr Gupta from the first interview and understood that Dr Gupta had previously assessed him as fit for trial. Importantly, GZW was able to give Dr Gupta an account for most of the offences including ones he disputed, and ones he did not.