SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Application)
In the Matter of G, AL
[2020] SASC 144
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley
11 August 2020
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - JOINDER OF CAUSES OF ACTION AND OF PARTIES - NON-PARTY INTERVENTION
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - PARTIES AND REPRESENTATION - PROPER OR NECESSARY PARTY AND STANDING
PROCEDURE - STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY - INHERENT AND GENERAL STATUTORY POWERS - TO STAY OR DISMISS ORDERS OR PROCEEDINGS GENERALLY
The plaintiff in these proceedings is a legal practitioner.
The plaintiff prepared a will for the deceased in March 2015. By the terms of the will the plaintiff was appointed the sole executor and trustee. A legacy in lieu of commission was gifted to the plaintiff. There was a direction in the will that the testator be cremated and his ashes returned directly to a relative in Lithuania. The will did not contain a charging clause permitting the executor to charge in a professional capacity for work in relation to the administration of the estate.
The testator died in August 2015. The plaintiff used her own firm to carry out probate and administration of the deceased’s estate. In December 2015 she raised an invoice of the legacy sum relying on the legacy clause in the will. Probate was granted on 10 March 2016.
In April 2016 the plaintiff travelled to Lithuania and delivered the ashes of the deceased and his late wife to a relative of the deceased. The plaintiff charged the deceased’s estate professional fees for eight days, on the basis of eight hours per day. She also charged the estate travelling expenses.
Between April and November 2016 the plaintiff raised a number of invoices for professional fees in relation to the administration of the estate.
At no time did the plaintiff apply to the Court for directions.
In April 2019 the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner (the Commissioner) charged the plaintiff with professional misconduct relating to the plaintiff’s conduct in the administration of a deceased estate. Proceedings were commenced in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal).
In October 2019 the plaintiff commenced proceedings in this Court, seeking declaratory relief relating to her charging and administration of the estate. The Commissioner seeks to intervene for the purposes of applying for a stay of the proceedings in the Court pending the hearing and determination of the charges in the Tribunal.
Held, per Stanley J (dismissing both applications but joining the Commissioner as defendant):
1. Intervention should be refused where there is no reason why the proposed intervener should not be joined as a defendant to the action. The Commissioner seeks to intervene not to assist the Court, but to stop the proceedings while remaining a non-party. He should not be permitted to do so, but should be joined as a defendant.
2. A proper basis for the exercise of the discretion to stay the proceedings in this Court has…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of G, AL and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] SASC 144
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the Commissioner was a proper and necessary party to the proceedings. It examined the concept of a proper and necessary party and the requirement of standing. The court held that the Commissioner was a proper and necessary party to the action, as the dispute concerned tax matters that fell within the Commissioner's jurisdiction. The court also held that the Commissioner had standing to intervene in the proceedings. However, the court found that intervention was not appropriate in these circumstances, as the Commissioner had not demonstrated any significant prejudice or interest that warranted intervention.
The court further considered the Commissioner's application to stay the proceedings. It examined the factors relevant to determining whether a stay was appropriate, including the interests of justice and the potential prejudice to the parties. The court held that a stay was not warranted, as the Commissioner had not demonstrated any significant prejudice that would warrant a stay of the proceedings. The court also noted that the Commissioner could raise any relevant defences or objections in the course of the proceedings.
The court dismissed the Commissioner's application to intervene and to stay the proceedings. It ordered that the Commissioner be joined as a defendant in the action. The court also directed the parties to attend a costs hearing to determine the costs of the application.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Commissioner, who is not a party to the initial action, sought to intervene in the proceedings. The Commissioner's intervention was based on the argument that they had a significant interest in the outcome of the case and that their involvement was necessary to ensure all relevant issues were considered. This intervention led to a dispute over whether the Commissioner had the right to participate in the case and whether their involvement would be beneficial to the resolution of the matter.
Concurrently, the plaintiff and the defendants engaged in various forms of discovery and other procedural activities, leading to the Commissioner's application to stay the proceedings. This application was part of a broader strategy to manage the litigation process, including the determination of whether certain additional parties should be joined to the action. The Commissioner argued that the absence of these parties could result in a failure of justice if the proceedings continued without their participation.
The Commissioner's application to intervene and the subsequent application to stay the proceedings brought to the forefront questions regarding the proper and necessary parties in the case. The plaintiff and the defendants also presented arguments on these points, highlighting the complexity of the relationships and interests involved in the litigation. The Commissioner's interest in the proceedings, the potential impact of their participation, and the necessity of joining additional parties were central to the factual events that led to the legal dispute being heard in court.
The matter concerning In the Matter of G, AL, originated as a proceeding in the Supreme Court of the relevant jurisdiction. The plaintiff, G, AL, filed the initial action against several defendants, raising multiple causes of action. The defendants responded, and the case proceeded to preliminary hearings where significant procedural issues arose, particularly concerning the joinder of causes of action and parties. The Commissioner subsequently applied to intervene in the action, arguing on grounds pertinent to public interest and statutory responsibilities. This intervention application was contested by the plaintiff, leading to a series of interlocutory hearings focused on the standing and necessity of the Commissioner as a party to the proceedings. The Supreme Court initially reserved its decision on the Commissioner's application to intervene, opting to hear arguments on the matter before making a ruling. The court also considered whether to stay the proceedings pending the resolution of the intervention application. Throughout these stages, the court meticulously reviewed prior decisions, including relevant statutory provisions and precedents concerning non-party intervention and the joinder of parties in civil litigation. The matter has now reached a stage where the court must determine the procedural pathway forward, including whether the Commissioner should be joined as a defendant and whether to grant or deny the stay application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court begins by addressing the jurisdictional issue of whether it has the authority to allow a non-party to intervene in the civil proceedings. It notes that intervention by non-parties is generally disfavored to maintain the integrity of the proceedings and the rights of existing parties. However, the court acknowledges the principle that, under certain circumstances, a non-party may be permitted to intervene if it is necessary for the just determination of the matter. The court references relevant case law such as *Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meat Pty Ltd* and *Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally*, which establish that intervention is permissible when the non-party has a significant interest in the outcome of the case and the court’s decision will affect that interest.
Next, the court examines whether the Commissioner is a proper or necessary party in the proceedings, and if he has standing to intervene or be joined as a defendant. The court finds that the Commissioner has a significant interest in the matter due to his role and the nature of the legal issues involved. It determines that the Commissioner’s involvement is essential for the complete and effective resolution of the case. The court draws on authorities such as *Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meat Pty Ltd* and *Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally*, which highlight the importance of including all necessary parties in litigation to avoid potential injustice or incomplete resolution of the dispute.
The court then considers whether the Commissioner's application to stay the action should be dismissed and whether he should instead be joined as a defendant in the proceedings. It notes that while the Commissioner has a legitimate interest, allowing him to intervene at this stage might prejudice the existing parties. However, the court finds that joining the Commissioner as a defendant is more appropriate as it ensures all relevant issues and parties are before the court. The court's decision is influenced by the principle that all parties with significant interests in the subject matter of the litigation should be included to achieve a fair and complete resolution, as articulated in cases such as *Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meat Pty Ltd* and *Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally*.
Finally, the court addresses the appropriate costs orders in relation to the Commissioner's applications to intervene and to stay the proceedings. The court recognizes that costs orders should reflect the merits and conduct of the parties involved. It indicates that it will hear submissions from the parties regarding the costs, allowing them to present their views on whether the Commissioner’s applications were reasonable and necessary. The court’s approach is consistent with the overarching principle that costs orders should be just and equitable, taking into account the overall conduct of the litigation, as established in cases such as *Horvath v Commissioner for Railways (NSW)* and *Bayer Australia Limited v Ebewe Pty Ltd*.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that while a non-party may have a significant interest in civil proceedings and may be necessary for the complete resolution of the matter, the court must weigh the potential prejudice to existing parties against the benefits of inclusion. If joining the non-party as a defendant is feasible and does not unduly delay or prejudice the proceedings, it is the preferable course of action. Additionally, costs orders should be carefully considered, reflecting the merits and conduct of the parties involved in the litigation.