IN THE ESTATE OF TLB

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction: Application)

IN THE ESTATE OF TLB

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Gray

6 December 2005

SUCCESSION - WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION - THE MAKING OF A WILL - EXECUTION - INFORMAL DOCUMENT INTENDED TO BE WILL

Application for an order that a document purporting to express testamentary intentions be admitted to probate - documents comprised a will instruction sheet and a will drafted in accordance with the instructions on the will instruction sheet - deceased committed suicide prior to executing the will - consideration of amendments to the Wills Act 1936 (SA) - consideration of which amendment applicable - consideration of testamentary capacity - application granted - will instruction sheet admitted to probate as the last will of the deceased.

Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 8, s 12(2); Wills Act Amendment Act (No 2) 1975 (SA) s 12(2); Statute Law Revision Act (No 2) 1990 s 12(2); Wills (Miscellaneous) Amendment Act 1994 (SA) s 7; Statutes Amendment (Attorney-General's Portfolio) Act 1998 (SA) s 22; Statutes Amendment and Repeal (Attorney-General's Portfolio) Act 2000 (SA) s 30; Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) s 72G(b), referred to.
In the Estate of McCarney deceased (unreported, S5884, 12 November 1996); Estate of Kolodnicky (1981) 27 SASR 374; Baumanis v Praulin (1980) 25 SASR 423; Estate of Parkinson (1988) 143 LSJS 336; Estate of Vauk (1986) 41 SASR 242; Estate of Krawzuk (1992) 168 LSJS 231; Estate of Templar-Warner (1993) 174 LSJS 263; Estate of Brewer deceased (unreported, S6134, 29 April 1997); Estate of Mead deceased (unreported S6547 13 February 1998); Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549; Re Hodges: Shorter v Hodges (1988) 14 NSWLR 698, considered.

IN THE ESTATE OF TLB
[2005] SASC 459

Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction

GRAY J:

  1. This is an application by summons for an order that a document purporting to express the testamentary intentions of the late T.L.B. be admitted to proof pursuant to section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 (SA).

  2. T.L.B. (“B”) committed suicide by hanging herself at the St Josephs Family Care Centre at Mitchell Park, South Australia.  Her body was found on 12 June 2000. She was last seen alive on 10 June 2000.

  3. At the time of her death, B was 31 years old.  She had two infant children, an eight-year-old daughter and a four-year-old son.  She was married to S.L.M. (“M”).  The two had separated in February 1999 due to M’s sexual interference with their daughter.  In October 1999, M was convicted of this offence.

  4. In May 2000, B commenced divorce proceedings in the Family Court.  Those proceedings were yet to be heard at the date of her death.

  5. At the time of death, B possessed personal estate that is said to not exceed $137,742.00.  Her assets comprised personal effects and a life insurance policy, both held in the State of South Australia.  Her liabilities were said to be limited to funeral expenses totalling $4,565.00.

  6. B’s life insurance policy was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IN THE ESTATE OF TLB and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 459
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case, In the Estate of TLB, involved an application for an order to admit a document, which purported to express testamentary intentions, to probate. The document in question comprised a will instruction sheet and a draft will. The deceased, B, had committed suicide before executing the will. The court was required to decide which version of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) applied to the circumstances and whether B had testamentary capacity at the time of the drafting of the will. The court also had to determine which document should be admitted to probate, the will instruction sheet or the draft will.

The court considered the amendments to the Wills Act 1936 (SA) and concluded that the version of the Act applicable to the present case was the 1998 version. The court found that B had testamentary capacity and had a continuing intention to execute a formal will. The court concluded that the Will Instruction Sheet, which expressed B's testamentary intentions, met the requirements of the relevant version of section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 (SA). The court also found that the draft will, which had not been signed or witnessed by B, did not meet the requirements of the Act.

The court granted the application and admitted the Will Instruction Sheet to probate as the last will of the deceased. The court noted that the Will Instruction Sheet was a clear expression of B's testamentary intentions and that it was in the best interests of her estate and beneficiaries for it to be admitted to probate. The court also noted that there was no evidence that B had knowledge of the draft will at the time of her death.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

B’s life insurance policy was in her married name, T.L.M. The document, the subject of the present application, being a draft will, was prepared in her maiden name, T.L.B. As a result, the applicant seeks a grant in the names T.L.B. otherwise T.L.M.The Evidence A body of documentary evidence has been filed in support of the application. That evidence includes a number of affidavits from V.R.H., the mother of B, an affidavit of A.M.B., the father of B, an affidavit of the administrator of the St Josephs Family Care Centre, an affidavit of Ms Josephson, a solicitor in the employ of D’Angelo Kavanagh, the solicitor for B and an affidavit of Annita Dagmar Paull, a psychiatrist providing a report prepared in regard to B’s mental health. The affidavits attach a number of documents including B’s Will Instruction Sheet and the unsigned “Last Will and Testament” said to have been prepared as a draft for B by Ms Josephson. Additional documentation included a copy of a post-mortem report concerning B, a copy of the remarks of the District Court in regard to the sentencing of M for the conviction of two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with the daughter of B and M. The affidavits also exhibited information from the Family Court proceedings concerning custody and access. I have had regard to this body of evidence in determining this application.The Will Instructions B instructed Ms Josephson of D’Angelo Kavanagh, a firm of solicitors, to act for her in the Family Court proceedings. B had seen Ms Josephson on or about 26 May 2000 for the purpose of giving instructions for her will. B’s mother accompanied her to the appointment. B’s mother recalls the deceased saying to Ms Josephson, “I do need to do a Will so he is not having my money or my kids”. B’s mother understood the reference to “he” to be M. As B’s mother and B left the offices of D’Angelo Kavanagh, B’s mother recalls B stating to her “I’ve taken care of the Will. I want you to look after my money and for the kids to live with you until they leave home. I have said in my Will that all my money and property is to go to the children and you have to make sure that they get it”. B provided Ms Josephson with instructions pertaining to her will. These were noted by Ms Josephson, in hand, on a “Will Instruction Sheet”. According to the Will Instruction Sheet, B’s mother was to be appointed sole executor and “In the alternative” the deceased’s father was to be appointed executor. Under the heading “Directions as to burial/cremation” the word “cremated” has been written. Under the heading “Distribution of residue” appear the words “to children equally at 21”. Under the heading “Giftover Provision” the instruction “To their Children at 21” has been written. The words “Minors Clause” and the heading “Guardianship” follow. Beneath these headings, “to my parents” have been written. Attached, as a schedule to these reasons is a copy of the Will Instruction Sheet.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Paull concluded:I feel very confident that if she had been interrupted as she was in the course of committing suicide and asked whether she hadn’t forgotten something – whether she wanted to sign her will – she would have said something to the effect of “Oh, I forgot that. Yes, I want to sign my will” and ceased her suicide attempt to enable her to sign the will. I have this opinion because of what I came to know about her from spending time with her. I am confident that her prime concern (if her mind had been brought to it) would have been to ensure that [M] did not receive any of her estate and that her children received it all…and that she had done everything she could to protect her children.Conclusion In order for a draft will to be admitted under the relevant 1998 version of section 12(2), it must meet the following requirements:-the death of the testator must have occurred on or between 3 December 1998 and 20 July 2000;-there must be a document, which expresses the testamentary intentions of the deceased person;-the document must not have been executed with the formalities required of the Act; and-the deceased must have intended to make a will or codicil to give effect to the testamentary intentions expressed in that document. In the present case, the first and third of the requirements listed above have been met. With respect to the second requirement, it is clear that B provided Ms Josephson with instructions expressing her testamentary intentions. These instructions were recorded on the Will Instruction Sheet. This document, in existence during B’s lifetime, expressed B’s testamentary intentions and meets the second requirement listed above. It is clear that B did not intend the Will Instruction Sheet to constitute her will. It is evident from B’s instructions to Ms Josephson that B envisaged that her will would be professionally drafted into a formal document in accordance with her intentions recorded on the Will Instruction Sheet. These circumstances indicate a continuing testamentary intention on the part of B to make a formal will to give effect to her intentions as noted on the Will Instruction Sheet. The fact that she took her own life does not negate these intentions or give rise to a presumption of abandonment or change of testamentary intentions. Therefore the fourth requirement of the relevant version of section 12(2) is satisfied. The question then arises: – which document ought to be admitted to probate - the Will Instruction Sheet or the draft will drawn up generally in accordance with those instructions? The summons to admit seeks an order:That a document purporting to express the testamentary intentions of [T.L.B.] be admitted to proof pursuant to Section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936... The affidavit filed in support of the application seeks an order that a document exhibited to the affidavit, the will prepared in accordance with B’s instructions, be admitted to proof. However, this document was neither sighted nor signed by B. There is no evidence that at the time of her death, B had knowledge of its existence. It may not even have been created during her lifetime.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established