Ghan v Ghan

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction: Application)

GHAN v GHAN

[2014] SASC 176

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Gray

18 November 2014

SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - EXECUTION - INFORMAL DOCUMENT INTENDED TO BE WILL - GENERALLY

Application to admit a will in solemn form.  The deceased made a will in 1985, the validity of which was never in dispute.  The deceased also authored a number of letters in 2004 and 2005 which could be considered testamentary in nature.  The parties reached a compromise and agreed that the 1985 will should be admitted in solemn form.  The parties further sought an order pronouncing against the validity of the most recent of the letters, a letter dated 14 October 2005.  A determination of the status of the earlier letters was not pursued.

Whether to admit the 1985 will in solemn form. Whether the letter dated 14 October 2005 satisfies the requirements of section 8 of the Wills Act 1936. Whether, if the letter dated 14 October 2005 does not satisfy the requirements of the Wills Act 1936, it satisfies the requirements of section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936.

Held (allowing the application):

1.  The will duly executed on 11 November 1985 is a valid will and should be admitted in solemn form.

2. The letter dated 14 October 2005 does not satisfy the requirements of section 8 of the Wills Act 1936 as it was only witnessed by one person.

3.  The letter dated 14 October 2005 expresses testamentary intentions as it addresses the distribution of the deceased’s estate in the context of him farewelling his children.

4. The letter dated 14 October 2005 does not satisfy the requirements of section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 as the evidence does not establish that it was intended to be a testamentary document. Rather, it was part of an ongoing dialogue concerning the distribution of the deceased’s estate.

Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 8 and s 12, referred to.
In the Estate of Nora Anella Leber (deceased) [2014] SASC 47; Boettcher v Driscoll and Anor (2014) 119 SASR 523; Fielder v Burgess [2014] SASC 98; In the Estate of William Edward Dodds (deceased) [2013] SASC 56; In the Estate of TLB (2005) 94 SASR 450; In the Estate of Ashley David Schwartzkopff (2006) 94 SASR 465; In the Estate of Graham (Deceased) (1978) 20 SASR 198, considered.

GHAN v GHAN
[2014] SASC 176

Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction

GRAY J.

  1. This is an application for a grant of probate in solemn form. 

    Background

  2. Tjoe Tjoan Ghan, known as Peter Ghan, the deceased, died on 18 July 2008 at his home in St George’s, South Australia.  His wife, Gek Hoen Ghan, predeceased him.  The deceased is survived by his three sons, who are all specialist medical practitioners resident in South Australia: the plaintiff, Francis Djin An Ghan; the first defendant, Stephen Djin Kiat Ghan; and the second defendant, Michael Djin Kiong…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ghan v Ghan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASC 176
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties in Ghan v Ghan were the sons of the late Tjoe Tjoan Ghan, also known as Peter Ghan, who died in 2008. The deceased's will dated 11 November 1985 had been executed in 1985 and appointed his wife, Gek Hoen Ghan, as executor, with Francis Djin An Ghan, one of the sons, as substitute executor. The will provided for the deceased's estate to pass to his wife, and if she predeceased him, to his sons in equal shares. Francis, one of the sons, sought a grant of probate in solemn form for the will. The other two sons, Stephen Djin Kiat Ghan and Michael Djin Kiong Ghan, pleaded that documents dated 14 September 2005 and 14 October 2005 may be codicils to the 1985 will. Francis adopted the position that there were no other testamentary documents. The court was required to determine the validity of the 1985 will and any other testamentary documents, and whether they should be admitted in solemn form. The court found that the 1985 will was valid and should be admitted in solemn form. The court also found that the letter dated 14 October 2005 did not satisfy the requirements of the Wills Act 1936 as it was only witnessed by one person, and that it did not satisfy the requirements of section 12(2) of the Act as the evidence did not establish that it was intended to be a testamentary document. Rather, it was part of an ongoing dialogue concerning the distribution of the deceased's estate. The court pronounced against the force and validity of the letter dated 14 October 2005. The court granted the application for a grant of probate in solemn form for the 1985 will, and rejected the claim that the 14 October 2005 letter was a valid codicil to the will.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held (allowing the application):

1. The will duly executed on 11 November 1985 is a valid will and should be admitted in solemn form.

2. The letter dated 14 October 2005 does not satisfy the requirements of section 8 of the Wills Act 1936 as it was only witnessed by one person.

3. The letter dated 14 October 2005 expresses testamentary intentions as it addresses the distribution of the deceased’s estate in the context of him farewelling his children.

4. The letter dated 14 October 2005 does not satisfy the requirements of section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 as the evidence does not establish that it was intended to be a testamentary document. Rather, it was part of an ongoing dialogue concerning the distribution of the deceased’s estate.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for a grant of probate in solemn form. Background Tjoe Tjoan Ghan, known as Peter Ghan, the deceased, died on 18 July 2008 at his home in St George’s, South Australia. His wife, Gek Hoen Ghan, predeceased him. The deceased is survived by his three sons, who are all specialist medical practitioners resident in South Australia: the plaintiff, Francis Djin An Ghan; the first defendant, Stephen Djin Kiat Ghan; and the second defendant, Michael Djin Kiong Ghan. The deceased made a will dated 11 November 1985. Gek is named executor in the will and Francis is named substitute executor. The will provided that the entirety of the deceased’s estate would pass to his wife. If she predeceased, the estate would pass in equal shares to his sons. On 9 May 2013, Francis filed a summons and statement of claim seeking, inter alia, an order pronouncing the validity of the 1985 will in solemn form. The statement of claim did not refer to any other documents of a testamentary nature. Stephen, by his defence, pleaded that documents dated 14 September 2005 and 14 October 2005 “may” be codicils to the 1985 will. Michael, by his defence, adopted the same position as Francis. In his affidavit sworn on 26 February 2014, Stephen states that the deceased wrote a number of letters to his sons in the years before his death which addressed the distribution of the deceased’s assets. It is unclear whether all of these letters were put before the Court. Stephen further states that the deceased made a number of attempts to discuss the distribution of his assets with his sons. No evidence was led of the contents of these discussions. In his affidavit sworn on 8 May 2014, Francis states that he made enquiries with Playfords Solicitors, who drafted the 1985 will on instructions from the deceased, but they have no records of any further wills executed by the deceased. In his affidavit sworn on 14 April 2014, Francis exhibits copies of four documents that may be considered testamentary in nature. These documents, dated 20 February 2004, 30 March 2005, 14 September 2005 and 14 October 2005, are all letters handwritten by the deceased. The first three letters are written in Indonesian. The most recent letter is written in English. Francis also provided a typed copy of each letter and an English translation of the letters which were written in Indonesian. It is to be understood that I have relied upon the English translations of the letters written in Indonesian. The deceased’s handwriting, as it appears in the copies of the letters provided to the Court, is extremely difficult to comprehend and I have not had the benefit of inspecting the original letters. As far as I can tell, the typed version of the English letter is an accurate reproduction of the copy of the handwritten letter exhibited to Francis’ affidavit. The letter dated 20 February 2004 is addressed to “An, Kiat, Kiong” and sets out the following division of the St George’s property: one sixth share to An, one half share to Kiat and one third share to Kiong. The letter further states that “Mama / Papa do not owe any monies to anyone” and that all bills have been paid as at the date of the letter. The letter does not appear to be signed or witnessed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
In circumstances where the parties have agreed on a compromise in these proceedings, and the 1985 will provides for what is, prima facie, a reasonable distribution of the estate between the parties, pronouncing against the October 2005 letter would not lead to a harsh or unjust outcome. I am also satisfied that all persons with an interest in the estate have been represented.Conclusion I pronounce the force and validity of the last will and testament of Tjoe Tjoan Ghan, known as Peter Ghan, being the will duly executed on 11 November 1985. I pronounce against the force and validity of the letter dated 14 October 2005.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J