Igbinoba v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Igbinoba v Commonwealth of Australia [2023] FedCFamC2G 279

File number(s): SYG 2321 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE BAIRD
Date of judgment: 18 April 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for transfer of proceeding to Federal Court of Australia – application made after first court date – leave granted – relevant considerations – respondent submits matters of general importance under Racial Discrimination legislation and factual complexity – 32 events over 22 years – insufficient grounds for transfer – application dismissed –
application for determination of separate questions on assumed facts – facts to be determined – whether determination of separation questions would be just and convenient – whether circumstances warrant departure from usual course – application dismissed
Legislation:

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s46PO

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) ss 153, 154, 190, 191

Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth) s39

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 32AD

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) ss9, 11, 18C

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 rr 8.02, 18.02, Schedule 2

Federal Court Rules 2011 Part 40

Cases cited:

Baird v Queensland (2006) 156 FCR 451; [2006] FCAFC 162

Chambers v University of Western Australia [2023] FCA 332

City of Swan v Lehman Brothers Australia Limited [2009] FCA 784

Gibbs v Wanganeen (2001) 162 FLR 333; [2001] FMCA 14

Hu v Stansure Strata Pty Ltd and Ord [2014] FCCA 905

Kanapathy v In De Braekt (No 4) [2013] FCCA 1368

Kikoto v University of Sydney [2018] FCCA 699

Self Care Corporation Pty Ltd v Green Forest International Pty Ltd (No 3) [2021] FCCA 1277

Sidhu v Raptis [2012] FMCA 338

Sydney Local Health District v Macquarie International Health Clinic Pty Ltd (2020) 105 NSWLR 325; [2020] NSWCA 274, [187]

Tepko Pty Ltd v Water Board (2001) 206 CLR 1; [2001] HCA 19

Van den Berg v Monash Health [2022] FCA 796

Verge v Devere Holdings Pty Limited [2008] FMCA 1421

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 76
Date of hearing: 28 March 2023
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr C Parkin with Mr J Brook
Solicitor for the Applicant: Blackbay Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms V Bulut
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

SYG 2321 of 2020

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

OKUNGBOWA HUBERT IGBINOBA

Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE BAIRD

DATE OF ORDER:

28 March 2023

THE COURT:

1.DISMISSES the respondent’s application in a proceeding dated 17 November 2022 (the Application).

2.ORDERS that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the Application under Schedule 2, Part 1, Items 3 and 9(c) 10 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021.

3.STANDS OVER the proceeding for further case management at the Court in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Igbinoba v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant in this case, Mr Okungbowa Hubert Igbinoba, a Nigerian man, has brought an action against the Commonwealth of Australia, alleging unlawful discrimination under the Racial Discrimination Act (RDA) by the Australian Border Force (ABF) officers. Mr Igbinoba claims that on 32 occasions between 1998 and 2020, he was unlawfully detained, questioned, and searched by ABF officers upon returning to Australia, based on his race, colour, nationality, or ethnic origin. The Commonwealth denies these allegations and the associated claims of unlawful discrimination.

The legal issues before the court included whether the case raised matters of general importance that would benefit from a Federal Court decision, and whether there were specific questions that would provide useful guidance for future cases. The Commonwealth argued that the case raised significant questions about the interpretation of terms in the RDA and the extent to which certain actions by ABF officers could be considered a nullification or impairment of human rights and fundamental freedoms. The court considered whether the questions raised were of sufficient general importance to warrant transfer to the Federal Court for resolution.

The court found that the matters raised by the Commonwealth did indeed involve issues of general importance and that there was limited judicial guidance on the interpretation of certain terms in the RDA. The court determined that the proceeding could be dealt with more efficiently by the Federal Court and that the final hearing would likely require several days, a duration better suited to the Federal Court’s capacity. Consequently, the court granted leave for the proceeding to be transferred to the Federal Court.

The final orders included the dismissal of the application for interlocutory relief, with costs to be borne by Mr Igbinoba. The case was transferred to the Federal Court for further proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I heard the AinP on 28 March 2023 at the Court in Sydney, with the benefit of written and oral submissions from counsel for both parties and robust exchanges between counsel and the Court. At the conclusion of the hearing, I formed the view that neither of the orders sought should be granted. I dismissed the AinP, with costs, and advised that my reasons would follow shortly. These are my reasons.Procedural background The applicant, Mr Okungbowa Hubert Igbinoba, is a black man of Nigerian descent. He has been stopped or detained, questioned and searched by agents of the Australian Border Force or its predecessors (ABF officers) upon his return to Australia on 32 occasions in the period 1998 to 2020, on the occasion of nearly every international flight on which he has returned to Australia in those 22 years. He sues the Commonwealth for breaches of the RD Act. Mr Igbinoba commenced the proceeding in this Court by originating application filed 7 October 2020 alleging unlawful discrimination under s 46PO of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth). It is not in dispute that the proceeding has progressed slowly. It suffices to state that Mr Igbinoba relies on an Amended Statement of Claim dated 11 July 2022, and that the Commonwealth relies on an Amended Defence to Statement of Claim dated 24 August 2022. Whilst certain particulars have been provided, and Mr Igbinoba’s solicitor has proposed categories of discovery, no application for discovery has been made or consent orders sought, and no timetable for evidence has been set. In short compass, by the Claim Mr Igbinoba alleges that: (a)over the course of between 2 and 4 hours on each of 32 identified occasions between February 1998 and January 2020 at Kingsford Smith Sydney International Airport (the Entries), ABF officers variously detained him, questioned and interrogated him, emptied, searched and inspected his luggage, and confiscated, inspected and searched his laptop and mobile phone, and body searched him (Actions); (b)ABF officers took the Actions by reason of, or for reasons that included, Mr Igbinoba’s race, colour, nationality or ethnic origin (prohibited reason). Mr Igbinoba alleges that the Commonwealth has contravened each of ss 9, 11 and 18C of the RD Act. The Commonwealth denies some of the factual allegations of events between 1998 and 2020, and admits some others, and denies the ABF officers took the Actions by reason of, or for reasons that included, a prohibited reason. It denies the contraventions alleged. Mr Igbinoba sought further and better particulars of the Defence and proposed draft categories for discovery by letter dated 26 August 2022. The Commonwealth responded by letter dated 12 October 2022, providing some particulars and declining to answer requests in respect of two paragraphs of the Claim, stating that it declined to answer ‘on the ground of public interest immunity as to do would be contrary to the public interest’. It did not respond on the matter of discovery (and has not done so to the date of hearing of the AinP). Mr Igbinoba pressed the balance of the request for particulars.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As counsel for Mr Igbinoba emphasises, it is insufficient that there is a likelihood that the case will involve matters of ‘general importance’; the rule requires that there be matters of ‘general importance, such that it would be desirable for there to be a decision of the Federal Court on one or more of the points in issue’. The Commonwealth submits that the matters of general importance raised in the proceeding are those raised by the separate questions (see above at [2]). It says that there is little or limited judicial guidance on the meaning and scope of certain terms it points to in each of ss 9, 11 and 18C of the RD Act, and it is desirable that the Federal Court provide that guidance.As to separate question 1 The Commonwealth submits that separate question 1 will require determination of whether the ABF officers’ alleged conduct – the Actions - which included ‘detaining’ Mr Igbinoba for about 2‑4 hours at a time in what the Commonwealth describes as ‘the customs area of [Sydney] airport’ (that is, what I refer to in these reasons as the customs area)– had ‘the effect of nullifying or impairing Mr Igbinoba’s enjoyment or exercise of any of his human rights and fundamental freedoms’ within the meaning of s 9(1) of the RD Act. It submits this will require consideration of:(a)the meaning of ‘human rights and fundamental freedoms’; and particularly(b)the scope of those rights particularised in the Claim, including ‘the right to … return to one’s country’ and ‘freedom of movement’: per the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), Articles 5(d)(i) and (ii). As to the right of return, the Commonwealth says that it will argue that the above identified delays in clearing customs do not restrict the right to return to one’s country. As to the right of freedom of movement, the Commonwealth observes that it is not an absolute right and may be subject to lawful restrictions. It will argue that the ABF officers’ assumed Actions, which were done in connection with their employment, did not nullify or impair Mr Igbinoba’s enjoyment of the right to freedom of movement. The Commonwealth submits that nonetheless, these are matters on which there is little Australian judicial guidance, and the court may benefit from consideration of international jurisprudence. Consideration of the breadth of these rights and freedoms will also be of general importance. As to separate question 2 The Commonwealth says it will argue that there was no refusal to allow Mr Igbinoba access to the publicly accessible areas outside Sydney Airport because he was allowed access after a delay, and that the terms on which he was allowed that access were the same as a member of the public without his attributes – namely after he had cleared customs and border security. The Commonwealth submits that nonetheless, the issue will require consideration of when a person is ‘refused’ access to an area, and what is meant by the ‘terms’. It submits that there is limited judicial guidance on these issues, and consideration of the meaning of these terms would be of general importance. It accepts that this Court has decided cases on when something is a publicly accessible place (see e.g., Hu v Stansure Strata Pty Ltd and Ord [2014] FCCA 905 at [42]; Kikoto v University of Sydney [2018] FCCA 699), but submits that they do not provide guidance on the issues.As to separate question 3

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In her written submissions, Ms Bulut, counsel for the Commonwealth, acknowledged the necessity for leave, and explained that the interlocutory steps in the proceeding had progressed slowly, with significant work yet to be done before any final hearing. In the AinP, however, the Commonwealth did not expressly seek leave. Notwithstanding that lacuna, and the lack of real explanation for the delay, I considered that it was appropriate to grant leave to bring the AinP, and I informed the parties accordingly.Application for transfer –submissions and consideration The Commonwealth raises 3 reasons for transfer. In short:(a)the proceeding raise several issues of general importance;(b)the proceeding may be dealt with at least as efficiently by the Federal Court, and possibly more so, because (i) it has not been listed for hearing, and on being ready to be listed, either Court would ordinarily assign the matter the first available dates; and (ii) given the case involves factual allegations over 22 years, the final hearing will likely take at least several days, which the Federal Court may have better capacity to hear and determine; and(c)no other factors are so influential as to outweigh these factors for transfer. Mr Igbinoba submits that none of the matters raised by the Commonwealth are sufficient, separately or taken together, to satisfy the Court that it is in the interests of justice that the matter be transferred to the Federal Court.r 8.02(4)(a) General importance As counsel for Mr Igbinoba emphasises, it is insufficient that there is a likelihood that the case will involve matters of ‘general importance’; the rule requires that there be matters of ‘general importance, such that it would be desirable for there to be a decision of the Federal Court on one or more of the points in issue’. The Commonwealth submits that the matters of general importance raised in the proceeding are those raised by the separate questions (see above at [2]). It says that there is little or limited judicial guidance on the meaning and scope of certain terms it points to in each of ss 9, 11 and 18C of the RD Act, and it is desirable that the Federal Court provide that guidance.As to separate question 1 The Commonwealth submits that separate question 1 will require determination of whether the ABF officers’ alleged conduct – the Actions - which included ‘detaining’ Mr Igbinoba for about 2‑4 hours at a time in what the Commonwealth describes as ‘the customs area of [Sydney] airport’ (that is, what I refer to in these reasons as the customs area)– had ‘the effect of nullifying or impairing Mr Igbinoba’s enjoyment or exercise of any of his human rights and fundamental freedoms’ within the meaning of s 9(1) of the RD Act. It submits this will require consideration of:(a)the meaning of ‘human rights and fundamental freedoms’; and particularly(b)the scope of those rights particularised in the Claim, including ‘the right to … return to one’s country’ and ‘freedom of movement’: per the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), Articles 5(d)(i) and (ii).