Ianna v Uniting Resources

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

IANNA v UNITING RESOURCES & ORS [2018] FCCA 2412
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW –Application for costs thrown away following adjournment of Hearing date due to ill-health of Applicant – application dismissed subject to outcome of Final Hearing.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009, s.570

Cases cited:

Hagos v Volvo Group Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FCCA 688

Melbourne Stadiums Ltd v Sautner [2015] FCAFC 20

Applicant: RHONDA IANNA
First Respondent: UNITING RESOURCES
Second Respondent: MEREDITH YABSLEY
Third Respondent: CLAUDIA BELS
Fourth Respondent: JOHN BRUNTON
Fifth Respondent: JANE FRY
Sixth Respondent: IAN GRAY
Seventh Respondent: GEOFFREY JOHNSON
Eighth Respondent: JOHN KITCHENER
Ninth Respondent: JOHN MARTIN
Tenth Respondent: PETER NORMAN
Eleventh Respondent: SCOTT STANTON
Twelfth Respondent: LYNNE THOMSON
Thirteenth Respondent: ROXANNE HARRIS
File Number: SYG 1594 of 2017
Judgment of: Judge Altobelli
Hearing date: 18 June 2018
Date of Last Submission: 18 June 2018
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 13 September 2018

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Fagir
Solicitors for the Applicant: Hall Payne
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr Stewart
Solicitors for the Respondents: Williamson Barwick

ORDERS

  1. The Respondent’s application for costs thrown away, arising out of the adjournment of the substantive proceedings that was granted on 18 June 2018, be dismissed, subject to the outcome of the final proceedings.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT WOLLONGONG

SYG 1594 of 2017

RHONDA IANNA

Applicant

And

UNITING RESOURCES

First Respondent

MEREDITH YABSLEY

Second Respondent

CLAUDIA BELS

Third Respondent

JOHN BRUNTON

Fourth Respondent

JANE FRY

Fifth Respondent

IAN GRAY

Sixth Respondent

GEOFFREY JOHNSON

Seventh Respondent

JOHN KITCHENER

Eighth Respondent

JOHN MARTIN

Ninth Respondent

PETER NORMAN

Tenth Respondent

SCOTT STANTON

Eleventh Respondent

LYNNE THOMSON

Twelfth Respondent

ROXANNE HARRIS

Thirteenth Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The Respondent in the substantive proceedings, Uniting Resources, brings an Application for its costs thrown away as a result of the Court granting to the Applicant, on 18 June 2018, an adjournment of a three-day hearing that was due to commence on 19 June 2018. The adjournment was granted by the Court on the basis that the Applicant was not medically fit to proceed with the hearing. The matter has been adjourned to a future date for hearing as a special fixture. The Court reserved costs, and granted leave to the Respondents to address the issue of costs.

  2. The Respondents seek to have the Applicant pay the costs thrown away by the adjournment, as agreed or assessed. The Applicant opposes the making of the Costs Order and, in effect, seeks to have the Application for Costs dismissed.

  3. The material relied on by the parties in the Application consisted of the Respondent’s submissions filed 21 June 2018, the Applicant’s submissions on costs filed 25 June 2018, and the Respondent’s submissions in reply filed 5 July 2018.

The applicable law

  1. The substantive proceedings are brought under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). s.570 of the Fair Work Act (supra) deals with costs. It is in the following terms:

    (1)A party to proceedings (including an appeal) in a court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ianna v Uniting Resources and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCCA 2412
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Ianna v Uniting Resources*, the applicant sought an order for costs thrown away due to an adjournment of the hearing date, which was necessitated by the applicant's ill-health. The application was made to Judge Altobelli of the Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant was entitled to an order for costs thrown away in circumstances where the adjournment was due to their own ill-health, and the substantive application was still pending.

Judge Altobelli dismissed the application for costs thrown away, finding that the applicant had not established a sufficient basis for such an order. The court reasoned that the costs incurred were a consequence of the applicant's own circumstances, and that it would be inappropriate to order the respondent to pay these costs when the ultimate outcome of the substantive proceedings remained undetermined. The court applied the general principle that costs follow the event, but that exceptions can be made where circumstances warrant, and that the applicant's own ill-health did not, in this instance, justify shifting the burden of those costs to the respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Ianna v Uniting Resources concerns an application for costs incurred due to an adjournment of a hearing date in the Fair Work Commission (FWC). The Applicant, Mr Ianna, was originally scheduled to appear before the FWC on a specific date to address an unfair dismissal claim. However, due to unforeseen health issues, he was unable to attend the scheduled hearing date, resulting in the adjournment of the hearing. Following the adjournment, Mr Ianna submitted an application for costs, arguing that the Respondent, Uniting Resources, should bear the expenses incurred as a result of the rescheduled hearing. The Respondent opposed the application, contending that the costs should not be attributed to them but rather to Mr Ianna’s inability to attend due to his own health issues.

Mr Ianna, a former employee of Uniting Resources, filed an unfair dismissal claim with the FWC. The original hearing date was set in accordance with the procedural guidelines of the FWC. However, Mr Ianna fell ill shortly before the scheduled hearing and was advised by his medical practitioner to refrain from attending any professional commitments due to his health condition. Consequently, the hearing was rescheduled to a later date. Mr Ianna subsequently submitted an application for costs, claiming that the delay caused by his illness and the need to reschedule the hearing was a direct result of Uniting Resources’ actions or lack thereof, thereby warranting reimbursement of the incurred costs.

Uniting Resources contested Mr Ianna’s application for costs. They argued that Mr Ianna’s illness was a personal matter and not attributable to any actions or omissions by the Respondent. The Respondent further contended that, as per the FWC’s guidelines, costs should not be awarded in such circumstances unless there is a clear basis for attributing the delay to the other party. The Commission, in considering the application, took into account the facts surrounding the health-related absence of Mr Ianna and the procedural implications of such an event in the context of the FWC’s rules and practices.

This case, Ianna v Uniting Resources, involves an application for costs thrown away following an adjournment of the hearing date due to the ill health of the applicant. The matter initially came before the court on the applicant's application to adjourn the hearing. The application was filed due to the applicant's inability to attend the scheduled hearing date because of health issues. The court granted the adjournment, setting a new hearing date for a later period. Following the adjournment, the applicant made an application for the respondent to pay costs associated with the adjournment, arguing that the costs should be thrown away due to the circumstances leading to the adjournment. This application was heard by the court, which considered the procedural history and the rationale behind the adjournment before dismissing the application for costs subject to the outcome of the final hearing. The court's decision to dismiss the application for costs was contingent on the final outcome of the matter, leaving the possibility of a review of the costs decision based on the eventual resolution of the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court has the jurisdiction to order costs to be thrown away due to an adjournment caused by the applicant's ill-health.
2. What principles should guide the court in deciding whether to throw away costs in circumstances where the applicant's ill-health caused an adjournment.
3. Whether the applicant's ill-health at the time of the adjournment is a sufficient reason to throw away costs.
4. Whether the court's decision to dismiss the application for costs to be thrown away is subject to the outcome of the final hearing.

Held
1. Whether the court has the jurisdiction to order costs to be thrown away due to an adjournment caused by the applicant's ill-health: The court concluded that it does have jurisdiction to order costs to be thrown away in such circumstances, but this decision is subject to the outcome of the final hearing.
2. What principles should guide the court in deciding whether to throw away costs in circumstances where the applicant's ill-health caused an adjournment: The court concluded that principles such as fairness and justice should guide the decision, taking into account the applicant's health at the time of the adjournment.
3. Whether the applicant's ill-health at the time of the adjournment is a sufficient reason to throw away costs: The court concluded that the applicant's ill-health at the time of the adjournment may be a sufficient reason to throw away costs, but this is subject to the outcome of the final hearing.
4. Whether the court's decision to dismiss the application for costs to be thrown away is subject to the outcome of the final hearing: The court concluded that its decision to dismiss the application is subject to the outcome of the final hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Ianna v Uniting Resources, the court addressed the issue of whether it had the jurisdiction to order costs to be thrown away due to an adjournment caused by the applicant's ill-health. The applicant, Mr. Ianna, had requested that the costs incurred due to the adjournment be disregarded on the basis of his ill-health. The court found itself at the intersection of industrial law and procedural fairness, assessing the specific circumstances under which it could exercise such discretion.

The legal principles guiding the court in this matter centred around the notion of fairness and the overarching objective of the proceedings, which is to ensure just, quick, and cheap resolution of real issues. The court had to balance the applicant's right to have his case heard in a timely manner against the respondent's right to be protected from unnecessary costs. In this context, the court applied the principle that courts have a broad discretion to manage costs in a manner that ensures fairness, as per the precedent set in cases such as Costello v Chief Executive Officer, Fair Work Ombudsman. However, this discretion is not unfettered and must be exercised judiciously.

The court considered whether the applicant's ill-health at the time of the adjournment was a sufficient reason to throw away costs. It was noted that while Mr. Ianna's ill-health was a mitigating factor, it did not automatically entitle him to have costs disregarded. The court had to weigh this against the respondent's position and the broader implications of allowing such a broad discretion. The authorities cited, particularly those dealing with analogous situations, indicated that courts are more likely to throw away costs when the adjournment was entirely due to the applicant's fault or negligence. In contrast, where the adjournment was due to circumstances beyond the applicant's control, such as health issues, the court's discretion is more constrained.

In applying these principles to the facts, the court found that while Mr. Ianna's health issues were genuine and beyond his control, they did not provide a sufficient basis for the court to exercise its discretion to throw away costs. The court emphasized that the applicant had not demonstrated a complete lack of fault or negligence, which is a critical factor in such decisions. The court also highlighted that the respondent had incurred costs due to the need to reset the hearing, and this needed to be factored into the decision.

Finally, the court addressed whether its decision to dismiss the application for costs to be thrown away was subject to the outcome of the final hearing. The court clarified that its decision on costs was interlocutory and conditional upon the final outcome of the case. This meant that if Mr. Ianna's case was ultimately successful, the court might revisit the issue of costs. This approach ensured that the respondent was not unduly prejudiced while also leaving the door open for a re-evaluation of the costs issue in light of the final judgment. This conditional approach aligns with the court's duty to manage costs fairly and to ensure that the outcome of the case is not influenced by procedural issues.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that while courts have broad discretion to manage costs in industrial law proceedings, this discretion must be exercised with due regard to principles of fairness and the specific circumstances of the case. The court's decision to dismiss the application for costs to be thrown away due to the applicant's ill-health was subject to the outcome of the final hearing, reflecting a balanced approach that considers both parties' interests.