FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| HAGOS v VOLVO GROUP AUSTRALIA PTY LTD | [2016] FCCA 688 |
| Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – General protections claim – complaints and inquiries about employment – where employee made complaint about employment and conduct of other employees – whether action taken against employee adverse action – whether adverse action taken for a prescribed reason. |
| Legislation: Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), r.16.05(2)(b), 16.05(2)(c) or 16.05(2)(d) |
| Applicant: | BERHANE HAGOS |
| Respondent: | VOLVO GROUP AUSTRALIA PTY LTD |
| File Number: | BRG 1109 of 2011 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Jarrett |
| Hearing date: | 21-24 May, 10 July 2013 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 26 July 2013 |
| Delivered at: | Brisbane |
| Delivered on: | 1 April 2016 |
REPRESENTATION
| The Applicant appeared in person |
| Counsel for the Respondent: | Mr Saunders |
| Solicitors for the Respondent: | Clinch Long Letherbarrow |
ORDERS
The application filed on 23 August, 2012 be dismissed.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT BRISBANE |
BRG 1109 of 2011
| BERHANE HAGOS |
Applicant
And
| VOLVO GROUP AUSTRALIA PTY LTD |
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Mr Hagos commenced employment with Volvo Group Australia Pty Ltd as an assembler on 25 June, 2010. His employment contract was in writing and, on its face, was for a fixed term of six months. On 10 September, 2010 he left before the completion of his work on that day, never to return to Volvo’s premises for work purposes again.
In these proceedings Mr Hagos claims an injunction, compensation and the imposition of a pecuniary penalty against Volvo because, he alleges, Volvo contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 (C’th) in a number of respects. More particularly, Mr Hagos claims that Volvo took a number of forms of adverse action against him because he exercised his workplace right to make a complaint or an inquiry in relation to his employment.
Volvo opposes the orders sought by Mr Hagos and denies that it has breached the Fair Work Act as Mr Hagos alleges.
The scope of Mr Hagos’ claim was initially larger than it is now. On 29 November, 2012 I ordered that certain parts of Annexure “A” to his Amended Claim (Form 4) filed on 23 August, 2012 be struck out (Hagos v Volvo Group Australia [2013] FMCA 1252). Those parts struck out related to Mr Hagos’ claim that Volvo had taken adverse action against him by terminating his employment. However, I found that because his employment contract was for a fixed term, that claim could not succeed. His employment came to an end because his employment contract expired by effluxion of time.
Mr Hagos is also pursuing his claim in these proceedings on the basis that “the Respondent failed to defend the case against it with due diligence”. This argument relates to certain failures by Volvo or its lawyers to abide by the Court’s directions from time to time.
Some preliminary matters
This application was initially listed for trial commencing on 9 August, 2012. On that day…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hagos v Volvo Group Australia Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] FCCA 688
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Commission was whether Mr Hagos had been unfairly dismissed from his employment with Volvo Group Australia. This required the Commission to consider whether Mr Hagos’s dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, and whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal.
The Commission found that Mr Hagos’s dismissal was not harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. It was satisfied that there was a valid reason for the dismissal, relating to Mr Hagos’s conduct and performance. The Commission noted that Mr Hagos had been provided with opportunities to improve his performance and address the concerns raised by his employer, but had failed to do so. The principles of procedural fairness were also considered and found to have been met.
Consequently, the Commission dismissed Mr Hagos’s application for relief.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr. Hagos' employment with Volvo began on 25 June 2010. He was provided with an Employee Induction Checklist and copies of Volvo’s policies on training and employee leave entitlements. During his employment, Mr. Hagos was trained by Mr. Reinaldo Pina and later by Mr. Stephen Lo in the Mack Piping section of the assembly line. Mr. Pina observed that Mr. Hagos made numerous mistakes in his work, including cutting cables incorrectly and leaving kinks, which posed safety risks.
Mr. Hagos' relationship with Mr. Lo deteriorated, leading to a confrontation on 11 August 2010. Mr. Hagos complained to his team leader, Mr. Terry Sheppard, about Mr. Lo's conduct. Mr. Sheppard reassigned Mr. Hagos to a new mentor and section of the production line. Dissatisfied, Mr. Hagos approached Ms. Jenny Horsey from HR, requesting a transfer, which was subsequently arranged.
In September 2010, Mr. Hagos was involved in incidents where he was issued two defect notices (numbered 86 and 91) for failing to tighten certain nuts and other quality assurance issues. He refused to sign off on these notices and additional training was mandated. On 10 September 2010, Mr. Hagos visited HR to complain about the defect notices, but his complaint was vague and unclear. Despite attempts by HR staff to investigate and understand his concerns, Mr. Hagos refused to cooperate further.
On 13 September 2010, Mr. Hagos did not attend work and sent a letter of complaint to Volvo’s HR Manager, Mr. Jim Georgiades. Mr. Georgiades responded with a letter requesting Mr. Hagos to clarify his complaint. Mr. Hagos did not respond to Mr. Georgiades or to subsequent attempts by Volvo to resolve his concerns. Consequently, Volvo did not renew Mr. Hagos’ contract when it expired on 24 December 2010.
Mr. Hagos’ claims include that Volvo issued improper defect notices against him, failed to properly investigate his complaints, provided incorrect information to WorkCover Queensland, and provided incorrect information to Fair Work Australia. He also claims that Volvo failed to re-engage him after his contract expired.
The court found that while Mr. Hagos made several complaints and inquiries about his employment, Volvo did not take any adverse action against him for those reasons. The defect notices and the requirement for additional training were due to Mr. Hagos’ defective work, not his complaints. Volvo's decision not to renew his contract was based on his demonstrated unreliability and failure to comply with company policies. Therefore, the court dismissed Mr. Hagos' application, concluding that Volvo did not take adverse action against him for the reasons he alleged.
The case of Hagos v Volvo Group Australia Pty Ltd came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia for a full hearing following initial proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court. Initially, Mr. Hagos filed an application for injunction, compensation, and a pecuniary penalty against Volvo Group Australia Pty Ltd, alleging that Volvo contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 in several respects. He claimed that Volvo took adverse action against him due to his exercise of workplace rights to make complaints or inquiries about his employment. Volvo opposed the claims, denying the allegations of contraventions. The Federal Magistrates Court, in an earlier ruling, had dismissed certain parts of Mr. Hagos' claim related to the termination of his employment, finding his fixed-term employment contract had expired by effluxion of time. This appeal pertains to the remaining claims before the Federal Circuit Court, where Mr. Hagos further sought to set aside previous orders and argued that Volvo failed to defend the case diligently. The procedural history includes applications for adjournments, interlocutory orders regarding document production and compliance with court directions, and submissions regarding the conduct of Volvo's legal representatives. The court has considered these procedural matters alongside the substantive claims, ultimately determining that Mr. Hagos' allegations of adverse action by Volvo were not substantiated by the evidence. The court found that the adverse actions taken by Volvo against Mr. Hagos, such as issuing defect notices and not renewing his employment contract, were not due to his complaints or inquiries but rather due to his unsatisfactory work performance and failure to comply with company policies and procedures.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should set aside the cost order of 12 July 2012, which required Mr Hagos to pay Volvo’s costs of the adjournment of the trial on 9 August 2012.
2. Whether the court should set aside the strike out order of 29 November 2012, which struck out certain paragraphs of Mr Hagos’ Amended Claim relating to his claim that Volvo had terminated his employment.
3. Whether Mr Hagos has proved that Volvo took adverse action against him for exercising his workplace rights.
4. Whether the adverse action taken by Volvo against Mr Hagos was for a proscribed reason under the Fair Work Act.
5. Whether Mr Hagos’ employment contract was terminated by Volvo, or whether it expired by effluxion of time.
Held
1. The court dismissed Mr Hagos' application to set aside the cost order of 12 July 2012.
2. The court dismissed Mr Hagos' application to set aside the strike out order of 29 November 2012.
3. The court found that Mr Hagos proved that Volvo took adverse action against him for exercising his workplace rights.
4. The court found that the adverse action taken by Volvo against Mr Hagos was not for a proscribed reason under the Fair Work Act.
5. The court found that Mr Hagos’ employment contract was not terminated by Volvo, but rather it expired by effluxion of time.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Federal Circuit Court dismissed Mr Hagos' application seeking compensation for adverse action taken against him by Volvo. The Court considered several issues, including whether to set aside cost and strike out orders, whether Mr Hagos proved adverse action was taken for proscribed reasons, and whether his employment contract was terminated or expired.
Regarding the cost order, the Court found Mr Hagos failed to demonstrate that Volvo acted deceitfully in obtaining the order. The Court also rejected Mr Hagos' argument that the strike out order was obtained fraudulently, finding no evidence of fraud.
The Court found that while Mr Hagos made complaints and inquiries about his employment, Volvo did not take adverse action against him for those reasons. The Court concluded that the defect notices were issued due to defective work, not Mr Hagos' complaints. Similarly, the refusal to renew Mr Hagos' contract was based on his unreliability and failure to follow policies, not his complaints.
The Court held that even if some adverse action was taken, Volvo proved it was not for proscribed reasons under the Fair Work Act. Mr Hagos' employment contract expired by effluxion of time, not termination.
In summary, the Court dismissed Mr Hagos' application on the basis that he failed to prove Volvo took adverse action against him for exercising his workplace rights, or that any adverse action was taken for proscribed reasons. The Court found Volvo did not breach the Fair Work Act in relation to Mr Hagos' employment.