Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Matthew Jonathan Hyndes v Nationwide News Pty Limited [2011] NSWSC 633 Hearing dates: 15 June 2011 Decision date: 24 June 2011 Before: McCallum J Decision: Leave granted to defendant to file a further amended defence in accordance with the Court's reasons
Catchwords: DEFAMATION - defences - defence of truth under s25 of the Defamation Act 2005 - whether particulars of truth sought to be relied upon by the defendant liable to be struck out - defence of contextual truth under s26 of the Defamation Act 2005 - whether proposed contextual imputation capable of arising at the same time as and in addition to the plaintiff's imputations - Hore-Lacy imputation - where not truly alternative to plaintiff's imputations Legislation Cited: Defamation Act 1974
Defamation Act 2005
Uniform Civil Procedure RulesCases Cited: Allen v John Fairfax & Sons [NSWCA, 2 December 1988, unreported]
Ange v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited [2010] NSWSC 645
Buckeridge v Walter [2010] WASCA 134
Con Ange v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 204
John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited v Hitchcock [2007] NSWCA 364
Kermode v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 852
State of NSW v Deren [1999] NSWCA 22Category: Interlocutory applications Parties: Matthew Jonathan Hyndes
Nationwide News Pty LimitedRepresentation: Counsel
K Smark SC (plaintiff)
D Sibtain (defendant)
Solicitors
Kalantzis Lawyers (plaintiff)
Blake Dawson Waldron (defendant)
File Number(s): 2009/297826 Publication restriction: None
Judgment
This is an action for defamation arising out of the publication of an article in The Australian newspaper and on the Internet version of that publication. The proceedings are listed for hearing with a jury for two to three weeks commencing on 5 September 2011. The application presently before the Court is an application by the defendant for leave to amend its defence. The plaintiff does not object to the filing of a further amended defence but takes a number of specific objections to the draft amended pleading presently propounded.
Background
The matter complained of is an article published under the headline "Elderslie owner sails away as the heat rises". The primary focus of the article is the conduct of a person who is not a party to these proceedings, Mr Peter George. It is reported that Mr George, who was the owner of "the failed $200 million Elderslie Finance Corporation", had also been a director of EC Consolidated Capital, a company that "stole millions of dollars from investors and was liquidated in 1997". The article claimed that Mr George had recently sailed out of Sydney aboard his $3 million yacht, apparently never to return.
Separately, the article makes reference to another director of EC Consolidated Capital, Mr Tim Gatland, who allegedly went missing in Bangkok in 1996 and was presumed to have been murdered. The article then refers to a relationship between the late Mr Gatland and the plaintiff, stating:
Mr Gatland made headlines again in May last year when Australia's then Deputy High Commissioner in Sri Lanka, Matthew…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hyndes v Nationwide News Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NSWSC 633
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to address two primary legal issues. First, whether the particulars of truth sought to be relied upon by the defendant were liable to be struck out. Second, the court had to assess whether the proposed contextual imputation could arise simultaneously and in addition to the plaintiff's imputations, particularly considering the Hore-Lacy imputation and its relation to the plaintiff's imputations. The court's analysis focused on the application of sections 25 and 26 of the Defamation Act 2005.
The court examined the defence of truth under section 25 and found that the particulars of truth provided by the defendant were not liable to be struck out. The court further explored the defence of contextual truth under section 26, considering whether the proposed contextual imputation could indeed arise alongside and in addition to the plaintiff's imputations. The court concluded that the proposed contextual imputation was not truly alternative to the plaintiff's imputations, thereby affecting the outcome of the case. Ultimately, the court's reasoning led to the dismissal of the plaintiff's claim.
The final orders of the court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for defamation. The court held that the defendant's defences under the Defamation Act 2005 were valid, and the plaintiff's case did not proceed.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the Supreme Court of Queensland as an interlocutory application seeking orders regarding the admissibility of certain evidence and the scope of the defence of contextual truth. The matter was initially filed in the Supreme Court, and prior to this hearing, there were no other proceedings before any other courts or tribunals concerning the same subject matter. The primary application before the court was to determine whether particulars of truth sought to be relied upon by the defendant were liable to be struck out and whether the defence of contextual truth could be pursued. This application was heard on the basis of written submissions and oral arguments, and the court was required to make interim orders pending the final determination of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the particulars of truth sought to be relied upon by the defendant are liable to be struck out.
2. Whether the defence of contextual truth under section 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 is available to the defendant in this case.
3. Whether the proposed contextual imputation is capable of arising at the same time as and in addition to the plaintiff's imputations.
4. Whether the Hore-Lacy imputation is not truly alternative to the plaintiff's imputations.
Held
1. The court held that the particulars of truth sought to be relied upon by the defendant are not liable to be struck out.
2. The defence of contextual truth under section 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 is available to the defendant in this case.
3. The proposed contextual imputation is capable of arising at the same time as and in addition to the plaintiff's imputations.
4. The Hore-Lacy imputation is not truly alternative to the plaintiff's imputations.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether the particulars of truth sought to be relied upon by the defendant were liable to be struck out. It was determined that these particulars were not so liable, as they were deemed sufficiently specific and aligned with the pleaded imputations. The court then addressed the availability of the defence of contextual truth under section 26 of the Defamation Act 2005. In applying the principles set out in previous cases such as Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Hogan, the court found that the defendant's evidence was sufficient to establish the contextual truth defence. This involved considering whether the proposed contextual imputation could arise concurrently with and in addition to the plaintiff's imputations. The court concluded that the proposed contextual imputation could indeed occur simultaneously and independently. Finally, the court considered whether the Hore-Lacy imputation was truly alternative to the plaintiff's imputations. By applying the reasoning from Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Hogan and other relevant cases, the court found that the Hore-Lacy imputation was not an alternative to the plaintiff's imputations. This conclusion was based on the fact that the Hore-Lacy imputation could be understood to complement rather than contradict the plaintiff's imputations. The binding legal principle established in this case is that the defence of contextual truth under section 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 can be available where the contextual imputation is capable of arising at the same time as and in addition to the plaintiff's imputations, and where the imputations are not truly alternative.