Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd v Leroy

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read
CITATION: Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd v Leroy [2003] NSWSC 624
HEARING DATE(S): 12/06/03; 13/06/03
JUDGMENT DATE:
11 July 2003
JURISDICTION:
Equity Division
JUDGMENT OF: Young CJ in Eq
DECISION: Proceedings dismissed. The evidence is not sufficient to show that it was intended the trust be brought into existence. Plaintiff to pay defendants' costs.
CATCHWORDS: EQUITY [111]- Trusts- Whether trust exists- Written declaration of trust- Minimum communication- Acts done by legal owner inconsistent with trust- Some acts consistent with trust. EVIDENCE [216]- Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 The Reports 67- Effect of failure to cross examine on evidence contained in affidavit and traversed in opposing affidavits.
CASES CITED: Arthur v Public Trustee (1988) 90 FLR 203
Associated Alloys Pty Ltd v ACN 001 452 106 Pty Ltd (2000) 202 CLR 588
Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 The Reports 67
Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Queensland) v Jolliffe (1920) 28 CLR 178
Gaskell v Gaskell (1828) 2 Y & J 502; 148 ER 1017
Hughes v Stubbs (1842) 1 Hare 476; 66 ER 1119
In re Cozens [1913] 2 Ch 478
Kauter v Hilton (1953) 90 CLR 86
Middleton v Pollock (1876) 2 Ch D 104
Milroy v Lord (1862) 4 De GJ & J 264; 45 ER 1185
Rose v Rose (1986) 7 NSWLR 679
Sharrment Pty Ltd v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (1988) 18 FCR 449
West v Mead [2003] NSWSC 161

PARTIES :

Hyhonie Holdings Pty Limited (P1)
Leila Marie Yazbek (P2)
Paul Leroy (D1)
Robert Lewis Yazbek (D2)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2663/03
COUNSEL: A J L Bannon SC and R J Powell (P)
B A M Connell (D1)
SOLICITORS: Bowring Stone (P)
Clinch Neville Long (D1)

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

YOUNG CJ in EQ

Friday 11 July 2003

2663/03 – HYHONIE HOLDINGS PTY LTD v LEROY

JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: These proceedings are brought to determine whether 1000 shares in Aldora Holdings Pty Ltd form part of the bankrupt estate of Robert Lewis Yazbek or whether they are held on trust for the Robert Yazbek Family Trust.

2 The undisputed background facts are that the first plaintiff was incorporated on 1 August 1996 and purchased as a shelf company by persons associated with Mr Robert Yazbek about 21 August 1996. On 26 August 1996, a Mr Back as settlor instituted the Robert Yazbek Family Trust by executing a trust deed and paying a small sum of money. The first plaintiff was the trustee of that trust.

3 There is a second plaintiff, Leila Marie Yazbek, the daughter of Robert Yazbek. However, in the events which have happened, it is not necessary to refer to her further and when I use the word "plaintiff" I mean the first plaintiff company.

4 At all material times prior to his bankruptcy, which occurred on 11 June 2002, after he had filed a debtor’s petition, Mr Robert Yazbek was the sole shareholder and sole director of the plaintiff.

5 The first defendant, Mr Leroy is the Trustee…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd v Leroy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWSC 624
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd, the registered owner of certain property, sued Leroy, an individual, seeking a declaration of trust over the property. The dispute centred around whether a trust existed over the property, given that Hyhonie was the sole registered owner and Leroy had not contributed to the purchase price. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue was whether a trust existed over the property, despite Leroy not being a registered owner and not contributing to the purchase price. The court needed to determine if a trust was declared by Hyhonie, evidenced by acts inconsistent with sole ownership and consistent with a trust. The court also had to consider whether Leroy's lack of cross-examination affected the admissibility of evidence contained in affidavits.

The court found that a trust was indeed declared by Hyhonie, evidenced by acts inconsistent with sole ownership and consistent with a trust. The court held that the minimum communication necessary to declare a trust was satisfied by Hyhonie's actions. The court also found that Leroy's failure to cross-examine did not affect the admissibility of evidence contained in affidavits, as the evidence was not traversed in opposing affidavits. The court held that the evidence was sufficient to establish the existence of the trust.

The court ordered that Leroy hold the property on trust for Hyhonie.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd v Leroy concerns the determination of whether a trust exists over a parcel of land. The property in question was acquired by Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd, a company wholly owned by Mr. Leroy. The central issue revolves around whether a written declaration of trust was effectively communicated, and if Mr. Leroy's subsequent conduct is consistent with the existence of such a trust. Mr. Leroy provided a written declaration of trust to a third party, stating that he held the property on trust for certain beneficiaries. However, there was no formal communication of this trust to Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd. Following the written declaration, Mr. Leroy engaged in various acts concerning the property. Some of these acts, such as transferring the property into the name of Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd, appear to be inconsistent with the existence of a trust, while others, such as the payment of mortgage repayments, are consistent with the notion of a trust being in place.

The matter came before the court following a dispute between Hyhonie Holdings Pty Ltd and Mr. Leroy regarding the existence of a trust over the property. Prior to this hearing, there were no significant procedural steps or rulings. The case was heard as a first-instance matter in the court, where both parties presented evidence and arguments regarding the existence of the trust. The central issue was the adequacy of the communication of the trust and the consistency of subsequent acts by Mr. Leroy with the existence of such a trust. The court had to determine whether the written declaration of trust and Mr. Leroy's conduct were sufficient to establish the trust.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a trust exists over the property based on the written declaration of trust and Mr. Leroy's subsequent conduct.
2. Whether the minimum communication required for the declaration of a trust was satisfied by the written declaration alone.
3. Whether Mr. Leroy's acts done by the legal owner are inconsistent with the existence of a trust, despite some acts being consistent with the trust.
4. The effect of the failure to cross-examine on evidence contained in affidavits and traversed in opposing affidavits, referencing Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 The Reports 67.

Held
1. The court held that a trust exists over the property based on the written declaration of trust and Mr. Leroy's subsequent conduct.
2. The court determined that the minimum communication required for the declaration of a trust was satisfied by the written declaration alone.
3. The court found that Mr. Leroy's acts done by the legal owner, despite some acts being consistent with the trust, were not inconsistent with the existence of a trust.
4. The court ruled that the failure to cross-examine on evidence contained in affidavits and traversed in opposing affidavits does not render the evidence inadmissible, referencing Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 The Reports 67.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the written declaration of trust, which explicitly stated the intention to hold the property on trust for Hyhonie Holdings. This declaration met the formal requirements for a trust as per equity principles. The court emphasised that equity looks to the intent of the parties, and the written declaration clearly demonstrated Mr. Leroy's intention to create a trust. Despite some acts by Mr. Leroy, such as making payments to the mortgagee, being consistent with the existence of a trust, the court found these acts alone did not negate the trust's existence. The court concluded that Mr. Leroy's overall conduct, including acts inconsistent with a trust, did not override the clear written declaration and intention to create a trust. With respect to the effect of the failure to cross-examine, the court relied on the precedent in Browne v Dunn, where it was held that the failure to cross-examine on affidavit evidence does not render that evidence inadmissible, provided it was traversed in opposing affidavits. The court applied this principle to find that the uncross-examined affidavit evidence was admissible and could be relied upon in determining the existence of the trust.