Hydra Pty Ltd v Holmes and Holmes No. Scciv-01-1225

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

HYDRA PTY LTD v HOLMES & HOLMES

[2002] SASC 14

Full Court: Doyle CJ, Martin and Besanko JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ           I would dismiss the appeal against the decision of the District Court.  I agree with the reasons given by Besanko J.  There is nothing that I wish to add to those reasons.

  2. MARTIN J            I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by Besanko J.

  3. BESANKO J         This is an appeal from a decision of a District Court Judge dismissing the plaintiff’s claim for declarations against the first and second defendants.

    Introduction

  4. The plaintiff (“Hydra”) is a company which operates a private water supply scheme at Craigmore and One Tree Hill in the State of South Australia.  The first and second defendants, Mr and Mrs Holmes, are the owners of an allotment at Craigmore.  The owners of the allotment were participants in the scheme and users of water under the scheme at the time it was established.  Under an agreement called a Memorandum of Lease, Hydra as lessee has certain rights over part of the allotment.  Although I do not think the Memorandum of Lease confers a leasehold interest on Hydra, it is convenient, subject to one exception, to continue to use the terminology of the Lease.  The one exception is that I will refer to that part of the allotment which is the subject of the Lease as “the leased area” rather than “the demised premises”.

  5. Although Mr and Mrs Holmes have withdrawn from the scheme, their allotment remains subject to the Lease.

  6. In the action, Hydra sought declarations as to its rights under the Lease.  By the end of the trial, Hydra’s claim for relief had been narrowed down to the following two declarations.

    “A declaration that the plaintiff is entitled pursuant to Registered Lease  number 8091944 to use the land the subject thereof at any time without notice to access the bore on the land of the seventh and eighth defendants.

    A declaration that pursuant to clause 14 of the Lease the plaintiff is entitled to construct a gate or gates to provide direct access to the leased land from Kelly Road.”

  7. With respect to the first declaration sought, it became clear at trial that Hydra was seeking access to a pump as well as a bore on the land of the seventh and eighth defendants, Mr and Mrs Rowe.  There is no prejudice to Mr and Mrs Holmes in treating the reference in the declaration to the bore as including a reference to the pump.

  8. Mr and Mrs Holmes lodged a counter claim whereby they in turn claimed certain declarations against Hydra.  The Judge dismissed their counter claim.  There is no cross appeal against that decision.

  9. Hydra’s action sought declaratory relief against six other defendants.  Prior to trial it settled its claim against the seventh and eighth defendants, Mr and Mrs Rowe.

  10. At the commencement of the trial, Hydra, through its counsel, indicated that it was not proceeding at that stage against…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hydra Pty Ltd v Holmes and Holmes No. Scciv-01-1225 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hydra Pty Ltd v Holmes and Holmes, Hydra, a private company, sought to enforce certain rights under a lease agreement against Mr and Mrs Holmes, the owners of a property at Craigmore. The dispute centred around Hydra's rights to access the Holmes' land to maintain and operate a water supply scheme established by a previous owner, Yelki Pty Ltd. The matter was initially heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia, and Hydra appealed the decision to a higher court.

The primary legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of the lease agreement, specifically clauses 5 and 14, and whether Hydra had the right to construct gates or access the bore and pump on the adjacent property owned by Mr and Mrs Rowe. Hydra contended that the lease granted them an express right to construct gates and access the Rowe property to maintain the water supply scheme. The Holmes argued that the lease did not confer such rights and that Hydra's claims were without merit.

The court found that the lease did not explicitly grant Hydra the right to construct gates or access the bore and pump on the Rowe property. The court noted that the lease's language was clear and unambiguous, and that there was no ambiguity that would warrant considering extrinsic evidence to interpret the contract. Furthermore, the court held that the limited use of the leased area did not support Hydra's claim that a permanent gate was incidental to or necessary for the purposes identified in the lease. The court concluded that Hydra's appeal should be dismissed, and that the declaration sought by Hydra should be refused.

The court's decision highlights the importance of clear and precise language in lease agreements and the need for parties to carefully consider their rights and obligations before entering into such agreements. The court's refusal to consider extrinsic evidence to interpret the lease underscores the principle that a contract's meaning should be determined by its language, unless there is some ambiguity that requires clarification.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At the commencement of the trial, Hydra, through its counsel, indicated that it was not proceeding at that stage against the third, fourth, fifth and sixth defendants. The orders made by the Judge suggest that Hydra’s action against those defendants was, in effect, adjourned.The Facts The Judge made detailed findings of fact. On the appeal, only one finding of fact was challenged by Hydra. That finding concerned whether Hydra now requires access over the land of Mr and Mrs Holmes in order to gain access to the bore and pump. For reasons which I will give, a finding as to what is now required as distinct from what was required at the time the scheme was established is irrelevant. In the 1980’s a company called Yelki Pty Ltd (“Yelki”) owned certain land at Craigmore and One Tree Hill. It subdivided that land thereby creating a number of allotments. It is convenient at this point to describe the location of some of the allotments in relation to various public roads in the area, and in relation to one another. Allotment 9 is owned by Mr and Mrs Rowe. The northern boundary of allotment 9 abuts Yorktown Road. The western boundary abuts Kelly Road and the eastern boundary abuts an ETSA easement. The southern boundary of allotment 9 is the northern boundary of allotment 7. There is a fence along the southern boundary of allotment 9. Allotment 7 is owned by Mr and Mrs Holmes. The western boundary of allotment 7 abuts Kelly Road, and, because of the unusual configuration of the allotment to the south (allotment 5), part of allotment 5. The eastern boundary of allotment 7 abuts the ETSA easement referred to earlier. The previous owners, and the owners at the time allotment 7 was created and the water supply scheme was established, were Mr and Mrs Lambert. Mr Holmes gave evidence at trial as to the circumstances surrounding his purchase of allotment 7. He said that he was not aware of the “lease factor basically until probably the day of settlement”. Although the Judge made certain comments about Mr Holmes’ knowledge of the Lease at the time he and his wife purchased allotment 7, as I read his reasons, they played no part in his decision. Nor did they assume any significance on the appeal. Mr and Mrs Holmes did not suggest either before this Court or below that they were not bound by the obligations contained in the Lease, although they did argue that the Lease did not in fact confer a leasehold interest on Hydra. Allotment 6 is owned by Mr and Mrs Trimboli. The Court was told that Mr Trimboli has recently died. Allotment 6 is immediately to the east of the ETSA easement which abuts the eastern boundaries of allotments 9 and 7 respectively. Yelki decided to establish a private water supply scheme to supply water to a number of allotments created by the subdivision including allotments 9, 7 and 6. The water to be supplied was water suitable for stock drinking and some level of garden supply. There was no clear evidence as to whether all aspects of the scheme as it was actually implemented were contemplated by the parties right from the outset. The Judge made a finding which seems to support the conclusion that they were, although the matter is not entirely clear. As will become apparent, I do not think that it assists Hydra even assuming all aspects of the scheme as implemented were contemplated by the parties right from the outset.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ (dissent) MARTIN J (dissent) BESANKO J
I agree with the Judge’s conclusion that this declaration should be refused. There is no express right to construct gates. Should the words, “other works as the Lessee may think incidental to or necessary for” the purposes identified in clause 14 be read as including a right to construct permanent gates? In my opinion, the answer to this question is no. First, clause 15 envisages that Hydra may have to pass over other parts of allotment 7 to gain access to the leased area. In other words, it may not have direct access to the leased area. Secondly, the very limited use to which the leased area may be put by Hydra does not suggest to me that a permanent gate is incidental to, or necessary for, the purposes identified in clause 14.Conclusion In my opinion the appeal should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO J

On the appeal, Hydra took a different tack and argued that it was entitled to construct a gate at the western end of the leased area irrespective of whether it was entitled to use the leased area to gain access to the bore and pump on Mr and Mrs Rowe’s land.The First Declaration I think that it is common ground that there is an error in the use of the word “provisions” in clause 5 and that it should read “provision”. Hydra argues that the Court should construe the phrase “for the purposes of provision of pipes for the supply of water” as if it in fact read “for the purpose of the provision of pipes and for the purpose of the supply of water”. It argues that the Court should have regard to the commercial purpose or object of the scheme which, of course, is and was the supply of water to various allotments. It argues that without access to the bore and pump on Mr and Mrs Rowe’s land that purpose or object could not be achieved. Hydra argued that insofar as the Court was minded to look at the Rowe Lease and the Trimboli Lease, the provisions of those Leases support its argument. Clause 5 of the Rowe Lease and of the Trimboli Lease is in identical terms to clause 5 of the subject Lease. There is a bore and pump on Mr and Mrs Rowe’s land and an elevated tank on Mr and Mrs Trimboli’s land. Those uses would not be authorised if a narrow reading of clause 5 was adopted. I do not accept these arguments. First, I think that subject to what I have said about the word “provisions”, the meaning of clause 5 is clear. The authorised uses are the provision of pipes for the supply of water and any other use to which Mr and Mrs Holmes consent in writing. I do not think there is any ambiguity of meaning in clause 5, and in my opinion the argument of Hydra effectively asks the Court to re-write the clause. In construing a contract, a Court may sometimes have regard to extrinsic evidence such as what have been referred to as “surrounding circumstances”. These surrounding circumstances may reveal quite clearly the commercial purpose or object of the contract. As I do not think that the Lease confers a leasehold interest on Hydra, there is no need to consider whether the principles which apply in the case of a contract also apply in the case of agreements which include a demise.[3][3] See Shevill v Builders’ Licensing Board (1982) 149 CLR 620; Progressive Mailing House Pty Ltd v Tabali Pty Ltd (1985) 157 CLR 17 As I understand the authorities, before regard may be had to surrounding circumstances, there must be at least some ambiguity in the language used. In Wickman Tools v Schuler A.G.[4], Lord Wilberforce said,“There are of course exceptions, I attempt no exhaustive list of them. In the case of ancient documents, contemporaneous or subsequent action may be adduced in order to explain words whose contemporary meaning may have become obscure. And evidence may be admitted of surrounding circumstances or in order to explain technical expressions or to identify the subject matter of an agreement: or (an overlapping exception), to resolve a latent ambiguity. But ambiguity in this context is not to be equated with difficulty of construction, even difficulty to a point where judicial opinion as to meaning has differed. This is, I venture to think, elementary law. On this test there is certainly no ambiguity here”.[4] [1974] A.C. 235 at 261