Hurstville City Council v Renaldo Plus 3 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Hurstville City Council v Renaldo Plus 3 Pty Ltd [2006]  NSWCA 248

FILE NUMBER(S):
40912/05

HEARING DATE(S):               15 August 2006

DECISION DATE:     08/09/2006

PARTIES:
Hurstville City Council
Renaldo Plus 3 Pty Ltd

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Hodgson JA Tobias JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Land & Environment Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          L&E 11591/04

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Pain J

COUNSEL:
A: T.F. Robertson SC
R: I. Hemmings

SOLICITORS:
A: Deacons, Sydney
R: Heidtman & Co, Sydney

CATCHWORDS:
LOCAL GOVERNMENT – building control – development consent – impact of development – consent refused by Council but allowed by Land and Environment Court – powers of Land and Environment Court – construction of orders – whether consent final – whether proper account was taken of impact of development

LEGISLATION CITED:
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
Hurstville Local Environmental Plan 1994
Land and Environment Court Act 1979
Land and Environment Court Rules 1996

DECISION:
(a) Grant leave to appeal upon condition that a notice of appeal containing the grounds of appeal argued on the appeal be filed within seven days of the date of these orders
(b)  Appeal dismissed
(c) The appellant to pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40912/05
L&E 11591/04

MASON P
HODGSON JA
TOBIAS JA

Friday 8 September 2006

HURSTVILLE CITY COUNCIL v RENALDO PLUS 3 PTY LTD

Facts:

The opponent sought permission to commence a mixed commercial, retail and residential development upon premises in Oatley. The claimant refused the development application and the matter was appealed to a Commissioner of the Land and Environment Court, who granted development consent subject to a number of conditions. The claimant again appealed to a judge of the Land and Environment Court, who dismissed the appeal.

The claimant sought leave to appeal against that decision on the basis of two primary grounds of appeal. First, the claimant argued that the Commissioner failed to take proper account of the impact the proposed development would have on the character of the area. Second, the claimant submitted that the Commissioner had failed to resolve some outstanding issues before granting development consent, which related to the Operations Management Plan with respect to a loading dock that was to be brought into existence. It was therefore contended that the consent lacked finality and certainty.

Held, granting leave to appeal and dismissing the appeal with costs:

Per Tobias JA (Mason P and Hodgson JA agreeing)

1. In considering the impact of the proposed development on the character of the area, the Commissioner was required to determine whether the development was consistent with the objectives of the zone in which the area was located, and to examine the impacts of the development in relation to the surrounding locality: [81].

2. In this case, although the residents of Oatley had raised a number of complaints about the impact of the development on the character of the area, all of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hurstville City Council v Renaldo Plus 3 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWCA 248
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hurstville City Council appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a decision of the Land and Environment Court that allowed a development application for a supermarket, café, offices, and residences. The Council contended that the Land and Environment Court had erred in its construction of its orders and had failed to properly consider the impact of the proposed development, particularly concerning a loading dock.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the development consent granted by the Land and Environment Court was final, and whether the court had adequately taken into account the amenity impacts of the proposed development, specifically in relation to the operation of the supermarket's loading dock. The Council also questioned the finality of the orders made by the Commissioner, which included liberty to restore with notice if an amended Operations Management Plan was not agreed upon.

The Court of Appeal considered that the Commissioner's orders, which allowed for the restoration of the matter if an agreement on the Operations Management Plan was not reached, did not render the consent non-final. The court noted that management plans are a recognised concept in environmental law and can be critical to the approval of development applications. The Commissioner had found that the proposed development, including the supermarket and its loading dock, would operate acceptably if managed in accordance with the Operations Management Plan, subject to certain amendments. The court found that the Commissioner had properly considered the expert evidence regarding the loading dock and the proposed management plan, and that the amendments made to the plan addressed the Council's concerns about amenity impacts.

The Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal but ultimately dismissed the appeal, ordering the appellant (Hurstville City Council) to pay the respondent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

(a) Grant leave to appeal upon condition that a notice of appeal containing the grounds of appeal argued on the appeal be filed within seven days of the date of these orders; (b) Appeal dismissed; (c) The appellant to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal

Background

Background to the litigation

In the present case the substantive appeal was heard concurrently with the application for leave. As I am of the opinion that leave to appeal should be granted, I shall hereafter refer to the opponent as the respondent.The background facts The site has an area of 2084 m² with a frontage to Mulga Road of 69.677 m and a depth of 40.235 m. The existing development on the site consists of four single dwelling houses and ancillary structures. The proposed development, in the form approved by the Commissioner, comprises two basement levels of car parking off Mulga Road at the eastern end of the site, a large supermarket to be operated by Coles with a gross floor area of 1890 m², a café located on the mezzanine level fronting Mulga Road with an area of 134 m², five office spaces with a combined gross floor area of 361 m² and two levels of residences comprising 11 x 2 bedroom townhouses. A proposed loading bay at the western end of the site, which is to service the supermarket located off Mulga Road, is of particular relevance to the issues agitated before the primary judge and this Court. The loading dock is designed to be one way with all vehicles entering and leaving in a forward direction, utilising for that purpose a turntable located at its rear. The largest vehicle using the loading dock will be an 11 metre rigid truck. The operation of the loading dock is to be controlled by what was referred to as an Operations Management Plan, which was Exhibit N before the Commissioner. I shall refer to it by the same title in these reasons. The site is within a 3(a) – General Business Zone under the Hurstville Local Environmental Plan 1994 (the LEP). The proposed development was permissible with consent. It complied with the floor space ratio and height restrictions applicable to that zone. Prior to the hearing before the Commissioner, the claimant had prepared, exhibited and adopted an amendment to the draft Hurstville Local Environmental Plan 1994 (Amendment No 60), which imposed a two storey height limit within the subject zone. The claimant resolved to proceed with that draft plan on 23 February 2005, approximately one month prior to the first hearing date of the appeal before the Commissioner. The claimant had further resolved to prepare a further amendment to the draft Hurstville Local Environmental Plan 1994 (Amendment No 66), which was publicly exhibited from 24 March 2005 to 20 April 2005. On 27 April 2005, the claimant resolved to proceed with that draft. The effect of Amendment 66 if and when made, at least from a practical point of view, would be to prohibit so much of the proposed development as comprised the Coles supermarket as it would restrict the display/sales area for retail activity to a maximum of 400 m². It further amended the zone name and objectives to accommodate “only small scale, local neighbourhood retail and business activities”. Local residents raised a number of objections to the proposed development. One of their major objections was that the supermarket would have an unacceptable amenity impact as it would not only cater for the retail needs of the local neighbourhood but would also attract customers from well outside the locality, thus increasing traffic and noise within the local residential area. This was a particular issue because the subject zone of which the site formed part was surrounded by an extensive residential zone in which the predominant urban form was that of detached dwelling houses.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

One or two residents also raised objections related to the amenity impacts of the residential component of the proposed development, but these are not presently relevant to the issues in the appeal. The Commissioner’s decision Three parts of the Commissioner’s judgment are relevant to the present appeal: first, those parts of the judgment that relate to the loading dock; second, those parts relating to amenity impacts; and, third, those with respect to the impact on the area’s character. The Commissioner dealt with each of these matters separately. With respect to the operation of the loading dock, the Commissioner (at [45]) acknowledged that that was a significant issue in the appeal. He noted that the respondent relied on the Operations Management Plan, Exhibit N, to control deliveries to the proposed supermarket in a manner that minimised any potential impact on Mulga Road and adjoining residential areas. However, the claimant maintained that the plan could not be relied upon and it was therefore likely that the proposed development, and in particular the supermarket, would have an unacceptable impact on Mulga Road and adjoining residential areas. In [46] of his judgment, the Commissioner noted that Exhibit N provided a series of restrictions and delivery constraints upon all vehicles delivering goods to the Coles supermarket. He then listed some 11 major components of the plan. In [49] he referred to the evidence given by Mr Pindar (the traffic engineering expert called on behalf of the respondent) that the loading arrangements were satisfactory having regard to the contents of Exhibit N and the frequency of deliveries. At [50] the Commissioner noted that Mr Shiels who, as I have observed, had qualifications in traffic engineering and had therefore addressed the operation of the loading dock, had“agreed that it would be acceptable if operated in accordance with the Operations Management Plan.” The Commissioner then summed up the expert evidence in the following terms:“52.In considering the range of evidence on the suitability of the loading dock, the general consensus of the experts was that if the loading were operated in accordance with the Operation Management Plan [Exhibit N], it would operate in an acceptable manner. This raises the important question of whether the Operation Management Plan can be relied upon to provide some certainty in its operations and consequently provide a reasonable level of amenity and safety for adjoining residents and other people using the Mulga Road shops.” After referring to the decision of this Court in Transport Action Group Against Motorways Inc v Roads and Traffic Authority (1999) 46 NSWLR 598 at 629–630 [122] as authority for the proposition that management plans were a well known concept in environmental law and could be used in a range of different circumstances, the Commissioner acknowledged (at [53]) that often the contents of a management plan were “critical to the decision of whether a development application should be approved or refused”and that that was so with respect to the application before him. Accordingly, in considering whether a management plan was appropriate for a particular use in a particular situation, a number of questions needed to be considered. The Commissioner then set out eight questions, each of which he addressed individually with respect to Exhibit N and which related to the issue of whether it could be relied upon to ensure that the loading dock operated in accordance with its terms.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As a consequence of the last sentence of [118], Order 4 of the formal orders made by the Commissioner was as follows:“Liberty to restore with 48 hours notice if no agreement is reached on the amended Operation Management Plan.”An Amended Operation Management Plan It will be appreciated from the foregoing that the Commissioner considered (in that part of his judgment which I have emphasised: see [33] above) that there was no reason why Exhibit N could not be relied upon to provide for the efficient operation of the loading dock and an acceptable level of protection to the surrounding residential areas. That conclusion was made subject to Exhibit N being amended in five respects. With respect to three of those amendments, the Commissioner specified that the loading dock was to close at 8pm on Sundays and public holidays ([65]); that no deliveries were to be programmed after 7pm on any night ([66]); and that the compactor must not be operated when the roller door to the loading dock was open ([114]). As for the other two amendments required by the Commissioner, the first was that Exhibit N should provide for a suitable parking location for trucks where the rescheduling of a delivery was neither appropriate nor necessary, provided that that location did not have the potential to impact on the amenity of any residential area ([58]). The second was that Exhibit N should contain a procedure for updating or changing its requirements ([71]). Although on its face this last amendment was somewhat vague, it was given substance by the fact that it was an answer to the question of whether there was a procedure for updating and changing the management plan that included the advertising of any such changes to the public. The Court was informed that the three amendments referred to in [65], [66] and [114] were all agreed upon and Exhibit N was amended to reflect them. Apparently there was disagreement with respect to the amendments referred to in [58] and [71]. Accordingly, the respondent purported to exercise the liberty to apply referred to in par 4 of the Commissioner’s orders of 12 July 2005. That application was adjourned until after the primary judge had determined the Council’s s56A appeal. As I have indicated, that appeal was dismissed on 1 November 2005 and the Commissioner dealt with the outstanding amendments to Exhibit N on 8 November 2005 when he ordered that “The Operation Management Plan is amended. The Amended Operation Management Plan is annexed and marked ‘A’.” Relevantly to the amendment required in [58] of the Commissioner’s judgment, two paragraphs were added to Exhibit N under the heading “TRUCK MANAGEMENT IN MULGA ROAD” immediately following the paragraph which read:“In the event that an unscheduled truck arrives and the loading dock is not free, the Store Manager will instruct the driver to reschedule the deliveries and return at a later time to be agreed upon with the Store Manager.” The additional paragraph inserted by the Commissioner to reflect the amendment required by him in [58] was as follows:“However, where the Store Manager is of the opinion that the loading dock will become free within a period of time not exceeding 30 minutes, the driver may be instructed to proceed to the southern side of Roberts Avenue between Depot Road and Lorraine Street as shown on the attached plan, to wait for the availability of the loading dock. The truck driver must be instructed that the truck is only to be parked at the location shown in the attached plan.”The plan so attached reveals that this location adjoins Hurstville Golf Course on the south and the Roberts Avenue industrial zone on the north. In other words, it does not adjoin a residential area.