Huntley Management Limited v Australian Olives Limited (No3)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Huntley Management Limited v Australian Olives Limited (No 3)

[2009] FCA 1549

CORPORATIONS – managed investment scheme – removal of responsible entity (RE) – appointment of replacement RE – entitlement to management fees – whether fees paid for full year apportionable as between the two REs – construction of “Grove Agreements” between individual investors and the removed RE – apportionment legislation – whether apportionment legislation applied.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 601FJ, 601FS, 601FT
Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) s 232

Ellis v Rowbotham [1900] 1 QB 740 cited
The Australian Guarantee Corporation Limited v Balding (1930) 43 CLR 140 cited
Amad v Grant; Grosglik v Grant (1947) 74 CLR 327 cited
Karacominakis v Big Country Developments Pty Ltd [2000] NSWCA 313; (2000) 10 BPR 18,235 cited

HUNTLEY MANAGEMENT LIMITED (ACN 089 240 513) v AUSTRALIAN OLIVES LIMITED (ACN 078 885 042)

NSD 346 of 2009

LINDGREN J
10 DECEMBER 2009
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 346 of 2009

BETWEEN:

HUNTLEY MANAGEMENT LIMITED
(ACN 089 240 513)
Plaintiff/Cross Defendant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN OLIVES LIMITED

(ACN 078 885 042)

Defendant/Cross Claimant

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 DECEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding be listed on Wednesday 16 December 2009 at 9.30 am for the making of orders, including orders as to costs.

2.The parties attempt to agree on the orders to be made, including orders as to costs, and

(a)if agreement is reached, the parties supply a copy of the agreed form of orders to the Associate to Lindgren J by 5.00 pm on Tuesday 15 December 2009; and

(b)if agreement is not reached by then, the parties supply to the Associate by then the forms of orders for which they will respectively contend and short written submissions in support.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 346 of 2009

BETWEEN:

HUNTLEY MANAGEMENT LIMITED

(ACN 089 240 513)

Plaintiff/Cross Defendant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN OLIVES LIMITED

(ACN 078 885 042)

Defendant/Cross Claimant

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE:

10 DECEMBER 2009

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  (No 3)

INTRODUCTION

  1. These reasons relate to a yet further aspect of disputation between a responsible entity (RE) in respect of certain managed investment schemes (MISs) that was removed from that position and the RE that was appointed in its place.  I have given the following earlier judgments in other proceedings relating to the same MISs:

    ·Huntley Management Limited v Australian Olives Limited [2009] FCA 664

    ·Huntley Management Ltd v Australian Olives Ltd (No 2) (2009) 178 FCR 51

    ·Australian Olive Holdings Pty Limited v Huntley Management Limited, in the matter of Huntley Management Limited [2009] FCA 1479 (Australian Olive Holdings).

  2. There are six MISs.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Huntley Management Limited v Australian Olives Limited (No3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1549
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Huntley Management Limited (Huntley) and Australian Olives Limited (AOL) were engaged in a legal dispute before the court, primarily concerning management fees for Projects 4 and 5, periods during which AOL was the Responsible Entity (RE) for these projects. The court was required to determine the apportionment of fees and the entitlement to a "Proceeds Fund" from the sale of Project 4 olives. The central legal issues involved the interpretation of the Grove Agreements, the statutory provisions under the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), and the effect of the Managed Investments Act 1998 (Cth) on the contractual rights and obligations of the parties.

The court's reasoning focused on the application of Section 232 of the Property Law Act, which dictates that rents and other periodical payments accrue from day to day and are apportionable accordingly. The court held that neither Section 601FS nor Section 601FT of the Act allows for the rewriting of contracts to which the former RE was a party, thereby affirming the RE's right to retain fees paid in satisfaction of a present debt. The court further clarified that while there might be debate about the application of certain contractual provisions, the primary operative provision in Section 601FS(1) places the new RE in the shoes of the former RE concerning rights, obligations, and liabilities from the post-changeover period. Additionally, the court addressed the specific clauses of the Project 1 and Project 2 Grove Agreements, confirming the RE's entitlement to fees and the creation of a debt at the commencement of each year.

The court's decision concluded that the parties should attempt to agree on the form of orders to be made, including costs, and scheduled a listing date for the finalisation of the orders. The court's final orders required the parties to either reach an agreement on the orders and submit them for approval or, if no agreement was reached, to submit their respective forms of orders and supporting submissions by a specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be listed on Wednesday 16 December 2009 at 9.30 am for the making of orders, including orders as to costs.

2. The parties attempt to agree on the orders to be made, including orders as to costs, and

(a) if agreement is reached, the parties supply a copy of the agreed form of orders to the Associate to Lindgren J by 5.00 pm on Tuesday 15 December 2009; and

(b) if agreement is not reached by then, the parties supply to the Associate by then the forms of orders for which they will respectively contend and short written submissions in support.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Huntley received management fees for Projects 4 and 5 in respect of annual periods that included a period during which AOL was the RE for those Projects.Two Agreed Facts The parties have agreed that:(1)Costs (excluding harvesting costs - see [21] below) of the RE in performing its duties under the Grove Agreements referred to below are incurred unevenly throughout the year, and vary in relation to time of the year and conditions; and(2)Management fees for Project 4 were in fact charged in arrears by AOL.THE DOCUMENTS Alone of the Projects, Project 1 was established prior to the amendment of the Corporations Law as from 1 July 1998 by the Managed Investments Act 1998 (Cth) (MI Act). Project 1 was established by a Project Deed dated 4 August 1997. After 1 July 1998 Project 1 was required to be registered with ASIC as an MIS. Under the MI Act, AOL was authorised to amend the Project Deed in certain respects and did so by a Supplemental Deed dated 5 June 2000. By reason of the Supplemental Deed references to “Trustee” and “Manager” in the Project Deed are to be read as references to the RE. The Constitution for Project 1 is therefore to be found in the Project Deed as amended by the Supplemental Deed. This consolidated document has a heading of “Trust Deed”. I will refer to the “Trust Deed” and the “Constitution” for Project 1 indiscriminately. Projects 2 to 6 were established directly by “Constitutions” to which AOL and all persons holding interests in the Project are parties.Grove Agreements The RE’s entitlement to management fees arises under a Grove Agreement between the RE and each member of the particular Project (Member). Save for the due date for fees in Projects 4 and 5, the material terms of the Grove Agreements for all Projects are mutuatis mutandis identical. (In Project 5 fees are payable six-monthly in arrears and in Project 4 they are payable on the rendering of an invoice (clause 6.3(c)) – as noted earlier, the parties agree that the fees have in fact been invoiced in arrears.) Clause 4.3 of the Project 1 Grove Agreement lists the ongoing management and harvesting duties that the RE must perform. Clause 6.3 of the Project 1 Grove Agreement entitles the RE (Manager) to management fees. It provides:(a)In consideration of the Manager carrying out its duties under clause 4.3 for the third Year and onwards of this Agreement (except for clause 4.3((l)) [sic] in the relevant Year) the Manager is entitled to be paid a fee calculated in accordance with the following formula:-A = B x C DWhere: - A = the new fee to be calculatedB =the annual fee payable under this Agreement and current at the time of the adjustmentC =the quarterly CPI figure most recently published before the date the adjustment is madeD =the quarterly CPI for the corresponding quarter in the Year before the CPI figure for “C” is taken.(b)Any adjustment made to the fee under clause 6.3((a)) [sic] must not lead to the fee in any Year which is the subject of the adjustment being less than the fee for the previous Year.(c)The Manager’s fees under clause 6.3((a)) are a debt due and owing by the Member to the Manager at the commencement of each Year.[My emphasis]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
There was a further issue in relation to Project 4 concerning AOL’s claim to be entitled to a “Proceeds Fund” of some $90,970.48 representing the proceeds of the sale of Project 4 olives. Huntley has now agreed, however, that AOL is entitled to this amount (which is held by Huntley) subject to any set off of any amount for which AOL may be indebted to Huntley. CONCLUSION I indicated on the hearing that I would publish reasons so that the parties would have an opportunity to work out the arithmetical implications of them. I hope that the parties will be able to agree on the form of orders to be made and I will list the proceeding for a date for the making of orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J

The governing law of each of the Projects is the law of Queensland (and in the case of Project 1, where applicable, the law of the Commonwealth of Australia). Section 232 of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) (Property Law Act) provides in subss (1) and (2) as follows:(1)All rents, annuities, dividends, and other periodical payments in the nature of income whether reserved or made payable under an instrument in writing or otherwise shall, like interest on money lent be considered as accruing from day to day, and shall be apportionable in respect of time accordingly.(2)The apportioned part of any such rent, annuity, or other payment shall be payable or recoverable in the case of a continuing rent, annuity, or other such payment, when the entire portion of which such apportioned part, forms part becomes due and payable, and not before, and in the case of a rent annuity or other such payment determined by re-entry, death, or otherwise, when the next entire portion of the same would have been payable if the same had not so determined, and not before.CONSIDERATIONProjects 1 and 2 At first blush it may seem odd that the Members or a representative of them has not been joined as a party. After all, each Grove Agreement is between AOL and a Member. The dispute, however, concerns fees that have in fact been paid by Members under the Grove Agreements to AOL or to Huntley and neither of those parties has suggested that any Member is liable to pay a second time. Nothing that I say in these reasons will affect the Members. In my opinion, neither s 601FS nor s 601FT of the Act permits a re-writing of contracts to which the former RE was a party: see Australian Olive Holdings at [85]. Sections 60FS(1) and 601FT(1) place a new RE in the shoes of the former RE in relation to rights, obligations and liabilities that would have been those of the former RE in respect of the post-changeover period, but for the changeover. Paragraph (a) of s 601FS(2) is not inconsistent with this construction. There may be room for debate concerning the application of para (a) of s 601FS(2) to certain contractual provisions for the payment of fees that can be hypothesised, but at least it is clear that the paragraph does not detract from a former RE’s right to retain fees that have been paid to it in satisfaction of a present debt. (One situation that would fall within para (a) would be a promise to pay the former RE at a point of time that, it transpired, post-dated its removal where the payment could be said to be for the performance of functions that occurred prior to its removal.) It must be remembered too that para (a) is in the nature of an exception or carving out: the primary operative provision is found in s 601FS(1). Under para (c) of cl 6.3 of the Project 1 Grove Agreement and of cl 5.3 of the Project 2 Grove Agreement, a debt in favour of AOL came into existence at the commencement of each year. AOL would have been entitled at that time, upon a failure to pay, to sue the Member as for debt and to obtain judgment. AOL would have been entitled, after giving the Member seven days’ notice to make the payment and a failure by the Member to comply, to terminate the Grove Agreement under cl 12.3 of the Project 1 Grove Agreement or cl 11.3 of the Project 2 Grove Agreement.