HUNTER and CITY OF JOONDALUP

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: DOG ACT 1976 (WA)

CITATION:   HUNTER and CITY OF JOONDALUP [2025] WASAT 36

MEMBER:   MS C CONLEY, MEMBER

HEARD:   24 OCTOBER 2024, 19 DECEMBER 2024 AND 30 JANUARY 2025

DELIVERED          :   29 APRIL 2025

FILE NO/S:   CC 378 of 2024

BETWEEN:   ANDREW HUNTER

Applicant

AND

CITY OF JOONDALUP

Respondent


Catchwords:

Review of decision by local government to dismiss application for revocation of dangerous dog declarations - Whether Tribunal is satisfied that the dogs can be kept without the likelihood of any contravention of the Dog Act 1976 (WA) or the Dog Regulations 2013 (WA)

Legislation:

Dog Act 1976 (WA), s 3(1), s 12A, s 12A(4), s 16(3), s 32, s 32(1), s 33B, s 33D, s 33D(1), s 33D(2), s 33E, s 33E(1)(a), s 33F, s 33F(6), s 33GA(2), s 33GA(6), s 33H(1), s 33H(2), s 33H(3), s 33H(4), s 33H(5), s 33H(5)(a), s 33I, s 33I(1)(a)(ii), s 33I(2)(b), s 33J, Pt VI, Div 2
Dog Regulations 2013 (WA)
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 3(1), s 9, s 46(1a), s 46(2)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 17, s 27, s 29, s 29(3), s 73
State Administrative Tribunal Rules 2004 (WA), r 39A

Result:

Decision of the Respondent affirmed
Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : In Person
Respondent : Mr TL Beckett

Solicitors:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : McLeods

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Dalgliesh v Brisbane City Council [2025] QCAT 34

Ioppolo and City of Wanneroo [2013] WASAT 172

Keatings and Town of Victoria Park [2008] WASAT 205

Killen v Commissioner of Police [2014] WASC 427

Lee v The State of Western Australia [2025] WASCA 32

Melanie and City of Kwinana [2020] WASAT 32

O'Donnell v Brisbane City Council [2024] QCAT 112

Oh and City of Cockburn [2022] WASAT 81

Phillips v Whitehorse City Council [2019] VCAT 762

Polizzi v Commissioner of Police [No.2] [2017] WASC 166

Porter v Cook [1971] 1 NSWLR 318

Sino Iron Pty Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [No.7] [2025] WASC 103

Willis v Hume City Council [2013] VCAT 1033

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Background

  1. The applicant (Mr Hunter) owns two Rottweiler cross dogs, Gidge and Troopa.[1]  The dogs were declared dangerous dogs by the City of Joondalup (City) in 2022 following two separate incidents each involving injury to another dog.

    [1] These are the names of the dogs which appear in the dangerous dog declarations.  However, Gidge and Troopa are also referred to as 'Gidget' and 'Trooper' in some of the other materials before the Tribunal.

  2. Mr Hunter has applied to the Tribunal, under s 33H(5)(a) of the Dog Act 1976 (WA) (Dog Act), for a review of the City's decision to dismiss his application to revoke the dangerous dog declarations made in respect of Gidge and Troopa (City's decision).

  3. For the reasons which follow, the Tribunal has decided to affirm the City's decision.

The issues for determination

  1. The issues for determination are:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HUNTER and CITY OF JOONDALUP and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] WASAT 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Hunter and City of Joondalup, the applicant, Mr Hunter, sought a review of the City of Joondalup's decision to dismiss his application for the revocation of dangerous dog declarations in relation to his two dogs, Gidge and Troopa. The dispute arose after the City declared the dogs dangerous following incidents where the dogs were involved in attacks on other animals. The case was heard and determined by the State Administrative Tribunal (Tribunal).

The central legal issues in the case were whether the Tribunal was satisfied that Gidge and Troopa could be kept without the likelihood of any contravention of the Dog Act 1976 (WA) or the Dog Regulations 2013 (WA), and whether the Tribunal could conduct a de novo review of the City's decision. Mr Hunter also sought to play videos of his dogs to the expert witnesses, seeking a certificate under section 11 of the Evidence Act 1906 (WA) to protect himself from self-incrimination. However, the Tribunal ruled that only a judge could issue such a certificate, and as the Tribunal did not include a judge, it could not provide the requested certificate.

The Tribunal considered the evidence and agreed facts, including the history of the dogs, the incidents leading to the dangerous dog declarations, and the City's refusal to revoke the declarations. The Tribunal also noted that the dangerous dog declarations remained in effect until revoked by the City or quashed by the Tribunal. In conducting its review, the Tribunal exercised its jurisdiction under the Dog Act and the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) to determine the correct and preferable decision based on the information and evidence before it. The Tribunal found that the City's decision to refuse the revocation of the dangerous dog declarations was correct and preferable, and dismissed Mr Hunter's application for review.

The Tribunal's decision was based on its assessment of the evidence and the circumstances surrounding the incidents involving Gidge and Troopa. It concluded that the dogs continued to pose a risk and could not be kept without the likelihood of any contravention of the Dog Act or the Dog Regulations. The Tribunal did not determine the validity of the City's original decision but rather exercised its review jurisdiction to arrive at the correct and preferable decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

During the Hearing, Mr Hunter wished to play certain videos of his dogs to the expert witnesses. Mr Hunter asked for a certificate under s 11 of the Evidence Act 1906 (WA) (Evidence Act) because he was concerned that he might incriminate himself as some of the videos he had taken of Gidge and Troopa might be construed as contravening the requirements of the dangerous dog declarations.[24] I ruled that I could not give such a certificate because a certificate under s 11 of the Evidence Act may only be given by a judge and the definition of that term[25] does not include an ordinary member of the Tribunal.[26] Mr Hunter indicated that he would play videos which did not incriminate him.[27][24] ts 77 - 80, 24 October 2024.[25] Evidence Act, s 3. [26] ts 88, 24 October 2024. See also s 32(2) of the SAT Act which says that the Evidence Act does not apply to Tribunal proceedings.[27] ts 88 - 89, 24 October 2024. The following facts are agreed between the parties,[28] or are not in dispute, and I find:[28] Applicant's Statement of Issues, Facts and Contentions filed on 8 September 2024 (Exhibit 1 at pages 59 - 61) and Respondent's Statement of Issues, Facts and Contentions filed on 22 August 2024 (Exhibit 1 at pages 221 - 227).(a)Mr Hunter is the owner of two dogs named Gidge (an unsterilised female who weighs about 35 kilograms) and Troopa (a sterilised male who weighs about 40 - 42 kilograms);[29][29] ts 4, 30 January 2025.(b)Ms Kya Hunter, Mr Hunter's daughter, is the owner of two dogs named Hunter and Chaz;(c)Hunter is a Staffy/Ridgeback cross and is the mother of Gidge, Troopa and Chaz;[30][30] ts 2 - 3, 30 January 2025.(d)Bear is a Rottweiler and is the father of Gidge, Troopa and Chaz;[31][31] ts 3, 30 January 2025.(e)Gidge, Troopa and Chaz are Rottweiler/Staffy/Ridgeback cross dogs who turned three years of age in December 2024;[32][32] ts 3, 30 January 2025.(f)on 16 October 2022, Gidge, Troopa, Hunter and Chaz were involved in an incident at a dog beach (the First Incident);(g)on 8 November 2022, Gidge, Troopa, Chaz and Hunter were involved in an incident at a dog park (the Second Incident);(h)on 9 November 2022, the City declared Gidge, Troopa, Chaz and Hunter as dangerous dogs under s 33E of the Dog Act;[33][33] Exhibit 1 at pages 120 - 135.(i)at the time the four dogs were declared dangerous, all four dogs were being kept at Mr Hunter's property;(j)Gidge and Troopa are currently kept at the applicant's property which is within the district of the City[34] whereas Chaz and Hunter now live with Ms Hunter at another address;[35][34] ts 5, 30 January 2025.[35] ts 5, 30 January 2025.(k)on 16 November 2022, Mr Hunter wrote to the City objecting to the City's decision to make the dangerous dog declarations in relation to Gidge and Troopa. This objection was refused by the City on the basis that Mr Hunter had a lack of control of his dogs and both attacks were severe and resulted in the injury of other animals;(l)Mr Hunter submitted a further objection to the City in relation to their decision to make the dangerous dog declarations in relation to Gidge and Troopa. This objection was also refused by the City on the same basis as the previous refusal;(m)Mr Hunter subsequently applied to have the City's decision to make the dangerous dog declarations reviewed by the Tribunal in proceeding CC 48 of 2023;(n)on 2 June 2023, the Tribunal found that the declaration of each of Mr Hunter's dogs as dangerous dogs pursuant to s 33E(1) of the Dog Act was the correct and preferable decision and Mr Hunter's application for review was dismissed (Tribunal's 2023 Oral Reasons for Decision);[36](o)Mr Hunter applied to the Supreme Court for leave to appeal against the Tribunal's decision. Leave was refused;[37](p)on 1 May 2024, Mr Hunter applied to the City to revoke the dangerous dog declarations in respect of Gidge and Troopa;[38](q)on 21 May 2024, the City refused to revoke the dangerous dog declarations because of the pending criminal proceedings against Mr Hunter in the Magistrates Court;[39] (r)on 12 June 2024, Mr Hunter lodged an application for review with the Tribunal;[40] and(s)at the time of the Hearing, Mr Hunter was still awaiting trial on criminal charges arising out of the First Incident and the Second Incident.[41]

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A local government may, by a notice in writing given in accordance with s 33F, declare an individual dog to be a dangerous dog (declared) (dangerous dog declaration) if, in the opinion of the local government, one of three things is shown:[2] the dog has caused injury or damage by an attack on, or chasing, a person, animal or vehicle; or the dog has, repeatedly, shown a tendency to attack, or chase, a person, animal or vehicle even though no injury has been caused by that behaviour, or has, repeatedly, shown a tendency to threaten to attack; or the behaviour of the dog meets other criteria prescribed for the purpose of this section.[3] [2] Dog Act, s 33E.[3] No behaviour has been prescribed in the Dog Regulations 2013 (WA) (Dog Regulations). A dangerous dog declaration remains in force until the dog dies, the declaration is revoked by the local government, or the decision pursuant to which the declaration was given is quashed by the Tribunal.[4] The local government may, on the application of the owner of the dog, revoke a dangerous dog declaration if the local government is satisfied that the dog can be kept without the likelihood of any contravention of the Dog Act or the Dog Regulations.[5] [5] Dog Act, s 33H(1). See also paragraphs [53] - [61]. The local government must, as soon as is practicable, give notice in writing to the owner of the dog, of any refusal to revoke the dangerous dog declaration and of the reasons for the making of the decision.[6] Where an application to revoke a dangerous dog declaration is made and the local government dismisses the application, the owner may, within seven days, apply to the Tribunal for a review of the decision.[7][7] Dog Act, s 33H(5). This application falls within the Tribunal's review jurisdiction under the Dog Act and the State AdministrativeTribunal Act 2004 (WA) (SAT Act).[8] In exercising the Tribunal's review jurisdiction, the Tribunal is to review the decision in question by way of a hearing de novo for the purposes of producing the correct and preferable decision on the basis of the information and the evidence before the Tribunal at the time of review.[9] [8] Dog Act, s 33H(5)(a) and s 33I and SAT Act, s 17.[9] SAT Act, s 27. The Tribunal does not determine the validity or otherwise of the reviewable decision.[10][10] Killen v Commissioner of Police [2014] WASC 427 [42] - [43]. The Tribunal is not limited in its consideration to the material that was before the original decision-maker, nor to a consideration of the original decision-maker's reasoning alone.[11][11] SAT Act, s 27. All of the functions and discretions conferred on the original decision-maker are conferred on the Tribunal in addition to the powers conferred on the Tribunal by the SAT Act.[12] Accordingly, the Tribunal stands in the shoes of the City to make the correct or preferable decision.[13][12] SAT Act, s 29.[13] Polizzi v Commissioner of Police[No.2] [2017] WASC 166 [67]. On review, the Tribunal may affirm, vary or set aside the reviewable decision and, in the latter case, may substitute its own decision to arrive at the correct and preferable decision.[14] [14] SAT Act, s 29(3) and Dog Act, s 33I.