Horton and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

Horton and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2019] AATA 953 (10 May 2019)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/6392; 2017/0719; and 2017/3188

Re:James Horton  

APPLICANT

Australian Capital TerritoryAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

Date:10 May 2019

Place:Canberra

The reviewable decision dated 7 October 2016 is set aside, and in substitution the Tribunal decides that Mr Horton is entitled to compensation pursuant to ss 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) with respect to the 22 determinations made between 23 March 2015 and 31 August 2016 to which that reviewable decision related.

The reviewable decisions dated 1 February 2017 and 26 May 2017 are set aside, and instead the Tribunal finds that Mr Horton is entitled to compensation pursuant to s 14 of the Act for major depressive disorder and adjustment disorder with anxiety, with a date of injury of 16 February 2015.

........................................................................

Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – aggravation of adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features – whether ailment excluded by operation of reasonable administrative action exception – exception not established – decision set aside and substituted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where Comcare made a reconsideration of own motion decision revoking 22 previous determinations – where Mr Horton suffers from a primary condition and aggravation of that earlier condition – whether both of Mr Horton’s conditions are the subject of Comcare’s reconsideration decision – scope of Tribunal’s jurisdiction – finding that Tribunal’s jurisdiction limited to later condition

Legislation

Public Sector Management Act 1994 (ACT) s 9
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 5A, 5B, 14, 16, 19

Cases

Comcare v Drinkwater [2018] FCAFC 62
Comcare v Martin [2016] HCA 43
Comcare v Martinez (No 2) (2013) 302 ALR 608
Commonwealth Bank v Reeve (2012) 199 FCR 463
Drenth v Comcare [2012] FCAFC 86
Long v Comcare [2016] FCA 737
Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19
O’Grady v Northern Queensland Co Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 356
Prain v Comcare [2017] FCAFC 143
Telstra Corporation Limited v Hannaford (2006) 151 FCR 253

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

10 May 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr James Horton was employed by the office of the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions (the DPP) from May 1997. In 2014 he lodged a claim for workers compensation for anxiety and depression that resulted from bullying in the workplace and another in 2016.[1]

    [1] In this decision, italicised text is generally used to indicate direct quotations.

  2. Three decisions of Comcare delegates relating to those claims came before the Tribunal for merits review in these proceedings. Ultimately, it was conceded that Mr Horton had suffered psychological conditions arising from his employment with the DPP, but Comcare argued that the conditions were not compensable as they arose from reasonable administrative action within the exclusion in s 5A of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act.

    CLAIMS HISTORY

  3. As the history of Mr Horton’s claims for compensation is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Horton and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 953
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Horton against decisions made by Comcare, which were subsequently to be effected by the Australian Capital Territory. The dispute centred on whether Mr Horton was entitled to compensation for two psychological conditions arising from his employment, specifically an adjustment disorder with mixed emotional features and an aggravation of that condition. Comcare had revoked 22 previous determinations that had accepted liability for compensation in respect of Mr Horton's conditions.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were the scope of its jurisdiction in relation to the reviewable decisions, and whether Mr Horton's conditions were excluded from compensation by the operation of the reasonable administrative action exception under section 5A of the relevant Act. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the 22 revoked determinations related to the initial condition or the subsequent aggravation, and to assess the validity of Comcare's reconsideration decision.

The Tribunal found that Mr Horton suffered two distinct psychological conditions: a primary condition in May 2014 and an aggravation of that condition in February 2015, which constituted a new condition. It determined that the 22 revoked determinations all related to the 2015 condition. Crucially, the Tribunal found that the reasonable administrative action exception under section 5A was not established, as the Drumgold inquiry, which was the basis for the administrative action, was not undertaken in respect of Mr Horton's employment.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside Comcare's decision of 7 October 2016, substituting a decision that Mr Horton was entitled to compensation for the 22 determinations relating to the 2015 condition. The Tribunal also set aside the reviewable decisions of 1 February 2017 and 26 May 2017, finding instead that Mr Horton was entitled to compensation for major depressive disorder and adjustment disorder with anxiety, with a date of injury of 16 February 2015. The Tribunal ordered that Mr Horton's costs be paid by the Australian Capital Territory.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal notes that Comcare was the Respondent in this matter at the time of the hearing on 19-21 February 2019; however from 1 March 2019, the Australian Capital Territory became the Respondent due to the ACT Government’s transition to obtain a self-insurance licence under Part VIII of the Act. Comcare is referred to throughout this decision, in its role as the Respondent during the hearing, though the decision is now to be effected by the Australian Capital Territory.EVIDENCE Mr Horton was employed in the office of the DPP (the Office) from 1997 (on a full-time basis), initially as an Administrative Services Officer Grade 2 (ASO2) and then as a Court Listing Officer (CLO) at the ASO5 level from February 2005. In September 2010, following the implementation of a new Case Management System, a workplace restructuring took place within the Office. In the course of that restructuring it was recommended that the CLO position be classified as an ASO5 position. Mr Horton and the Office negotiated an agreement on his revised duty statement in November 2011, in which his position was now designated as Assistant Paralegal Manager, reporting to the Paralegal Manager, Ms Susan Little. Ms Hollow started at the Office in 2008. In the witness box Mr Horton described her style of management as confrontational, reactionary. When the issue of an alleged overpayment due to not being entitled to a higher retention point pay level arose in 2011, he said that his relationship with Ms Hollow was strained. He took some leave from the Office at this time. When he returned from leave in December 2011 he was told that he had been overpaid, and was required to repay approximately $10,000. Eventually, after about 18 months, the overpayment issue was resolved in his favour, but not before he had had his ongoing salary reduced. While the overpayment issue was ongoing, Mr Horton asked Ms Hollow to review his personnel file. He also reviewed it himself. He told the Tribunal that he took copies of a number of documents from the file and then showed them to Ms Hollow. Shortly afterwards, it was conceded that he had not been overpaid and the issue was resolved. Mr Horton gave evidence that, in 2012, while he was on secondment outside the Office, another employee was given the role that he had previously occupied as CLO, at the ASO 5 level, a position he believed had been designated as no longer required. A new, non-legal position of Allocations Manager, classified at a SOG C level, was created in 2013. This position was initially filled on a temporary basis for a period of 6 months. Mr Horton applied for this position, but Ms Little was the successful candidate. With her elevation to this role, it became necessary to backfill the role of Paralegal Manager for the first half of 2014. In January 2014, Ms Hollow was Mr Horton’s supervisor. He told the Tribunal that an agreement was struck at about this time between himself, Ms Hollow and another employee, Ms Eleanor Hoskins, so that both he and Ms Hoskins would act in the Paralegal Manager position for a period of 3 months each, beginning with Ms Hoskins. The manner in which this arrangement for Mr Horton to act in the Paralegal Manager role was conducted was a seminal issue in these proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It would be dangerous to be dogmatic in these circumstances, but, on balance, I consider that the Drumgold inquiry was not undertaken in respect of Mr Horton’s employment. It seems to me that an employee may have a very close or personal interest in an operational activity at their place of employment without that activity constituting something about them or their employment. If it were imagined, for example, that the Drumgold inquiry had been undertaken into Ms Hollow’s conduct as the result of complaints by employees other than Mr Horton, the outcome might well have been as injurious to him, but would be clearly not an inquiry in respect of his employment.CONCLUSION Since the s 5A exclusion is not made out, the decisions under review – all of which relate to the 2015 condition – must be set aside. The reviewable decision dated 7 October 2016 is set aside, and in substitution decides that Mr Horton is entitled to compensation pursuant to ss 16 and 19 of the Act with respect to the 22 determinations made between 23 March 2015 and 31 August 2016 to which that reviewable decision related. The reviewable decisions dated 1 February 2017 and 26 May 2017 are set aside, and instead the Tribunal finds that Mr Horton is entitled to compensation pursuant to s 14 of the Act for major depressive disorder and adjustment disorder with anxiety, with a date of injury of 16 February 2015. Pursuant to s 67(8) of the Act, the Tribunal orders that Mr Horton’s costs be paid by the Australian Capital Territory.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In similar fashion, s 19 provides for compensation for incapacity to work resulting from an injury.CONSIDERATIONThe Tribunal’s jurisdiction The first step in determining the correct or preferable decision in these proceedings is to set out the nature of the issues confronting the Tribunal. The following essential facts around Mr Horton’s injuries are uncontroversial. He suffered two psychological conditions related to his employment. The first occurred in May 2014, and arose out of the events surrounding Mr Horton being denied the opportunity to act in the Paralegal Manager role (the 2014 condition). The second occurred in February 2015, and arose out of Mr Horton being advised of the outcome of the investigation into his complaint about Ms Hollow (the 2015 condition). This 2015 condition is an aggravation of the 2014 condition; it is, as Dr Duke’s report makes clear, a new condition, not the mere re-emergence or re-expression of the 2014 condition. There are ostensibly three reviewable decisions before the Tribunal relating to those two conditions. However, the reviewable decisions in 2017/0719 and 2017/3188 amount to the same thing, both being denials of liability under s 14 for the 2015 condition, albeit for different reasons. While the subject matter of the reviewable decisions in 2017/0719 and 2017/3188 is clear, the same cannot be said of the subject matter of the reviewable decision in 2016/6392. Careful examination of that subject matter is necessary. This reviewable decision was made on 7 October 2016. By this decision (a reconsideration of own motion determination), a Comcare delegate revoked 22 determinations made between 23 March 2015 and 31 August 2016 which had accepted liability for compensation under ss 16 and 19 in respect of Mr Horton. The delegate found that his accepted condition, the 2014 condition, had substantially resolved in August 2014. The delegate further found that a new set of circumstances in February 2015 was the cause of Mr Horton’s incapacity for work, not the accepted 2014 condition. This new set of circumstances had created a major worsening of your condition (an aggravation). Implicit in this decision is that the 22 determinations made between March 2015 and August 2016 related to the new condition – the aggravation – originating in February 2015. Though not explicitly stated, the logic implicit here is that since the determinations related to a new condition for which there had been no acceptance of liability, compensation was not payable. An examination of the 22 determinations confirms that they do indeed relate to the 2015 condition. The earliest of the determinations, dated 23 March 2015, accepted liability under s 16 pursuant to a medical certificate issued by Mr Horton’s GP dated 3 March 2015. It is reasonable to assume that the certificate was in respect of treatment provided at around that time, some two weeks after the meeting of 16 February 2015. Each of the subsequent s 16 determinations relates to treatment provided later than 16 February 2015. Similarly the first determination made pursuant to s 19 relates to periods of incapacity commencing on 17 February 2015. Each of the subsequent s 19 determinations relates to periods subsequent to this.