Horsington and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ Entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Horsington and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ Entitlements) [2016] AATA 223 (8 April 2016) 

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2015/0182

Re

Anthony Horsington

APPLICANT

And

Repatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

Date 8 April 2016
Place Sydney

The decision under review dated 12 November 2014 is set aside and the decision made that the applicant is entitled to the intermediate rate of pension. The date of effect is 4 January 2011.

................................[sgd]........................................

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

VETERAN’S ENTITLEMENTS – rate of pension – whether Applicant eligible for special rate – whether Applicant eligible for intermediate rate – alone test – Applicant entitled to payment at intermediate rate – decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 ss 23, 24

CASES

Repatriation Commission v Richmond [2014] FCAFC 124

Repatriation Commission v Watkins [2015] FCAFC 10

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

8 April 2016

Introduction

  1. The applicant, Mr Horsington, seeks the review of the decision made on 12 November 2014 by the Veterans’ Review Board, affirming the 12 November 2013 decision made by the Repatriation Commission to continue the disability pension at 100 per cent of the General Rate from 4 January 2011 and at 100 per cent of the General rate from 16 July 2013.

  2. The applicant claims that he satisfies the criteria for a pension at the special rate, or alternatively, a pension at the intermediate rate under the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (the Act), sections 24 and 23 respectively.

    The issues in this case

  3. In summary, the issues in this case are whether the applicant’s incapacity from war-caused injury or war-caused disease, or both, is of itself alone, of such a nature to render him incapable of undertaking remunerative work for more than 8 hours per week (the special rate of pension) or more than 20 hours or more per week (the intermediate rate of pension) and whether he is suffering a loss of salary, wages or earnings on his own account that he would not be suffering if he were free of that incapacity.  This is referred to as the “alone test”.

    The law

  4. Relevantly, s 24 of the Act provides:

    (1)  This section applies to a veteran if:

    (aa) the veteran has made a claim under section 14 for a pension, or an application under section 15 for an increase in the rate of the pension that he or she is receiving; and

    (aab) the veteran had not yet turned 65 when the claim or application was made; and

    (a) either:

    (i) the degree of incapacity of the veteran from war-caused injury or war-caused disease, or both, is determined under section 21A to be at least 70% or has been so determined by a determination that is in force; or

    (ii) the veteran is, because he or she has suffered or is suffering from pulmonary tuberculosis, receiving or entitled to receive a pension at the general rate; and

    (b) the veteran is totally and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Horsington and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ Entitlemen... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 223
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Horsington v Repatriation Commission, the applicant, a former member of the RAAF, sought an increase in his pension entitlement based on his eligibility for either a special or an intermediate rate of pension. The Repatriation Commission was the respondent in the matter. The central issue before the court was whether the applicant met the criteria for either a special or an intermediate rate of pension under sections 23 and 24 of the relevant Act, specifically considering the "alone test" as interpreted in previous cases. The court needed to determine whether the applicant's circumstances justified a higher pension rate beyond the general rate he was receiving.

The court reviewed the applicant's work history, including his current mortgage broking business, and the nature of the difficulties he experienced in previous employment due to his service-related conditions. The applicant's evidence about his work hours and income from the mortgage broking business was considered, along with the concession by the respondent that the applicant qualified for a general rate of pension at a minimum of 70%. The court evaluated the applicant's claim that he was unemployable in 2009 and subsequently started his own business, working approximately five to six hours a week. The applicant's tax returns and income sources were also scrutinized.

The court found that while the applicant's conditions significantly impacted his ability to work, he did not meet the stringent criteria for a special rate of pension, which requires the person to be entirely unemployable. However, the court determined that the applicant did satisfy the "alone test" for an intermediate rate of pension, as he was not capable of gainful employment without the assistance of another person. Consequently, the court set aside the previous decision and substituted it with a decision awarding the applicant a pension at the intermediate rate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The most recent authorities on the interpretation of the “alone test” expressed in each of sections 23 and 24 are Repatriation Commission v Watkins [2015] FCAFC 10 and Repatriation Commission v Richmond [2014] FCAFC 124. On 4 November 2015 the High Court dismissed an application for special leave in Watkins. Background The following findings are not contentious. The applicant was born in 1948. He served in the RAAF. His period of service from 7 December 1972 to 5 February 1990 is considered to be eligible defence service under the Act. He was 63 years of age on the application day, 4 April 2011. The earliest possible date of effect is 4 January 2011. The applicant’s accepted conditions are sensorineural hearing loss, tinnitus, lumbar spondylosis, solar keratosis, osteoarthrosis of the right knee, dysthymic disorder, and nerve hyper-excitability disorder, generalised, superimposed upon chronic polyradiculopathy. The conditions that have not been accepted are loss of teeth, metatarsalgia of the right foot, osteoarthrosis affecting both hands, disturbances of sensation of smell and taste, scoliosis, internal derangement of the left knee and plantar fasciitis of the left foot. The respondent concedes that the applicant warrants a general rate of pension at a rate of at least 70% and therefore satisfies s 24(1)(a)(i) and s 23(1)(a)(i). Consideration of the evidence and findings I find on the evidence of Mr Horsington, including his statement of 2 April 2015 and his evidence given at the Tribunal hearing, that he currently runs a mortgage broking business from his home in a rural town in New South Wales. He moved there from Sydney in about January 2010 as a consequence of a new relationship. He claimed that he works about five or six hours a week. Some weeks he does nothing. It varies. The applicant claimed that the last time he worked more than eight hours a week was a long time ago, probably in 2009 when he was employed by Jacobs Australia generating computerised training material for aircrew training at RAAF Base Richmond. He described the difficulties he suffered arising from sitting in a cold environment operating a computer. He had cramping in his legs, and his knees and back were very stiff and sore. He was unable to sand without assistance after an hour or so at his work station. Those difficulties added to his “recognised anxiety, depression and stress levels – particularly when” his “services were terminated in May 2009”. He said that his annual salary was $89,000 although he only worked in that job for six weeks. The applicant claimed that as he appeared unemployable in 2009, he commenced a mortgage broking business from an office at his then Windsor home, working an hour or two a day. He claimed that he had previously worked as a mortgage broker from 2002 to 2009 receiving a minimum payment of $35,000 plus commission. The applicant’s other qualifications and experience include the following. He undertook photographic duties in the RAAF, ran a commercial photograph company for about a year in 1990, worked in real estate from 1991 to 1994 and gained his real estate licence, was the photo media co-ordinator at the University of Technology Sydney from 1994 to 1995, worked in real estate sales in 1995 and 1996, and then managed a commercial photographic business from 1997 to 1999. From 1999 to 2002 he was a licensee in charge of a real estate business.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent concedes that the applicant warrants a general rate of pension at a rate of at least 70% and therefore satisfies s 24(1)(a)(i) and s 23(1)(a)(i). Consideration of the evidence and findings I find on the evidence of Mr Horsington, including his statement of 2 April 2015 and his evidence given at the Tribunal hearing, that he currently runs a mortgage broking business from his home in a rural town in New South Wales. He moved there from Sydney in about January 2010 as a consequence of a new relationship. He claimed that he works about five or six hours a week. Some weeks he does nothing. It varies. The applicant claimed that the last time he worked more than eight hours a week was a long time ago, probably in 2009 when he was employed by Jacobs Australia generating computerised training material for aircrew training at RAAF Base Richmond. He described the difficulties he suffered arising from sitting in a cold environment operating a computer. He had cramping in his legs, and his knees and back were very stiff and sore. He was unable to sand without assistance after an hour or so at his work station. Those difficulties added to his “recognised anxiety, depression and stress levels – particularly when” his “services were terminated in May 2009”. He said that his annual salary was $89,000 although he only worked in that job for six weeks. The applicant claimed that as he appeared unemployable in 2009, he commenced a mortgage broking business from an office at his then Windsor home, working an hour or two a day. He claimed that he had previously worked as a mortgage broker from 2002 to 2009 receiving a minimum payment of $35,000 plus commission. The applicant’s other qualifications and experience include the following. He undertook photographic duties in the RAAF, ran a commercial photograph company for about a year in 1990, worked in real estate from 1991 to 1994 and gained his real estate licence, was the photo media co-ordinator at the University of Technology Sydney from 1994 to 1995, worked in real estate sales in 1995 and 1996, and then managed a commercial photographic business from 1997 to 1999. From 1999 to 2002 he was a licensee in charge of a real estate business. It was not in dispute that relevantly, the remunerative work that the applicant was undertaking was mortgage broking. The applicant provided a detailed account in his statement of the difficulties he suffered in his employment over the years arising from his various conditions. In support of his claim, the applicant provided tax returns for the years ending June 2011, June 2012, June 2013 and June 2014. He gave oral evidence about the sources of his income. He claimed that on average over that period, he earned $6,000 gross from his mortgage broking business, or $4,000 net, per year. The applicant was cross-examined about his wife’s statement recorded in the report of Dr Chase dated 10 July 2015, that the business has never been busy and that one week there might be no work at all and another week they night get 10 or 12 hours’ work. The applicant said that was not accurate. He explained that while a client might ring up and you might think that there would be 10 or 12 hours of work from that client, he would not do it “in one hit”. During re-examination, the applicant said that he cannot predict how much work he can do in a week, because his cramps may be not as frequent for a couple of weeks but then are much more frequent. He was also asked about his statement to Dr Chase that another broker had asked him to help her but he declined. He said that she asked him on a couple of occasions over the last six years. He has helped her when she has gone on holiday. It just involved making a couple of telephone calls and making sure a file was processed by a lender.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.