Horsfall and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2009] AATA 811

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No 2008/4437

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

)

Re SIMON & KATHLEEN HORSFALL

Applicants

And

AUSTRALIAN COMMUNITY PHARMACY AUTHORITY

Respondent

And

PAMELA CARTER

Joined Party

DECISION

Tribunal Ms Naida Isenberg, Senior Member

Date22 October 2009

PlaceSydney

Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Authority for its recommendation in accordance with section 99K of the National Health Act 1953 (Cth) that the Applicants’ application under section 90, in respect of the Horsfall premises, be approved. The Tribunal orders that the Authority pay the Applicants' costs of the application.

....................[Sgd]..................

Ms Naida Isenberg
  Senior Member

25.     Any restriction on the Tribunal to consider only conduct and events up to a certain point in time would have to arise from the intention of the legislation under consideration and the nature of the decision under review. 

26.     The Respondent submitted that the requirement of Item 114(b) of the Rules, that the proposed premises be at least 10km from the nearest approved premises, is not fixed in time.[3] By contrast, Items 201(a) and (b) impose criteria that must be satisfied 'on the date of the application’. The Respondent submitted that those items explicitly set the relevant time that certain criteria must be satisfied, and in relation to those criteria only, the Tribunal must have regard to the state of affairs at the prescribed time.  By implication, all other criteria in relation to which no time for satisfaction is specified, are to be assessed as at the date of the Tribunal's decision.  Because Item 114(b) contains no temporal element, the question for the Tribunal in this case is whether at the date of its decision the Horsfall application satisfies Item 114(b) of the Rules. It was further submitted by the Respondent that it is entirely irrelevant that the requirement was satisfied at the time the Authority made its decision.

[3] An example of a reviewable decision fixed in time is a decision to deny a person a pension payable in a particular fortnight because during that fortnight the person did not qualify under the relevant legislation for the pension

27.     I do not agree with the Respondent’s submissions. I have considered the decision of Deputy President Jarvis in Re Friendly Society Medical Association Ltd and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (2008) 106 ALD 635 where, curiously, the Authority’s position was contrary to the position it takes in this matter. DP Jarvis stated at [36]:

I find it unnecessary to determine the conflict of evidence as to this issue. I accept the argument of counsel for the authority, Mr Dillon, that the present matter is an example of the sort of matter that was referred to by Kirby J in the case of Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286 where his Honour said at [44] that sometimes it may be inherent in the nature of a particular decision that review…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Horsfall and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and Ano... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] AATA 811
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Horsfall and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and Anor involved the applicants, Horsfall, challenging the decision of the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (the Authority) to not approve their application to supply pharmaceutical benefits at a particular premises. The dispute was heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The applicants argued that the Authority's decision was flawed and sought to have it overturned and replaced with a decision in their favour.

The primary legal issues that the Tribunal needed to determine were whether it was limited to the material that was available to the decision-maker and whether it was entitled to consider facts that emerged at the time of the review. The applicants contended that the Tribunal should not be constrained by the material available to the decision-maker and should be able to consider new evidence. They further argued that the Authority failed to properly consider their application and did not adequately address the applicants' submissions.

In its decision, the Tribunal held that it was not limited to the material available to the decision-maker and could consider facts that came to light during the review process. The Tribunal found that the Authority had not adequately considered the applicants' submissions and had failed to properly weigh the merits of the application. The decision was set aside and remitted to the Authority for reconsideration in accordance with the statutory provisions. The Tribunal also ordered that the Authority pay the applicants' costs of the application.

The Tribunal's decision highlights the importance of decision-makers properly considering all relevant material and giving adequate weight to the submissions of applicants. It also confirms that the Tribunal is not limited to the material available to the decision-maker and can consider new evidence that comes to light during the review process.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Authority for its recommendation in accordance with section 99K of the National Health Act 1953 (Cth) that the Applicants’ application under section 90, in respect of the Horsfall premises, be approved. The Tribunal orders that the Authority pay the Applicants' costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Horsfall, applied for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits under the National Health Act 1953 (Cth) at a particular premises. The Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (the Authority) considered the application and recommended against approval. Horsfall sought a review of the Authority's decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether it was limited to considering only the material available to the decision-maker or if it could also consider facts that arose at the time of the review. The decision under review was the Authority's recommendation not to approve Horsfall's application.

This matter came before the Tribunal as a result of Horsfall seeking a review of the Authority's decision under section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). Horsfall applied to the Tribunal for review of the Authority's decision to not approve their application to supply pharmaceutical benefits at a particular premises. The Tribunal held a hearing to consider the matter and subsequently delivered a decision setting aside the Authority's recommendation and remitting the matter to the Authority for reconsideration in accordance with section 99K of the National Health Act 1953 (Cth).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Tribunal was limited to considering only the material available to the decision-maker or if it could also consider facts that arose at the time of the review.
2. Whether the Tribunal was entitled to consider facts at the time of the review in setting aside the decision under review and remitting the matter to the Authority for reconsideration.

Held
1. The court held that the Tribunal was not limited to considering only the material available to the decision-maker, but could also consider facts that arose at the time of the review.
2. The court held that the Tribunal was entitled to consider facts at the time of the review in setting aside the decision under review and remitting the matter to the Authority for reconsideration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the legislative framework provided by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and the National Health Act 1953, specifically section 43 of the former and sections 90, 99K, 99L(1) and 105AD of the latter. The Tribunal was empowered to review decisions made by the Authority and to remit the matter back to the Authority for reconsideration if necessary. The court emphasised that the Tribunal's scope of review was not confined to the material before the decision-maker, as per the precedent set in Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority. This decision allowed for a broader consideration of facts that emerged after the original decision was made, but before the review. The court also drew on the authorities Re Friendly Society Medical Association Ltd and Re Maryborough/Hervey Bay Friendly Society Chemists Ltd, which supported the view that the Tribunal had the discretion to consider new facts in certain circumstances. The binding principle established here is that the Tribunal can consider facts arising after the decision in question if such facts are relevant to the decision-making process. This principle aligns with the court's decision to set aside the Authority's decision and remit the matter back for reconsideration, taking into account the new facts presented during the review process.