Hong and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 634

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N 1999/1800

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      MINH DUC HONG
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President           

Date1 August 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is set aside and the matter is remitted back to the Minister with a direction that Mr Hong not be deported.           

..............................................
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
  IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – criminal deportation – citizen of Vietnam – entry into Australia age 12 – refugee from Vietnam – convictions for drug related offences – history of drug use and dependence – consideration of seriousness of the offences – not abhorrent in the sense envisaged by the policy direction – risk of recidivism assessed to be quite high – some prospect for rehabilitation– consideration of deterrent factor – little general deterrent value  - consideration of hardship – consideration of family and associated ties - family would suffer real hardship – consideration of conditions in Vietnam – prospect of rehabilitation in Vietnam minimal – applicant would suffer very severe hardship in Vietnam –consideration of the expectations of the Australian community – Australian community should not be exposed to further risks – weighing of factors against deportation – decision set aside
Migration Act 1958 s200
New South Wales Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985
Hong v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1567
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1238
Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2000) FCA 698
Lau v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2000) FCA 698

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President   

BACKGROUND
Application and Hearing

  1. Mr Minh Duc Hong, the applicant, seeks review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Minister), made pursuant to s200 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act), to deport him from Australia. The Tribunal's jurisdiction to review that decision is granted by s500(1)(a) of the Act.

  2. Mr Bruce Miles, a solicitor, represented Mr Hong at the hearing.  Mr Hong appeared in person and gave personal testimony to the Tribunal.  The following witnesses also testified on his behalf:

    Ms Viet Hua Hong
    Ms Tua Hoa Hong

    Mr Minh Vi Hong
    Mr A. Hadjipanayotis
    Mr Thanh Kak Le
    Mr A. Lam
    Mr M.L. Green
    Dr  T.O. Clark

  3. Mr Geoffrey Johnson, of counsel, instructed by Ms Juanita Kapel, a departmental advocate, represented the respondent at the hearing.  The following witnesses testified on behalf of the respondent:

    Dr G. R.W. Davies
    Ms H.J. Campbell
    Ms A.M. Paxton
    Mr M. L. Green
    Dr Truong Thin

  4. The Tribunal had before it documents filed for the purposes of s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T documents). The following exhibits were also received into evidence on behalf of the applicant and the respondent:
    Exhibit No.     Description    Date   
    A1      Certificate of Australian Citizenship – Mr Minh Vi Hong          21/2/1996     
    A2      Cable from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hong and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 634
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hong and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved a Vietnamese national, Mr Hong, who had been living in Australia since the age of 12. He was facing deportation due to several drug-related convictions. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with reviewing the decision of the Tribunal, which had recommended against deportation. The legal issues before the court included the consideration of the seriousness of Mr Hong's offences, the risk of recidivism, the potential for rehabilitation, and the hardships associated with deportation to Vietnam.

The court's reasoning focused on weighing the factors for and against deportation. It found that while Mr Hong's drug-related offences were serious, they were not deemed abhorrent in the sense envisaged by the policy direction. The court also assessed that the risk of recidivism was high, but there was some prospect for rehabilitation. Given the severe hardship Mr Hong would face if deported to Vietnam, including minimal prospects for rehabilitation and significant family hardship, the court concluded that these factors outweighed the considerations favouring deportation. The court emphasised the importance of considering the community's expectations and the potential deterrent effect of deportation, finding little general deterrent value in this instance.

Ultimately, the court set aside the decision of the Tribunal, finding that the Tribunal had not adequately balanced the factors as required by the policy direction. The court's decision highlighted the need for a careful and balanced approach to deportation decisions, taking into account all relevant considerations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The only description that was available to the Tribunal concerning the events which led to Mr Hong's arrest in regard to the deportable offences was a Facts Sheet prepared by the police shortly after Mr Hong had been taken into custody on 9 March 1995 at the Cabramatta Police Station. The police Facts Sheet said, in part, the following:FULL FACTS: At 5.05pm on Thursday 9th March, 1995 the deft. approached an undercover Police Officer and supplied him with two caps of heroin for $80.00. in the Arthur Street, Carpark, Cabramatta. The deft. meet with the same undercover officer at 5.55pm in the same carpark and supplied the [sic] him with 5 caps of heroin for $180.00. When other Police approached the deft. he ran through the carpark, whilst running away the deft. threw $180.00 on the ground. The deft. was apprehended a short distance away. Police located the money and the deft. was cautioned and placed under arrest. The deft. was conveyed to Cabramatta Police Station where he refused to be interviewed.1. Supply Prohibited Drug – 2 Caps2. Supply Prohibited Drug – 5 Caps3. Possess Prohibited Drug – 2 Caps4. Possess Prohibited Drug – 5 Caps5. Goods In Custody - $80.006. Goods In Custody - $150.00Street Value: $260.00Weight: 1.5 gramsBAIL: It is requested that bail be refused due to the following facts:1. The deft. has no fixed place of abode.2. The deft. has three previous supply heroin offences.3. The deft. supplied twice to Police in the one day.I.SAUNDERSConstable 27814Cabramatta Police Station9th March, 1995.(T: 240) During the course of giving his personal testimony to the Tribunal Mr Hong did not dispute these facts or challenge the validity of any other aspect of his criminal record. He said that his involvement in the supply of drugs had been solely to maintain his own heroin addiction. He had become involved in drugs in 1992. At the time he was jobless, feeling bored and drifting around the streets of Cabramatta. He had then met a person who had introduced him to heroin. Mr Hong described this introduction in the following way:THE INTERPRETER: In the beginning I did not know that he is a user himself, he was a user himself. And later I found out is because he invited me free of charge to test some of his. In the beginning I refused. Then over a period of time I tried it. In the beginning I loved it. I knew I was addicted, I feel so helpless and couldn't help myself. So, I changed to use a syringe and that's how I started.MR MILES: Why did you commit the crimes, particularly providing drugs to other people?THE INTERPRETER: I didn't know much about life. He was with me, he was the one seduces me. So I got addicted was when I was with him and he was a drug pusher. I had no choice because I need the drug on a daily basis. Therefore, I help him out.(transcript 17 April 2000: 38) Paragraph 13 of the Policy Direction provides guidance to decision makers about the factors which should be considered when assessing the risk of recidivism. The Policy Direction makes it clear that a person's previous general conduct and total criminal history are highly relevant to assessing this risk. In particular, the following factors will also be relevant to that assessment:the person commits a further offence after having been warned previously about the risk of deportation. They should expect that the warning will be given significant weight in consideration of his or her case;a person with several previous convictions in Australia should be considered as an increased risk in the light of that past behaviour. In cases where there is a gap or gaps between convictions, the inference may be open that the potential deportee has demonstrated that a substantial period since an earlier conviction is not a reliable indicator that future offences will not be committed;the extent of rehabilitation already achieved, the prospect of further rehabilitation and the positive contribution to the community the person may be reasonably be expected to make.(Policy Direction: paragraph 13)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Given the importance and relevance of the three factors which have just been listed, attention is now turned to the evidence before the Tribunal in relation to each. Following this review the evidence is examined concerning certain other factors which the Policy Direction indicates require consideration by the Tribunal.EVIDENCESeriousness and Nature of the Crime Only scant information was made available to the Tribunal concerning the circumstance surrounding any of the offences committed by Mr Hong throughout his criminal career, including the deportable offences. As the respondent's officials observed in their report to the Minister's delegate in December 1997, written transcripts were not available at that time in proceedings before New South Wales local courts. Thus no official record was kept of the comments made by the Magistrate who sentenced Mr Hong at the Liverpool Local Court in March 1995 (see T: 76). The only description that was available to the Tribunal concerning the events which led to Mr Hong's arrest in regard to the deportable offences was a Facts Sheet prepared by the police shortly after Mr Hong had been taken into custody on 9 March 1995 at the Cabramatta Police Station. The police Facts Sheet said, in part, the following:FULL FACTS: At 5.05pm on Thursday 9th March, 1995 the deft. approached an undercover Police Officer and supplied him with two caps of heroin for $80.00. in the Arthur Street, Carpark, Cabramatta. The deft. meet with the same undercover officer at 5.55pm in the same carpark and supplied the [sic] him with 5 caps of heroin for $180.00. When other Police approached the deft. he ran through the carpark, whilst running away the deft. threw $180.00 on the ground. The deft. was apprehended a short distance away. Police located the money and the deft. was cautioned and placed under arrest. The deft. was conveyed to Cabramatta Police Station where he refused to be interviewed.1. Supply Prohibited Drug – 2 Caps2. Supply Prohibited Drug – 5 Caps3. Possess Prohibited Drug – 2 Caps4. Possess Prohibited Drug – 5 Caps5. Goods In Custody - $80.006. Goods In Custody - $150.00Street Value: $260.00Weight: 1.5 gramsBAIL: It is requested that bail be refused due to the following facts:1. The deft. has no fixed place of abode.2. The deft. has three previous supply heroin offences.3. The deft. supplied twice to Police in the one day.I.SAUNDERSConstable 27814Cabramatta Police Station9th March, 1995.(T: 240) During the course of giving his personal testimony to the Tribunal Mr Hong did not dispute these facts or challenge the validity of any other aspect of his criminal record. He said that his involvement in the supply of drugs had been solely to maintain his own heroin addiction. He had become involved in drugs in 1992. At the time he was jobless, feeling bored and drifting around the streets of Cabramatta. He had then met a person who had introduced him to heroin. Mr Hong described this introduction in the following way:THE INTERPRETER: In the beginning I did not know that he is a user himself, he was a user himself. And later I found out is because he invited me free of charge to test some of his. In the beginning I refused. Then over a period of time I tried it. In the beginning I loved it. I knew I was addicted, I feel so helpless and couldn't help myself. So, I changed to use a syringe and that's how I started.MR MILES: Why did you commit the crimes, particularly providing drugs to other people?THE INTERPRETER: I didn't know much about life. He was with me, he was the one seduces me. So I got addicted was when I was with him and he was a drug pusher. I had no choice because I need the drug on a daily basis. Therefore, I help him out.(transcript 17 April 2000: 38)

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is also satisfied that Mr Hong's prospects of rehabilitation would be minimal should he be returned to Vietnam. It is unlikely that he would either be able to afford or maintain the type of commitment required to complete the traditional treatment program described by Dr Thin in the course of his testimony to the Tribunal. Without any family members to provide immediate support and assistance, and without any realistic employment opportunities, Mr Hong's long-term survival prospects if returned to Vietnam would seem to be very bleak.CONCLUSION Perhaps no power given to decision makers under the Act is as extreme or fateful in its consequences than that of deportation. The permanent banishment of a non-citizen affects not only the individual subject to removal but also all of that person's immediate family. It is for this reason that it is a power which should be exercised with great care by the Tribunal. As the Policy Direction indicates, in exercising this power the Tribunal has a responsibility to protect the community from the possibility of further criminal behaviour, and to remove from the community persons whose actions are so abhorrent that they should not be allowed to remain within it. It was the Australian community which originally proffered to Mr Hong and his family a safe haven from their harrowing experiences in Vietnam. Mr Hong has now been a resident in Australia for the majority of his life, including those critical and formative years between 12 and 18 when he achieved adulthood. As an adult Mr Hong has been convicted of a number of serious drug related offences and both he and his family have suffered significantly as a result of that offending. The Australian community has suffered as well, and it has every right to demand that it should not be further exposed to unacceptable risks of re-offending by Mr Hong. Nonetheless, having regard to all of the evidence before it the Tribunal is satisfied that despite the level of risk of Mr Hong becoming involved in further drug related offences the very severe hardship that would be inflicted upon him should he be returned to Vietnam is sufficient on this occasion to outweigh the factors favouring his deportation. The Tribunal believes that the Australian community has sufficient understanding of and compassion for persons who are afflicted by the scourge of heroin addiction. It is a regrettable but widely known fact that many Australian families are touched by this tragic problem, and are required to cope with children who become entrapped in the heroin trade as a result of their own craving for the drug. There remains a hope that Mr Hong has now reached an age at which he may be able to remove himself from this trap with the assistance of his family and the professional advice and aid which has been identified. None of those possibilities would seem to be available to him in Vietnam. There would also seem to be little general deterrent value in deporting a person like Mr Hong whose criminal activities have been driven to such a significant degree by an addiction to heroin.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Cross-examined by Mr Miles, Dr Thin said that he would be optimistic about a case like Mr Hong's who had not used heroin for a period of two years while in gaol. Dr Thin said that there had not been successful treatment of hepatitis C in Vietnam. They had also not been very successful in treating heroin addiction which was a very difficult matter and required treatment for the whole of a patient's life. Dr Thin also said that no members of his Institute spoke Cantonese and that a patient who attended with such a language background would require counselling and other advice from another organisation which did have staff who spoke Cantonese (see in general transcript 19 June 2000: 39-46).CONSIDERATIONPolicy and Submissions As is clear from the general statement of facts and chronology of events set out at the commencement of this decision this matter has now been the subject of extensive review both by this Tribunal and by the Federal Court. The present hearing of this matter occupied seven days and the Tribunal had the benefit of receiving substantial and additional evidence about a number of the factors relevant to its decision making function within the framework of the Act and the Policy Direction. In their respective submissions to the Tribunal both parties referred to the circumstances which had led to the remittal of the case back to the Tribunal by Madgwick J in the Federal Court. Mr Johnson, on behalf of the respondent, emphasised that it was now for the Tribunal to assess the merits of the case and any suggestion that these merits had already been assessed by Madgwick J, or that it was open to Madgwick J to assess them, was plainly incorrect. Justice Madgwick was hearing an appeal on a question of law and the case really was determined, as in the Full Court decision of Rokobatini by the fact that the Tribunal had regard to the old criminal deportation policy rather than to the new Policy Direction. The Tribunal is in complete agreement with these contentions advanced on behalf of the respondent, recognising that it is now required to make a fresh decision on the merits having regard to all of the evidence presented during what was not only a protracted but quite strongly contested hearing. The Tribunal is also now able to have the benefit of the guidance and direction provided by a number of Federal Court decisions which have considered the interpretation of the new Policy Direction: see Rokobatini; Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1713; and Lau v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2000) FCA 698 (hereinafter Lau). As the Full Federal Court said in the most recent decision of Lau, the Policy Direction makes it clear:… that it is necessary to balance a number of important factors in reaching a decision as to deportation. A decision-maker is required to have due regard to the importance placed by the government on the two primary considerations nominated, but it states a balancing process should also be adopted, one which takes into account all relevant considerations. It is clear that it is open to a decision maker to regard the primary considerations as not governing the outcome in a particular case. It has been held that the Direction does not have the rigid operation as that for which the appellant contends: Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1713 (Sackville J).(per Kiefel, North, Mansfield JJ at para 29)