Mai and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 786

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N98/793

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION        )          
           Re      CUONG NGOC MAI          
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President

Date7 September 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is set aside and the matter is directed back to the Minister with a direction that Mr Mai not be deported.   
  (Sgd Dr D Chappell)
  ..............................................
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
  IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – criminal deportation – citizen of Vietnam – entry into Australia age 12 – refugee from Vietnam – convictions for drug related offences – history of drug use and dependence – prior warning with regard to possible deportation - consideration of seriousness of the offences – not abhorrent in the sense envisaged by the policy direction – risk of recidivism high – some prospect for rehabilitation – consideration of deterrent factor – little general deterrent value – consideration of hardship – applicant's family Australian citizens - consideration of conditions in Vietnam – applicant has virtually not ties to Vietnam - prospect for rehabilitation in Vietnam minimal – applicant would suffer severe hardship in Vietnam – applicant's formative years spent in Australia – consideration of the expectations of the Australian community – Australian community should not be exposed to further risks – weighing of factors against deportation – decision set aside
Migration Act 1958 s 200
Hong v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 1567
Hong v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 634
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 1238
Danionel Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 1713
New South Wales Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985

REASONS FOR DECISION

September 2000     Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President           

  1. Mr Cuong Ngoc Mai, the applicant, seeks review of a decision of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Minister), made pursuant to s200 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act), to deport him from Australia. The Tribunal's jurisdiction to review that decision is granted by s500(1)(a) of the Act.

  2. Mr Julian Van Aalst, of counsel, represented Mr Mai on a pro bono basis at the hearing.  Mr Mai appeared in person and gave personal testimony to the Tribunal.  The Tribunal was assisted by the help of an interpreter, Ms Anna Nguyen.  The following witnesses also testified on Mr Mai's behalf:

    Tung Ngoc Mai
    Truynh Huynh

  3. Mr Jennan Ambikapathy, a departmental advocate, represented the respondent at the hearing.  The following witness also testified on behalf of the
    respondent:

    Dr Robert David Lewin

  4. The Tribunal had before it documents filed for the purposes of s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T and S documents). The Tribunal received no exhibits.
    CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS

  5. The following facts and chronology of events, which led to the present proceedings, were not a matter of dispute between the parties.  Mr Mai was born in Vietnam on 1 October 1973.  Mr Mai's…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mai and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 786
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Mai and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the applicant, a Vietnamese citizen, was the subject of a deportation order issued under the Migration Act 1958. Mai had entered Australia as a refugee at the age of 12 and had accumulated a history of drug-related convictions. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Minister’s decision to deport Mai should be affirmed or set aside. The primary legal issues concerned the balance between the severity of Mai's criminal offences, the potential for rehabilitation, the hardship that deportation would cause to Mai and his family, and the implications for the Australian community.

The Federal Court examined the evidence presented, including the seriousness of Mai's drug-related offences, which involved supplying heroin, and his repeated reoffending despite previous warnings and imprisonment. The Court also considered the likelihood of Mai's reoffending, the prospects for his rehabilitation in Australia versus Vietnam, and the hardship that deportation would impose on him and his family, all of whom are Australian citizens. The Court found that while the offences were serious, the potential for severe hardship in Vietnam, where Mai had virtually no ties, weighed heavily against deportation. The Court concluded that the risk of reoffending, although present, did not outweigh the significant hardship that deportation would cause.

In light of these considerations, the Court set aside the Minister’s decision to deport Mai, recognising the severe hardship that would result from his return to Vietnam. The Court's decision underscores the need for a balanced approach when exercising deportation powers, particularly when the individual in question has spent a significant portion of their life in Australia and has family ties here.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Given the importance and relevance of the three factors which have just been listed, attention is now turned to the evidence before the Tribunal in relation to each. Following this review the evidence is examined concerning certain other factors which the Policy Direction indicates require consideration by the Tribunal.EVIDENCESeriousness and Nature of the Crime Only scant information was made available to the Tribunal concerning the circumstances surrounding any of the offences committed by Mr Mai throughout his criminal career, including deportable offences. The Tribunal did have before it the transcript of proceedings for the trial of Mr Mai in Fairfield Local Court in Cabramatta relating to Mr Mai's first deportable offence. In that matter the magistrate was recorded as stating the following:….Well Mr Mai these are serious matters. Supplying heroin. And of course you were on bail to the district court for doing the same thing after being sentenced to imprisonment. Now I can't say whether, I can't comment on what happened at Liverpool because I didn't hear the submissions or the pre-sentence report. I don't even know whether you were suitable for alternatives to imprisonment. But you were sentenced to three months hard labour from October last year until January 1993 on a breach of community service order, so you wouldn't have been eligible for a cso. And of course in February just shortly after getting out of jail you were convicted of supplying heroin… without knowing the specifics of the case I can't comment further. But having been released on bail on the six month sentence for supplying heroin – straight away virtually, well certainly within a couple of months, you were supplying heroin again. And supplying it for money, possibly to feed the drug habit. Probably that's the situation. But after looking at your record and all of the circumstances there simply is no alternative to full time imprisonment. People are dying in the streets of heroin overdoses. There can't be more serious matters come before these local courts than supply heroin. And people's lives are being destroyed by heroin and you're of sufficient age to realise that selling heroin is just worsening the problem. I'll bear in mind the plea of guilty and the matters raised by Miss Jones [Mr Mai's representative] on your behalf. The decision of the court in relation to the supply heroin is that you are sentenced to nine months hard labour… additional three months subject to probation and parole supervision….(T: 23) The Tribunal also had before it the judgment of Judge Tupman, of the New South Wales District Court, in Mr Mai's appeal against the severity of the sentence handed down to him in Fairfield Local Court, Cabramatta for the conviction of supply heroin in 1997. It was this conviction which led to the issue of the deportation order, and the present proceedings before this Tribunal. Mr Justice Tupman's judgment stated in part:…The facts are that the appellant [Mr Mai] supplied two small balloon packages of heroin to an undercover police officer in John Street Cabramatta on 21 March 1997 in return for sixty dollars.The appellant pleaded guilty at the first opportunity. The appellant has a significant criminal history, including convictions for similar offences which have led to periods of imprisonment, two in 1993 and again in 1995. The appellant was also given the benefit of recognizance under Section 558 of the Crimes Act in March 1995, with a bond of two years being imposed for the offence of possession of a prohibited drug, in fact that bond came to an end just five days before this offence was committed.The appellant is clearly a heroin addict and had been I accept for some four years, although there have been some times when he has not used heroin. He claims to have withdrawn from using heroin since going into custody. The appellant claims that on his release from custody on this occasion he intends to change his life. It can only be said that at twenty three years of age, if the appellant does not change his life in relation to heroin at this stage it is highly likely that the appellant's life will be much shorter than it might otherwise have been.The appellant has in the past attempted to use community help projects for Drug and Alcohol counselling and has used the benefit of supervision from Probation and Parole Service, both during the course of the bond and whilst on parole on earlier occasions. He appears to be prepared to cooperate with the authorities in this regard, although so far none of this has been able to cure his need for heroin.I am prepared to give the appellant an opportunity to make good his words to the Court. It seems to me, however, that the overall sentence of fifteen months, given the appellant's criminal record for the same offences is an appropriate sentence but I am prepared to find and I do find special circumstances to break the statutory nexus between a minimum and an additional term, so that the appellant can be given the opportunity to rehabilitate himself in the community with the supervision of the Probation and Parole Service and with regular attendance at Drug and Alcohol Counselling.(T33)

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal accepts as credible the evidence provided by both Mr Mai's aunt and uncle that they both felt for the plight that Mr Mai and his siblings were in. Mr Mai's aunt and uncle were giving truthful testimony when they told the Tribunal that they were unable to give Mr Mai accommodation in their housing commission home. The Tribunal accepts, however, that Mr Mai's aunt and uncle would be available to give Mr Mai the emotional support he requires in order to end his addiction to heroin, and his uncle would also be able to provide him with assistance in finding employment and alternative accommodation. The Tribunal is satisfied that these plans represent a genuine desire to assist Mr Mai. Further, the Tribunal finds that to deport Mr Mai would result in significant hardship, as contemplated in paragraph 24(b) of the Policy Direction, for a family that has made the best efforts it could to be of assistance and support to Mr Mai. CONCLUSION The deportation power is a power with extreme and fateful consequences for not only the person who is deported but also for their families. It is a power, which should be exercised with great care by the Tribunal. Equally the Tribunal should be mindful that it is also under an obligation to protect the community from the possibility of further criminal behaviour, and to remove from the community persons whose actions are so abhorrent that they should not be allowed to remain within it. The Australian community offered Mr Mai a safe haven from the harrowing experiences of the war in Vietnam and its aftermath. Mr Mai has been a resident in Australia for the majority of his life, including those critical and formative years between 12 and 18 when he achieved adulthood. As an adult Mr Mai has been convicted of a number of serious drug related offences. Mr Mai and his family have suffered as a result of those offences. The Australian community has also suffered and it has every right to demand that it should not be further exposed to unacceptable risks of re-offending by Mr Mai. That blanket demand is one which, in accordance with both the Policy Direction and the case law, must still come under careful scrutiny. In this case, and having regard to all the evidence that is before it, the Tribunal is satisfied that despite the level of risk of Mr Mai becoming involved in further drug related offences the very severe hardship that would be inflicted upon him should he be returned to Vietnam is sufficient on this occasion to outweigh the factors favouring his deportation to Vietnam, a country where he has virtually no established ties and very few prospects. As this Tribunal noted in the case of Hong: The Tribunal believes that the Australian community has sufficient understanding of and compassion for persons who are afflicted by the scourge of heroin addiction. It is a regrettable but widely known fact that many Australian families are touched by this tragic problem, and are required to cope with children who become entrapped in the heroin trade as a result of their craving for the drug.(paragraph 91)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established