Holborow v MacDonald Rudder (a firm)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE FULL COURT (WA)

CITATION:   HOLBOROW & ORS -v- MACDONALD RUDDER (A FIRM) [2001] WASCA 91

CORAM:   ANDERSON J

STEYTLER J

HEARD:   6 MARCH 2001

DELIVERED          :   28 MARCH 2001

FILE NO/S:   FUL 105 of 2000

BETWEEN:   VALERIE HOLBOROW

ROBERT BOONA
COLIN COSMOS
KEVIN COSMOS
JANICE COSMOS
MARY COSMOS
SUSAN MOWARIN
LINDA DELOWER
AUDREY COSMOS
DANNY COOPER
DORENE WESCOMBE
MARGARET BOONA
BARBARA SINCLAIR
GAIL SINCLAIR
DORRIE WALLY
Appellants (Plaintiffs)

AND

MACDONALD RUDDER (A FIRM)
Respondent (Defendant)

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Solicitors - Account - Claim for - Solicitor and client relationship - Client claiming order for account - Preliminary questions to be tried - Rules of the Supreme Court O 45 r 1

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court O 45 r 1

Result:

Appeal dismissed

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellants (Plaintiffs)     :     Mr N J Mullany

Respondent (Defendant) :     Mr M J Buss QC & Mr P A Tottle

Solicitors:

Appellants (Plaintiffs)     :     Ilberys

Respondent (Defendant) :     Tottle Christensen

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Cullen v Steen [1932] St R Qd 192

Hutchings v Snowden (1897) 18 ALT 268

Le Mesurier v Connor (1926) 29 WALR 66

Makepeace v Rogers (1865) 34 LJ Ch 396

McKenzie v Beaver (1910) 12 WALR 45

Poole v The Perpetual Executors Trustee & Agency Co (WA) Ltd (1930) 32 WALR 96

R v McIlwraith, McEachern & Co Pty Ltd (1903) 6 WALR 32

Re Bowen [1882] 20 Ch D 538

Re Gyhon[1885] 29 Ch D 834

Re Van Laun, Ex parte Chatterton [1907] 2 KB 23

Case(s) also cited:

Adams v Bank of New South Wales [1984] 1 NSWLR 285

Burrows v Walls (1855) 43 ER 859

Christensen v Christensen [1954] QWN 37

Clarke v Earl of Ormonde (1821) 37 ER 791

Colin D Young Pty Ltd v Commercial and General Acceptance Ltd (1982) NSW Conv R 55-097

Garnham v Skipper (1885) 29 Ch D 566

Jefferys v Marshall (1870) 23 LT 548

London, Chatham and Dover Railway Co v South Eastern Railway Co [1892] 1 Ch 120

Maher v Maher [1961] Qd R 333

McLauchlan v Prince [2001] WASC 43

Ottley v Gilby (1845) 50 ER 237

Rapid Metal Developments (Australia) Pty Ltd v Rosato [1971] Qd R 82

Re Bosworth; Martin v Lamb (1889) 58 LJ Ch NS 432

Re Fairbairn (dec’d) [1967] VR 633

Re Lake; ex parte Dyer [1901] 1 KB 710

Re Simersall; Blackwell v Bray (1992) 35 FCR 584

Re Whitehouse [1982] Qd R 196

Sharer v Wallace [1950] 2 All ER 463

Springett v Dashwood (1860) 66 ER 218

Tindall v Powell (1858) 6 WR 850

White v Lady Lincoln (1803) 8 Ves 363

Wroe v Seed (1863) 66 ER 773

  1. JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This is an appeal from the refusal of Wheeler J to direct the taking of accounts on a summons taken out by the appellants (plaintiffs) under O 45 r 1 which provides:

    "(1)Where the statement of claim claims an account…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holborow v MacDonald Rudder (a firm) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] WASCA 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Holborow and another v MacDonald Rudder (a firm) is a case before the court where the plaintiffs, Holborow and another, sought an order for an account from the defendant, MacDonald Rudder, a firm of legal practitioners. The plaintiffs claim that they retained the defendant between 1996 and 1999 in relation to federal court proceedings and that during this period, the defendant received approximately $1,800,000 and other benefits on behalf of the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs further allege that the defendant has failed to account for all trust property received and seek an order for an account of all trust property received by the defendant on behalf of the plaintiffs, along with other claims. The legal issues the court had to decide were whether the court should order an account to be taken and whether there was a preliminary question to be tried. The court considered the fiduciary nature of the solicitor-client relationship and the statutory obligations of solicitors to keep and render accounts. The court concluded that the defendant is an accounting party and that there was no preliminary question to be tried. Therefore, the court ordered that an account be taken and that any amount certified on taking the account to be due to either party be paid within a specified time. The final orders of the court were that the defendant account to the plaintiffs for all trust property received by the defendant on behalf of the plaintiffs, that discovery be granted in aid of such account, and that the defendant pay all sums found to be due on the taking of such account.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This is an appeal from the refusal of Wheeler J to direct the taking of accounts on a summons taken out by the appellants (plaintiffs) under O 45 r 1 which provides:"(1)Where the statement of claim claims an account or involves the taking of an account the plaintiff may, at any time after the defendant has entered an appearance, or after the time limited for appearing, apply for an order under this Rule.(2)An application under this Rule must be made by summons and must, unless the Court otherwise directs, be supported by affidavit or other evidence.(3)On the hearing of the application, the Court may, unless satisfied by the defendant by affidavit or otherwise that there is some preliminary question to be tried, order that an account be taken and may also order that any amount certified on taking the account to be due to either party be paid to him within a time specified in the order." The statement of claim here claims an account, the relevant paragraphs of the statement of claim being:"2.The Defendant is a firm of Legal Practitioners within the meaning of the Legal Practitioners Act1893.3.Between 1996 and 30 August 1999, the Plaintiffs' [sic] retained the Defendant in relation to the Federal Court Proceedings and all related matters.4.Between 1996 and 30 August 1999 the Defendant received divers money and benefits on behalf of the Plaintiff (the 'Trust Property').ParticularsThe Defendant received payment of approximately $1,800,000 and other benefits including, but without limitation, Frequent Flyer Points. Further particulars of the monies and benefits received are the subject of the account sought herein.…10.Despite requests and demands and in breach of its duty set out in paragraph 9 above, the Defendant has failed and/or refused to:(a)Account for all Trust Property received by it;…AND THE PLAINTIFFS CLAIM:(1)An account of all Trust Property received by the Defendant on behalf of the Plaintiffs.… " Other claims are made in the statement of claim, including claims of breach of duty and non‑compliance with provisions of the Legal Practitioners Act concerning the keeping and maintaining of accounts and the production to clients of accounting records. In the summons before Wheeler J, the appellants sought orders that:"1.The Defendant account to the Plaintiffs for all trust property received by the Defendant on behalf of the Plaintiffs.2.Discovery in aid of such account.3.Payment by the Defendant to the Plaintiffs of all sums found to be due on the taking of such account.… " It is not in dispute that the relationship of solicitor‑client existed between the parties as pleaded in par 3 of the statement of claim, nor is it in dispute that the respondent received money on behalf of the appellants and expended or applied those moneys purportedly on behalf of the appellants. Under these circumstances, it is clear that the respondent is an accounting party. Quite apart from the statutory obligations in the Legal Practitioners Act regarding the keeping and rendering of accounts by solicitors, the solicitor‑client relationship is a fiduciary relationship (Re Van Laun, Ex parte Chatterton [1907] 2 KB 23 at 29) and it is the duty of a person acting in a fiduciary capacity to keep and to render true and proper accounts of his transactions: Makepeace v Rogers (1865) 34 LJ Ch 396; Le Mesurier v Connor (1926) 29 WALR 66; Fridman, "Law of Agency" (4th ed) 137, 206; "Bowstead on Agency" (15th ed) 192; Bullen & Leake and Jacobs, "Precedents of Pleadings" (12th ed) 183.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.