Holani v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Holani v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 1140

MIGRATION – cancellation of applicant’s visa by the Minister – whether decision to cancel the applicant’s visa affected by jurisdictional error – applicant has four children under the age of 18 years – whether Minister took into account as a primary consideration the best interests of the children – whether Minister took into account the best interests of all four of the children – whether Minister gave “proper, genuine and realistic consideration” to the best interests of applicant’s children Joshua and Larni

Held: Appeal dismissed. It is not possible to conclude other than that the Minister did properly give primary consideration to the best interests of all of the applicant’s children aged under 18 years. The Minister acknowledged that the applicant had a close relationship with all four children, and the material before the Minister did not bring to attention the specific needs of any particular child other than that of the applicant’s autistic son, upon whom the Minister specifically commented. The Minister was not obliged to inquire further. The Minister considered the material before him regarding Joshua and Larni in so far as it described their close relationship with the applicant and the support the applicant provided to them. In doing so the Minister gave their interests proper, genuine and realistic consideration. Any error the Minister made with respect to the living arrangements of and the applicant’s access to Joshua and Larni were errors of fact. Ultimately, the Minister found that the best interests of the children should be given substantial weight, but that such interests were outweighed by those of the Australian community. Such a finding is not for this Court to reconsider in the absence of jurisdictional error.

Migration Act 1958 s 476A, s 501(2)

Djalic v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 139 FCR 292 cited
Lei Wan v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 568 cited
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Teoh (1995) 183 CLR 273 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairsv Lorenzo [2005] FCAFC 13 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323 cited
NABE v Minister for Immigration and Indigenous Affairs (No 2) [2004] FCAFC 263 cited
Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth of Australia (2003) 211 CLR 476 cited
Taylor v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 208 cited
Tuncok v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 172 cited
Turner v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1981) 35 ALR 388 cited
Vaitaiki v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1998) 150 ALR 608 cited
Yalniz v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 426 cited

CLYDE KIVALU HOLANI v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
QUD118 OF 2007

COLLIER J
3 AUGUST 2007
BRISBANE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD118 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

CLYDE KIVALU HOLANI
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holani v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Holani v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship involved a challenge by Holani against the decision of the Minister to cancel his visa under section 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958. Holani, a permanent resident in Australia, was notified by the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs of the Minister’s intention to cancel his visa, citing concerns under sections 501(2) and 501(6)(a). Holani and his family submitted responses to the Department, providing information about his four children under 18 years of age. The Minister decided to cancel Holani’s visa on 20 February 2007, citing reasons that were later communicated to Holani.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Minister's decision to cancel Holani's visa was affected by jurisdictional error due to a failure to properly consider the best interests of Holani's children under the age of 18 as a primary consideration. According to established legal principles, failure to consider the best interests of children as a primary consideration in such decisions would result in jurisdictional error. The Court had to determine if the Minister had indeed given proper, genuine, and realistic consideration to the best interests of Holani's children in his decision-making process.

The Court found that while the Minister had stated that he gave substantial weight to the best interests of the children, the actual consideration given to the interests of each child, particularly Larni and Joshua, was questionable. The Minister's Statement of Reasons did not provide specific findings or considerations for each child, leading to the conclusion that the Minister may not have given the best interests of all children proper, genuine, and realistic consideration. This omission constituted a jurisdictional error. Consequently, the Court decided to dismiss Holani's application for judicial review.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The result of this amendment to the application is that the issues for consideration by the Court have substantially narrowed.Background The applicant first entered Australia from Tonga on 5 January 1974 aged 21 and was granted permanent residence on arrival. I understand that he has lived predominantly in Australia during the intervening time. The applicant was given a “Notice of Intention to Consider Cancelling a Visa under Subsection 501(2) Migration Act 1958” (“Notice”) dated 19 September 2006 by the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (“Department”). The Notice specified s 501(2) and s 501(6)(a) as containing the particular grounds on which his visa was liable to cancellation. The applicant was invited to respond to the Notice and did so, as did his family and friends. Responses were received by the Department between 29 September and 12 October 2006, and included information concerning the applicant’s four children under the age of 18, Larni, Nikita, Darryl and Joshua. The Department prepared a paper summarising the relevant details (“the Issues Paper”) for consideration by the Minister, which was received in the Minister’s office on 16 February 2007. The Minister decided to cancel the applicant’s visa on 20 February 2007 and set out his reasons in a document (“Statement of Reasons”). The applicant was notified of the Minister’s decision on 18 April 2007.Relevant legislation The decision of the Minister to personally cancel the visa of the applicant was made pursuant to s 501(2) of the Act. Section 501(2) provides:The Minister may cancel a visa that has been granted to a person if:(a)the Minister reasonably suspects that the person does not pass the character test; and(b)the person does not satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test. It is not in dispute that the Minister’s decision is a privative clause decision within the meaning of s 474(2), or at least a purported privative clause decision within the meaning of s 5E. The Federal Court therefore has original jurisdiction in relation to this decision in accordance with s 476A of the Act. However, the jurisdiction of the Court is limited to the same as the jurisdiction of the High Court under para 75(v) of the Constitution (s 476A(2)). Accordingly, in this case the Court can only set aside the Minister’s decision for jurisdictional error: Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth of Australia (2003) 211 CLR 476 at 506-508 and 511 per Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow, Kirby and Hayne JJ; Tuncok v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 172 at [8]. An error of fact which may have been made by the Minister is not reviewable by this Court unless it relates to a jurisdictional fact or is a manifestation of some error of law, substantive or procedural, which constitutes jurisdictional error and thereby vitiates the purported decision: Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323 at 351-352 per McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ; NABE v Minister for Immigration and Indigenous Affairs (No 2) [2004] FCAFC 263 at [53].The Minister’s decision

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
It is not in dispute that the Minister’s decision is a privative clause decision within the meaning of s 474(2), or at least a purported privative clause decision within the meaning of s 5E. The Federal Court therefore has original jurisdiction in relation to this decision in accordance with s 476A of the Act. However, the jurisdiction of the Court is limited to the same as the jurisdiction of the High Court under para 75(v) of the Constitution (s 476A(2)). Accordingly, in this case the Court can only set aside the Minister’s decision for jurisdictional error: Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth of Australia (2003) 211 CLR 476 at 506-508 and 511 per Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow, Kirby and Hayne JJ; Tuncok v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 172 at [8]. An error of fact which may have been made by the Minister is not reviewable by this Court unless it relates to a jurisdictional fact or is a manifestation of some error of law, substantive or procedural, which constitutes jurisdictional error and thereby vitiates the purported decision: Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323 at 351-352 per McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ; NABE v Minister for Immigration and Indigenous Affairs (No 2) [2004] FCAFC 263 at [53].The Minister’s decision It is not in dispute that, in making his decision, the Minister was bound to take into account as a primary consideration the best interests of the children of the applicant under the age of 18. Failure to do so as a primary consideration would result in the decision of the Minister being affected by jurisdictional error: Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairsv Lorenzo [2005] FCAFC 13 at [57]-[58]. Guidance for decision-makers in making decisions to refuse or cancel a visa under s 501(2) is found in the Minister’s “Direction under section 499 - Visa Refusal and Cancellation under section 501 of the Migration Act - No 21” (“Direction No 21”). Although not binding on the Minister himself, the Minister indicated at para 5 of the Statement of Reasons that he had followed his usual practice and proceeded in accordance with Direction No 21. It is not in dispute that it is relevant for the Minister to have regard to the contents of Direction No 21 in making his decision. Paragraph 2.3 of Direction No 21 states the primary considerations for the decision-maker in respect of a decision to refuse or cancel a visa:“2.3 In making a decision whether to refuse or cancel a visa, there are three primary considerations:(a)the protection of the Australian community, and members of the community;(b)the expectations of the Australian community; and(c)in all cases involving a parental or other close relationship between a child or children and the person under consideration, the best interests of the child or children.” Paragraphs 2.13-2.16 of Direction No 21 contain further guidance with respect to the best interests of the child, as follows:2.13 This consideration only applies if the child is or would be less than 18 years of age at the time when the decision is intended to come into effect. The best interests of any children aged 18 years or more is not a primary consideration but may be considered with other considerations under paragraph 2.17.2.14 Where there are two or more relevant children, it should not be assumed that the interests of each child will coincide, and it may be that the best interests of one child may indicate the non-citizen parent should not be refused a visa or removed from Australia, but that the best interests of another child may point towards visa refusal or cancellation.2.15 In general terms, the child’s best interest will be served if the child remains with its parents. Countervailing considerations, which may point to the child’s best interests being served by separation from the non-citizen, include, but are not limited to:(a) any evidence that the non-citizen has abused or neglected the child in any way, including physical, sexual and/or mental abuse or neglect; or(b) any evidence that the child has suffered or experienced any physical or emotional trauma arising from the non-citizen’s conduct.2.16 When considering the best interests of the child, decision-makers should have regard to the following:(a) the nature of the relationship between the child and the non-citizen;(b) the duration of the relationship including the number and length of any separations and reason/s for the separation; the hypothetical prospect for developing a better/stronger relationship in future (whether or not there has been significant recent contact) would normally be given relatively less weight than the proven history of the relationship based on past conduct;(c) the age of the child;(d) whether the child is an Australian citizen or permanent resident;(e) the likely effect that any separation from the non-citizen would have on the child;(f) the impact of the non-citizen’s prior conduct on the child;(g) the time (if any) that the child has spent in Australia;(h) the circumstances of the probable receiving country, including the educational facilities and the standard of the health support system of the country to which the child may have to go, or return to, should the non-citizen not be permitted to enter or remain in Australia;(i) any language barriers for the child in the probable country of future residence, but taking into account the relative ease with which younger children acquire new languages; and(j) any cultural barriers for the child in the probable country of future residence, but taking into account the relative ease with which younger children adapt to new circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

In his Statement of Reasons, the Minister refers to the children cumulatively, singling out only one child (Darryl Holani). This in itself would not necessarily mean that the Minister has not taken into account the best interests of each of the applicant’s children, in particular Larni and Joshua as submitted by the applicant, if the reasons of the Minister indicated that their interests had been taken into account: cf Mason CJ and Deane J in Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Teoh (1995) 183 CLR 273 at 292; Burchett J in Vaitaiki v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1998) 150 ALR 608 at 614, Lei Wan v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 568 at [283].Primary consideration In his Statement of Reasons, the Minister states that he gave primary consideration to the best interests of the children and that he gave that consideration “substantial weight”. The weight given by the Minister to a relevant factor can not be the subject of judicial review: Taylor v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 208 at [19]. However the issue of whether the Minister actually undertook the task is a matter for this Court. As noted by Toohey J in Turner v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1981) 35 ALR 388 at 392:“In many cases it will be clear whether or not the decision maker has taken a relevant consideration into account. That is not to say that the mere assertion by the decision maker that he has done so will conclude the matter. It may be possible to demonstrate from a consideration of all the reasons leading to the decision, or indeed from the decision itself, that a consideration has not been taken into account in any real sense. Conversely the omission of an express reference to some consideration will not lead inevitably to a conclusion that it was not taken into account. An examination of the reasons for decision and of the decision itself may justify the inference that it was.” (emphasis added)(cf Branson J in Vaitaiki 150 ALR at 631) The key issue in this case is whether, in making findings concerning the best interests of Larni and Joshua, the Minister has in fact given the best interests of the children “proper, genuine and realistic consideration” (Branson J in Vaitaiki 150 ALR at 631; Branson, North and Stone JJ in Lei Wan [2001] FCA 568 at [34]).Material before the Minister In this case there appeared to be limited material before the Minister as to the best interests of each of the applicant’s children under the age of 18. Ms Wheatley for the Minister submitted that there was no obligation on the Minister to initiate further inquiries as to information concerning the children, and indeed this point was not in contention: cf Djalic v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 139 FCR 292 at 314, Taylor [2005] FCAFC 208 at [19], Yalniz v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 426 at [24]. Relevant material before the Minister in relation to the applicant’s case, which is also before me, included:·from the Issues Paper, information including:o the applicant has four children under the age of 18o one child, Darryl Holani is autisticothe applicant has an order of the court dated 15 October 2003, allowing him regular contact with his children Darryl and Nikita, “at all reasonable times as may be agreed between the parties” but on no less than four days per fortnighto according to Ms Susan Amery, the mother of Joshua:“Clyde is a wonderful & loving father. Our son and he are very close. The bond they enjoy is enormous and I fear the Joshua will not be able to understand or cope with suddenly losing someone who is such a big part of his life. He look (sic) up to his father and loves him so much.”oit was open to the Minister to find from the information given that the cancellation of the applicant’s visa and his removal from Australia would have a detrimental effect on his younger children·a submission from the applicant wherein, inter alia, the applicant stated that:o if his visa were removed his children would suffer the consequenceso he had duties towards his childrenothere was a very close and strong bond between himself and his children·a submission from Larni Holani in support of her father, indicating a close relationship with her father. In that letter Ms Holani made no reference to access or living arrangements except to say that her mother has raised her, as has her father (RBRD 1 p 244)·a submission from Leonard Holani, a child of the applicant over 18 years of age, dated 6 October 2006 wherein Mr Holani stated that his five brothers and sisters all relied on the applicant either financially or emotionally, and that “I believe my youngest brothers and sisters would be affected the most as they are still quite young and need a father figure in their lives as does any child” (RBRD 1 p 245)·a submission from James Gordon Wallace dated 1 October 2006 (RBRD 1 pp 248-249) wherein Mr Wallace states that, inter alia, the applicant is a doting and loving father of six children, and that, with respect to the children under 18 years,“Larni Holani, his eldest daughter, presently attends the Carina San Sisto Girls College and again Clyde Holani has paid for her schooling.Darryl Holani is autistic, attends a special school and needs the ongoing support of his father. Nakita [sic] and Joshua Holani attend a public primary school prior to receiving a private school education ostensibly to be funded by their father should he still reside in Australia.”·a submission from Sqn Ldr S J Curran (Rtd) dated 25 September 2006 (RBRD 1 pp 254-255) containing the following:“His elder daughter is Larni born 2 November 1989 completes year 12 this year.Three younger children are:Darryl born 21 November 1996Nakita [sic] born 31 March 1998Joshua born 22 August 2000Clyde paid for his children’s education to ensure they would have a good future.The four younger children show great affection for their father. I think I recall I said in my last letter it would be heartbreaking to separate the children from their father, particularly as their biological mother shows little affection toward them.Clyde’s partner Vicky Wallace has been living with him since 2000. She is very good with the young children and it is obvious that they are also very affectionate toward her.”Findings