Hogan and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

Hogan and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation) [2019] AATA 780 (1 May 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2016/5938 and 2018/1352

Re:Kylie Hogan

APPLICANT

AndNational Australia Bank Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

Date:1 May 2019

Place:Brisbane

I affirm the decisions under review.

.........................[SGD].........................................

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – claim for a psychiatric injury as a result of the applicant’s employment with the respondent – liability accepted for the injury by the respondent – applicant’s failure to undertake a rehabilitation program – applicant’s compensation payments suspended – whether there was a reasonable excuse to not undertake a rehabilitation program – decisions under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

CASES

Nunez and Australian Postal Corporation [2014] AATA 125
Australian Postal Corporation and Nunez [2014] FCA 1095
Singh and Comcare [2012] AATA 652
Comcare and Singh [2012] FCA 136
Pascoe and Australian Postal Corporation [2004] FCAFC 4

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guidelines for Rehabilitation Authorities 2012
Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

1 May 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Kylie Hogan, has worked with the respondent (“NAB”) since 1996. When she left paid employment with NAB, due to an alleged psychiatric illness, she had been an employee at NAB for nearly 20 years. Her most recent position was as a lending associate.

  2. The applicant suffered an alleged psychiatric injury in February 2015, when she received an email from an external mortgage broker who she had interactions with as part of her lending associate role.  

    CLAIM HISTORY

  3. On 17 March 2015 the applicant submitted a compensation claim with the respondent for “reactive severe major depression/anxiety”.[1] The cause of her injury was noted to be, “email from client/broker”. The claim form noted that the applicant had a “past history of reactive depression (2012) – settled without treatment”.

    [1] Exhibit A, T-Documents, T11.

  4. On 12 May 2015 the respondent accepted liability for the injury “adjustment disorder with anxiety and depressed mood” pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (“the Act”).[2] The respondent was satisfied that the applicant’s compensable injury was sustained on the day she first sought treatment, being 24 February 2015. Liability for the applicant’s medical expenses was also accepted pursuant to s 16 of the Act.

    [2] Exhibit A, T-Documents, T16.

  5. On 27 July 2016 the applicant was provided with a rehabilitation program and return to work plan pursuant to s 37 of the Act.[3] These documents were sent through subsequent to the applicant being provided with a draft on 13 July 2016.[4] On 27 July 2016 the applicant responded by email and indicated that she would not be signing the return to work plan, nor would she be returning to work with NAB.[5] The applicant requested a reconsideration of the return to work plan. In this email the applicant referred to the medical certificate of Dr Morris dated 16 March 2016,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hogan and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 780
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for compensation by the applicant, Ms Hogan, for a psychiatric injury sustained during her employment with National Australia Bank Limited (NAB). NAB had accepted liability for the injury, but the applicant's compensation payments were subsequently suspended due to her failure to undertake a proposed rehabilitation program. The applicant contended that her refusal was based on medical advice and that her conduct demonstrated a genuine intention to engage in the rehabilitation process.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the applicant had a reasonable excuse for failing to undertake the rehabilitation program as directed. This involved considering the applicant's stated reasons for refusal, the medical evidence provided, and the relevant provisions of the Guidelines for Rehabilitation Authorities 2012, particularly those pertaining to what constitutes a "reasonable excuse" for an employee's refusal or failure to participate in a rehabilitation program.

The court found that the applicant had refused to undertake the rehabilitation program on two occasions, as evidenced by her emails. It determined that the applicant did not have a reasonable excuse for this refusal. While the applicant relied on medical advice from her psychiatrist, Dr Morris, the court noted that Dr Morris had previously recommended return-to-work programs with NAB. The court inferred that the applicant's preference was not to return to NAB, and that there was no clinical explanation provided for Dr Morris's change in recommendation. The court affirmed the decisions under review, meaning the suspension of the applicant's compensation payments was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Guidelines for Rehabilitation Authorities 2012 were developed in respondent to s 41 of the Act (s 4 of the Guidelines). Section 33.3 of the Guidelines provide that: In considering the refusal, failure or obstruction the case manager should have regard to what constitutes ‘reasonable excuse’, including but not limited to:(a) the medical inability or risk to the employee in undertaking the rehabilitation examination or program – supporting medical evidence would be required if medical reasons are an issue; or (b) a critical and unforeseen incident; And, that the employee’s stated belief that an examination or rehabilitation program is not required or not appropriate does not, on its own, constitute a reasonable excuse. An employee’s request for a reconsideration of a determination requiring attendance at an examination or to undertake a rehabilitation program, lodged prior to the refusal, failure or obstruction, may however be considered a reasonable excuse. APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE The applicant provided a statement in support of her application dated 14 June 2017.[12] In this statement the applicant confirmed that she had not worked in any paid employment since February 2015. She listed some other activities that she had undertaken in that time, including some voluntary work at her sons’ school in 2016, when she helped out at the tuckshop and uniform shop. She stated that as it was not intellectually stimulating she lost interest and she did not return. She also enrolled in a Diploma of Project Management in 2016, but she withdrew three weeks after enrolling and never began the course because she found it “overwhelming” just looking at the requirements of the course. [12] Exhibit E. The applicant stated that she was looking at becoming a self-employed finance broker, and to do this she was required to complete a refresher course in “anti-money laundering”. She completed this course online and it took her around 20 minutes. She stated that she did not find the course easy. The applicant stated that there had been three return to work programs proposed by NAB which were rejected as they went against the instructions of her psychiatrist, Dr Morris, and after this she suggested a “host employment” to get her back into the workforce; this was refused by NAB. In her statement the applicant stated that her current GP was Dr Paul Bryan. Dr Bryan had referred her to her treating psychiatrist, Dr Morris. She met with Dr Morris monthly until September 2015, at which point she states that Susan Magar from NAB adjusted the visits to fortnightly. The applicant’s visits with Dr Morris continued fortnightly until May 2016, when they went back to monthly visits. The applicant stated that she has not seen Dr Morris since September 2016, when her compensation payments ceased, as Dr Morris is no longer being reimbursed by NAB and she cannot afford his fees. The applicant stated that she is currently taking Lexapro. The applicant’s statement referred to several interactions she had with NAB employees and Konekt consultants, with Konekt being the company hired by NAB to facilitate the applicant’s return to work. The applicant met with Ms Christy Livingstone from Konekt on or about 3 June 2015. She later received a report from Ms Livingstone dated 16 June 2015,[13] which contains what the applicant referred to as an accurate summary of their discussion and her previous work duties. The applicant also had several telephone conversations with Ms Livingstone and kept her advised of her medical appointments and progress. [13] Exhibit E, annexure KH-1.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to all the evidence I am satisfied that the applicant refused to undertake the rehabilitation program on 27 July 2016 and 18 September 2016. I do not consider that the applicant had a reasonable excuse for not undertaking the rehabilitation program on 27 July 2016 or 18 September 2016 when the applicant sent her emails or on 22 September 2016 when the determination to suspend the applicant’s rights to compensation was made. I have been greatly assisted by the observations of Jagot J in Comcare and Singh [2012] FCA 136 at [27], I do not consider that there was any rational foundation for the applicant to not undertake the rehabilitation program at the respondent. In my opinion Dr Lovell gave cogent reasons why the rehabilitation program should be undertaken at the respondent.DECISIONS I affirm the decisions under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant submits that the applicant may well have vacillated between being prepared and then unprepared to return to work for the respondent however this is explicable by the nature of her psychiatric illness and symptoms and that the applicant’s evidence that she was willing to, and genuinely intended to pursue a return to work program should be accepted. The applicant submits that her conduct during the period leading up to the program decision supports a finding that the applicant consistently engaged in the rehabilitation process with a view to establishing a suitable program, evidenced by her own steps to identify possible work at a local branch. The applicant submits that her reason for advising that she will not undertake the program is evidenced in her email reply on 27 July 2016 which highlights that this position was based on the medical advice of Dr Morris. CONSIDERATION On 22 August 2016 a determination was made under s 37(1) of the Act for the applicant to undertake a rehabilitation program. The case for the applicant is that the rehabilitation program was not a suitable or appropriate one for medical reasons. In Pascoe and Australian Postal Commission [2004] FCAFC 4 (at [14]) the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia emphasised that the appropriate way to challenge a particular program is to seek its reconsideration under s 38(2) of the Act, this was done in this case. On 27 July 2016 the applicant sought reconsideration of the rehabilitation program on the ground that in a medical certificate dated 16 March 2016 Dr Morris had recommended that the RTW should be done in a different company and not with the respondent. However, on a number of occasions Dr Morris had previously recommended that the RTW should occur at the respondent: he did this when he made recommendations on 9 December 2015 and on 11 February 2016. On 16 March 2015 Dr Morris made a recommendation that the RTW should involve a different role to lending assessors but did not recommend that the applicant work somewhere other than at the respondent. It was only after the applicant and her husband had attended on Dr Morris on 5 April 2016 that Dr Morris made a recommendation on 24 May 2016 that the applicant will need a RTW in a different company and not at the respondent. It is apparent from an examination of the notes of the attendance on 5 April 2016 that there is a reference to the applicant being “Open to return to RTW, not to NAB”. I have made the inference that it was the applicant who did not want to work at the respondent. There are no clinical notes which explain or give any reasons for why Dr Morris considered that the applicant should not work at the respondent and why he changed his previous recommendations. The applicant in her email dated 27 July 2016 has indicated that she will not undertake the rehabilitation program. On 18 September 2016 the applicant also indicated that she would not undertake the rehabilitation program. I rely upon these emails to make a finding that the applicant had refused to undertake the rehabilitation program.