Edison Nunez and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

[2014] AATA  125

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/2815

Re

Edison Nunez

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr Dean Letcher QC, Senior Member

Date 7 March 2014  
Place Sydney

The reviewable decision dated 22 May 2012 is set aside and substituted with a decision that the Applicant did not fail or refuse to undertake the Program without reasonable excuse. The payment of benefits and expenses suspended as a result of the reviewable decision should be made from the date upon which they were suspended. The matter is remitted to the respondent for re-institution of payments and calculation of monies owed.

.........................[SGD]...............................................

Mr Dean Letcher QC, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – liability accepted for psychological injury- rehabilitation program –refusal and failure to recommence work - failure to follow program - compensation suspended – reasonable excuse – intention to return to work - reasonable belief in views expressed by medical experts – decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988; ss 14, 37(2), 37(7), 37(8), 38

CASES

R v Jones [1995] 3 All ER 139

Conners v Craigie (1994) 756 A Crim R 502
A v Police (1999) 2 NZLR 501
Australian Securities Commission v Ampolex Ltd (1995) 18 ACSR 735
Australian Postal Corporation v Pascoe [2005] FCA 289 
Taikato v The Queen (1996) 186 CLR 454
Chowdhary and Comcare [1998] AATA 448
Freeman and Fleetmastrer Services [2013] AATA 38
Finch and Telstra Corporation [1998] AATA 557
Singh and Comcare [2012] AATA 652

Otley and Asciano Services [2013] AATA 18

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr Dean Letcher QC, Senior Member

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant has been employed by the respondent for 25 years in administrative positions at Sydney suburban mail centres. He worked at the Rockdale Mail Centre until it was closed. Although most of the staff from Rockdale were moved to the newly opened Kingsgrove Centre, he was appointed to Croydon Park and then Strathfield. He says that at these two centres he encountered harassment and bullying (which he had not encountered at Rockdale). He made numerous complaints. He applied for positions at Kingsgrove but was not successful. He was notified of his lack of success on 25 August 2011 and ceased work during the morning the next day. He consulted his local doctor, Dr Nigro, stayed off work and has engaged in acrimonious discourse with Australia Post ever since. He says that Australia Post has refused to acknowledge his need for a settled, peaceful workplace, and instead the respondent has insisted on accepting his re-entry to work only at a stressful or distant mail centre.

    LEGAL BACKGROUND

  2. The respondent has accepted that the applicant suffered psychological injury in connection with his work, and has made payments of compensation and medical expenses under s 14 Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (‘the SRC Act’). A Rehabilitation Program (‘the Program’) under s 37(2)(a) of the SRC Act was prepared and, as a final part of it, the applicant was required to re-commence work on 21…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Edison Nunez and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 125
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr. Edison Nunez, was employed by the respondent, Australian Postal Corporation, for 25 years and faced issues of harassment and bullying at various mail centres, culminating in his ceasing work on 26 August 2011. Mr. Nunez applied for positions at Kingsgrove but was unsuccessful, and despite being required to recommence work at Waterloo Mail Centre under a Rehabilitation Program, he did not comply with this requirement, leading to the suspension of his benefits. Mr. Nunez argues that he did not fail or refuse to undertake the Rehabilitation Program without reasonable excuse, and the respondent's decision to suspend his benefits is challenged.

The primary legal issue in this case is whether the applicant's refusal to undertake the Rehabilitation Program was without reasonable excuse under s 37(7) of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The applicant contends that his belief, supported by his local doctor and psychiatrist, that he should return to work at Kingsgrove, and his strong belief that he could not return to work except in a Kingsgrove environment, constituted a reasonable excuse for not complying with the Program. The respondent argues that the applicant's refusal was without reasonable excuse, and his benefits should remain suspended.

The tribunal found that the applicant presented a formidable difficulty in arranging a return to full work and had an honest and reasonable belief that he could obtain a position at Kingsgrove to assist him in returning to work. The tribunal accepted that the applicant genuinely intended to return to work and believed his local doctor and the psychiatrist supported a return to Kingsgrove. The tribunal concluded that the applicant's refusal to attend Waterloo Mail Centre as required by the Rehabilitation Program was not without reasonable excuse. The tribunal set aside the reviewable decision and substituted it with a decision that the applicant did not fail or refuse to undertake the Program without reasonable excuse. The tribunal ordered the respondent to reinstate the applicant's benefits and calculate the monies owed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant has been employed by the respondent for 25 years in administrative positions at Sydney suburban mail centres. He worked at the Rockdale Mail Centre until it was closed. Although most of the staff from Rockdale were moved to the newly opened Kingsgrove Centre, he was appointed to Croydon Park and then Strathfield. He says that at these two centres he encountered harassment and bullying (which he had not encountered at Rockdale). He made numerous complaints. He applied for positions at Kingsgrove but was not successful. He was notified of his lack of success on 25 August 2011 and ceased work during the morning the next day. He consulted his local doctor, Dr Nigro, stayed off work and has engaged in acrimonious discourse with Australia Post ever since. He says that Australia Post has refused to acknowledge his need for a settled, peaceful workplace, and instead the respondent has insisted on accepting his re-entry to work only at a stressful or distant mail centre.LEGAL BACKGROUND The respondent has accepted that the applicant suffered psychological injury in connection with his work, and has made payments of compensation and medical expenses under s 14 Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (‘the SRC Act’). A Rehabilitation Program (‘the Program’) under s 37(2)(a) of the SRC Act was prepared and, as a final part of it, the applicant was required to re-commence work on 21 March 2012 at the Waterloo Mail Centre. The applicant did not re-commence work as required by the Program and as a consequence his benefits were ceased on and from 13 April 2012 and they remain suspended as at the date of the hearing in this matter. Under s 37(7):“Where an employee refuses or fails, without reasonable excuse, to undertake a rehabilitation program provided for the employee under this section, the employee’s rights to compensation under this Act, and to institute or continue any proceedings under this Act in relation to compensation, are suspended until the employee begins to undertake the program.” Under s 37(8):“Where an employee’s right to compensation is suspended under subsection (7), compensation is not payable in respect of the period of the suspension”. The applicant says he was not without reasonable excuse within the meaning of s 37 of the Act for not complying with the Program. The respondent decided otherwise initially, and affirmed this decision in its reconsideration dated 16 April 2013 and internal review dated 22 May 2012. The applicant now applies to this Tribunal for view of the latter decision.WITHOUT REASONABLE EXCUSE ‘Reasonable’ is one of those words which take its’ meaning from its’ context. Dictionary definitions of “having reason” or “not absurd” may not be greatly helpful in a vacuum. In recent times in this Tribunal, what is ‘reasonable’ has been debated frequently in the context of s 5A of the SRC Act, in the context of the phrase “reasonable administrative action in a reasonable manner”. But here the question is not reasonable action or manner but “absence of a reasonable excuse”. The range of meanings given this phrase in decided cases is as wide as the subject matter.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have no doubt that the applicant presented a formidable difficulty in arranging a return to full work. Equally, I accept that he had an honest and reasonable belief that a position could be obtained for him at Kingsgrove, on at least a short-term basis to assist him in returning to work. I believe that he understood that the respondent’s psychiatrist had recommended if not undertook that he should be re-introduced to work at Kingsgrove. I accept that he believed his local treating doctor supported a start at Kingsgrove only and, if the doctor signified differently to Australia Post initially, I think his reversal was genuine when he realised that the return planned was not to Kingsgrove.CONCLUSION I find, on the balance of probabilities, that the applicant genuinely intended to return to work, that he believed that his local doctor and the psychiatrist felt that this return should start at Kingsgrove, and that he himself strongly (rightly or wrongly) believed that he would not be able to return to work except in a Kingsgrove environment. Further, I find that Drs Nigro and Abeya did believe, and convey to the applicant, their view that the return to work should be at Kingsgrove and not elsewhere. In the particular circumstances of this case, I find that the applicant’s refusal and failure to attend Waterloo Mail Centre on 21 March 2012, as required by the Rehabilitation Program of 19 March 2012, was not without reasonable excuse. The reviewable decision dated 22 May 2012 is set aside and substituted with a decision that the Applicant did not fail or refuse to undertake the Program without reasonable excuse . The payment of benefits and expenses suspended as a result of the reviewable decision should be made from the date upon which they were suspended. The matter is remitted to the respondent for re-institution of payments and calculation of monies owed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.