IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
| SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND | Appeal No. 859 of 1996 |
| Brisbane | |
| Before | Macrossan C.J. Fitzgerald P. Davies J.A. |
[Ho v. Queensland Director of Public Prosecutions)
BETWEEN:
TRUNG NHA HO Appellant
AND:
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THE COURT
Judgment delivered 01/03/1996
This is an appeal from an order made by a Chamber Judge on 11 January 1996 refusing the
appellant’s application for bail. The appellant had been arrested on 21 December 1995 on a
warrant issued on 12 May 1995 and charged with eight offences against the Drugs Misuse Act
1986; six counts of supply of a dangerous drug (heroin), one count of possession of a thing used
in connection with a crime, and one count of trafficking in heroin. The trafficking charge is
based upon the six supply counts, each of which involved the sale of heroin to a covert police
operative. All six sales occurred in a period of slightly more than one month, and the total sale
price of the heroin supplied was about $7,000-$8,000. After others alleged to have been involved
in the offences had been arrested, the appellant was located and taken into custody by police at
the Sydney International Airport on 20 December 1995 shortly prior to his departure for Vietnam,
his country of origin. At the time, he was travelling under his own name and using his own
passport.
The applicant, who is aged 22 years, has resided in Australia since he was 16 years old, and has
generally resided with his mother in Sydney and, until his parents separated, with his father. He
has a reasonable level of education and work record, and employment and accommodation with
his mother are available to him if he is released on bail. He has no prior convictions for any
offence. Further, his passport has been confiscated and his elder brother, who came to Australia
with their father prior to the appellant and his mother arriving, has offered a surety of $10,000
which is said to represent the “totality of the savings of the entire family”. According to the
appellant, he was not departing for Vietnam to evade arrest, but to visit a sister who continues
to reside there.
The appellant has four brothers and three sisters, all of whom have migrated to Australia except
for the sister who remains in Vietnam. There is no suggestion that any member of the family
other than the appellant is not an exemplary citizen, and the appellant’s brother, who is prepared
to provide the surety, is married with a child and in full-time employment. Apart from one of
the appellant’s sisters in Australia who is unemployed, all of his siblings are either employed or
students.
Various conditions of bail were offered by the applicant and the prosecution did not ask for
further conditions, although an opportunity for that to be done would be provided if bail were to
be granted. It is likely that the parties could agree on appropriate conditions.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ho v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1996] QCA 23
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the risk factors relevant to the appellant's flight risk, including their Vietnamese heritage, the high value of the surety, and the appellant's attempt to leave the country despite the charges. The court considered the appellant's history, the strength of the prosecution case, and the potential penalties if convicted. Ultimately, the court determined that the appellant's actions and background indicated a substantial risk that they might not return for their court appearances, leading to the refusal of bail.
In concluding, the court held that the appellant's background, history, and actions collectively presented a significant risk that they might abscond, justifying the refusal of bail. The appeal was dismissed, and the order refusing bail was upheld.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case represents an appeal against an order refusing Ho's application for bail. The matter has been heard at a lower court, which determined that bail should not be granted due to the perceived risk of Ho not appearing in court. This decision is now being challenged in the higher court, focusing on the reasons provided by the lower court for denying bail. The appeal seeks to review the lower court's assessment of the risk factors associated with granting bail to Ho.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the lower court's determination that there exists a real risk that the appellant might not answer bail was correct.
2. Whether the lower court appropriately considered the factors relevant to assessing the risk of the appellant not appearing in court.
Held
1. The court held that the lower court's determination that there exists a real risk that the appellant might not answer bail was correct. This was based on the appellant's intent to leave Queensland and the fact that they were apprehended whilst seeking to leave Australia.
2. The court held that the lower court did not appropriately consider the factors relevant to assessing the risk of the appellant not appearing in court. The court found that the lower court gave insufficient weight to the appellant's offer of a $10,000 surety by their family.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In assessing the first issue, the court found that the lower court was correct in determining that there was a real risk the appellant might not answer bail. This conclusion was based on the appellant's clear intention to leave Queensland and the fact that they had already been apprehended while attempting to leave Australia. The court emphasised that the appellant's intent and actions demonstrated a significant risk that they would abscond if granted bail.
Regarding the second issue, the court identified that the lower court did not appropriately weigh the $10,000 surety offered by the appellant's family. The court noted that a substantial surety, coupled with other factors such as the appellant's family ties in Queensland, should have been considered more thoroughly. The court held that the lower court's failure to give adequate weight to this factor was a misdirection of law, as it did not appropriately consider all relevant factors in determining the risk of non-appearance.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that when assessing the risk of non-appearance for bail purposes, courts must consider all relevant factors, including the amount of surety offered and the appellant's ties to the community, and give appropriate weight to each factor. The court distinguished the lower court's approach in not sufficiently considering the surety amount and the appellant's family ties. This decision reinforces the importance of a balanced and thorough assessment of all factors when determining bail applications.