Hislop v Paltar Petroleum Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hislop v Paltar Petroleum Limited (No 2) [2017] FCA 1213

File number: NSD 1383 of 2017
Judge: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 12 September 2017
Date of publication of reasons: 13 October 2017
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for discharge of injunction – where injunction was ordered ex parte – where defendants allege material non-disclosure by plaintiff on application for injunction – whether material non-disclosure – where defendants allege that injunction should be dissolved on materials before the Court – where delay in bringing application for discharge – whether injunction should be dissolved – application dismissed
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 236, 237
Cases cited:

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Allam (2016) 327 ALR 595; [2016] HCA 3

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57

Carpenter v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd(in liq) (2004) 51 ACSR 245; [2004] NSWSC 973

Chahwan v Euphoric Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 1002

Farrell v Delaney (1952) 52 SR (NSW) 236

Fitz Jersey Pty Ltd v Atlas Construction Group Pty Ltd [2017] NSWCA 53

Huang v Wang (2016) 114 ACSR 586; [2016] NSWCA 164

The Owners of the S.S. Kalibia v Wilson (1910) 11 CLR 689

Swansson v R A Pratt Properties Pty Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 313; [2002] NSWSC 583

Syndicate Mortgage Solutions Pty Ltd v Khaled El-Sayed [2010] NSWSC 348

Thomas A Edison Limited v Bullock (1912) 15 CLR 679

Date of hearing: 12 September 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 68
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr A Leopold SC with Ms E Holmes
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Johnson Winter & Slattery
Counsel for the Defendants: Mr M Henry SC with Mr D E Baran
Solicitor for the Defendants: Dentons

ORDERS

NSD 1383 of 2017
BETWEEN:

JOHN HISLOP

Plaintiff

AND:

PALTAR PETROLEUM LIMITED

First Defendant

ROBERT MADZEJ

Second Defendant

MICHAEL CAETANO (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Defendant

JUDGE:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 SEPTEMBER 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave be granted for the evidence of Michael Caetano to be taken by video link from an external site in Denver Colorado in the United States of America suitable to the Court at a time convenient to the Court and the parties in the proceeding set down for hearing before Farrell J on 18 and 20 September 2017 pursuant to ss 47A to 47F of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

2.Liberty be granted to either party to apply on 24 hours’ notice to seek any further directions to facilitate the giving of evidence in accordance with Order 1 herein.

3.Paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 of the interlocutory application dated 6 September 2017 be dismissed.

4.The defendants are to pay the plaintiff’s costs of paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 of the interlocutory application.

5.Paragraph 1 of the interlocutory application dated 6 September 2017 be dismissed.

6.The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hislop v Paltar Petroleum Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 1213
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Hislop v Paltar Petroleum Limited (No 2), the plaintiff, Mr Hislop, sought leave to bring proceedings against various defendants on behalf of and in the name of Nation Australia, a wholly owned subsidiary of Nation Energy Inc (Nation Wyoming). The defendants contested the application, alleging material non-disclosure and delay in bringing the application for discharge of the injunction. The Court had to decide whether the injunction should be dissolved due to the defendants' allegations of material non-disclosure and the delay in bringing the application.

The Court found that Nation Australia had no funds or other realisable assets to make any payments under the Earning Agreements going forward, making it difficult for it to fund works and expenses to exploit the exploration permits. Furthermore, the Court accepted Mr Hislop's submission that Nation Wyoming might not be the only source of funds for Nation Australia, but only one possible source. Thus, the defendants' argument that the injunction should be dissolved based on the materials before the Court was not accepted. The Court also found that the delay in bringing the application for discharge did not warrant the dissolution of the injunction. Consequently, the application for discharge of the injunction was dismissed.

The Court granted leave for the evidence of Michael Caetano to be taken by video link from an external site in Denver, Colorado. The defendants were ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs of the interlocutory application. Additionally, the Court granted leave to issue a subpoena to Dentons Australia Pty Ltd and set the return date for the subpoena. Any application to set aside the subpoena had to be filed and served by a specific date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave be granted for the evidence of Michael Caetano to be taken by video link from an external site in Denver Colorado in the United States of America suitable to the Court at a time convenient to the Court and the parties in the proceeding set down for hearing before Farrell J on 18 and 20 September 2017 pursuant to ss 47A to 47F of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

2. Liberty be granted to either party to apply on 24 hours’ notice to seek any further directions to facilitate the giving of evidence in accordance with Order 1 herein.

3. Paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 of the interlocutory application dated 6 September 2017 be dismissed.

4. The defendants are to pay the plaintiff’s costs of paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 of the interlocutory application.

5. Paragraph 1 of the interlocutory application dated 6 September 2017 be dismissed.

6. The defendants to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the application made in paragraph 1 of the interlocutory application dated 6 September 2017.

7. Grant leave to the plaintiff to file electronically an interlocutory process dated 12 September 2017, such interlocutory process to be made returnable instanter.

8. Grant leave to issue a subpoena to Dentons Australia Pty Ltd.

9. The subpoena referred to in Order 8 to be served on Dentons Australia Pty Ltd by 5.30 pm today and the time for service is abridged accordingly.

10. The subpoena referred to in Order 8 to be made returnable at 2.15 pm on 15 September 2017 before Gleeson J.

11. Any application to set aside the subpoena referred to in Order 8 and affidavits in support of that application to be filed and served by 4.00 pm on 13 September 2017.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Clause 5.3(b)(i) of the Earning Agreements requires Nation Australia to pay all work program expenses “[a]s soon as practicable after [it] has such funds conveniently available”, at which time it must deliver to Paltar the full amount of the Work Program and Budget costs incurred for the third Permit Year and those estimated for the fourth Permit Year. Mr Hislop pointed out that in paragraph 11 of the affidavit affirmed on 12 August 2017 by Carmen (Tony) Lotito, the executive vice president of Paltar, Mr Lotito deposed, among other things, that Nation Australia had no funds or other realisable assets to make any payments under the Earning Agreements going forward and that it had no source of funds available to it for those payments. That being so, it is difficult to see how Nation Australia would return to a position in which it would be liable to fund works and expenses to exploit the exploration permits. But more fundamental is Mr Hislop’s submission, which I accepted, that Nation Wyoming may not be the only source of funds for Nation Australia but only one possible source. In those circumstances, the SEC Report and the statement that Nation Wyoming did not currently have sufficient funds to acquire and develop, among other things, the third amended and restated agreement with Paltar cannot be said to be material. The decision in Huang The defendants submitted that at [85]-[87] of Huang Barrett AJA observed that an application under s 237 of the Corporations Act is solely a matter of internal governance and domestic concern of the relevant company and that, generally speaking, unrelated third parties who the applicant wishes to see the company sue are not necessary parties. The defendants contended that this was plainly material to whether the Court should grant the Injunction because if, as the first to fourth defendants contend, they are unnecessary parties then there was no serious question to be tried between Mr Hislop and those defendants. In Huang the New South Wales Court of Appeal had before it an appeal from a decision to dismiss a summons brought pursuant to s 237 of the Corporations Act. At [85]-[87] Barrett AJA said:85A person with standing under s 236(1) may file a s 237 leave application which merely names the company itself as respondent and identifies the case that the person wishes the company to pursue against some unrelated third party. A recent example of such a case is Cooper v Myrtace Consulting Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 480. Because the reason for the application is usually the unwillingness of the company to bring the proceeding in question, the likelihood is that the company will oppose the application. In such a case, the debate is solely on an issue of internal governance and domestic concern: whether the company should sue the third party and whether the applicant, who otherwise lacks the ability to put the company into motion, has established a statutory entitlement to act on the company’s behalf in that respect. The only persons legitimately interested in that debate are the applicant and the company.86When a s 237 application is framed and advanced in the way just described, the only parties to the controversy before the court are the applicant and the company. It follows that an order granting leave under s 237 in such a case is an order that finally disposes of the rights of those parties regarding the relevant subject matter, being the question whether the applicant should be permitted to bring the particular action on the company’s behalf.87 Generally speaking, the unrelated third party that the s 237 applicant wishes to see the company sue is not a necessary party to the s 237 application: see Carpenter v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd (in liq) (2004) 51 ACSR 245; 186 FLR 104; [2004] NSWSC 973 (leave to appeal refused by this Court on 20 May 2005); Roach v Winnote Pty Ltd; Leslie (2006) 227 ALR 758; 57 ACSR 138; [2006] NSWSC 231; O’Meara v FWV Stanke Holdings Pty Ltd [2007] SASC 286. But if, as in McEvoy v Caplan, the application for leave is brought in existing proceedings and the applicant actively involves the third party in the application, that issue is preempted or sidestepped by the applicant’s own decision to proceed in that particular way: see, for example Chahwan v Euphoric Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 1002 at [9]-[15].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The final relief sought by Mr Hislop is an order pursuant to s 237 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) that he be granted leave to bring proceedings against the first to fourth defendants on behalf of and in the name of Nation Australia. Nation Australia is a wholly owned subsidiary of Nation Energy Inc (Nation Wyoming). Mr Hislop and Paltar are shareholders in Nation Wyoming. Messrs Madzej, Caetano and Causbrook are directors of Nation Australia. The nature of the claim that Mr Hislop seeks leave to bring, should he be successful in obtaining an order pursuant to s 237 of the Corporations Act, is set out in a draft document titled "Draft Outline of Proposed Claim (Revised)" (Proposed Claim) annexed to the amended originating process. A summary of the proposed claim is included in my reasons for judgment delivered on 8 September 2017 in relation to Mr Hislop's application to set aside a notice to produce dated 29 August 2017 that was served by the defendants: see Hislop v Paltar Petroleum Limited [2017] FCA 1078 at [5]-[8]. I do not propose to repeat that summary here. The proceeding was initially set down for hearing on 5 September 2017. However, for reasons that were unavoidable and through no fault of the parties, the hearing was adjourned to 18 September 2017. On 5 September 2017, at the same time the hearing was adjourned, the Court made orders for the defendants to file any application for security for costs or for variation or discharge of the Injunction, which had been extended and was at that time again extended by order of the Court. On 6 September 2017 the defendants filed an interlocutory process seeking orders to that effect (Defendants’ Interlocutory Process). The Defendants’ Interlocutory Process came before me for hearing on 11 and 12 September 2017. Because the defendants did not press their application for security for costs, the only matter before me for determination was the application for variation or discharge of the Injunction. After hearing from the parties I dismissed the Defendants’ Interlocutory Process. These are my reasons for doing so.PROCEDURAL HISTORY As I have already observed, this proceeding was commenced on an urgent basis. The matter first came before the commercial and corporations duty judge on 11 August 2017 on an ex parte basis. Relevantly, the Court made an order that:Upon the plaintiff by his counsel giving to the Court the usual undertaking as to damages which undertaking is hereby noted and upon the solicitor for the plaintiff undertaking to pay any further applicable filing feesTHE COURT:…5. ORDERS that up to and including Tuesday 15 August 2017, the defendants by themselves, their servants or agents and in any way howsoever be restrained from in any way taking or participating in any steps to:(a) Enforce or give effect to the (or the proposed) Settlement Agreement and Release of All Claims (between the first defendant and Nation Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd (Nation Australia);(b) Enforce or give effect to any of the (or the proposed) Surrender Agreements (between the first defendant and Nation Australia); and/or(c) Exploit any of the Earning Agreements by granting any right, title or interest in any of the Earning Agreements to any other person and/or otherwise deal in any way with any right, title or interest in any of the Earning Agreements.