Hipkins v ACT Planning and Land Authority & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

HIPKINS v ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY & ORS (Administrative Review) [2022] ACAT 41

AT 97/2021

Catchwords:               ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – planning and development – proposed development of dual occupancy in RZ1 – multiple issues raised under the Multi-unit Housing Dwelling Code – inaccurate site area affecting calculation of plot ratio – whether stair area included in gross floor area calculation – designed according to site conditions but consequential issues with setbacks, fences and courtyard walls – consideration of contribution to streetscape – safety of basement ramps and functionality of basement car parking – not inconsistent with zone objectives

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 68

Common Boundaries Act 1981
Planning and Development Act 2007 ss 50, 119

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        Australian/New Zealand Standard – Parking facilities – Off-Street Parking – AS 2890.1

Territory Plan
Multi Unit Housing Development Code

Planning for Bushfire Risk Mitigation General Code

Residential Boundary Fences General Code
RZ1 Suburban Zone

Cases cited:Downer Community Association and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2007] ACTAAT 20

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 24 ALR 577
Eldridge v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2020] ACAT 22
Glass v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2016] ACAT 96
Goffman & Ors v ACT Planning and Land Authority & Ors [2012] ACAT 7
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Pochi [1980] FCA 85

4thd Planning and Design Pty Ltd v ACT Planning and Land Authority & Ors [2021] ACAT 59

Tribunal:Senior Member K Katavic (Presiding)

Senior Member G Trickett

Date of Orders:  20 May 2022

Date of Reasons for Decision:      20 May 2022

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AT 97/2021

BETWEEN:

MARCUS HIPKINS
Applicant

AND:

ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY
First Respondent

TERENCE PHILLIP RING

First Party Joined

D&H DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD

Second Party Joined

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member K Katavic (Presiding)

Senior Member G Trickett

DATE:20 May 2022

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision that Development Application 202139020 is refused.

………………………………..
Senior Member K Katavic
For and on behalf of the Tribunal

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. Mr Hipkins, the applicant, lives across the road from a proposed development on Block 1 Section 77 Ainslie (the subject site). The subject site is a former ‘Mr Fluffy’ block which has been cleared. The proposal seeks to demolish an existing shed and some hard landscaping and construct two new two storey dwellings with separate basement car parking to each with landscaping and associated site works.[1]

    [1] T-documents pages 7-13

  2. On 17 September 2021, the respondent approved the development as described above subject to conditions (the decision).[2] The applicant seeks review of that decision on the basis that it is inconsistent with various parts of the Territory Plan as detailed below.

The hearing and evidence

[2] T-documents pages 7-13

  1. The applicant relied upon his written submissions dated 16 December 2021. He did…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hipkins v ACT Planning and Land Authority & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ACAT 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, the applicant sought review of a decision by the respondent, the ACT Planning and Land Authority, to approve a development application for a corner block at Chisholm and Ebden Streets in Ainslie. The applicant argued that the decision was inconsistent with various parts of the Territory Plan, including the plot ratio rule. The respondent initially sought to vary the decision but later submitted that the development should be refused. The first party joined, an architect, provided evidence and relied on an email from Veris asserting the site area, though the accuracy of this assertion was uncertain. The second party joined, the crown lessee and developer, did not file written submissions or evidence.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the site area was correctly calculated and if the plot ratio rule was satisfied. The parties agreed on a site area of 861m², but discrepancies in the documentation and the inability to independently verify this figure led the Tribunal to prefer the information from the site survey and the crown lease, which indicated a site area of 860m². This discrepancy, combined with the applicant's argument that the stairwell area should be included in the gross floor area calculation for every level, meant that the plot ratio rule was not met. As this was a mandatory rule, its non-compliance was sufficient grounds to refuse the development approval.

The Tribunal set aside the respondent's decision and substituted it with a decision refusing the development application. The Tribunal found that the plot ratio rule was not met due to uncertainties in the site area and the inclusion of stairwell area in the gross floor area calculation, leading to the conclusion that the development approval should be refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision that Development Application 202139020 is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 17 September 2021, the respondent approved the development as described above subject to conditions (the decision).[2] The applicant seeks review of that decision on the basis that it is inconsistent with various parts of the Territory Plan as detailed below. The applicant relied upon his written submissions dated 16 December 2021. He did not give evidence at the hearing. The applicant seeks orders setting aside the decision and substituting it with a decision refusing approval. The respondent relied upon its written submissions dated 25 January 2022 and a witness statement of Christopher Gell dated 27 January 2022.[3] Mr Gell gave evidence before the Tribunal and was cross-examined. The respondent also relied upon the statement of findings dated 29 October 2021.[4] [3] Exhibit R1[4] Exhibit R2 Initially, the respondent supported the development subject to some minor variation to the conditions and sought orders to vary the decision. In the course of final submissions however, the respondent’s position changed and it submitted that the development could not be approved in its current form and should be refused. Counsel for the respondent was reluctant to make any substantive submissions on the specific issues raised and explored during the course of the hearing, however the Tribunal indicated it was necessary to understand the respondent’s position on those issues so that they could be resolved by the Tribunal and the parties joined would be sufficiently informed as to what required amending should the Tribunal adopt the course suggested by the respondent. The first party joined, Mr Ring, is an architect who had oversight of the design and submitted the development application for approval. He relied upon a written statement filed on 13 January 2022.[5] He gave evidence before the Tribunal and was cross-examined. He also relied upon an email dated 4 February 2022 from David Stone at Veris[6] and an email dated 18 February 2022 from Kristian Starkovski.[7][5] Exhibit PJ1[6] Exhibit PJ2[7] Exhibit PJ3 The second party joined is the crown lessee and developer. It was represented by Mr Wen Tao Ding. The second party joined did not file any written submissions or evidence. Mr Ding participated in the hearing and made brief submissions only. In preparing these reasons the Tribunal has had regard to the T-documents, the submissions and evidence relied upon by the parties and the transcript of the hearing. The subject site is a corner block located at Chisholm and Ebden Streets in Ainslie. Its site area is an issue in contention and discussed below. The original dwelling was a semi-detached duplex and was demolished as part of the ‘Mr Fluffy’ asbestos removal program. The other duplex was also demolished and is a separate site. It is a surrendered residential block in RZ1 as defined in the Territory Plan. The land has been mostly cleared except for a shed and a substantial mature hedge that boarders the perimeter of the site. The site is not level and slopes down from east to west with a large excavation hole left behind following the removal of the existing dwelling. Mr Ring gave evidence as to how the design utilised the peculiar topography of the site. He said that:The nature of the ‘Mr Fluffly’ block is that during the removal process of contaminated materials the site was left extremely altered with ground levels now reflecting a site that saw extensive excavation; resulting in the design having to combat these large excavations. The hole in the ground created by the removal of the existing ‘Fluffy’ houses shown on the existing survey, but is not the natural ground level of the site.As has been noted the block sees a natural slope to the side boundary to the rear of Unit 2 which in combination with the extensive removal of soil due to Asbestos removal has resulted in the proposal of a terrace that is retained to this side to maintain a usable area that provided amenity to the occupants as this space is their Private Open Space.Part of the approval has required that these boundary conditions do not exceed 1.8m in height from the Natural Ground Level; the proposed retaining wall is to be accompanied by a fence that changes in height to meet this height limit as well as hedging to provide adequate amenity to the neighbouring block as well as the occupants of the proposed Units.The proposed revised plan for Unit 2 incorporates a reduction in level of 500mm, lowering the required retention to the side of the boundary however introducing a cut to the front boundary that would require its own retention.[8][8] First Party Joined submission dated 13 January 2022 pages 1-2

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant also raised an issue regarding condition 2(a)(ii) of the approval regarding the height of fencing/courtyard walls.Plot ratio (R7) MUHDC Rule 7 is a mandatory rule, there is no corresponding criterion. It relevantly requires a plot ratio of 50% which is calculated excluding basement car parking. There are two parts to this issue. The first issue relates to the correct site area for the subject site as the basis for calculating the plot ratio and the second relates to whether the stairwell has been correctly captured in the calculation of gross floor area (GFA). Both the respondent and first party joined submitted the site area for the subject site is 861m2. This is based on information derived from ACTmapi. This was the figure used to calculate the plot ratio. Using this site area figure, the total GFA must be no more than 430.5m2 to meet the 50% requirement. The GFA calculated for each dwelling is 214m2 for house 1 and 216.5m2 for house 2.[14] This equates to the maximum GFA assuming the site area is 861m2.[14] See drawings at T-documents pages 129-147 The parties joined did not obtain an updated independent site survey for submission with the development application nor for the purposes of the hearing. They instead rely upon the email from David Stone at Veris,[15] which asserts the site area is 861m2. Mr Stone was not called to give evidence before the Tribunal and the Tribunal was unable to ascertain with any certainty the accuracy of his assertion or the basis for it.[15] Exhibit PJ2 The Tribunal has before it a site survey prepared by Veris for the ACT Government and submitted by the first party joined as part of the development application which states the site area is “860m2”[16] and the crown lease which states the site area is “860 square metres or thereabouts”.[17] The Demolition Plan has “860?m2” on it.[18] [16] T-documents page 148[17] Exhibit R1, Annexure CG1[18] T-documents page 135 In light of the discrepancy and the inability to independently verify the site area we do not consider R7 has been met. The GFA for both dwellings is 430.5m2 and we cannot be comfortably satisfied that the site area is 861m2 and prefer the information contained on the site survey and the crown lease. For this reason it is over the required 50%. As this is a mandatory rule and it is has not been met, this is sufficient basis to refuse the development approval. The second issue regrading plot ratio is based on the applicant’s interpretation of how the stairwells are to be treated for the purposes of calculating GFA. In this development the area occupied by the stairs has only been counted once in the calculation of the GFA. The applicant submits the area of the stairwell should be included in the GFA calculation for every level. He relied upon the definition of GFA in the Territory Plan and contented that nothing in the definition suggests stairs are only counted once or that it required looking at whether the areas were usable or walkable.