Hillier v Hewett No. Scciv-00-1141

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

HILLIER v HEWETT
[2001] SASC 225

Full Court:  Olsson, Perry and Gray JJ

  1. OLSSON J           This is an appeal against an assessment of damages by a District Court Judge.  It is complained that the learned trial judge erred in concluding that an injury to the respondent’s L4-5 disc was caused by her involvement in a relevant motor vehicle accident;  that a finding that back pain was experienced by the respondent at about the time of the accident and has remained much the same ever since was against the weight of the evidence;  that the award made for pain and suffering was manifestly excessive;  and that the award for future economic loss was also manifestly excessive – specifically because, it was said, the learned trial judge did not have particular regard to the respondent’s capacity to take on a second part time job and her capacity to retrain in sedentary work.

    The narrative facts

  2. It was never disputed that, on 17 December 1994, the respondent was involved in a motor vehicle accident whilst driving an old Toyota Celica in a northerly direction along a street in Mt Gambier.  She was then 22 years of age.

  3. At the time of the accident the respondent was in the process of making a right turn into the driveway of the house where she was living.  Her vehicle was struck by a heavy motor cycle which had been travelling in the opposite direction, along the same street.  The learned trial judge pointed out that the configuration of the road made it difficult for the respondent to see the oncoming motor cycle.  The extent of damage to the car was suggestive of excessive speed on the part of the appellant.

  4. When the proceedings came before the learned trial judge he was informed that liability had, earlier. been determined in the Magistrates Court.  It was there ordered that the respondent receive 70% of her damages to be assessed.  The matter came before the learned trial judge for that assessment, consequent upon the transfer of the action to the District Court.

  5. In the course of his reasons the learned trial judge made these specific points:-

    .the respondent believed that, on impact, her vehicle was, literally, lifted from the ground and pushed a few metres to her left;

    .photographs taken post accident revealed that the damage to the vehicle was extensive;

    .the impact was clearly violent enough to have caused the injuries complained of by the respondent;

    .neither door to the vehicle could be opened and the respondent was extricated through the driver’s side window;

    .the respondent had been taken completely by surprise and had not been prepared for the impact which had occurred.  She was shocked and upset;

    .she was wearing a seat belt at the time of impact and, as her vehicle was pushed to the right, her body would have moved left, relative to the interior of the car;

    .it is likely that she did so with considerable force;

    .prior to the accident the respondent was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hillier v Hewett No. Scciv-00-1141 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 225
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Hillier v Hewett (No. Scciv-00-1141) concerned a motor vehicle collision that took place on 17 December 1994 at Mount Gambier, where the defendant's motorcycle collided with the plaintiff's vehicle. The plaintiff was turning right into her driveway at a slow speed, while the defendant was riding at a considerable speed, resulting in a heavy impact. Liability and apportionment were agreed upon, with the plaintiff entitled to recover 70% of her damages. The plaintiff alleged that she sustained an injury to her lower back, which was confirmed by a magnetic-resonance imaging scan in October 1998 that showed degenerative changes with a central disc protrusion at the lumbar 4-5 level, consistent with an annular tear of the disc. The primary legal issue was whether the defendant's negligence caused the disc protrusion, the annular tear, and the plaintiff's ongoing disability.

The court had to determine the appropriate assessment of damages, particularly focusing on the future economic loss of the plaintiff. The trial judge assessed the total damages at $135,000, with the plaintiff receiving 70% of that amount, equating to $94,500. The defendant argued that this assessment was excessive, especially the $100,000 for future economic loss. The court considered the criticisms made about the plaintiff's evidence and the reliability of her account of ongoing pain. The trial judge accepted the plaintiff as a truthful witness and concluded that it was probable she injured her L4-5 disc in the accident.

The court, in dismissing the appeal, found that the assessment of damages was not manifestly excessive. The judge emphasized that the award, particularly for future loss of earning capacity, was at the top of the range but not unreasonable. The court highlighted that the plaintiff's level of earnings over the period before the trial was not a reliable guide to her long-term future earning capacity. Furthermore, the court noted that the award for loss of earning capacity must reflect the extent to which the loss is likely to result in financial loss. The court concluded that the defendant had not demonstrated that the award was manifestly excessive, thus upholding the trial judge's assessment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have had the opportunity of reading the reasons of Olsson J. I agree that the appeal should be dismissed but in part for different reasons. I adopt Olsson J’s detailed treatment of the facts. I recount them in summary form when necessary for my reasons. BackgroundThe Collision and Injury A motor vehicle collision occurred on 17 December 1994 at Mount Gambier between the defendant’s motor cycle and a motor vehicle driven by the plaintiff.[1] The plaintiff was turning right into the driveway of her home and was travelling slowly at the time. The defendant was riding at considerable speed. A heavy impact occurred. Liability and apportionment were agreed. The plaintiff was entitled to recover 70 per cent of her damages to be assessed. [1] I refer to the parties as “plaintiff” and “defendant” throughout this judgment. The plaintiff claimed that she sustained an injury to her lower back. She attended the Mount Gambier Hospital outpatient department. She received physiotherapy treatment for three months. She claimed to suffer ongoing pain, in particular, when bending and lifting and when required to stand on hard surfaces for extended periods. In October 1998 magnetic-resonance imaging was undertaken. The scan revealed degenerative changes with a central disc protrusion at the lumbar 4-5 level. This was consistent with an annular tear of the disc. It was common ground that a motor vehicle collision could have led to such injury. It was also common ground that the existence of such a condition was consistent with the low back pain of which the plaintiff complained. An issue at trial was whether on the balance of probabilities, the negligence of the defendant was a cause of the disc protrusion, the annular tear and the plaintiff’s ongoing disability.The Assessment The trial judge made the following assessment:“Non economic loss $28,600.00Special damagespast $400.00future $1,000.00 Loss of earning capacitypast $5,000.00future $100.000.00TOTAL $135,000.00The plaintiff is to have 70% of that amount, which is $94,500.”The defendant submitted that this assessment was excessive.Findings and Conclusions of the Trial Judge The trial judge summarised the central issue as follows:“If it is true that the plaintiff did suffer continuous low back pain after the accident, it is probable that that was the cause of it. If she had a significant pain-free period, it is argued that one should look to some later event which brought that to an end and which is responsible for the bulge in the disc. In determining whether or not the plaintiff did suffer continuous pain, one is almost entirely dependent on her. Her truthfulness is crucial. It is clear that she was not accurate in everything she said in evidence. Can I trust her on this crucial matter?” At trial counsel for the defendant submitted that the plaintiff should be disbelieved and her account of ongoing pain rejected. However the trial judge accepted the plaintiff as a truthful witness. In coming to that conclusion he considered the many criticisms made about her evidence. The trial judge gave detailed consideration to those criticisms and then made the following finding:“Despite the reasons for caution which I have detailed, I accept her and conclude that it is probable that she did injury her L4-5 disc in the accident and that the appearance in the later MRI is the result.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

OLSSON J PERRY J (dissent) GRAY J
It follows, from the foregoing considerations, that an assessment of $100,000 for future economic loss, whilst being near the top end of the spectrum, is by no means extravagant or unrealistic. I consider that the appellant has fallen far short of demonstrating that it is manifestly excessive.Conclusion All in all, on an objective appraisal of the whole of the evidence, I am unable to perceive any substance in the various criticisms advanced by the appellant before this Court. I would dismiss the appeal. I agree with Olsson J that the appeal should be dismissed, substantially for the reasons given by him. The award in this case, particularly for future loss of earning capacity, was at the top of the range, but the appellant has failed to demonstrate that it is manifestly excessive. I would emphasis that ordinarily, it will be appropriate to assess future loss of earning capacity by reference to the level of earnings over the last twelve months or so before trial, with whatever adjustments and allowances the circumstances of the particular case might justify. But I agree that in this case, the respondent’s level of earnings over that period was not a reliable guide to her long-term future earning capacity. I make the further point that while it is true that the award is for loss of earning capacity rather than loss of earnings, the assessment of damages on this head must reflect the extent to which the loss of earning capacity will more than likely be productive of financial loss. The award must compensate for projected financial loss, not for loss of a capacity which might never have been utilised, or loss of a capacity the application of which might in any event have been interrupted for reasons unassociated with the compensable injury. This is a defendant’s appeal against an assessment of damages. I have had the opportunity of reading the reasons of Olsson J. I agree that the appeal should be dismissed but in part for different reasons. I adopt Olsson J’s detailed treatment of the facts. I recount them in summary form when necessary for my reasons. BackgroundThe Collision and Injury A motor vehicle collision occurred on 17 December 1994 at Mount Gambier between the defendant’s motor cycle and a motor vehicle driven by the plaintiff.[1] The plaintiff was turning right into the driveway of her home and was travelling slowly at the time. The defendant was riding at considerable speed. A heavy impact occurred. Liability and apportionment were agreed. The plaintiff was entitled to recover 70 per cent of her damages to be assessed. [1] I refer to the parties as “plaintiff” and “defendant” throughout this judgment. The plaintiff claimed that she sustained an injury to her lower back. She attended the Mount Gambier Hospital outpatient department. She received physiotherapy treatment for three months. She claimed to suffer ongoing pain, in particular, when bending and lifting and when required to stand on hard surfaces for extended periods. In October 1998 magnetic-resonance imaging was undertaken. The scan revealed degenerative changes with a central disc protrusion at the lumbar 4-5 level. This was consistent with an annular tear of the disc. It was common ground that a motor vehicle collision could have led to such injury. It was also common ground that the existence of such a condition was consistent with the low back pain of which the plaintiff complained. An issue at trial was whether on the balance of probabilities, the negligence of the defendant was a cause of the disc protrusion, the annular tear and the plaintiff’s ongoing disability.The Assessment

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: OLSSON J, GRAY J

Full text does not contain this section.