HGNT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

HGNT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2020] AATA 5181 (22 December 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2020/1993

Re:HGNT

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndWLGP

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member P J Clauson AM

Date:22 December 2020

Place:Brisbane

The Reviewable Decision is affirmed.

.................................[SGD].......................................

Senior Member P J Clauson AM

Catchwords

SOCIAL SECURITY – Family Assistance – Percentage of Care – Consideration of correct percentage of care – whether decision should be varied – decision affirmed.

Legislation

Child Support (Assessment) Act1989 (Cth)

Cases

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 46 FLR 409

Gillson and Secretary, Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs [2011] AATA 473

P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98

Polec and Staker [2011] FMCA 959

Re Drake v. The Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Wade v Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services [2004] FCA 1660

Secondary Materials

The Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member P J Clauson AM

22 December 2020

  1. The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of Child H, born 28 April 2010; Child A, born 19 November 2004 and Child C born 3 November 2016. This matter relates only to Child H.[1]

    [1] Exhibit 1, T24, page 165.

  2. The Applicant notified Services Australia (“the Agency”) on 13 August 2019 of a change in care arrangements for Child H[2] insofar as she was now staying with him for one night per week pursuant to a Parenting Plan signed by the parties on 15 July 2019.[3] Up until this notice, the Applicant’s percentage of care was recorded as zero.

    [2] Exhibit 1, T26, pages 181 to 183.

    [3] Exhibit 1, T4, pages 16 to 18.

  3. On 27 September 2019, a decision was made that there was no change in care and the care continued at zero percentage to the Applicant.[4]

    [4] Exhibit 1, T26, pages 190 to 192.

  4. The Applicant objected to this decision on 10 October 2019[5] and on 12 December 2019, that objection regarding Child H was disallowed.[6] The Applicant then sought a review in the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Tribunal (“AAT1”) of the decision of 12 December 2019 on 20 December 2019[7] and this review affirmed the decision.

    [5] Exhibit 1, T26 at page 197.

    [6] Exhibit 1, T23, pages 126 to 164.

    [7] Exhibit 1, T24 at page 165.

  5. The Applicant then sought review of the AAT1 decision on 31 March 2020.[8]

    [8] Exhibit 1, T1 at pages 1 to 5.

    THE ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

  6. The issue for determination in this matter is whether there was a change in care in relation to Child H from 27 July 2019, as notified by the Applicant on 13 August 2019 and, if so, what percentage of care allocation should be reflected in the Child Support Register from the date the care changed. Also, can, in the circumstances, an Interim Care…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HGNT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 5181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) of a decision by the Child Support Registrar regarding the percentage of care for a child. The applicant sought to vary the Registrar's decision, arguing that the AAT had erred in its previous determination. The dispute centred on whether the applicant had taken reasonable steps to ensure compliance with a parenting plan, which was crucial for establishing a change in the percentage of care.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant had taken reasonable action to ensure compliance with the parenting plan, as required by section 51(1) of the Assessment Act, to warrant an Interim Care Determination. This involved assessing the applicant's extensive correspondence with the other party and her legal representatives, and determining if these actions constituted reasonable steps to enforce his parenting rights under the plan, particularly in light of the child's expressed reluctance to stay overnight.

The Tribunal considered the evidence, including written submissions, text messages, and oral testimony. It noted that the other party had indicated the child's reluctance to stay overnight and that she was hesitant to force the child against her will. The Tribunal also acknowledged correspondence from the other party's solicitors advising a sensitive approach to parenting that respected the child's views. Despite this, the applicant continued extensive dialogue with the other party and her representatives for a considerable period without seeking legal advice or commencing court proceedings to enforce the parenting plan. The Tribunal concluded that, given the circumstances, including the child's reluctance and the advice received, it would have been reasonable for the applicant to initiate court proceedings earlier. Consequently, the Tribunal found that the applicant had not taken "reasonable action" as required by the Assessment Act.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that there was no change of care occurring as at the date the applicant notified a change in care.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a dispute between the Applicant and the Child Support Registrar (CSR) concerning the percentage of care the Applicant should be attributed for the purpose of determining child support payments. The Applicant originally entered into a Parenting Plan with the Other Party in July 2019, which stipulated certain care arrangements for their child, Child H. The Applicant subsequently made a notification of change in care on 13 August 2019, seeking to enforce the agreed Parenting Plan. Despite numerous attempts to contact Child H and negotiate the agreed care arrangements, the Applicant's care of Child H remained minimal, eventually reducing to zero. The CSR determined that the Applicant's percentage of care was between 0% and 14%, which the Applicant contested.

The Tribunal heard both written and oral evidence from the parties. The Applicant submitted that the CSR's decision was erroneous because it failed to consider the Applicant's efforts to restore the agreed Parenting Plan as reasonable actions under the relevant legislation. The Applicant argued that the CSR should have made an Interim Care Determination under section 51(1) of the Assessment Act, despite the minimal care he had of Child H post the Parenting Plan establishment. The CSR, however, noted the Applicant's extensive text messages to the Other Party attempting to enforce the Parenting Plan, and the Other Party's evidence that Child H was reluctant to stay with the Applicant. The Other Party encouraged Child H to participate in the agreed care arrangements but did not force the child to comply against her will.

In its decision, the Tribunal affirmed the CSR's determination, finding that there was no change in care as of 13 August 2019, the date the Applicant notified the change in care. The Tribunal found that the Applicant had ample opportunity to enforce his parenting rights through legal channels but did not do so until January 2020, well after the CSR's decision was made. The Tribunal concluded that the Applicant's attempts to enforce the Parenting Plan, while persistent, did not constitute "reasonable action" under the relevant provisions of the Assessment Act.

This case came before the Tribunal following an appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which had rejected the Applicant's claim for a change in care arrangements under the Assessment Act. The Applicant had sought to vary the care percentage attributed to him, arguing that the AAT had erred by not recognising that his efforts to comply with the Parenting Plan were reasonable. The Applicant provided extensive evidence, including written submissions, timelines of his contacts with the Other Party, and oral testimony, asserting that the child's reluctance to stay with him should not negate his attempts to adhere to the agreed care arrangements. The Child Support Registrar (CSR) argued that the Tribunal should affirm the AAT's decision, contending that the Applicant had not taken reasonable action to ensure compliance with the care arrangement. The Tribunal considered both the written submissions and oral evidence provided by the parties, along with text messages and correspondence between the Applicant and the Other Party. It also reviewed the AAT's decision, which had been made after considering the same evidence and legal arguments. The Tribunal ultimately decided to affirm the AAT's decision, concluding that the Applicant had not taken reasonable action as required under the Assessment Act, and thus, there was no basis to vary the care percentage attributed to him.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In this matter, as contended by the CSR, should the Tribunal decide that a change of care had occurred and that the Applicant’s percentage of care aligned with the Parenting Plan at 14%, there would be no necessity for the Tribunal to make an Interim Care Decision, the actual care determined by the Tribunal and that under the Parenting Plan being the same.EVIDENCE OF THE PARTIES RELATING TO THE ACTUAL CARE OF THE CHILD The Tribunal had both written evidence before it as well as the oral evidence of the parties. At the hearing, both parties were affirmed and provided oral evidence by telephone. The Applicant, at the hearing, stated that he relied upon his submissions filed with the Tribunal on 3 July 2020 as part of Exhibit 3. This material consisted of four pages of a timeline outlining the list of contacts and other steps taken to attempt a normalisation of the Parenting Plan entered into in July 2019. The Applicant submitted that the decision of the AAT1 was in error on the basis that it had not considered that the Applicant’s attempts to restore the agreed Parenting Plan arrangements in accordance with the Assessment Act section 51(1)(d) were reasonable actions in the circumstances. The Applicant contended further that the decision maker should have made an Interim Care Determination under the section 51(1) provisions notwithstanding that the actual care that the Applicant consisted of one night only following the establishment of the Parenting Plan and had become reduced to zero subsequently. In the circumstances, the CSR considered that the pattern of care had changed and determined that the percentage of care for the Applicant had reduced to between 0% and 14%. The Tribunal has noted the extensive number of text messages which the Applicant sent to the Other Party asking for Child H to be made available to him pursuant to the Parenting Plan and querying why she was not being made available. The Tribunal has also considered the Other Party’s replies in this regard where she states that she has encouraged Child H to go and stay with her father on the agreed occasions, but that Child H refused to go and the Other Party was reluctant to force the child to participate against her will. The Other Party told the Tribunal that Child H was reluctant to stay and was:At this stage to only go to day visits and I encourage her and she is very happy with that and comfortable with just the day visits on a Saturday at this stage.[19] [19] See Transcript of Proceedings, page 4. The Other Party, in response to the Tribunal’s question as to how she handled Child H’s reluctance to go to her father’s residence and stay over if she didn’t wish to go, replied: I encourage her and tell her that she should be going - and - but she’s very reluctant. The Other Party stated further:That she should have a relationship with her father as well. Further, she told the Tribunal that:She goes on a Tuesday night for dinner and then she - and then she goes on the Saturday at this stage.[20][20] See Transcript of Proceedings, pages 4 and 5.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal has decided that, consistently with the decision that there was no change of care occurring as at 13 August 2019 when the Applicant made a notification of change in care for Child H, the decision under review is affirmed.DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal considers that these allegations and counterclaims are matters that should be more properly ventilated in the Court proceedings which have now been commenced by the Applicant. CONSIDERATION It is noted from the proceedings at the AAT1 that the Applicant had been apprised of the Other Party’s attitude to the parenting matters by her lawyers at that time insofar as that:In the interim and whilst the children are vulnerable and going through a significant change in their lives, our client suggests you and she take an approach to parenting that is sensitive to the children’s views and emotions. Our client does not agree that any of the children should be forced into situations they do not feel comfortable with and that necessary safeguards should be put in place to ensure their emotional well-being is being adequately cared for.[21] [21] Exhibit 1, T22, page 147. Extract from correspondence from KLM Solicitors to the applicant dated 26 August 2019, transcribed and supplied by the applicant. Although this extract of correspondence from the Other Party’s then lawyers was received by the Applicant, it appears that the Applicant continued to engage in lengthy dialogue with the Other Party notwithstanding the tenor of the Other Party’s lawyer’s letter to him on this issue. He also continued such dialogue well past the date of the Other Party’s lawyers having their instructions withdrawn in relation to parenting matters in early December 2019. Given that a Family Report was commissioned on or around 24 October 2019,[22] the contents of which were alluded to by the parties at the hearing, and the Applicant had received a letter of 26 August 2019 from the Other Party’s solicitors, it is the view of the Tribunal that, in these circumstances, it would have been reasonable for the Applicant to begin proceedings in a Court of appropriate jurisdiction to enforce his parenting rights. The Applicant ultimately sought legal advice on 28 January 2020 and then filed an Initiating Application in the Federal Circuit Court for the purpose of having his rights under the parenting arrangements enforced on 18 March 2020.[23][22] Exhibit 1, T2, page 10.[23] Exhibit 2, Registrar’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, paragraph 41. The Assessment Act requires that for an Interim Care Determination to be made, attempts by the person who has reduced care of the child, has taken reasonable action to ensure that the care arrangement is complied with.[24][24] Sub-section 51(1) of the Assessment Act. The question thus, for this Tribunal, is whether, in the circumstances, the attempts made by the Applicant to ensure compliance of the care arrangement were reasonable. The evidence does indeed, indicate a lengthy and continuous record of correspondence between the Applicant and both the Other Party’s legal representatives (until the withdrawal of their instructions) and with the Other Party, both contemporaneously and discretely, up until 2 December 2019. Up to and beyond this time, he had not taken any steps to consult legal representatives with a view to enforcing his rights under the parenting arrangements. In fact, it was not until the end of January 2020 that he did so. An Application was filed with the Federal Circuit Court on 18 March 2020. It is the considered view of the Tribunal that the evidence indicates that the Applicant had not taken “reasonable action” as outlined in the Guide at Chapter 2.2.4.