HFFV and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

HFFV and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2020] AATA 1712 (7 May 2020)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:          2019/5244

Re:HFFV

APPLICANT

AndTax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:F D O'Loughlin QC, Deputy President
Professor A O'Connell, Senior Member

Date:7 May 2020

Date of written reasons:        11 June 2020

Place:Melbourne

1.The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in lieu thereof:

(a)pursuant to s 30-15 of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (TAS Act) directs that the Applicant be given a written caution;

(b)pursuant to s 30-20 of the TAS Act orders as follows:

(i)on or before 31 May 2020, or such later date as, in its discretion, may be agreed by the Respondent, the Applicant must provide to the Respondent and to the Commissioner of Taxation a report in relation to its primary Superannuation Guarantee and tax obligations, with supporting documentation that shows the information included in the report is correct, that sets out:

(1)in relation to the Superannuation Guarantee obligations for each quarter for the period from 1 October 2014 to date:

(A)the total amount of the Applicant’s salary and wages and other remuneration paid that was subject to Superannuation Guarantee obligations;

(B)the superannuation contribution obligations arising in respect of the salary or wages paid in (A) above (not including interest or administration fee charges);

(C)the payments made to either superannuation funds or the Commissioner of Taxation in respect of Superannuation Guarantee obligations in (B) above and the dates thereof; and

(D)the amount, if any, by which the sum of the payments in (C) falls short of the sum of the amounts in (B);

(2)in relation to the Applicant’s Integrated Client Account balance of $174,587.91 as at 1 April 2020, the likely composition of the outstanding balance, after reducing it by the duplicated entries total of $46,510, that represents PAYG and GST obligations posted to the account, other primary tax liabilities (if any) posted to the account, penalties posted to the account and interest charges posted to the account, by undertaking a process of beginning at 1 April 2020 and working backwards until the total of the amounts in (A) to (E) below reaches the amount of $128,077.91, identifying:

(A)the most recent debits to the account that represent PAYG withholding obligations;

(B)the most recent debits to the account that represent GST obligations;

(C)the most recent debits to the account that represent other primary tax obligations (if any);

(D)the most recent debits to the account that represent penalties;

(E)the most recent debits to the account that represent interest charges; and

(F)the total of (A) to (C) above; and

(ii)on or before 30 June 2020 or such later date as, in its discretion, may be agreed by the Respondent, the Applicant is to pay to the Commissioner the amounts in (1)(D) and (2)(F) above; and

(iii)the Applicant procure that its director undertakes, and satisfactorily completes, remedial education in one of the following courses, and to provide details of satisfactory completion to the Respondent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HFFV and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 1712
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by HFFV, a company operating an accountancy business and providing tax agent services, against a decision by the Tax Practitioners Board to terminate its registration as a tax agent. The dispute arose from the Applicant's failure to comply with its own taxation laws, specifically concerning outstanding lodgements and unpaid tax debts, which the Board considered a breach of the Code of Professional Conduct, particularly under the heading of "Honesty and integrity." The case was heard by F D O'Loughlin QC, Deputy President, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the appropriate response to the Applicant's breaches of the Code of Professional Conduct, given the circumstances. This involved assessing whether the termination of registration was a necessary or proportionate consequence of the Applicant's failure to comply with its personal taxation obligations, especially in light of the director's explanations and the history of the matter. The Tribunal also had to consider the Applicant's submissions that termination should be reserved for the most serious cases of wrongdoing and that the decided cases did not mandate termination in all circumstances.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on a detailed examination of the evidence, particularly the testimony of the Applicant's sole director. It accepted the director's account of compounding unfortunate events, including personal health issues and the psychological impact of assisting clients affected by financial hardship, which contributed to the compliance difficulties. The Tribunal noted that many of the issues raised by the Board had been addressed in previous renewal considerations, and subsequent shortcomings were seen as a continuation of an unresolved situation rather than new or deliberate misconduct. Crucially, the Tribunal found it difficult to conclude that the director was not truthful about the company's cash flow difficulties, which appeared to be genuine and impacted its ability to meet tax obligations. The Tribunal also observed that the apparent discrepancies in outstanding tax liabilities, particularly concerning ICA and SGC balances, were the result of a "shambolic" process between the Applicant and the ATO in resolving the exact amounts owed.

Ultimately, the Tribunal found that termination of registration was not the appropriate response in this case. It concluded that the breaches, while serious, were not indicative of dishonesty or a lack of integrity, but rather a result of compounding difficulties and an inability to retrieve the situation. The Tribunal was influenced by the director's honest account and the lack of evidence suggesting funds were taken from the company for private use rather than meeting tax obligations. The Tribunal allowed the appeal and set aside the decision of the Tax Practitioners Board to terminate the Applicant's registration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

A critical feature of the Code in the present context is that personal compliance with taxation laws by a registered tax agent is a requirement under the heading Honesty and integrity. Headings are part of the TAS Act[9] and inform construction of what falls under them. Here, the breaches of the Code, which are not disputed, call for a response in the setting of their role in an assessment of honesty and integrity and the appropriate response to shortcomings thereto.[9]TAS Act, s 80-1; Acts Interpretation Acts 1901 (Cth), s 13(2)(d). Facts The Applicant, a company, operates an accountancy business and provides tax agent services to approximately 800-850 clients in regional Australia. The company employs six people in addition to its director. The Applicant was formed in 2007 and its shares were acquired by the current (sole) director and a related party in 2009. The Applicant has been registered as a tax agent since 2009. The majority of its clients operate in the small to medium business market: approximately 50 per cent operate agricultural businesses; approximately 40 per cent operate non‑agricultural businesses, and approximately 10 per cent are non-business taxpayers. All clients are clients who require tax agent services, and some require broader accounting services and all clients would not be clients but for the tax agent services provided. The Applicant’s director has a history of community service to the rural sector, specifically to the dairy industry during long periods of turbulence caused by volatility of the milk price and periodical drought. He is also active in community sporting organisations and was involved in providing assistance to those affected by the recent bush fires. In August 2018, the Board considered whether to renew the Applicant’s registration, for the period commencing 1 July 2017, in light of outstanding tax lodgements and unpaid tax debts. The Board noted that the Applicant had previously been issued a written caution and had previously lodged its Annual Declaration stating that it had no overdue tax obligations. At the time, the Board decided to renew the Applicant’s registration from 1 July 2017 to 30 June 2020 after the Applicant’s director advised the Board that:(a)most of the BAS compliance items have been completed and will be finalised today (25 July 2018);(b)he had reengaged with the ATO[10] in disputing the SGC[11] debt and enclosed a copy of the fax dated 16 June 2017 addressed to the ATO Review and Dispute resolution in this regard; and(c)personal circumstances including physical health issues he had experienced and the psychological impact from his involvement with clients who suffered significant financial hardship through the milk price crisis had had an impact on his ability to deal with the Applicant’s compliance issues.[10]Australian Taxation Office.[11]Superannuation Guarantee Charge. The Applicant did attempt to address outstanding issues and complied with an ATO direction following an employer obligation audit in July 2018 to lodge outstanding activity statements. The Applicant submitted that this caused its PAYG-W[12] liabilities for a number of months to be double-counted. The Applicant does not dispute that some amounts are still owing to the ATO but takes issue with the quantum that is owed.[12]Pay as you go withholding.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant submitted that many of the decided cases were concerned with the fit and proper person test, but also referred to Kishore,[34] as supporting the notion that termination should be reserved for the most serious cases of wrongdoing.[35] The Tribunal does not believe that the decided cases determine that termination is necessarily the most appropriate response to breaches of the Code. [34]Kishore and Tax Practitioners Board [2017] AATA 271.[35]Ibid, DP Frost at [20].Conclusions Some observations need to be made of the evidence and of the Applicant’s director. (a)The Tribunal was influenced by what it regards as a searching but thoroughly appropriate cross-examination of the Applicant’s sole director. The evidence of the director and the cross-examination allowed the Tribunal to gain some insights, possibly that the Respondent did not have, into the most likely reason for the development of the current state of affairs, namely an absence of dishonesty, an absence of lack of integrity, and a compounding of unfortunate events and an inability at the time for the Applicant’s sole director, who the Tribunal accepts gave an honest and unreserved account of what he could remember of the events leading to the present predicament, to retrieve the situation. The Applicant’s director’s evidence has been accepted by the Tribunal.(b)It should also be noted that many of the complaints made of the Applicant were complaints made in the lead up to renewal of its current registration and in respect of which the Board thought fit to respond to in ways other than denial of registration. The later shortcomings can be seen as the follow-on product of a situation that the Applicant’s director has not been able to retrieve to date as noted below.(c)The Respondent’s challenges to the Applicant’s cash flow difficulty assertions relied on apparent profitability and apparent positive cash flow disclosed by BAS. These challenges need to be approached and received with care, particularly in a setting where statutory burden of proof advantages for respondents[36] do not apply. Appearances from above or at the surface, of profit and loss statements and the limited information disclosed in BAS, might not always reflect what lies beneath. While they might legitimately be advanced in support of a theory as to ability to meet obligations, neither profitability nor amounts revealed by BAS are necessarily a reflection of cash flow or available cash in every case. In the present case, the Applicant’s profitability was quite a modest proportion of gross fees: for example, in 2018 profit before income tax was 9.8% of reported sales revenue with very modest obvious non-cash outgoing expenses (depreciation and the like). And the monthly BAS is not necessarily a good guide to cash flow either. Again using 2018 as an example, monthly BAS filings, with the limited information they have, suggest a positive cash flow of $184,916 but it is apparent that these filings do not include all expenses. The profit and loss statement for that year reveals interest charges, rent, finance charges and bank charges totalling $191,019 which do not appear to be disclosed in BAS. Combining these indicators, a negative cash flow for the year consistent with the Applicant’s asserted cash flow difficulties emerges. Similar caution is needed concerning dividends and directors fees. While quite modest amounts have been declared and apparently paid or credited as dividends, and in one year a $50,000 director’s fee paid, it is not clear whether payments have been made as there have been fluctuating director’s loans so it is possible that dividends payable were off-set against loans. It is not apparent that funds have been taken from the Applicant’s reserves and used privately rather than in meeting tax obligations. The evidence disclosed very modest bank balances and trade and other payables (which included tax) that exceeded trade and other receivables over the 2014 to 2018 period. The Tribunal is left with the impression that the Applicant’s business was somewhat hand to mouth operating on thin profitability margins, financed by very substantial amounts of retained earnings consistent with the Applicant’s director’s evidence that it had cash flow problems. What is quite clear to the Tribunal is that it is difficult to come to a conclusion that the Applicant’s director was not telling the truth when he spoke of cash flow difficulties, and other difficulties, and that it would be inappropriate to do so given the Tribunal’s view that he was a witness who told the truth. Without going so far as to suggest a Briginshaw[37] standard might be applicable in these matters,[38] where there is conflicting analysis concerning cash flow difficulties, a conclusion that the Applicant did not have these difficulties ought not be made without a targeted and directed cash flow analysis prepared by a person with some forensic accounting or other appropriate expertise.(d)The ICA and SGC balances said to be owed to the ATO are well beyond the amount the Applicant believes he owes and crying out for attention of both the Applicant and the ATO to identify accurately the outstanding primary obligations and the consequent outstanding penalty and interest obligations. The chain of events that has led to the balances recorded as owing by ATO systems, and the seeming inability of the ATO and the Applicant between them to sort them out to arrive at what is likely to be a more accurate reflection of the amount of the Applicant’s primary obligations that are due and payable can justifiably be described as shambolic.[36]E.g. s 14ZZK of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth).[37]Briginshaw v Briginshaw[1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336.[38]In a state revenue context, the principle has been applied in questions associated with conclusions of dishonesty: see R M Tang in Green v Commissioner of State Revenue (Review and Regulation) [2018] VCAT 640 at [18] and [71]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.