Heydon v Perpetual Executors Trustees & Agency Co (WA) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read
45 CLR 111

THE PERPETUAL EXECUTORS, TRUS-

TEES AND AGENCY COMPANY (W.A.)

RESPONDENT. LIMITED

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Onus of proof-Action by executor-Claims on behalf of deceased person's estate-

Money lent-Money had and receivedDefence-Gift by deceased.

In an action by an executor for money lent by a testatrix and money had and received to her use in which the defence was that the testatrix had given the money to the defendant,

Held, that the onus of proving that the transaction amounted to a loan or that the money was received to the use of the testatrix lay upon the plaintiff, and was not satisfied by proof merely of the payment by her to the defendant of the amount claimed.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia (Full Court): Perpetual Executors, Trustees and Agency Co. (W.A.) Ltd. v. Heydon, (1930) 32 W.A.L.R. 89, reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

In an action brought by the Perpetual Executors, Trustees and Agency Co. (W.A.) Ltd. against A. A. Heydon, the plaintiff in its statement of claim sued as executor of Bessie Albo de Bernales deceased for the recovery of £150 for money payable by the defendant to the plaintiff as such executor for money lent by Bessie Albo de Bernales deceased to the defendant at her request and, by an

45 CLR 112

amendment, for money had and received by the defendant as trustee

for the plaintiff. By her defence the defendant pleaded that the said Bessie Albo de Bernales did not lend to the defendant the money alleged or any part thereof and that she gave the said money to the defendant as a gift.

On these pleadings the trial Judge, Macmillan C.J., held that the Co. (W.A.)

burden of establishing a gift was upon the defendant, who must begin. The defendant thereupon gave evidence to the effect that on 14th July 1926 the deceased, whom she had befriended, gave her a cheque for £150, insisting that it should be a gift and not a loan, and that before the death of the deceased, which occurred on 11th August 1927, no claim was made on the defendant for repayment. The plaintiff then went into evidence. His Honor considered that the defendant's case amounted to a claim on a deceased person's estate and required corroboration. He held that the defence failed, not because it had been disproved by any evidence, but because it failed of its own inherent weakness. He entered judgment for the plaintiff with costs.

On appeal to the Full Court of Western Australia this judgment was affirmed: Perpetual Executors, Trustees and Agency Co. (W.A.) V. Heydon 1.

From the decision of the Full Court the defendant now, by special leave, appealed to the High Court.

Goold, for the appellant, referred to Cary v. Gerrish 2: Welch V. Seaborn 3. [He was stopped by the Court.]

P. O'Dea, for the respondent. When it appeared that the defendant admitted receiving the money…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Heydon v Perpetual Executors Trustees & Agency Co (WA) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1930] HCA 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Heydon v Perpetual Executors Trustees & Agency Co (WA) Ltd* involved an appeal to the High Court of Australia from the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The plaintiff, acting as executor for the estate of Bessie Albo de Bernales, sought to recover £150 from the defendant, alleging it was money lent by the deceased or money had and received by the defendant for the deceased's use. The defendant, however, claimed that the deceased had gifted the money to her.

The central legal issue before the High Court was the correct allocation of the burden of proof in an action brought by an executor to recover money allegedly lent or received to the use of the deceased, where the defence asserted a gift. The trial judge had placed the onus on the defendant to prove the gift, a decision affirmed by the Full Court of Western Australia.

The High Court, in allowing the appeal, reasoned that the burden of proving the facts supporting the plaintiff's claims – that the transaction constituted a loan or that the money was received to the deceased's use – lay squarely with the plaintiff. Merely demonstrating the payment of money by the deceased to the defendant was insufficient to discharge this onus. The Court found that the evidence presented did not satisfy the plaintiff's burden of proof, and therefore, the defence of gift, while not necessarily disproved, did not need to be established by the defendant. The Court concluded that the appeal should be allowed, the order of the Supreme Court set aside, and judgment entered for the defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established