CITATION: Hetherington v Mirvac Pty Ltd & 3 Ors [1999] NSWSC 515 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Civil FILE NUMBER(S): 20982/86 HEARING DATE(S): JUDGMENT DATE:
31 May 1999PARTIES :
Garry Colin Hetherington
Mirvac Pty Ltd
Taylor & Scott
Boral Roof Tiles Ltd
KeddiesJUDGMENT OF: Wood CJatCL
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S) : LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
COUNSEL : R.P. McLoughlin SC with P.A. Regattieri (P)
C.Simpson (1d)
M.L. Williams (2d)
G. Curtin (3d)
N. Perram (4d)SOLICITORS: Hunt & Hunt (P)
Minter Ellison (1d)
Colin Biggers & Paisley (2d)
Phillips Fox (3d)
Mallesons (4d)CATCHWORDS: DECISION: Order - Plaintiff to pay costs of Mirvac on party-party basis up to 18 November 1998 and upon indemnity basis therafter; Order - Plaintiff to pay costs of Boral on party-party basis up to 22 August 1995 and upon an indemnity basis thereafter; Order - Plaintiff to pay costs of Taylor & Scott and of Keddies, confined to the claims brought against them for negligence, on a party-party basis; Stay granted in relation to costs orders for 28 days
THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONWOOD CJ AT CL
MONDAY 31 MAY 199920982/86 - GARRY COLIN HETHERINGTON V MIRVAC PTY LIMITED & ORS
JUDGMENT - On costs
1 HIS HONOUR: This matter has been relisted in order to determine the outstanding issues as to costs of the proceedings.Boral
2 It has now been shown, in relation to the proceedings concerning this party, that:
(a) On 6 April 1993 Boral, through its solicitors, made an offer to Taylor & Scott to bear its own costs of the proceedings if they were discontinued against it, and outlined the basis on which it contended that the proceedings against it should fail.
(b) This offer was repeated in a Calderbank letter from Boral's solicitors to Keddies dated 9 February 1995, in which Boral advised that it intended to seek costs upon an indemnity basis from that date, if this offer was not accepted.
(c) On 22 August 1995 Boral's solicitors wrote to Hunt & Hunt, drawing attention to the fact that special leave to appeal from the decision in O'Brien v Boral Roof Tiles had been refused by the High Court, and repeated the offer contained in the letter of 9 February 1995.
(d) On 12 December 1995 a letter was sent advising that the earlier offer remained open and again giving notice of Boral's intention to seek indemnity costs.
(e) Mediation was attempted, unsuccessfully, on 29 May 1998.(f) On 18 November 1998 a further letter was sent to the plaintiff's current solicitors, drawing attention to the very same matters which led to the proceedings ultimately being decided by me in favour of Mirvac and Boral, and making a joint offer on behalf of each of those parties to pay the plaintiff's costs in the sum of $30,000 in return for a judgment in their favour accompanied by a deed of release and indemnity. Express reference was made…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hetherington v Mirvac Pty Ltd and 3 Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 515
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the appropriate allocation of costs among the parties, considering the various offers of compromise and settlement attempts that had occurred throughout the proceedings. Specifically, the court had to decide whether certain costs should be awarded on a party-and-party basis or on an indemnity basis, in light of the unsuccessful outcome for the plaintiff and the rejected settlement offers. The court also needed to consider the professional conduct of the plaintiff's former solicitors, Taylor & Scott, and Keddies, in advising and representing the plaintiff.
The court, in its judgment, held that the plaintiff's claims against Mirvac and Boral were always weak, and the defendants had made clear the challenges the plaintiff faced. Despite the rejection of settlement offers, the court found that the defendants had acted reasonably and should be compensated for costs on an indemnity basis from certain dates. Conversely, regarding Taylor & Scott and Keddies, while their conduct was found to be unsatisfactory, it did not amount to misconduct warranting a reimbursement of the plaintiff's costs. The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the costs of these defendants on a party-and-party basis for the claims brought against them.
The final orders of the court mandated that the plaintiff pay the costs of Mirvac on a party-and-party basis up to 18 November 1998, and on an indemnity basis thereafter. Similar orders were made concerning Boral. For Taylor & Scott and Keddies, the orders required the plaintiff to pay their costs on a party-and-party basis, but only in relation to the claims for negligence brought against them. The court also granted a stay on the enforcement of these costs orders for a period of twenty-eight days.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. It was initially heard and decided on the merits, with the Court ruling in favor of the defendants on the claims brought by the plaintiff. The matter was then relisted to determine the outstanding issues of costs. Prior to this, various offers of compromise had been made by the defendants, including Calderbank offers, which were not accepted by the plaintiff. The procedural history includes the filing of offers, mediation attempts, and several written communications between the parties' solicitors regarding the offers and the basis for seeking indemnity costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Should the plaintiff be ordered to pay the costs of Mirvac on a party-party basis up to a certain date and on an indemnity basis thereafter?
2. Should the plaintiff be ordered to pay the costs of Boral on a party-party basis up to a certain date and on an indemnity basis thereafter?
3. Should the plaintiff be ordered to pay the costs of Taylor & Scott and Keddies on a party-party basis for the claims brought against them for negligence?
Held
1. The plaintiff is ordered to pay the costs of Mirvac on a party-party basis up to 18 November 1998 and on an indemnity basis thereafter.
2. The plaintiff is ordered to pay the costs of Boral on a party-party basis up to 22 August 1995 and on an indemnity basis thereafter.
3. The plaintiff is ordered to pay the costs of Taylor & Scott and of Keddies on a party-party basis for the claims brought against them for negligence.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by noting the various offers made by the defendants to settle the proceedings under the principles established in Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] QB 560, and the plaintiff's failure to accept these offers. It was established that both Mirvac and Boral had made clear offers to settle the proceedings against them, which were not accepted by the plaintiff. Given the weak nature of the plaintiff's claims against Mirvac and Boral, and the defendants' efforts to resolve the litigation, the court found it appropriate to order indemnity costs for Mirvac from 18 November 1998 and for Boral from 22 August 1995, when the Calderbank offers were made.
Turning to Taylor & Scott and Keddies, the court noted that while the firms had been dilatory in their conduct, there was insufficient evidence to find misconduct or improper encouragement of the plaintiff's claims. The court emphasised that the plaintiff had elected to proceed with the claims despite the defendants flagging the problems in doing so. Therefore, while the plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendants' costs, these were limited to a party-party basis for the claims brought against them for negligence.
In reaching these decisions, the court relied on the Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW) and the Supreme Court Rules, which provide for the court's discretion in awarding costs, including on an indemnity basis where offers of compromise have been made and rejected. The court also drew on the principles established in Multicon Engineering Pty Ltd v Federal Airports Corporation (1996) 138 ALR 425, which support ordering indemnity costs where a rejected offer of settlement results in a not more favourable outcome for the plaintiff. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where defendants make clear offers of compromise under Calderbank and the plaintiff rejects these offers, leading to an outcome not more favourable than the terms of the offer, the court may order indemnity costs against the plaintiff from the date of the offer.