Heintje Lange v Bickford's Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read
[2020] FWC 613
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Heintje Lange
v
Bickford’s Australia Pty Ltd
(U2019/11463)

COMMISSIONER HAMPTON

ADELAIDE, 4 MARCH 2020

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – preliminary jurisdictional issue – whether genuine redundancy – winemakers – multiple roles combined – whether job no longer required – whether consultation requirements of modern award met – whether reasonable redeployment options overlooked – duties continued but job no longer required due to operational changes – new role with broader management responsibilities - merit of changes beyond the scope of this matter – consultation after a decision had been made was undertaken and requirements met – whether reasonable in the circumstances that applicant be redeployed into the new position – other positions and work assessed and not reasonable to redeploy – new position not agitated by the applicant as redeployment option but arises from the facts of the matter – whether distinction between selection for redundancy and selection for redeployment – evidence supports the position that objective assessment made about relative merit of the two winemakers and reasonable conclusion in the circumstances – found on balance that not reasonable in all of the circumstances for applicant to have been redeployed within the employer’s enterprise or the enterprise of an associated entity – genuine redundancy found – application dismissed.

1. What this decision is about

[1] Mr Heintje Lange has made an application seeking a remedy for an alleged unfair dismissal under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the FW Act). The respondent in this matter is his former employer, Bickford’s Australia Pty Ltd (Bickford’s or the Respondent).

[2] Mr Lange was employed as the Winemaker at the Step Road Winery operated by Bickford’s (the Winery) until September 2019 when he was dismissed on the stated basis of a redundancy arising from structural changes to the senior management of the winery. At that time, the Winery also engaged a Technical Winemaker, Mr Fenton-Smith, as well as utilising a number of other leadership roles located at the Winery and within the Bickford’s group of companies more generally.

[3] According to Bickford’s, in September 2019, after discussions within senior group management over a number of months as to the efficiencies of the Winery from an operational and staffing perspective, and after determining that the Winery would likely incur a significant loss in that financial year, Bickford's determined that:

•  A structural change was required in the operations of the Winery;

•  A single Winery Manager role would be implemented; and

•  The roles of Winemaker and Technical Winemaker at the Winery were to be made redundant.

[4] Ultimately, Mr Fenton-Smith was selected to fill the new Winery Manager role. No suitable redeployment opportunities were available within the Bickford's group of companies for Mr Lange and on 24 September 2019, following three meetings regarding the proposal, the Applicant was dismissed as a consequence of the redundancy.

[5] Mr Lange disputes many of the above…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Heintje Lange v Bickford's Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FWC 613
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Heintje Lange v Bickford's Australia Pty Ltd, the Fair Work Commission was asked to determine whether the applicant, Mr Lange, had been unfairly dismissed by the respondent company, Bickford's Australia Pty Ltd. Mr Lange, a winemaker, contended that his dismissal was unjust, asserting that there had been no genuine redundancy and that the company had failed to meet its consultation obligations. The respondent maintained that Mr Lange's position had been genuinely made redundant due to operational changes and that all procedural requirements had been satisfied.

The primary legal issues before the Commission were whether the dismissal was due to a genuine redundancy, if the respondent had properly consulted with Mr Lange as required by the relevant modern award, and whether there were reasonable redeployment options that were overlooked. Additionally, the Commission had to consider whether the respondent's decision to not redeploy Mr Lange was reasonable under the circumstances.

The Commission examined the evidence and found that Mr Lange's role had indeed been genuinely made redundant due to operational changes that rendered his specific duties unnecessary. Despite the continuation of some duties, the overall role had been restructured to include broader management responsibilities, which Mr Lange was not selected to perform. The respondent had fulfilled its consultation obligations by engaging with Mr Lange after a decision had been made, and the Commission was satisfied that the consultation met the requirements of the modern award. Regarding redeployment, the Commission assessed other positions and work available and concluded that it was not reasonable to redeploy Mr Lange into another role within the company. The Commission also noted that Mr Lange had not proposed the new role as a redeployment option, and it found that there was a distinction between being selected for redundancy and being selected for redeployment. The evidence supported the conclusion that an objective assessment had been made about the relative merits of the two winemakers, and it was reasonable to conclude that Mr Lange was not selected for redeployment.

The Commission ultimately found that, on balance, it was not reasonable in all circumstances for Mr Lange to have been redeployed within the respondent's enterprise or the enterprise of an associated entity. Consequently, the application for an unfair dismissal remedy was dismissed, and the Commission ruled that the dismissal was genuine.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established