Healy and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Healy and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2018] AATA 1051 (13 April 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2018/0401      

Re:Daniel Healy

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member C Edwardes

Date:13 April 2018

Place:Perth

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the Applicant should not be refused a Skilled (Residence)(Class VB) visa under subsection 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958.

........................................................................

Member C Edwardes

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – decision to refuse a visa – failure to pass character test – where applicant has substantial criminal record – South Africa -- culpable homicide (motor vehicle accident) – primary considerations weigh in favour of granting visa – risk of reoffending low – best interests of minor children – expectations of the Australian community – other considerations – decision under review is set aside.

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – s 499 – s 499(2A) – s 500(1)(b) – s 501(1) – s 501(6) – s 501(6)(c) – s 501(7) – s 501CA
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) para 43(1)(c)(i)

CASES

Labi and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 316
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1990) 90 FCR 583

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Direction No. 65 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s501CA – para 6.1 – para 6.2 – para 6.3 – para 7(1) – para 8 – para 11.1(1) – para 11.1.1(1) – para 11.1.2 – para 11.2(4) – para 11.3(1) – para 12(1)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member C Edwardes

13 April 2018

THE APPLICATION

  1. This is an application for the review of a decision by a delegate of the Respondent (Minister) under subsection 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act) to refuse to grant the Applicant a Skilled (Residence) (Class VB) (the visa) (G5 87) (R1). The decision of the delegate to refuse to grant the Applicant the visa was communicated to the Applicant on 23 January 2018 (G5 87) (R1).  The Applicant was taken into Yongah Hill Detention Centre and subsequently lodged this application on 30 January 2018. (G2 3)(R1)

  2. The application for review is made under subsection 500(1)(b) of the Act which allows applications to be made to this tribunal (the Tribunal) for review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister under subsection 501(1) of the Act. The Tribunal is satisfied that it has jurisdiction to review the delegate’s decision.

  3. The application was heard by the Tribunal on 9 April 2018. The Applicant was represented by Ms Alice Graziotti of Estrin Saul Lawyers and the Respondent was represented by Ms Elle Tattersall of Sparke Helmore Lawyers.

    ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

  4. Pursuant to subsection 501(1) of the Act, the Applicant’s application for the visa was refused by the delegate of the Minister on the ground that the delegate was not satisfied that the Applicant passed the character test stipulated under the Act. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Healy and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 1051
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the case of Healy and the Minister for Home Affairs concerning the refusal of a visa application. The applicant, a citizen of South Africa, had applied for a Skilled (Residence) visa after arriving in Australia in 2013. The Minister's delegate refused the visa on the grounds that the applicant did not pass the character test, specifically due to having a substantial criminal record as defined by the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant passed the character test and, if not, whether the discretion under subsection 501(1) of the Act should be exercised to refuse the visa. The applicant's criminal record included convictions in South Africa for culpable homicide arising from a motor vehicle accident and driving under the influence of liquor, as well as a more recent conviction in Western Australia for exceeding the prescribed concentration of alcohol while driving.

The Tribunal reasoned that while the applicant did not pass the character test due to his substantial criminal record, the primary considerations under Direction 65 weighed in favour of granting the visa. The Tribunal found that the risk of the applicant re-offending was low, and his demeanour and character, supported by evidence, did not indicate a chronic disrespect for legal obligations. The Tribunal also considered the expectations of the Australian community regarding adherence to the law. Ultimately, the Tribunal set aside the delegate's decision and determined that the applicant should not be refused the visa.

Background

Background to the litigation

Pursuant to subsection 501(1) of the Act, the Applicant’s application for the visa was refused by the delegate of the Minister on the ground that the delegate was not satisfied that the Applicant passed the character test stipulated under the Act. The issues for determination by the Tribunal are whether:(a)the Applicant passes the character test under the Act; and(b)the Tribunal ought to exercise the discretion under subsection 501(1) of the Act to refuse to grant the visa, or not to refuse to grant the visa.BACKGROUND The Applicant is a citizen of South Africa. The Applicant arrived in Australia on 2 September 2013 after being granted a Skilled Regional (subclass 489) visa. (A20 2) On 2 November 2015 the Applicant lodged an application for a Skilled (Residence) (Class VB) (subclass 887) visa. His Temporary visa expired on 2 September 2017 and he was granted a Bridging visa A until the determination of his application. (A20 2) On 29 November 2017 the Minister’s delegate refused to grant the visa and the Applicant was advised in the following terms:“…. After careful consideration of your response and the matters listed in the Notice, a delegate of the Minister decided on 29 November 2017 to refuse to grant you a visa under subsection 501(1) of the Migration Act.The particular grounds of subsection 501(6) under which you did not satisfy a of the Minister that you pass the character test issubsection 501(6)(a): the person has a substantial criminal record (as defined by subsection 501(7))Under subsection 501(7)(c), a person will have a substantial criminal record if they have been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more.” (G5 87-8)History of relevant conduct The details of all of the Applicant’s convictions are set out below:·On 30 April 1997 the Applicant was convicted in a court in South Africa of culpable homicide – motor vehicle accident. He was sentenced to “R3000 or one year imprisonment plus a further 18 months imprisonment which is conditionally suspended for four years.” His driver licence was suspended for 6 months. The Applicant paid the fine of 3000 rand.·On 3 February 1995 the Applicant was convicted in South Africa of driving a motor vehicle whilst under the influence of intoxicating liquor. He received a penalty of “R1 000 or 6 months imprisonment of which R500 or 3 months imprisonment is conditionally suspended for 4 years.” The applicant paid the fine. (G8 114) (R1)·On 20 August 2014 the Applicant was convicted in the Bunbury Magistrates Court in Western Australia of exceeding .08 grams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of blood whilst driving. He was fined $750 and had his licence disqualified for 9 months. (G7 112) (R1)LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Subsection 501(1) of the Act is as follows:(1) The Minister may refuse to grant a visa to a person if the person does not satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test. Note: Character test is defined by subsection (6). Relevantly, subsection 501(6) of the Act is as follows:(6) For the purposes of this section, a person does not pass the character test if:(a) the person has a substantial criminal record (as defined by subsection (7));…

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Part B of Direction 65 (paragraphs 11 and 12) sets out considerations that are relevant when deciding whether to refuse a non-citizen’s visa application.EVIDENCE The Tribunal received the following evidence:·Exhibit A1 – Email enclosing documents attached to Respondent’s notice of visa refusal dated 2 February 2018.·Exhibit A2 – Index – Applicant’s Bundle of Evidence dated 9 March 2018.·Exhibit A3 – Witness statement of Daniel Healy dated 9 March 2018.·Exhibit A4 – Witness statement of Magdalena Healy dated 9 March 2018.·Exhibit A5 – Witness statement of Annerie Naude dated 8 March 2018.·Exhibit A6 – Witness statement of Mark Naude dated 7 March 2018.·Exhibit A7 – Draft witness statement of Peter Clark undated.·Exhibit A8 – Letter from Douglas Hatchett dated 8 March 2018.·Exhibit A9 – Psychological report from Mercurio Cicchini dated 6 March 2018.·Exhibit A10 – Character reference from Austin Dignan dated 6 March 2018.·Exhibit A11 – History for Court – Criminal and Traffic dated 27 February 2018.·Exhibit A12 – Prosecution Notice and written plea dated 3 July 2014.·Exhibit A13 – Letter from Magistrate’s Court – East London dated 13 April 2012.·Exhibit A14 – Letter from Department of Justice (Queenstown) stamped 12 April 2012.·Exhibit A15 – Crime administration system extract and note dated 25 January 2011.·Exhibit A16 – Letter from Rev. J van Rensburg undated.·Exhibit A17 – Letter from MJ Allam dated 24 April 2013.·Exhibit A18 – Letter from Dora Nell dated 9 December 2012.·Exhibit A19 – Letter from LG Kriedemann dated 1 January 2011.·Exhibit A20 – Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SOFIC) dated 9 March 2018.·Exhibit A21- Hearing certificate with list of witnesses dated 12 March 2018.·Exhibit A22- Signed statement of Daniel Healy dated 29 March 2018·Exhibit A23 – Summons material from Dr Hatchett dated 29 March 2018 ·Exhibit R1 – G1-G18 (pages 1-130) documents received 14 February 2018.·Exhibit R2 – Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions (SOFIC) dated 23 March 2018. The Tribunal has reviewed all of the material before it and is satisfied all relevant evidence was before it, and that both parties were provided an opportunity to address the evidence, either orally or in writing. Relevant aspects of the evidence and material before the Tribunal will be analysed and referred to below. At the commencement of the hearing the Applicant drew to the attention of the Tribunal an amendment at paragraph 114 (A20) of his submission – reference to the Applicant’s son-in-law should in fact be referenced to the Applicant’s mother-in-lawSHOULD THE TRIBUNAL EXERCISE THE DISCRETION UNDER S 501(1) OF THE ACT TO REFUSE TO GRANT THE VISA? It is clear that the Applicant does not pass the character test under subsection 501(6) of the Act. In April 1997, the Applicant was convicted of culpable homicide – motor vehicle accident in South Africa. He was fined R3000 or one year imprisonment plus a further 18 months imprisonment conditionally suspended for four years. Subsection 501(6) of the Act provides that a person does not pass the character test if he has a “substantial criminal record.” Paragraph 501(7)(c) of the Act provides that a person has a substantial criminal record if he has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Relevant to exercising its discretion under subsection 501(1) of the Act and complying with Direction Number 65 under subsection 499(2A) of the Act, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant passes the character test. Particularly, the Tribunal notes, in relation to primary considerations that the Tribunal must take into account under Direction 65:(a)the protection of the Australian community weighs heavily in favour of the Applicant being not being refused the grant of a visa. The nature and seriousness of the Applicant’s conduct and the likelihood of his re-offending pose a low risk to the Australian community;(b)the best interests of minor children in Australia is not a consideration in this case; and(c)Whilst the Applicant has been convicted of the offences mentioned in the above paragraphs, the Tribunal finds, taking into account all evidence before it, that the Applicant has a low risk of committing further offences of a serious nature, and that the Applicant’s demeanour during the hearing, and character, as provided by evidence before the Tribunal, does not indicate that the Applicant is a person that will exhibit chronic disrespect of legal obligations and responsibility in Australia. The Tribunal finds that this assessment satisfies expectations of the Australian community. Relevantly, being that non-citizens obey Australian law while in Australia. DECISION For the reasons set out above pursuant to paragraph 43(1)(c)(i) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the Applicant should not be refused a Skilled (Residence)(Class VB) visa under subsection 501(1) of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Paragraph 8 of Direction 65 further states:8. Taking the relevant considerations into account1Decision-makers must take into account the primary and other considerations relevant to the individual case…2In applying the considerations (both primary and other), information and evidence from independent and authoritative sources should be given appropriate weight.3Both primary and other considerations may weigh in favour of, or against, refusal, cancellation of the visa, or whether or not to revoke a mandatory cancellation of the visa.4Primary considerations should generally be given more weight than the other considerations.5One or more primary considerations may outweigh other primary considerations. Part B of Direction 65 (paragraphs 11 and 12) sets out considerations that are relevant when deciding whether to refuse a non-citizen’s visa application.EVIDENCE The Tribunal received the following evidence:·Exhibit A1 – Email enclosing documents attached to Respondent’s notice of visa refusal dated 2 February 2018.·Exhibit A2 – Index – Applicant’s Bundle of Evidence dated 9 March 2018.·Exhibit A3 – Witness statement of Daniel Healy dated 9 March 2018.·Exhibit A4 – Witness statement of Magdalena Healy dated 9 March 2018.·Exhibit A5 – Witness statement of Annerie Naude dated 8 March 2018.·Exhibit A6 – Witness statement of Mark Naude dated 7 March 2018.·Exhibit A7 – Draft witness statement of Peter Clark undated.·Exhibit A8 – Letter from Douglas Hatchett dated 8 March 2018.·Exhibit A9 – Psychological report from Mercurio Cicchini dated 6 March 2018.·Exhibit A10 – Character reference from Austin Dignan dated 6 March 2018.·Exhibit A11 – History for Court – Criminal and Traffic dated 27 February 2018.·Exhibit A12 – Prosecution Notice and written plea dated 3 July 2014.·Exhibit A13 – Letter from Magistrate’s Court – East London dated 13 April 2012.·Exhibit A14 – Letter from Department of Justice (Queenstown) stamped 12 April 2012.·Exhibit A15 – Crime administration system extract and note dated 25 January 2011.·Exhibit A16 – Letter from Rev. J van Rensburg undated.·Exhibit A17 – Letter from MJ Allam dated 24 April 2013.·Exhibit A18 – Letter from Dora Nell dated 9 December 2012.·Exhibit A19 – Letter from LG Kriedemann dated 1 January 2011.·Exhibit A20 – Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SOFIC) dated 9 March 2018.·Exhibit A21- Hearing certificate with list of witnesses dated 12 March 2018.·Exhibit A22- Signed statement of Daniel Healy dated 29 March 2018·Exhibit A23 – Summons material from Dr Hatchett dated 29 March 2018 ·Exhibit R1 – G1-G18 (pages 1-130) documents received 14 February 2018.·Exhibit R2 – Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions (SOFIC) dated 23 March 2018. The Tribunal has reviewed all of the material before it and is satisfied all relevant evidence was before it, and that both parties were provided an opportunity to address the evidence, either orally or in writing. Relevant aspects of the evidence and material before the Tribunal will be analysed and referred to below.