| [2022] FWC 2911 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.437—Protected action
Health Services Union
v
Cabrini Health Ltd
(B2022/1637)
| Deputy President Clancy | MELBOURNE, 31 OCTOBER 2022 |
Proposed protected action ballot of employees of Cabrini Health Ltd.
On Thursday 27 October 2022, the Health Service Union Victoria No.3 Branch (the Union) applied to the Commission for a protected action ballot order (PABO).[1]
In its application, the Union sought a protected action ballot order in relation to employees of Cabrini Health Ltd (Cabrini) and specified the employees to be balloted as being those who will be covered by the proposed Cabrini Health, Health Professionals Agreement 2022 and are members of the Union.
The Union also sought that a person other than the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) be the ballot agent for the protected action ballot. The person proposed in the application as the protected action ballot agent is TrueVote Pty Ltd (TrueVote). Mr Stephen Donaldson, the Managing Director of TrueVote provided a statutory declaration setting out that he would carry out the functions of the protected ballot agent for TrueVote and that he has relevant experience in conducting protected action ballots.
At 12.31pm on Friday 28 August 2022, my Associate was advised that Cabrini opposed the making of a protected action ballot order on the following grounds:
· The phrasing of the questions within the Application are too wide and unclear;
· Many of the questions pose legitimate health and safety concerns to patients and the health/clinical safety environment in general and require further specificity and clarification before they could be ordered by the Commission; and/or
· Many of the other draft questions are “simply impossible from a resourcing and rostering point of view – during a skills shortage in the health industry - whereby employees cannot simply choose what time to take their breaks or ‘walk off the line’ when patients are being rostered for appointments with them or life-critical Nuclear Medicine Technologist work (e.g. scans) are essential to be performed and forwarded to other departments (such as emergency)”.
Therefore, my Associate shortly after sent an email to the Union seeking their views in relation to Cabrini’s objections. The Union replied via email at 12:59pm on 28 October 2022 opposing the grounds of objection outlined above.
In these circumstances, the matter was listed for a Mention hearing before me at 3pm on Friday 28 October 2022, at which I issued directions for the filing and service of material and listed the application for a hearing at 1.00pm on Monday 31 October 2022.
In the material filed and served, Cabrini submitted:
1) Questions 4, 8 and 9 of the proposed protected action ballot order cannot form part of any order made because they do not sufficiently specify the nature of the proposed industrial action, as required by s437(3)(b) and s443(3)(d) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act);
2) The Commission can be satisfied the circumstances of Cabrini arising from the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Services Union v Cabrini Health Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] FWC 2911
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the proposed ballot constituted protected action and if the balance of convenience favoured the HSU in seeking an injunction to facilitate it. The central issue was whether the potential disruption to hospital operations by allowing the ballot outweighed the union's right to organise and inform its members about proposed industrial action. The court considered the impact of the ballot on patient care, the potential for industrial action, and the rights of the union under the Fair Work Act.
The court found that the proposed ballot did constitute protected action under the Fair Work Act, as it involved informing employees of potential industrial action. However, it also determined that the balance of convenience favoured Cabrini. The potential disruption to hospital operations and the impact on patient care were significant factors that outweighed the union's right to conduct the ballot. The court held that allowing the ballot could lead to industrial action, which would further disrupt hospital services and potentially harm patients. Consequently, the court refused the HSU's application for an injunction.
The court ordered that the HSU was not entitled to compel Cabrini to allow the proposed protected action ballot. The decision underscored the importance of balancing the rights of unions to organise with the need to maintain the proper administration and operation of essential services, particularly in healthcare settings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi