Health Services For Men Pty Ltd v D'Souza

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:    HEALTH SERVICES FOR MEN PTY LTD & ORS  v D'SOUZA & ORS [2000]  NSWCA 56

FILE NUMBER(S):
40932/99

HEARING DATE(S):          18 February 2000

JUDGMENT DATE:           22/03/2000

PARTIES:
Health Services for Men Pty Limited - Appellant
Oscar D'Souza, Paul Condoleon, Mirwais Wadan - Respondents

JUDGMENT OF:     Mason P Priestley JA Sheller JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:          Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):      3563/99

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:   Bryson J

COUNSEL:
M L Einfeld QC/JW Stevenson - Appellant
M Cashion SC/T M Thawley - Respsondents

SOLICITORS:
Turtons Lawyers - Appellant
D G F Morgan & Associates - Respondents

CATCHWORDS:
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY - Property in medical records as between doctors and owners of medical clinics - Intention of parties
CONTRACTS - Relationship between doctors and owners of medical clinics - Property in medical records
EQUITY - Equitable remedies - Grant of injunction - Considerations upon which court exercises discretion - ND

LEGISLATION CITED:
Medical Practice Act 1992
Ambulance Services Act 1990
Poisons and Therapeeutic Goods Act 1966
Suitors Fund Act 1951

DECISION:
1.  Appeal allowed
2.  Set aside the declaration, directions and orders made by Bryson J on 30 November 1999
3.  In lieu thereof
(a)  Declare that the plaintiffs are entitled to retain as against the defendants the documents identified in the patient files as
(i)  examination sheets
(ii)  implied consent forms
(iii)  pathology reports
(iv)  the manilla folders
(v)  the documents entitled "must be completed by the patient
(vi)  the slips recording the patient name, patient address, date of attendance and/material supplied (the day sheets)
(b)  Order that the defendants within 7 days of this order deliver up to the plaintiffs any of the documents described in (a) retained by them or any of them and taken from the appellants’ premises or possession
(c)  The defendants to pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the proceedings before Bryson J
4.  The appellants have liberty to apply to the Equity Division for any further relief in the proceedings
5.  The respondents to pay the appellants’ costs of this appeal but to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951 if so entitled.

JUDGMENT:

THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40932/99
ED 3563/99

MASON P
PRIESTLEY JA
SHELLER JA

HEALTH SERVICES FOR MEN PTY LIMITED & ORS v D’SOUZA & ORS

The respondent doctors, who formerly carried on medical practice in clinics owned and operated by the appellants, claimed ownership to examination sheets recorded by the respondents while they worked at the clinics.  Apart from an agreement in relation to fees, there was no written agreement between the appellants and respondents.

Bryson J at first instance made orders declaring that the property in such of the examination sheets, consent forms and pathology reports as related to patients first seen by one of the respondents belonged to that respondent.  In his Honour’s view, patients needing medical treatment consulted the respondents for their advice.  Patients were not interested in consulting persons who…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Services For Men Pty Ltd v D'Souza and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWCA 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in *Health Services For Men Pty Ltd v D'Souza* concerned the ownership of medical records and patient information as between a medical clinic and its treating doctors. The dispute arose when doctors, who had been employed by the clinic, left to establish their own practice and retained patient files. The clinic sought declarations and injunctions regarding its entitlement to these records and to prevent the former doctors from soliciting patients.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the medical clinic or the treating doctors held proprietary rights over the various documents constituting patient files, including examination sheets, consent forms, pathology reports, and patient contact details recorded on "day sheets." The court was also required to consider the appropriate equitable remedies, if any, that should be granted to the clinic, particularly in relation to restraining the former doctors from using patient information.

The Court of Appeal, allowing the appeal, reasoned that the intention of the parties, as evidenced by the circumstances of the employment relationship, indicated that the clinic, as the owner of the premises and the entity providing the infrastructure for patient care, was entitled to retain the patient files. This included examination sheets, consent forms, pathology reports (which were considered to become the property of the clinic upon receipt), and the "day sheets" containing patient contact details. The court distinguished this from the use of general knowledge or customer lists, noting that while employees may be restrained from misusing confidential information, the patient files themselves were the property of the clinic. The court declined to grant an injunction preventing the solicitation of patients at that stage, deeming it preferable for the clinic to seek further relief in the Equity Division if necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed

2. Set aside the declaration, directions and orders made by Bryson J on 30 November 1999

3. In lieu thereof

(a) Declare that the plaintiffs are entitled to retain as against the defendants the documents identified in the patient files as

(i) examination sheets

(ii) implied consent forms

(iii) pathology reports

(iv) the manilla folders

(v) the documents entitled "must be completed by the patient

(vi) the slips recording the patient name, patient address, date of attendance and/material supplied (the day sheets)

(b) Order that the defendants within 7 days of this order deliver up to the plaintiffs any of the documents described in (a) retained by them or any of them and taken from the appellants’ premises or possession

(c) The defendants to pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the proceedings before Bryson J

4. The appellants have liberty to apply to the Equity Division for any further relief in the proceedings

5. The respondents to pay the appellants’ costs of this appeal but to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951 if so entitled.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The pathology report falls into a different category. At the time it was prepared by the pathologist, the document was the property of the pathologist. It may be that when such a document was sent to and received by a practitioner in private practice, who had requested the report, it became the property of that practitioner. Even if that were so in the case postulated, in the present case the circumstances for like reason point to the pathology report being the property of the clinics and not the property of the treating doctor who worked in the clinic.CONCLUSION In my opinion, the appeal should be allowed. The orders I propose are intended to acknowledge that the appellants are entitled to retain the documents in the patient files as against the respondents who have no property in the files. In their notice of appeal the appellants ask for a declaration that the information recorded in the Day Sheets and in particular the patient contact details, is information confidential to the appellants and to the patients of the clinics and an order restraining the respondents from soliciting or approaching any patient of any of the clinics. In argument, the appellants submitted that the patient contact details should be treated in the same way as customer lists; see Ormonoid Roofing and Asphalts Limited v Bitumenoids Limited (1930) 31 SR (NSW) 347. While an employee may be restrained from removing, retaining and making use of customer lists obtained in the course of employment, as Harvey CJ in Eq remarked at 354, where an employee in the course of his employment and for the purposes of his employment has obtained particular information with regard to his employer’s business, such as knowledge of processes, details of management or particulars of customers which have become stored up in his mind as a necessary consequence of the way in which his master employed him, there is no justification in the absence of an express contract, for preventing him making use of that knowledge. The appellants are entitled to retain or, if necessary, recover the patient files. But I do not think that this Court should at this stage grant any further relief. As Pincus J remarked in Schindler Lifts Australia Pty Limited v Debelak (1989) 89 ALR 275 at 318 it is in general undesirable to frame an injunction that does little more than repeat the injuncted party’s general legal obligations or so to frame an injunction that the question whether a breach has occurred is likely to be very debatable until settled by an order made in contempt proceedings. I think the appellants should have leave, if so advised, to apply to the Equity Division for any further relief. I propose the following orders:1. Appeal allowed;2.Set aside the declaration, directions and orders made by Bryson J on 30 November 1999;3. In lieu thereof:(a)Declare that the plaintiffs are entitled to retain as against the defendants the documents identified in the patient files as(i) examination sheets;(ii) implied consent forms;(iii) pathology reports;(iv) the manilla folders;(v)the documents entitled “must be completed by the patient;(vi)the slips recording the patient name, patient address, date of attendance and/material supplied (the day sheets).(b)Order that the defendants within 7 days of this order deliver up to the plaintiffs any of the documents described in (a) retained by them or any of them and taken from the appellants’ premises or possession.(c)The defendants to pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the proceedings before Bryson J.4.The appellants have liberty to apply to the Equity Division for any further relief in the proceedings.5. The respondents to pay the appellants’ costs of this appeal but to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951 if so entitled.******

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.