HDCZ and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

HDCZ and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 812 (31 March 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2021/1836

Re:HDCZ

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency (No 2)

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member P Smith

Date:31 March 2023

Place:Sydney

Leave is granted to the Chief Executive Officer of The National Disability Insurance Agency to be released from the implied undertaking under Part 5 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal: General Practice Direction given under section 18B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) in respect of the documents identified below so that they may use the documents at future planning meetings for the purpose of conducting reassessments of the Applicant’s Plan to determine reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded under the National Disability Insurance Scheme for the purpose of section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth):

1.The document titled “details of the Applicant’s treating health professionals, including any allied health professionals”, identified by the Applicant as 2 in the bundle of documents the Applicant provided on 8 June 2021.

2.The undated letter titled ‘Physiotherapy’ by Radwan Dannawi, ‘Principal physiotherapist’ identified by the Applicant as H13 in the bundle of documents provided by the Applicant on 8 June 2021 in accordance with the direction given by the Tribunal on 13 May 2021.

3.The undated letter titled ‘Speech pathology’ by Fida Hajaj, ‘Principal Snr occupational therapist’, on Fit By Physio letterhead identified by the Applicant as H13 in the bundle of documents provided by the Applicant on 8 June 2021 in accordance with the direction given by the Tribunal on 13 May 2021.

4.The letter of Dr Omar Najjarine, podiatrist, dated 12 December 2020 identified by the Applicant as H13 in the bundle of documents provided by the Applicant on 8 June 2021 in accordance with the direction given by the Tribunal on 13 May 2021.

5.The undated letter titled ‘Occupational therapy’ by Fida Hajaj, ‘Principal Snr occupational therapist’ on ‘Occupational Therapy Services’ letterhead identified by the Applicant as H13 in the bundle of documents provided by the Applicant on 8 June 2021 in accordance with the direction given by the Tribunal on 13 May 2021.

6.The ‘AHP community and community services podiatric therapy functional report’ by John Mamis, podiatrist, dated 24 April 2021 identified by the Applicant as H19 in the bundle of documents provided by the Applicant on 8 June 2021 in accordance with the direction given by the Tribunal on 13 May 2021.

7.The ‘Client assessment report’ by Nazan Arabul, provisional psychologist, dated 1 April 2021 identified by the Applicant as H20 in the bundle of documents provided by the Applicant on 8 June 2021 in accordance with the direction given by the Tribunal on 13 May 2021.

8.The ‘Occupational therapy functional capacity assessment’ by Sobhi Maaliki, occupational therapist, dated 29 April 2021 identified by the Applicant as H21 in the bundle of documents provided by the Applicant on 8 June 2021 in accordance with the direction given by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HDCZ and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 812
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a request by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent) for leave to be released from an implied undertaking concerning three sets of documents. The Applicant argued that the Respondent's request was not for a proper purpose and should be refused for various reasons, including the confidential nature of the documents, the lack of necessity for reassessment of certain supports, and the Respondent's alleged intention to use the documents for a collateral purpose.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant the Respondent leave to be released from the implied undertaking. This required the Tribunal to determine if an implied undertaking applied to an expert report provided by the Respondent, even though it was not obtained under the compulsory processes of the Tribunal, because it referred to documents that were subject to such an undertaking. The Tribunal also had to consider whether special circumstances existed to justify releasing the Respondent from the undertaking, and whether the Respondent's stated reasons for the request were sufficiently substantial and connected to their functions under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

The Tribunal reasoned that an implied undertaking applied to two sets of documents provided by the Applicant under compulsion, and also extended to the Respondent's legal representative. It further found that an implied undertaking also applied to the expert report, as it referenced these compulsorily obtained documents. The Tribunal noted that it would only grant leave to be released from an implied undertaking if special circumstances were demonstrated. After considering the Applicant's objections and the Respondent's stated purpose for seeking release, the Tribunal concluded that the Respondent's request was sufficiently substantiated and aligned with their statutory functions.

Consequently, the Tribunal granted leave to the Respondent to be released from the implied undertaking in respect of the specified documents. This release was for the purpose of using the documents at future planning meetings to reassess the Applicant's Plan and determine reasonable and necessary supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

It is the Applicant’s case that the Respondent’s request for leave to be released from the implied undertaking they say applies to the three sets of documents identified above has not been made for a proper purpose. It was therefore submitted for the Applicant that the Respondent’s request should be refused for the following reasons:(i)The Applicant is not pressing for the Respondent to fund psychological support or physiotherapy as a reasonable and necessary support, so the Applicant’s current plan does not contain these services and there is no need for the Respondent to consider documents relating to those supports when the Applicant does not request them, including the report of Dr Roldan. (ii)No assessment of the Applicant’s Plan is required for those supports the Applicant does not press. (iii)The Respondent has already agreed to fund many supports based on the evidence that was before the Tribunal. (iv)The Applicant’s current Plan does not need to be reassessed until 3 September 2024[16]. (v)The Respondent’s reasons for requesting a release from the implied undertaking are mysterious and/or vague and fails to refer to specific functions under the NDIS Act. (vi)There are no substantial reasons given by the Respondent to be granted leave to be released from the implied undertaking. (vii)The Respondent intends to use the documents for a collateral or ulterior purpose. (viii)There are no special circumstances that exist. (ix)There are no legal proceedings that exist. (x)The documents are confidential and contain health and personal information of the Applicant.(xi)There is a public interest immunity. (xii)The Respondent’s legal representative breached the implied undertaking when they engaged Dr Roldan (who the Applicant claims is not a party to the proceedings) to assess the Applicant who in turn breached the implied undertaking.[16] This date Mr Ramadan refers to may not be correct. This is because the statement of participants supports approved in the Applicant’s Plan on 19 September 2022 is a two-year Plan that commenced on 19 September 2022 and ends before 18 September 2024. The Respondent must reassess this Plan before 18 September 2023 as is required under Division 4 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). See Annexure 4 to the Applicant’s supplementary written submissions dated 2 February 2023.RELEVANT BACKGROUND Before I determine the question of whether or not the Tribunal should grant leave to the Respondent to be released from the implied undertaking, they say applies to the three sets of documents identified above, it is necessary that I set out some of the relevant background to this case. On 1 December 2020[17], following a scheduled review of the Applicant’s previous Plan[18], a delegate of the CEO of the Respondent approved a SOPS in the Applicant’s Plan. This was approved under subsection 33(2) of the NDIS Act for a 12-month period commencing on 1 December 2020 and ending before 1 December 2021. This was the date by which the Respondent was required to reassess the Applicant’s Plan under Division 4 of the NDIS Act[19], as was specified by the reviewer after varying the delegate’s decision.[17] See T7 of the T-documents. The Tribunal notes that the Respondent also approved a statement of participant supports in the Applicant’s Plan on 4 December 2019 for a 12-month period commencing from 4 December 2019 until 3 December 2020. [18] See T14 of the T-documents.[19] Section 48 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) sets out the ways in which a participant’s plan can be reassessed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal grants leave to the Respondent to be released from the implied undertaking as it applies to the documents identified at pages 1 to 4 of this Decision.DECISION Leave is granted to the Chief Executive Officer of The National Disability Insurance Agency to be released from the implied undertaking under Part 5 of the Administrative Appeal Tribunal: General Practice Direction given under section 18B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) in respect of the documents identified at pages 1 to 4 of this decision so that they may use the documents at future planning meetings for the purpose of conducting reassessments of the Applicant’s Plan to determine reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded under the National Disability Insurance Scheme for the purpose of section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The GPD provides that if a party wants to use the documents for another purpose, they must request the leave of the Tribunal to be released from the implied undertaking by making the request in accordance with a number of requirements as set out in Parts 5.6 and 5.7 of the GPD. The request must be made in writing. The request must specify with particularity the documents in relation to which is release sought. The request must tell the Tribunal in clear terms why the requesting party wants to be released from the implied undertaking and who will use the documents. Finally, if it is possible, the request must specify whether or not the person to whom the documents relate consents to the release from the implied undertaking[40]. Unless a party believes that it is unnecessary or inappropriate, a copy of the request must be sent to the other party or parties to the application in which the documents were originally provided[41]. [40] See Part 5.6(a) to (d) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal: General Practice Direction, dated 28 February 2019.[41] See Part 5.7of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal: General Practice Direction, dated 28 February 2019.CONSIDERATION The issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether it should grant leave to the Respondent to be released from an implied undertaking they say applies to the three sets of documents identified above. The Tribunal will only release a party from an implied undertaking if there are special circumstances. Before I deal with the immediate issue, I propose to first consider whether the implied undertaking applies to the Respondent in respect of the documents identified above. The documents that were provided to the Tribunal and the Respondent and their legal representative on 8 June 2021 and 26 August 2021 were provided by the Applicant under the compulsory processes of the Tribunal. As the Respondent received those documents from the Applicant under compulsion, they have an obligation not to use the documents for another purpose without the leave of the Tribunal. The scope of the obligation also extends to the Respondent’s legal representative[42]. The documents were not received in evidence or read aloud in open court. As the documents were not received in evidence or read aloud in open court, the obligation not to use the documents does not end. For these reasons, there is an implied undertaking that applies to the Respondent not to use the documents they received on 8 June 2021 and 26 August 2021 for another purpose without the leave of the Tribunal.[42] Harman at 302, per Lord Diplock. In the course of the proceeding, the Applicant was medically assessed by Dr Roldan to assist the Tribunal to determine whether the Applicant’s request for psychological and behavioural supports were reasonable and necessary. The Applicant was directed by the Tribunal to attend the assessment with Dr Roldan on 5 October 2021. The report was provided to the Tribunal and to the Applicant by the Respondent via email on 23 December 2021[43]. The Respondent did not provide the report to the Tribunal and the Applicant under the compulsory processes of the Tribunal. [43] The Respondent also attached to their email of 23 December 2021 a copy of their letter of instruction Ms Miller sent to Dr Roldan on 30 September 2021.