Cook and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Cook and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1111 (4 May 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/3331

Re:Leisa Cook

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J W Constance

Date:4 May 2021

Place:Sydney

The Respondent is released from the implied undertaking in respect of the following documents:

(a)Supplementary report of Krystele Hurcum, occupational therapist, dated 17 September 2020 lodged by the Applicant on 18 September 2020;

(b)Email chain between James Miller, disability advocate, and Justyn Cook, physiotherapist, dated 21 September 2020 lodged by the Applicant on 24 September 2020; and

(c)Documents produced under summons by:

(i)Medical Records, Medicolegal, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, The Proper Officer (Metabolism and Obesity Services Clinic);

(ii)Maitland Orthopaedics and Rehab Specialists, The Practice Manager (Dr Rebecca Beiers, rehabilitation medicine consultant);

(iii)Hunter Diabetes Centre, The Practice Manager (Dr Claire Morbey, endocrinologist);

(iv)Dr Rod Gillespie, dermatologist;

(v)Dr Brain Draganic, colorectal and general surgeon;

(vi)Broadmeadow Neurology, The Practice Manager (Dr Tom Wellings, neurologist);

(vii)A/Prof Michael Boyle, immunologist; and

(viii)Adamstown Clinic, The Practice Manager (Dr Edward Bennett, general practitioner).

...........................[SGD].............................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – implied undertaking – where release is for the purpose of assessing the Applicant’s entitlements under the NDIS Act – where documents produced under compulsion – nature of Tribunal’s discretion to release a party from the implied undertaking – circumstances of the case – nature of the National Disability Insurance Scheme – where ongoing relationship between the parties – where documents would otherwise be available – interests of good public administration for decision makers to have available material before it when making reviewable decisions – where Applicant consented to use of information by the Agency – release from the implied undertaking granted

CASES

Liberty Funding Pty Ltd v Phoenix Capital Ltd  [2005] FCAFC 3

LMFP and Comcare (Compensation) [2017] AATA 1512

NWCB, ZFND and GXFS and National Disability Insurance Agency [2020] AATA 4555

Otter Gold Mines Ltd v Deputy President G L McDonald of the Administrative Appeals & Ors [1997] FCA 694

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J W Constance

INTRODUCTION 

4 May 2021

  1. Ms Cook is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme.

  2. In June 2020 Ms Cook applied to the Tribunal to review a decision of the Respondent Agency to refuse her request that it fund the installation of a swimming pool and awning at her home and the provision of a computer as a reasonable and necessary supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (“the NDIS Act”).

  3. During the Tribunal’s alternative dispute resolution processes prior to the matter being set down for hearing, several documents were produced to the Tribunal as a result of summonses issued at the request of the Agency. The Tribunal permitted both parties to inspect and copy these documents. Ms Cook also produced additional documents to the Tribunal and provided copies to the Agency.

  4. In October 2020 the Agency applied to the Tribunal for an order releasing it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cook and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a request by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Agency) to be released from an implied undertaking regarding documents produced during review proceedings initiated by Ms Cook. Ms Cook had applied for a review of the Agency's decision concerning specific support items, and during the proceedings, various documents, including an occupational therapist's report and emails, were lodged with the Tribunal and provided to the Agency. Additionally, the Agency had issued summonses for medical records from health professionals. Ms Cook subsequently withdrew her application for review, but the Agency then sought to use the documents produced for the ongoing administration of Ms Cook's National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) plan.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant the Agency's request to be released from its implied undertaking concerning the use of documents that had been produced under compulsion for the purposes of the review proceedings. Ms Cook objected to this release, arguing that the undertaking was intended to facilitate engagement in the review process and should only be waived in special circumstances, expressing concern that the Agency might use the information for ulterior purposes, such as reducing supports or reassessing her eligibility for the Scheme.

Deputy President Constance P reasoned that the Tribunal possessed a broad discretion to release parties from such undertakings. The nature of the NDIS, involving an ongoing relationship between a participant and the Agency, was a key factor. Unlike adversarial court proceedings where parties typically have no future interaction, participants in the NDIS have regular plan reviews. The Tribunal found that the documents would assist the Agency in making future decisions regarding Ms Cook's NDIS plan, and it would be inefficient to require the Agency to obtain these documents again. Furthermore, the Tribunal considered that if the Agency made future decisions that were subject to review, these documents would likely be available to the Agency and the Tribunal, thus serving the interests of both Ms Cook and good public administration by ensuring decision-makers have all relevant material.

Consequently, the Tribunal granted the Agency's request to be released from its implied undertaking in respect of all the documents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow I have decided that the Agency will be released from its undertaking.BACKGROUND The application for review, lodged in the Tribunal on 1 June 2020 by the Applicant, related to a swimming pool, an associated awning and a computer. No other supports were in issue. In accordance with a direction of the Tribunal made 10 August 2020, Ms Cook lodged in the Tribunal and provided to the Agency copies of the following:·a report of an Occupational Therapist;·emails between her Disability Advocate and her Physiotherapist. On 21 August 2020, at the request of the Agency, the Tribunal issued summonses to produce documents to nine health professionals and organisations requiring the production of medical records relating to Ms Cook. Documents were produced in answer to the summonses and both parties were given leave to inspect and copy the documents. On 23 October 2020 Ms Cook advised the Tribunal that she intended to withdraw her application for review of the Agency’s decision. She did so on 27 October 2020.THE AGENCY’S REQUEST FOR RELEASE AND MS COOK’S OBJECTION On 23 October 2020 (the same day that Ms Cook notified her intention to withdraw the proceedings) the Agency applied to be released from its implied undertaking as to the use of the documents produced. The request was made in the following terms:The Respondent respectfully requests that the Tribunal releases it from the implied undertaking in respect of the following documents, so that the Respondent may use these documents for the purposes of administering the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 in respect of the Applicant, including for planning purposes:[here followed a list of the documents lodged by Ms Cook and the documents produced in response to the summonses referred to above]We have copied the Applicant and her advocate and would be grateful if either could respond indicating whether the Applicant consents to this request. [Emphasis added]. On 29 October 2020 Ms Cook advised the Tribunal that she objected to the Agency being released from its undertaking. The objection stated:We advise that the Applicant does not consent for the respondent to be released from the implied undertaking. It is the applicants understanding the undertaking is made available to assist people to fully engage in the process at the Tribunal and is only to be waived in special circumstances. Based on the respondents’ most recent statement of issues at paragraphs 20-23 there are concerns that the Respondent intends to utilise this information to look at the disability criteria in s24(1) and may be used for the purposes of reducing supports as they do not relate to a disability in relation to Rule 5.1(b) as is mentioned in paragraph 13. Further the issue in dispute at the Tribunal was relating to a specific support item, rather than to the planning process as a whole, or multiple support items. Overall the applicant objects to this request as she feels that the request to release information will be used for an ulterior purpose than they were intended.THE TRIBUNAL’S GENERAL PRACTICE DIRECTION OF 28 FEBRUARY 2019

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

So far as possible all the information required by the Practice Direction should be provided at the time the request for release is made. However, as the additional information was provided prior to the hearing of the request for release, I do not consider that there has been any disadvantage to Ms Cook.CONSIDERATION The documents in question were produced under compulsion, by either a summons to produce documents or a direction of the Tribunal;[1] they were not documents taken into evidence. On this basis they are subject to the implied undertaking referred to in the General Practice Direction.[1] Otter Gold Mines Ltd v Deputy President G L McDonald of the Administrative Appeals & Ors [1997] FCA 694. Once the undertaking is in place the Tribunal has a broad discretion in deciding whether the documents should be available for use for purposes beyond those of the proceedings in which they were produced. In this application I have reached the conclusion that the Agency should be released from its undertaking in respect of all the documents. My reasons follow. First, the nature of the National Disability Insurance Scheme is different to other jurisdictions in which the Tribunal and the Courts have considered whether the undertaking should be released. The documents have not been produced in litigious proceedings before a court between parties who are unlikely to have an ongoing relationship. As Ms Cook is a participant in the Scheme she will have an ongoing relationship with the Agency which is required to regularly review her plan. The documents will assist the Agency in making decisions in relation to Ms Cook’s plans, possibly for years to come. On the material before me there is no apparent reason why the Agency should be required to take the time and incur the expense to obtain, by other means, documents which are already in its possession. Ms Cook has argued that although the documents were produced in proceedings related to particular supports requested by her, they may be used by the Agency in considering other supports and in considering whether she should remain a participant in the Scheme. I do not consider that this is a relevant consideration in view of the ongoing relationship between herself as a participant and the Agency as the body responsible for the administration of the Scheme. Given the ongoing supports being provided to Ms Cook under her present plan and the potential for further supports under future plans, the Agency’s request to be permitted to use the documents “for the purposes of assessing the Applicant’s entitlements under the NDIS Act”[2] is appropriate.[2] Respondents Submissions as to its request for a release from the implied undertaking dated 23 November 2020 at [33]. Secondly, if the Agency makes decisions relating to other supports or Ms Cook’s continuing participation in the Scheme, it is likely that all of the documents would be available to it should Ms Cook apply to the Tribunal to review those decisions. It is in the interests of Ms Cook and the interests of good public administration that the Agency have all available material before it in making reviewable decisions to minimize the need for administrative review by the Tribunal.