Hawthorn v Tomago Aluminium Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Hawthorn v Tomago Aluminium Co Pty Ltd [2022] NSWPIC 56

APPLICANT: Gary Allan Hawthorn
RESPONDENT: Tomago Aluminium Co Pty Ltd
MEMBER: Brett Batchelor
DATE OF DECISION: 9 February 2022
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION -  Claim for the cost of bilateral hearing aids as being reasonably necessary as a result of undisputed noise induced hearing loss; the respondent asserts, based on the opinion of Dr Fernandes, that the average bilateral hearing loss is to be 40 dB over the higher frequencies of 2000, 3000 and 4000 Hz before a person becomes hearing handicapped such as to show the reasonable necessity for hearing aids as a result of injury; differing results of audiograms relied upon by the applicant and respondent; detailed examination of the medical evidence; Murphy v Allity and Diab v NRMA Insurance Ltd referred to; Held - award for the applicant and the respondent ordered to pay for the provision of bilateral hearing aids pursuant to the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the Workers Compensation (Hearing Aid Fees) Order 2021. 

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1.    The supply and fitting of hearing aids to the applicant is reasonably necessary as a result of injury, namely, the bilateral loss of hearing due to noise exposure.

2. The respondent is to pay for the provision of bilateral hearing aids for the applicant pursuant to s 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the Workers Compensation (Hearing Aid Fees) Order 2021.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Gary Allan Hawthorn (the applicant/Mr Hawthorn) seeks compensation for the cost of supply and fitting of hearing aids pursuant to s 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act) as a result of industrial deafness he suffered arising out of or in the course of his employment with Tomago Aluminium Co Pty Ltd (the respondent) over the period from 18 April 1995 to 29 August 2017. During that time Mr Hawthorn was exposed to noise from ingot chain(s), aluminium machinery, diesel forklifts, overhead cranes, conveyor belts, robots, thumping machinery, and general manufacturing noise. He worked four to five days a week, five to six hours a day. Hearing protection was provided.

  2. The respondent does not dispute that the applicant was engaged in noisy employment, that is, employment to the nature of which his loss, or further loss, of hearing was due.

  3. The applicant was assessed by Dr Paul Fagan, ear nose and throat surgeon, on 8 December 2017 who produced reports dated 28 February 2018 and 5 January 2021. Dr Fagan assessed Mr Hawthorn as having sustained a total compensable percentage binaural hearing loss (BHL) of 10.1, which converts to 5% whole person impairment (WPI). The doctor found that the nature of the applicant’s hearing loss would warrant the use of digital hearing aids with a minimum of 20 processing channels with feedback cancellation capability which would provide superior clarity and intelligibility of speech.

  4. On 1 August 2018 the applicant was assessed by Dr Sylvester Fernandes, ear, nose, and throat surgeon, who produced…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hawthorn v Tomago Aluminium Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPIC 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hawthorn v Tomago Aluminium Co Pty Ltd, the applicant sought compensation for the cost of bilateral hearing aids, asserting that these were reasonably necessary due to noise-induced hearing loss resulting from his employment. The respondent contested the claim, arguing that the average bilateral hearing loss should be 40 dB over certain frequencies before it could be considered that hearing aids were necessary. The court had to determine whether the applicant's hearing loss was sufficient to warrant the provision of bilateral hearing aids under the Workers Compensation Act 1987. This required a detailed examination of the medical evidence presented by both parties, particularly the differing audiograms and expert opinions regarding the extent of the hearing loss and its impact on the applicant's ability to comprehend speech.

The court considered the reports of Dr Fagan and Dr Fernandes, along with the conclusions of Brian Moore on the effects of noise-induced hearing loss at higher frequencies. Dr Fagan's report emphasised the adverse effects of such hearing loss on speech comprehension, especially in noisy environments, and concluded that the applicant's NIHL was a material contributor to his need for hearing aids. In contrast, Dr Fernandes argued that the applicant's hearing loss was not severe enough to necessitate hearing aids, based on his own audiogram results and the belief that the best recorded audiogram was the most accurate. The court had to weigh these conflicting opinions and determine the threshold for hearing aid necessity.

After careful consideration of the evidence and authorities, including the cases of Murphy v Allity and Diab v NRMA Insurance Ltd, the court found that the applicant's hearing loss was indeed significant enough to warrant the provision of bilateral hearing aids. The court accepted Dr Fagan's expert opinion and the conclusions of Brian Moore, finding that the applicant's ability to comprehend speech was materially affected by his hearing loss. Consequently, the court ruled in favour of the applicant, ordering the respondent to pay for the provision of bilateral hearing aids as per the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the Workers Compensation (Hearing Aid Fees) Order 2021.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Dr Fagan refers back to the paper by Brian Moore where he concludes:“There is very strong evidence that NIHL (noise induced hearing loss) for frequencies above 3kHz has adverse effects on the ability to understand speech, especially when background noise is present. Hearing loss for frequencies above 3kHz also adversely affects sound localization”. (emphasis in original)Dr Fagan refers to the major complaints of Mr Hawthorn of an inability to comprehend speech in person or over the telephone in the presence of background noise, and his observation of improved comprehension of speech following the trial of hearing aids, which is entirely consistent with the conclusions presented by Moore. Dr Fagan concludes his report with the view that he has no doubt hearing aids would benefit the applicant, as his noise induced hearing loss (NIHL) is a material contributor to his need for hearing aids. Without his NIHL, Dr Fagan doubts that the applicant would require hearing aids. In his first report dated 2 August 2018[6] Dr Fernandes records the hearing losses in the left and right ears found by him as follows:[6] Reply p 2. In that report Dr Fernandes says that as a result of the audiogram he carried out that Mr Hawthorn has an asymmetric hearing loss, with the right side being worse that the left side. Noise induced hearing loss is essentially symmetric, as in most occupational environments, the ears are exposed to similar sound levels bilaterally, even when the apparent noise source comes from one side. The right ear is hence equated to the left. As a result, the hearing loss on the left side has been taken into consideration for the calculation of the noise induced hearing loss on the right side. Dr Fernandes says that frequencies below 2 KHz are not included in the calculation because the configuration of the audiogram obtained in the lower frequencies is not comparable with that of noise induced hearing loss. He says that after consideration of the nature and duration (immission levels) of occupational noise exposure and the nature and extent of all the hearing losses, including those at 0.5, 1 and 1.5 KHz, the hearing losses at 2, 3 and 4 Hz are caused by his occupational noise exposure. Dr Fernandes comments on the report of Dr Fagan, noting that he obtained higher thresholds. He says that such may occur, inter alia, as a result of contamination by temporary threshold shift (TTS), by functional hearing loss or by some other source of fluctuating loss. He says:“Nevertheless being a behavioural test, it should be obvious that when hearing levels on contemporary serial audiograms differ in the absence of an obvious and identifiable intervening contributory causative incident detrimental to hearing, the best recorded audiogram is likely to be the most precise and correct one.” Dr Fernandes says that hearing aids are not reasonably and necessary as a result of the compensable injury, as in the audiogram that he obtained it appears that the speech reception frequencies are not significantly affected. Also the speech recognition thresholds are 95% at 55 dB on the left and 85% at 70 dB on the right. In answer to a specific question put to him, Dr Fernandes expresses the belief that Mr Hawthorn’s hearing loss is partially due to his employment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established