Hassan v Sydney Local Health District

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Hassan v Sydney Local Health District [2019] NSWSC 1652
Hearing dates: 18 October 2019
Date of orders: 28 November 2019
Decision date: 28 November 2019
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Fagan J
Decision:

1. Plaintiff’s claim dismissed in part for non-compliance with r 31.36.
2. Order for separate determination of a question with respect to balance of proceedings and directions for service of evidence.

Legislation Cited: Health Services Act 1997 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Hassan v Royal Prince Alfred Hospital [2019] NSWSC 1651
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Ayan Abdi Hassan (plaintiff)
Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
N/A
B Bradley (defendant)

  Solicitors:
Plaintiff self-represented
Makinson d’Apice Lawyers
File Number(s): 2018/00114499
Publication restriction: No

Judgment

  1. Before the Court is a notice of motion filed by the plaintiff on 10 October 2019 seeking leave “to issue subpoenas and then to amend the statement of claim”. Leave is required under r 7.3(1) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (“UCPR”). The substantive proceeding is a claim in medical negligence pursuant to a statement of claim filed on 5 April 2018. No draft of an amended statement of claim has been proffered by the plaintiff. The plaintiff has tendered a draft subpoena addressed to Dr R Jones, Medicolegal Section, Medical Records Department, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital and Institute of Rheumatology and Orthopaedics.

  2. The plaintiff has been self-represented throughout the proceedings, with the exception of the period from 26 July 2019 to 27 September 2019, during which time she had a solicitor on the record. The plaintiff’s present notice of motion contains submissions in support of the leave that she seeks, including references to statutes, rules and authorities. The notice of motion is supported by affidavits of the plaintiff affirmed on 10 October 2019 and 18 October 2019.

  3. The Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (“the Hospital”) is named in the plaintiff’s pleading as defendant but it is not a legal entity against which an action in negligence can appropriately be brought. Pursuant to ss 7 and 17 of the Health Services Act 1997 (NSW) the statutory corporation that should be joined as defendant in proceedings alleging negligence in the provision of health care at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital is the Sydney Local Health District. This has been pointed out to the plaintiff by the defendant and confirmed to her by the Court on a number of occasions.

  4. The plaintiff has disregarded what she has been told in this respect and insists that not only the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital but also the Institute of Rheumatology and Orthopaedics should be named defendants. The Hospital is an enterprise operated in that name by the Sydney Local Health District and the Institute is a clinical service conducted by the Sydney Local Health District within the Hospital. On prior occasions when the proceedings have been before the Court the plaintiff has sought to have the Institute joined as defendant. That application is misconceived and has been rejected. In order to regularise…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hassan v Sydney Local Health District and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWSC 1652
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved a notice of motion filed by Ayan Abdi Hassan, the plaintiff, seeking leave to issue subpoenas and amend the statement of claim. The substantive proceeding was a claim in medical negligence against the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital. The defendant, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, was represented by B Bradley, while the plaintiff was self-represented, except for a brief period from 26 July 2019 to 27 September 2019, during which time she had a solicitor on the record. The plaintiff had been advised that the statutory corporation that should be joined as defendant in proceedings alleging negligence in the provision of health care at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital is the Sydney Local Health District, pursuant to ss 7 and 17 of the Health Services Act 1997 (NSW). The plaintiff had disregarded this advice and insisted on naming the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital and the Institute of Rheumatology and Orthopaedics as defendants. The court ruled that the Sydney Local Health District should be added as a defendant to regularise the proceedings.

The court also considered the plaintiff's ongoing non-compliance with r 31.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR). The rule requires that any claim in medical negligence must be supported by an expert's opinion that is filed and served along with the statement of claim. The plaintiff had asserted that she could not comply with r 31.36 unless she first obtained the Hospital's records, which was incorrect. The court had previously ordered the plaintiff to comply with r 31.36 by 15 March 2019. Despite this, the plaintiff had still not served a report under r 31.36 and was still pressing for the defendant to provide more documents.

The court found that the plaintiff's claims in negligence were not supportable by medical opinion, as the reports provided by Professor David Morris and Dr Ali Kian Mehr did not substantiate the allegations made by the plaintiff. As a result, the court exercised its discretion under subrule (3) of r 31.36 to dismiss the relevant parts of the claim. The single surviving claim was allegation (1), based upon the plaintiff's allegation that she did not consent to a biopsy of her left quadriceps. The court ordered that the question of whether the plaintiff gave a valid and effective consent for the muscle biopsy to be carried out by the defendant on her left vastus or quadriceps muscle should be determined separately and before all other issues in the proceedings.

In summary, the court dismissed the plaintiff's notice of motion, ordered the Sydney Local Health District to be added as a defendant, and dismissed most of the plaintiff's claims in negligence due to non-compliance with r 31.36. The court also ordered the separate determination of the question of whether the plaintiff gave a valid and effective consent for the muscle biopsy to be carried out by the defendant on her left vastus or quadriceps muscle.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ayan Abdi Hassan (the plaintiff) initiated a claim for medical negligence against the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (the defendant) on 5 April 2018. The plaintiff alleged several instances of negligence during medical procedures performed on her on 7 April 2015, including lack of consent for a muscle biopsy on her left quadriceps, administration of general anaesthetic instead of local anaesthetic, performance of procedures by unqualified personnel, failure to suture surgical wounds, performing an operation on her left rotator cuff tendons instead of a muscle biopsy, removal of bone tumours instead of muscle biopsies, failure to diagnose her condition, and using her tissue samples for research without consent. The plaintiff was self-represented throughout the proceedings except for a brief period where she had a solicitor. The defendant pointed out that the proper defendant in a claim for negligence in the provision of health care at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital is the Sydney Local Health District, but the plaintiff insisted on naming the hospital and the Institute of Rheumatology and Orthopaedics as defendants. The Court ordered the Sydney Local Health District to be added as a defendant. The plaintiff failed to comply with rule 31.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that any claim in medical negligence must be supported by an expert's opinion filed and served along with the statement of claim.

The plaintiff filed a notice of motion on 10 October 2019 seeking leave to issue subpoenas and amend the statement of claim. The matter was heard by Fagan J on 18 October 2019. This was not the first time the plaintiff had sought to amend her pleadings or obtain further discovery. The Court had previously granted the plaintiff extensions of time to comply with rule 31.36 and had directed her to do so by 19 July 2019. Despite receiving a verified list of documents from the defendant, the plaintiff failed to serve a report under rule 31.36. In a prior decision, Hassan v Royal Prince Alfred Hospital [2019] NSWSC 1651, the Court found that the plaintiff had ample documents to comply with rule 31.36 and directed her to do so by 19 July 2019. The matter was stood over to 26 July 2019 for confirmation of compliance, and further extensions of time were granted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to leave to issue subpoenas and amend the statement of claim?
2. Whether the plaintiff's claim should be dismissed in part for non-compliance with rule 31.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules?
3. Whether the question of whether the plaintiff gave a valid and effective consent for a muscle biopsy to be carried out by the defendant on her left vastus or quadriceps muscle should be determined separately and before all other questions in the proceedings?

Held
1. The plaintiff is not entitled to leave to issue subpoenas and amend the statement of claim.
2. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed in part for non-compliance with rule 31.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.
3. The question of whether the plaintiff gave a valid and effective consent for a muscle biopsy to be carried out by the defendant on her left vastus or quadriceps muscle should be determined separately and before all other questions in the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the plaintiff's notice of motion seeking leave to issue subpoenas and amend the statement of claim. The plaintiff had been self-represented throughout the proceedings except for a brief period when she had a solicitor on the record. The court noted that the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, named as defendant, was not a legal entity against which an action in negligence could be brought and added the Sydney Local Health District as a defendant instead. The court also addressed the plaintiff's non-compliance with rule 31.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that any claim in medical negligence must be supported by an expert's opinion filed and served along with the statement of claim. Despite multiple opportunities, the plaintiff had not complied with the rule. The court found that the medical reports provided did not support the allegations of negligence and dismissed the relevant parts of the claim.

Regarding the remaining claim of lack of consent for a muscle biopsy on the plaintiff's left quadriceps, the court determined that the question of consent should be determined separately and before all other questions in the proceedings. The court ordered the plaintiff and the Sydney Local Health District to file and serve evidentiary statements of themselves and any other witnesses they propose to call at the hearing of the separate question.

The court dismissed the plaintiff's notice of motion and ordered her to pay the costs of the Sydney Local Health District. The proceedings were listed for directions and for the appointment of a hearing date for the separate question.