Hassan v Royal Prince Alfred Hospital

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Hassan v Royal Prince Alfred Hospital [2019] NSWSC 1651
Hearing dates: 14 June 2019
Date of orders: 14 June 2019
Decision date: 14 June 2019
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Fagan J
Decision:

1. The proceedings are stood over to 26 Jul 2019 at 9.30am.
2. The plaintiff is directed to file an expert medical report complying with rule 31.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules no later than 5pm on Friday 19 July 2019.
3. If order 2 is not complied with then on Friday 26 July 2019 the plaintiff will be required to show cause why her statement of claim should not be dismissed.
4. Costs of the hearing of the notices of motion and of the proceedings to date are reserved.

Legislation Cited: Health Services Act 1997 (NSW)
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Ayan Abdi Hassan (plaintiff)
Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
N/A
B Bradley (defendant)

  Solicitors:
Plaintiff self-represented
Makinson d’Apice Lawyers
File Number(s): 2018/00114499

Judgment

  1. The plaintiff filed on 5 April 2018 a statement of claim for damages for alleged negligent provision of medical care by the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital. The named defendant in the proceedings is Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (“RPAH”. The proper defendant would be the Sydney Local Area Health District, being a body constituted under s 17(1) of the Health Services Act 1997(NSW). If the proceedings continue the plaintiff will be required to file an amended statement of claim naming the correct defendant.

  2. Before the Court is a notice of motion filed by the defendant on 8 October 2018 seeking dismissal of the proceedings pursuant to r 31.36(3) of the UCPR on the ground that there has not been filed with the statement of claim an expert's report supporting essential elements of the plaintiff's alleged cause of action in negligence.

  3. Three notices of motion filed by the plaintiff on 6 July 2018, 20 December 2018 and 15 April 2019 must also be determined. Those notices of motion seek a variety of orders for the discovery and production of documents, for the setting aside of directions made on 7 December 2018 and for supplementary discovery. During the hearing on 14 June 2019 the plaintiff also applied orally for leave to issue a subpoena in the form of a document which was marked exhibit A.

The substantive claim

  1. The plaintiff is self-represented and appeared in person on the hearing of the notices of motion. I have relied upon documents produced by the defendant to ascertain in broad terms the circumstances in which the negligence claim has been made. During 2014 the plaintiff's general practitioner Dr Kwok of Auburn referred her to Dr Teychenne who apparently has some expertise in neurology. The plaintiff had presented over the preceding two years with proximal muscle wasting of the lower and upper limbs associated with muscle weakness. Doctor Teychenne found her symptoms consistent with myopathy and/or dystrophy.

  2. On 14 October 2014 he referred her to Dr Judith…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hassan v Royal Prince Alfred Hospital and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWSC 1651
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ayan Abdi Hassan, the plaintiff, is proceeding with a claim for damages for alleged negligent provision of medical care by the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (the defendant). The proceedings have been stayed by Fagan J. The plaintiff is to file an expert medical report complying with rule 31.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules by 5pm on 19 July 2019. If the plaintiff does not file the report by this date, the proceedings will be dismissed. Costs of the hearing and of the proceedings to date are reserved. The plaintiff is a self-represented litigant proceeding in person. The Court has been required to determine a number of matters. These include a notice of motion filed by the defendant seeking dismissal of the proceedings on the ground that there has not been filed with the statement of claim an expert's report supporting essential elements of the plaintiff's alleged cause of action in negligence. The plaintiff has also filed notices of motion seeking a variety of orders for the discovery and production of documents, for the setting aside of directions made on 7 December 2018 and for supplementary discovery. During the hearing on 14 June 2019 the plaintiff also applied orally for leave to issue a subpoena in the form of a document which was marked exhibit A. The plaintiff's claim is that she consented to a muscle biopsy of her left deltoid only and gave no consent for the biopsy of her left quadriceps which the hospital says it carried out. She consented only to local anaesthetic but a general anaesthetic was administered. The procedure was done by Dr Gkikas, Dr Snir and Dr Goltsman, and the anaesthesia was administered by Dr Allenby, all of whom, the plaintiff alleges, were not qualified doctors but medical students. The hospital failed to suture the plaintiff's surgical wounds or to provide adequate preoperative or postoperative care to avert infection of those wounds. Instead of a muscle biopsy being performed on her left deltoid, open surgery on her left rotator cuff tendons was carried out. The procedures on her left arm and left leg were not merely muscle biopsies, but were procedures for removal of bone tumours and the hospital fabricated a false referral to itself from Dr Edward Lurie for the performance of the bone tumour removal procedure. The hospital failed to diagnose the plaintiff's condition. The hospital permitted tissue extracted from the plaintiff to be used for research by Professor Barnett, Professor Pamphlett, Dr Salemajar, Professor Ng and Professor Kapoor without having advised the plaintiff that this would occur without having obtained her consent. The defendant has supplied what it says are copies of all of its records. These have been exhibited to affidavits read on the hearing of the notices of motion and they appear complete. The defendant says that its case will be that these documents are accurate as to the events, subject to some anomalies of record-keeping, to which reference has already been made. The defendant says that the anomalies can be explained and that, broadly, the records describe what occurred in the procedure performed upon the plaintiff. The plaintiff asserted that she was unable to provide any medical expert report in support of her case as required by rule 31.36 in the absence of a complete copy of the defendant's records relating to her treatment and care. The Court has considered the evidence and concluded that the plaintiff should have been able to file a report under rule 31.36 without the necessity of further documents being provided by the defendant. The Court has therefore ordered that the plaintiff file an expert medical report complying with rule 31.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules by 5pm on Friday 19 July 2019. If the plaintiff does not comply with this order, the proceedings will be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established