Harvey and Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 654

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No  S1999/158  

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      RICHARD HARVEY          
  Applicant
           And    COMCARE  
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Senior Member J.A. Kiosoglous MBE Ms U. Dahl (Member)

Date3 August 2000

PlaceAdelaide

Decision      Pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
  (Signed)
  J.A. KIOSOGLOUS MBE
  (Senior Member)
CATCHWORDS
COMPENSATION - impotence - accepted back injury - morphine use related to impotence - whether applicant suffers from impotence - "reasonable" rehabilitative treatment considered - whether certain available treatments reasonable - causation - novus actus interveniens - assault prior to  morphine use - whether causal connection remains between back injury and impotence - applicant's evidence and reliability as a witness considered - application of s48 - distinction drawn between injuries claimed
 Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss. 4, 24, 48
Re O'Maley and Comcare (1997) 48 ALD 300
Re Drage and Comcare (AAT 10925, 10 May 1996)
Re PAK and Commonwealth of Australia (AAT 4409, 8 June 1988)
Fazlic v Milingimbi Community Inc (1982) 150 CLR 345
Dragojlovic v Director-General of Social Security (1984) 52 ALR 157
March v Stramare Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 506
Home Office v Dorset Yacht Co Ltd [1970] AC 1026
Starr v Northern Territory of Australia [1998] NTSC 90
Australian Eagle Insurance Company Ltd v Federation Insurance Ltd (1976) 15 SASR 282
Telstra Corporation Limited v Barrow (1994) 35 ALD 461

REASONS FOR DECISION

3 August 2000    Senior Member J.A. Kiosoglous MBE  Ms U. Dahl (Member)                    

  1. This is an application by Mr Richard Harvey (the applicant) for review of a decision of a review officer of the respondent dated 24 February 1999 (T34) which affirmed a decision of a  delegate of the respondent dated 5 October 1998 (T31) to cease liability in respect of the claimed condition "permanent impairment for penile dysfunction".

  2. The Tribunal received into evidence the documents lodged pursuant to s.37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T1-T35) and supplementary documents (ST1-ST17), together with 11 exhibits, 2 lodged by the applicant (Exhibits A1-A2) and 9 lodged by the respondent (Exhibits R1-R9). In addition, the Tribunal heard evidence from the applicant, who also called Mrs A. Harvey, his wife, and Dr J. Siow, General Practitioner. The respondent called Dr C. Lott, Radiologist, as a witness, and required Dr J. Bolt, Urologist, for cross-examination. The applicant was represented by Mr P. Humphries and the respondent was represented by Mr M. Roder, both of counsel.

  3. The issues before the Tribunal are whether or not the applicant suffers a permanent impairment in respect of impotence; and if so, to what extent.
    applicant's evidence

  4. The applicant, who was born on 17 February 1945, told the Tribunal that he had a back injury in 1978 whilst in the employ of the Department of Defence and has continued to have problems since that time.  He has been married for 34 years and enjoyed an active sex life up…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harvey and Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 654
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case, Harvey and Comcare, was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, where the applicant, Harvey, sought compensation for a back injury he sustained in 1978 while employed by the Department of Defence. Harvey claimed that this injury resulted in impotence, which he attributed to his use of morphine. The Tribunal had to decide if the applicant suffered from impotence due to the back injury and if so, to what extent. Additionally, the Tribunal had to determine whether certain treatments for impotence were reasonable and whether the applicant's morphine use, which he claimed was related to his impotence, could be considered as a reasonable rehabilitative treatment. The Tribunal also had to assess the reliability of the applicant's evidence and consider the application of section 48 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

The Tribunal found that Harvey's claim of impotence was linked to his morphine use, which was a consequence of his back injury. However, the Tribunal noted that the assault Harvey experienced in 1993 could have also contributed to his sexual problems. Despite this, the Tribunal concluded that the back injury remained the primary cause of Harvey's impotence. The Tribunal examined various treatments for impotence, including a vacuum pump, cream, Viagra, and MUSE, and found that these treatments were reasonable. The Tribunal also considered the applicant's evidence, taking into account his past legal issues and credibility. The Tribunal found that section 48 of the Act did not apply in this case, as there was a clear distinction between the injury for which compensation was received in the criminal injury compensation proceedings and the injury claimed in these proceedings.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that Harvey suffered from impotence due to his back injury, but that the assault in 1993 and his morphine use also contributed to his condition. The Tribunal concluded that reasonable rehabilitative treatments were available to Harvey and that his morphine use, while related to his impotence, was not a reasonable treatment option. The Tribunal's decision was based on a careful consideration of the evidence and the applicable legal principles.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issues before the Tribunal are whether or not the applicant suffers a permanent impairment in respect of impotence; and if so, to what extent. applicant's evidence The applicant, who was born on 17 February 1945, told the Tribunal that he had a back injury in 1978 whilst in the employ of the Department of Defence and has continued to have problems since that time. He has been married for 34 years and enjoyed an active sex life up until 1993, fluctuating somewhat according to his back injury. He estimated having sex about 2-3 times per week in 1992. He stated that his sexual interest waned in 1993 but that he did not mention this to Dr Siow, his General Practitioner, because he was too embarrassed. He stated that following an incident where he was assaulted in 1993, he did not feel like sex for about four to six weeks, but returned to normal later. He further stated that some time after this in 1993 he began to lose interest in sex, which he put down to the medication he was on. He stated that by early 1994 he could not obtain a satisfactory erection, and considered his last full erection to be in late 1992/early 1993. He stated, in cross-examination, that he could count on one hand the number of times between 1993 and 1996 that he had actual sex involving an erection and penetration. He stated that he has tried a vacuum pump, cream and a trial of Viagra, none of which have been successful. He further stated that he has tried MUSE on one occasion with out success but got a second prescription filled because he wished to try again. In relation to the Viagra trial, he stated that he would try for several nights in a row and then leave it for a couple of weeks over the course of six to nine months. He is prepared to try a different vacuum pump if one is offered. He is reticent to have an operation, and is terrified of injections, such that regular injections are not a practical solution to his problem. He told the Tribunal that he has not had sex for the past three years. He told the Tribunal that he is slowly coming off morphine from 120 to 70-80 milligrams per day with the help of a psychologist. His general health has also been improving in the past few months, and he is exercising more frequently. He could not recall the details about his admission to Hillcrest Psychiatric Hospital in 1990 and 1991, nor the details of his court appearances in respect of a false report conviction in 1990. In respect of the conviction, he stated that he lied to the police whilst intoxicated. Once he was sober and had been told by others present what he had done, he proceeded immediately to the police station to correct this and tell the truth. He agreed, in cross-examination, that he was only now able to pinpoint the onset of sexual problems as being 1992/1993 by reference to records of when the assault occurred. He also stated that his wife sleeps in a separate bedroom most of the time.mrs a. harvey Mrs A. Harvey stated that between 1990 and 1992 she and her husband enjoyed a consistent and active sex life, given the circumstances and length of their marriage. She stated that it was uncommon at that time to go a month without sex.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the Tribunal does not consider that section 48 of the Act has a role to play here and so finds. There is clearly a difference in the Tribunal's opinion between the injury that compensation was received "in respect of" in the criminal injury compensation proceedings resulting from the assault and the injury claimed in these proceedings. The criminal injury compensation claim includes a head of claim for "decline in sexual life" which is to be factually distinguished as an "injury" from this impotence claim. "Decline in sexual life" does not necessarily relate to impotence, but could arise as a result of any of the other problems which arose as a result of the assault. There is a sufficient factual distinction to be drawn in this case between the two "injuries", consistent with the approach taken by the Full Federal Court in Telstra Corporation Limited v Barrow (1994) 35 ALD 461.decision For the reasons given, and pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.I certify that the 75 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Senior Member J.A. Kiosoglous MBE and Ms U. Dahl (Member)Signed: ..................................................................................... Personal AssistantDate/s of Hearing 29-30 May 2000 & 19 July 2000 Date of Decision 3 August 2000Counsel for the Applicant Mr P. Humphries Solicitor for the Applicant Duncan Basheer Hannon Counsel for the Respondent Mr M. Roder Solicitor for the Respondent Norman Waterhouse

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established