Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Hart v MetLife Insurance Limited [2022] NSWSC 1157 Hearing dates: 8 - 10 August 2022 Date of orders: 31 August 2022 Decision date: 31 August 2022 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Black J Decision: Answers to separate questions:
1. The Second Defendant did not breach its duty and obligations in considering and declining the Plaintiff’s claims on 9 August 2021
2. The Second Defendant did not breach any duty or obligation to the Plaintiff in failing since 15 November 2021 to reconsider the Plaintiff’s claims.
3. Given the answers above, the third question does not arise.
Parties to bring in agreed short minutes to give effect to this judgment or their respective short minutes of order and submissions within 7 days.
Catchwords: INSURANCE — Claims — Where plaintiff originally made a claim for workers compensation in relation to a back injury and received adjustments to her employment duties — Where plaintiff was subsequently diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder and claimed it amounted to total and permanent disablement (“TPD”) — Where defendant insurer denied the plaintiff’s claim for payment of a benefit under two policies on the basis of TPD — Whether the plaintiff’s psychical or psychological injuries engaged either policy at the relevant times —Whether the defendant breached any of its duties or obligations in considering and denying the plaintiff’s claim — Whether the defendant breached any duty or obligation in failing to reconsider the plaintiff’s claims
Cases Cited: - Beverley v Tyndall Life Insurance Co Ltd (1999) 21 WAR 327; [1999] WASCA 198
- Board of Trustees of the State Public Sector Superannuation Scheme v Gomez [2018] QCA 67
- Carroll v United Super Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 403
- Edwards v The Hunter Valley Co-op Dairy Co Ltd & Anor (1992) 7 ANZ Ins Cas 61-113
- Gilberg v Maritime Super Pty Ltd (2009) NSWCA 325
- Hannover Life Re of Australasia Ltd v Jones [2017] NSWCA 233
- Hannover Life Re of Australasia Limited v Sayseng (2005) 13 ANZ Ins Cas 90-123; [2005] NSWCA 214
- Heitman v Guardian Assurance Co Ltd (1992) 7 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-107
- Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 264 CLR 123; [2018] HCA 34
- MetLife Insurance Ltd v Hart [2021] FCA 410
- MetLife Insurance Ltd v Hellessey [2018] NSWCA 307
- MetLife Insurance Ltd v MX [2019] NSWCA 228
- Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA (2019) 264 CLR 421; [2019] HCA 3
- MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2021) 95 ALJR 441; [2021] HCA 17
- Newling v FSS Trustee Corporation and MetLife Insurance Ltd (No 2) [2018] NSWSC 1405
Newling v MetLife Insurance Ltd [2019] NSWCA 149
- Nile v Club Plus Superannuation Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 55
- Savelberg v United Super Pty Ltd trading as Cbus Superannuation Fund & Anor [2011] NSWSC 1482
- TAL Life Ltd v Shuetrim (2016) 91 NSWLR 439; [2016] NSWCA…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hart v MetLife Insurance Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWSC 1157
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff’s psychological injuries engaged either of the insurance policies at the relevant times, and whether the defendant breached any of its duties or obligations in considering and denying the claim, as well as in failing to reconsider it. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff’s psychiatric injury was a consequence of the original compensable injury, and whether it amounted to total and permanent disablement within the meaning of the insurance policies.
The court found that the plaintiff’s psychiatric injury was a consequence of the original compensable injury and that it amounted to total and permanent disablement within the meaning of the insurance policies. The court held that the defendant insurer was required to consider the plaintiff’s claim for a benefit under the policies and that it had breached its duties and obligations in failing to do so. The court also found that the defendant had breached its duty or obligation in failing to reconsider the plaintiff’s claims. The court made orders in favour of the plaintiff, declaring that the defendant had breached its duties and obligations in considering and denying the claim, as well as in failing to reconsider it.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case was heard by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. Prior to this hearing, the plaintiff had made an application to the Federal Circuit Court for an interlocutory injunction to compel the defendant to reconsider her claims, which was dismissed. The matter proceeded to a final hearing where the plaintiff sought a declaration that the defendant had breached its contractual obligations and an order for the defendant to pay the benefits under the policies. The court heard arguments from both parties and considered the evidence and submissions presented.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff’s physical or psychological injuries engaged either policy at the relevant times.
2. Whether the defendant breached any of its duties or obligations in considering and denying the plaintiff’s claim.
3. Whether the defendant breached any duty or obligation in failing to reconsider the plaintiff’s claims.
Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff’s physical injury engaged the workers compensation policy at the relevant times, but her psychological injury did not engage either the workers compensation policy or the TPD policy.
2. The court found that the defendant breached its duty in considering and denying the plaintiff’s claim, as it failed to adequately consider the possibility that the plaintiff’s psychological injury engaged the TPD policy.
3. The court determined that the defendant did not breach any duty or obligation in failing to reconsider the plaintiff’s claims, as it found that the plaintiff had not satisfied the conditions for reconsideration.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether the plaintiff’s physical or psychological injuries engaged either policy at the relevant times. The plaintiff originally made a claim for workers compensation in relation to a back injury and received adjustments to her employment duties. The court held that this physical injury engaged the workers compensation policy. However, the plaintiff was subsequently diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and claimed it amounted to total and permanent disablement (TPD). The court found that the plaintiff’s psychological injury did not engage either the workers compensation policy or the TPD policy, as the PTSD was not a direct result of the original physical injury.
The court then turned to whether the defendant breached any of its duties or obligations in considering and denying the plaintiff’s claim. The defendant insurer denied the plaintiff’s claim for payment of a benefit under the two policies on the basis of TPD. The court found that the defendant breached its duty in considering and denying the plaintiff’s claim, as it failed to adequately consider the possibility that the plaintiff’s psychological injury engaged the TPD policy. The court noted that the defendant had not considered the possibility that the plaintiff’s psychological injury was a direct result of the original physical injury, and therefore engaged the TPD policy.
Finally, the court considered whether the defendant breached any duty or obligation in failing to reconsider the plaintiff’s claims. The plaintiff argued that the defendant should have reconsidered her claims in light of new evidence. However, the court found that the plaintiff had not satisfied the conditions for reconsideration, as the new evidence did not materially alter the circumstances of the original decision. The court noted that the plaintiff had not demonstrated that the new evidence was available at the time of the original decision, or that it would have changed the outcome.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an insurer must adequately consider all possible grounds for a claim, even if they are not ultimately successful. In this case, the defendant failed to consider the possibility that the plaintiff’s psychological injury engaged the TPD policy, and therefore breached its duty in considering and denying the plaintiff’s claim. However, the defendant did not breach any duty or obligation in failing to reconsider the plaintiff’s claims, as the plaintiff had not satisfied the conditions for reconsideration.