Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Hart v MetLife Insurance Limited [2023] NSWCA 230 Hearing dates: 31 July 2023, 6 September 2023 Date of orders: 28 September 2023 Decision date: 28 September 2023 Before: Meagher JA at [1];
Leeming JA at [95];
Mitchelmore JA at [96]Decision: (1) Leave be granted to amend the notice of appeal to include ground 5.
(2) Allow the appeal on ground 5.
(3) Set aside order 1 made by Black J on 15 September 2022 to the extent that order dismisses the prayers for relief referred to in order 4 below.
(4) Order that the proceedings in respect of the prayers for relief made by pars 4, 5 and 6 as supported by pars 8, 10-12, 16-27 and 36 of the Statement of Claim be remitted to the Equity Division for determination of those claims.
(5) Set aside order 2 made by Black J on 15 September 2022.
(6) Direct that MetLife provide written submissions not to exceed 3 pages within 7 days of the making of these orders on the question of costs, and that Ms Hart respond to those submissions within 7 days of their receipt, her submissions also not to exceed 3 pages. In each case the submissions are to be provided to Meagher JA’s Associate.
Catchwords: INSURANCE — Claims — Where insurer denied insured’s claim to total and permanent disablement benefit on basis that it was not “on risk” for injury or illness causing disablement — Where parties consented to determination of separate questions which could not decide that issue — Issue remitted to Equity Division for decision
CIVIL PROCEDURE — Separate determination of questions — Where primary judge dismissed whole of proceedings following answers to separate questions — Where separate questions asked whether there were breaches by insurer in denying and failing to reconsider insured’s claim — Whether separate questions capable of disposing of whole of proceedings — Whether parties’ agreement justified making an order under UCPR r 28.4 dismissing proceedings
Legislation Cited: Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (Cth), s 46(1)
Uniform Civil Procedural Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 28.2, 28.4
Cases Cited: Burke v MetLife Insurance Ltd [2019] NSWSC 177
CGU Insurance Limited v AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd (2007) 235 CLR 1; [2007] HCA 36
Edwards v The Hunter Valley Co-op Dairy Co Ltd (1992) 7 ANZ Ins Cas 61-113
Fidelitas Shipping Co Ltd v V/O Exportchleb [1966] 1 QB 630
Hannover Life Re of Australasia Limited v Sayseng [2005] NSWCA 214; (2005) 13 ANZ Ins Cas 90-123
Hannover Life Re of Australasia Ltd v Jones [2017] NSWCA 233
McArthur v Mercantile Mutual Life Ins Co Ltd [2002] 2 Qd R 197; [2001] QCA 317
Medical Defence Union Ltd v Department of Trade [1980] Ch 82
MetLife Insurance Ltd v Hart [2021] FCA 410
MetLife Insurance Ltd v Hellessey [2018] NSWCA 307
O’Toole v Charles David Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 232; [1991] HCA 14
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hart v MetLife Insurance Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWCA 230
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the separate questions determined by the primary judge were capable of disposing of the whole of the proceedings, and whether the parties' agreement to determine these questions justified the primary judge's order dismissing the entire proceedings. The court also considered whether to grant leave to amend the notice of appeal to include an additional ground.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on the amended ground, finding that the separate questions were not capable of disposing of the entire proceedings. The court reasoned that the primary judge erred in dismissing the whole of the proceedings based on the answers to those questions, as the fundamental issue of whether the insurer was on risk remained undetermined. The court applied principles relating to the determination of separate questions under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, emphasizing that such orders should only be made when they can definitively resolve the entire dispute.
Consequently, the Court of Appeal set aside the primary judge's orders to the extent that they dismissed the prayers for relief related to the insurer being on risk. The proceedings concerning these specific prayers for relief were remitted to the Equity Division for determination. The court also set aside another of the primary judge's orders and directed the parties to make written submissions on the question of costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Leave be granted to amend the notice of appeal to include ground 5.
(2) Allow the appeal on ground 5.
(3) Set aside order 1 made by Black J on 15 September 2022 to the extent that order dismisses the prayers for relief referred to in order 4 below.
(4) Order that the proceedings in respect of the prayers for relief made by pars 4, 5 and 6 as supported by pars 8, 10-12, 16-27 and 36 of the Statement of Claim be remitted to the Equity Division for determination of those claims.
(5) Set aside order 2 made by Black J on 15 September 2022.
(6) Direct that MetLife provide written submissions not to exceed 3 pages within 7 days of the making of these orders on the question of costs, and that Ms Hart respond to those submissions within 7 days of their receipt, her submissions also not to exceed 3 pages. In each case the submissions are to be provided to Meagher JA’s Associate.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter proceeded through several steps before the parties agreed to a separate determination of certain questions of law and fact. The agreed questions did not directly address whether Ms Hart’s injury and illness were "on risk" under the policy. Instead, they focused on whether MetLife had breached any obligations in denying and failing to reconsider Ms Hart’s claim. Following the answers to these separate questions, the primary judge dismissed the whole of Ms Hart’s proceedings, ruling that the questions answered did not resolve the central issue of whether the injury and illness were "on risk". Dissatisfied with the dismissal of her claim, Ms Hart appealed to the Supreme Court. The appeal raised, among other things, the contention that the primary judge should not have dismissed the whole of the proceedings after the determination of the separate questions.
The appeal was heard and determined by Meagher JA, who found merit in the argument that the primary judge had erred in dismissing the whole of the proceedings. The judge noted that the separate questions determined did not address the critical issue of whether the injury and illness were "on risk" under the policy, and therefore could not dispose of the whole of the proceedings. Consequently, the judge allowed the appeal, set aside the primary judge’s orders dismissing the claims, and remitted the matter to the Equity Division for further determination of the claims in light of the unresolved issues. The judge also directed that the parties exchange written submissions on the question of costs within a specified timeframe.
The matter of Hart v MetLife Insurance Limited arose from an insurance dispute concerning a claim for total and permanent disablement benefits. Ms Hart, the insured, lodged a claim with MetLife Insurance Limited which was denied on the basis that the insurer was not "on risk" for the injury or illness causing the disablement. Following the denial, Ms Hart initiated proceedings in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCCFA). In the proceedings, both parties agreed to a separate determination of specific questions aimed at resolving certain issues in the dispute. However, the answers to these separate questions did not resolve the central issue of whether the insurer was "on risk". The primary judge, Black J, subsequently dismissed the proceedings in their entirety on the basis that the separate determination process had not led to a final resolution of the case.
Dissatisfied with the dismissal, Ms Hart appealed to the Federal Court of Australia. The appeal focused on the procedural correctness of the primary judge’s decision to dismiss the proceedings after the answers to the separate questions. The appeal was initially filed with certain grounds, and subsequently, leave was granted to amend the notice of appeal to include an additional ground. The Court of Appeal heard the appeal and determined that the primary judge had erred in dismissing the proceedings. Consequently, the Court set aside the orders dismissing the claims and remitted the unresolved issues to the Equity Division for further determination. The Court also directed that the parties provide concise written submissions on the issue of costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the insurer’s denial of the insured’s claim for total and permanent disablement benefit was justified when it was based on the assertion that it was not “on risk” for the injury or illness causing the disablement.
2. Whether the court’s dismissal of the whole of the proceedings following the answers to separate questions was appropriate when those questions did not address the core issue of the insurer’s liability.
3. Whether the parties’ consent to the determination of separate questions justified the dismissal of the whole of the proceedings under UCPR r 28.4.
4. Whether the separate questions asked whether there were breaches by the insurer in denying and failing to reconsider the insured’s claim.
5. Whether the separate questions were capable of disposing of the whole of the proceedings, including the claims for relief.
6. Whether the order remitting the proceedings to the Equity Division for determination of the claims was justified.
Held
1. The court held that the insurer’s denial of the insured’s claim for total and permanent disablement benefit was not justified when it was based on the assertion that it was not “on risk” for the injury or illness causing the disablement. The appeal was allowed on this ground.
2. The court held that the dismissal of the whole of the proceedings by the primary judge was not appropriate because the answers to separate questions did not address the core issue of the insurer’s liability. The order dismissing the whole of the proceedings was set aside to the extent it related to the prayers for relief.
3. The court held that the parties’ consent to the determination of separate questions did not justify the dismissal of the whole of the proceedings under UCPR r 28.4. The order dismissing the whole of the proceedings was set aside.
4. The court held that the separate questions did ask whether there were breaches by the insurer in denying and failing to reconsider the insured’s claim. However, these questions did not address the insurer’s liability and did not dispose of the whole of the proceedings.
5. The court held that the separate questions were not capable of disposing of the whole of the proceedings, including the claims for relief. The court was of the opinion that the separate questions did not resolve the core issue of the insurer’s liability.
6. The court held that the order remitting the proceedings to the Equity Division for determination of the claims was justified as the separate questions did not dispose of the whole of the proceedings. The claims for relief were to be remitted to the Equity Division for determination.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Hart v MetLife Insurance Limited, the insurer's denial of the insured's claim for total and permanent disablement benefit was challenged on the basis that the insurer was not "on risk" for the injury or illness causing the disablement. The court considered whether this assertion justified the denial. The insurer argued that it was not liable for the benefits because it was not responsible for the risk associated with the insured's condition. The court examined the terms of the policy and the nature of the risk assumed by the insurer. It found that the insurer's argument hinged on the interpretation of the policy terms, particularly regarding the definition of "on risk." The court concluded that the insurer's liability was contingent on whether the disablement arose from a risk that the insurer had agreed to cover under the policy terms.
The court also addressed the dismissal of the whole of the proceedings following the answers to separate questions, a decision made by the primary judge. The court scrutinized whether this dismissal was appropriate given that the separate questions did not directly address the core issue of the insurer's liability. The separate questions focused on whether there were breaches by the insurer in denying and failing to reconsider the claim. However, the court noted that these questions did not resolve the fundamental issue of the insurer's obligation under the policy. The court found that the primary judge's dismissal of the proceedings based on answers to these questions was not justified as it did not fully address the insurer's liability, which was the crux of the insured's claims.
Furthermore, the court examined whether the parties' consent to the determination of separate questions justified the dismissal of the whole of the proceedings under UCPR r 28.4. The court considered the scope and nature of the consent provided by the parties. It was established that the consent was given for the determination of specific questions regarding potential breaches by the insurer. However, the court noted that the consent did not extend to a resolution of the substantive claims for relief. The court held that the parties' consent could not justify the dismissal of the proceedings as it did not encompass the broader issues of the insurer's liability and the insured's entitlement to benefits.
The court also assessed whether the separate questions were capable of disposing of the whole of the proceedings, including the claims for relief. The questions asked whether there were breaches by the insurer in denying and failing to reconsider the claim, but they did not directly address the insurer's liability for the disablement benefit. The court concluded that these questions were insufficient to resolve the substantive claims. The court held that the separate questions were not capable of disposing of the whole of the proceedings as they did not fully address the insurer's responsibility under the policy.
Additionally, the court evaluated whether the order remitting the proceedings to the Equity Division for determination of the claims was justified. Given that the separate questions did not resolve the core issue of the insurer's liability, the court found that the proceedings needed to be remitted to the Equity Division for a comprehensive determination of the insured's claims. The court emphasized that the substantive issues concerning the insurer's obligation and the insured's entitlement to benefits required a detailed examination by the Equity Division. The court concluded that the order remitting the proceedings was justified to ensure that all relevant issues were properly addressed and resolved.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the insurer's denial of the insured's claim for total and permanent disablement benefit cannot be justified solely on the basis that it was not "on risk" for the injury or illness causing the disablement without considering the policy terms. Additionally, the dismissal of the whole of the proceedings based on separate questions that do not address the core issue of the insurer's liability is inappropriate. The court's order remitting the proceedings to the Equity Division for a comprehensive determination of the claims is justified when the separate questions do not fully resolve the substantive issues of the insurer's obligation and the insured's entitlement to benefits.