Harding Hotels Pty Ltd v Jatadd Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

HARDING HOTELS PTY LTD & ORS  v  JATADD PTY LTD
[2001] SASC 439

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Martin & Besanko JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:            This is an appeal by leave against a decision of the Licensing Court.

  2. The Licensing Court Judge granted an application for a retail liquor merchant’s licence pursuant to s 37 of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) (“the Act”) for premises at Strathalbyn. Strathalbyn is a rural town about 60 kilometres by road, south-east of Adelaide.

  3. The appeal raises two issues. The first is whether the Judge erred in making findings, on the evidence before him, that the applicant had satisfied the Judge that existing licensed premises in the locality “do not adequately cater for the public demand for liquor for consumption off licensed premises and the licence is necessary to satisfy that demand”: s 58(2) of the Act. Mr Firth, counsel for the appellant, conceded that if the findings which the Judge made were properly made, they provided a basis for the grant of the licence. The second issue is the significance of the fact that fifteen months before making his decision the Judge had refused an application by the same applicant for the same kind of licence in respect of the same premises at Strathalbyn. It was common ground before the Judge and on appeal that in the period of fifteen months there had been no significant change affecting the public demand for liquor in the locality and the ability of the existing premises to cater for that demand. Mr Firth argued that, in those circumstances, the Judge should have exercised his discretion to refuse the application.

    Facts and findings

  4. What follows is taken from the Judge’s reasons in the first application and in the second application.

  5. Strathalbyn is a town of about 3,000 people.  An additional 3,700 people live within about ten to fifteen kilometres of Strathalbyn.  The Judge treated the town and the surrounding area within a radius of about fifteen kilometres as the relevant locality, and I will refer to it as the locality.  Strathalbyn is the shopping centre for the bulk of the people living in the locality.  Many of the people in the locality who have paid employment work out of the locality, in Adelaide and in other places.  But, presumably, many people also work in the locality.  The Judge found that people in the locality make occasional use of larger shopping centres outside the locality, such as those at Mt Barker, Victor Harbor and Adelaide.  The evidence supported that finding, and indicated that people who went to these places regularly made reasonably regular use of them for shopping.  Commonsense also suggests that people in the locality would, occasionally, make special shopping trips to larger centres outside the locality.

  6. There are a number of hotels in Strathalbyn itself, in the locality and outside the locality.  The Judge proceeded on the basis that with one exception these hotels could be put to one side, because of their very limited facilities for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harding Hotels Pty Ltd v Jatadd Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 439
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Harding Hotels Pty Ltd v Jatadd Pty Ltd, the appellant, Harding Hotels, sought to appeal a decision of the Magistrates Court of South Australia, which had refused to grant a liquor licence to the respondent, Jatadd Pty Ltd, for premises in Strathalbyn. The primary Judge had previously refused a similar application by Jatadd for the same premises, fifteen months earlier. The appeal to the Supreme Court of South Australia raised two key issues. The first was whether the Judge had correctly found that existing licensed premises in the locality did not adequately cater for public demand for liquor for consumption off the premises, and that the proposed licence was necessary to satisfy this demand. The second issue was whether the fact that the Judge had previously refused a similar application by Jatadd constituted a sufficient basis for refusing the current application.

The Court considered the first issue, concluding that the findings made by the Judge were properly based on the evidence presented. The Judge had found that the Commercial Hotel in Strathalbyn, the only outlet that required consideration, had a small and unattractive walk-in bottle department, which had only marginally improved since the previous application. The Court held that the Judge’s findings provided a basis for the grant of the licence. Regarding the second issue, the Court noted that while the Judge had a broad discretion to refuse an application, the fact that a similar application had been made and refused previously was not, by itself, sufficient grounds to exercise that discretion. The Court found that there had been no significant change in the public demand for liquor or the ability of existing premises to cater for that demand since the previous application.

The appeal was dismissed by the Supreme Court, with the Chief Justice and Justice Besanzo concurring that the decision of the Magistrates Court should stand. The Court held that the findings of the Judge were correctly made, and that the previous refusal of a similar application was not a sufficient basis to exercise the discretion to refuse the current application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal raises two issues. The first is whether the Judge erred in making findings, on the evidence before him, that the applicant had satisfied the Judge that existing licensed premises in the locality “do not adequately cater for the public demand for liquor for consumption off licensed premises and the licence is necessary to satisfy that demand”: s 58(2) of the Act. Mr Firth, counsel for the appellant, conceded that if the findings which the Judge made were properly made, they provided a basis for the grant of the licence. The second issue is the significance of the fact that fifteen months before making his decision the Judge had refused an application by the same applicant for the same kind of licence in respect of the same premises at Strathalbyn. It was common ground before the Judge and on appeal that in the period of fifteen months there had been no significant change affecting the public demand for liquor in the locality and the ability of the existing premises to cater for that demand. Mr Firth argued that, in those circumstances, the Judge should have exercised his discretion to refuse the application.Facts and findings What follows is taken from the Judge’s reasons in the first application and in the second application. Strathalbyn is a town of about 3,000 people. An additional 3,700 people live within about ten to fifteen kilometres of Strathalbyn. The Judge treated the town and the surrounding area within a radius of about fifteen kilometres as the relevant locality, and I will refer to it as the locality. Strathalbyn is the shopping centre for the bulk of the people living in the locality. Many of the people in the locality who have paid employment work out of the locality, in Adelaide and in other places. But, presumably, many people also work in the locality. The Judge found that people in the locality make occasional use of larger shopping centres outside the locality, such as those at Mt Barker, Victor Harbor and Adelaide. The evidence supported that finding, and indicated that people who went to these places regularly made reasonably regular use of them for shopping. Commonsense also suggests that people in the locality would, occasionally, make special shopping trips to larger centres outside the locality. There are a number of hotels in Strathalbyn itself, in the locality and outside the locality. The Judge proceeded on the basis that with one exception these hotels could be put to one side, because of their very limited facilities for the sale of liquor for consumption off the premises. This approach was not challenged on appeal. There is only one outlet that required consideration. It is the Commercial Hotel in Strathalbyn. It has a drive-in bottle department and a walk-in bottle department. As would be expected, for the purposes of the application attention was focused on the walk-in bottle department. In his first decision the Judge described this as “small and rather cluttered.” He said:“It is not particularly attractive in its setting but it certainly does not repel. Its range of liquor seems to me, for the locality, to be pretty well sufficient. In saying that I bear in mind all of the evidence which was tendered to suggest otherwise.”In his second decision the Judge found that since the first decision the licensee of the Commercial Hotel had changed, and the range of liquor in the walk-in had improved “to some small extent.” He commented that, if anything, it was rather more cluttered than before, because of the increased stock. He noted that it was still “unattractive”, and that moving around in the walk-in “could prove awkward” if a number of customers were in the shop at one time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In saying that I do not overlook the fact that by s 53 of the Act the Court has a very wide discretion, which discretion it can exercise to refuse an application even though a basis for the grant of the application has been made out. But in my opinion the fact that an earlier unsuccessful application had been made by this applicant is not, of itself, a sufficient basis for refusing the application, and that appears to me to be the only matter supporting an exercise of the discretion to refuse to grant the licence sought.Conclusions For those reasons I would dismiss the appeal. MARTIN J: I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by the Chief Justice. BESANKO J: I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by the Chief Justice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established