Carleton Investments Pty Ltd v J & B Development Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

CARLETON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v J & B DEVELOPMENT INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

[2009] SASC 282

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Layton and The Honourable Justice Kelly)

9 September 2009

LIQUOR LAW - LICENSING - LICENSING TRIBUNALS GENERALLY - REVIEWS, APPEALS AND CASES STATED

LIQUOR LAW - LICENSING - APPLICATION FOR NEW LICENCE - HEARING OF APPLICATION - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION - WHETHER REQUIRED FOR NEEDS OF PUBLIC

Appeal against a decision of a judge of the Licensing Court granting a certificate of approval under s 59 of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 - the s 59 certificate approved the respondent's plans to gain a grant of a Retail Liquor Merchant's Licence and open a liquor outlet within a shopping complex - the appellant opposed the application in the Licensing Court - the appellant is the holder of a hotel licence relating to a tavern within close proximity to the respondent's proposed site - whether licensing judge overlooked or ignored aspects of unchallenged evidence - whether there had been material and substantial changes in the relevant locality since previous application - whether the evidence of the need witnesses could be relied upon - whether the relevant population had increased - whether existing licensed premises were adequate - whether the shopping centre which was to house the proposed liquor outlet had undergone substantial change.

Held:  appeal allowed - Licensing Court judgment set aside - respondent's application dismissed.

Liquor Licensing Act 1997 s 59, s 58(2), s 56, s 57, referred to.
Woolies Liquor Stores Pty Ltd v Carleton Investments Pty Ltd (1998) 73 SASR 6; Harding Hotels Pty Ltd v Jatadd Pty Ltd (2001) 81 SASR 222; Temple v Liquor Licensing Commissioner & Ors (1987) 138 LSJS 376; Nuriootpa Vine Inn & Anor v Liquor Licensing Commissioner [1999] SASC 512; Woolies Liquor Stores v Seaford Rise Tavern (2000) 76 SASR 290; South Eastern Hotel Pty Ltd v Woolies Liquor Stores (1998) 71 SASR 402, applied.

CARLETON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v J & B DEVELOPMENT INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
[2009] SASC 282

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Layton and Kelly JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:I agree with the reasons of Kelly J.  I would allow the appeal, set aside the order of the Licensing Court granting a certificate to the applicant, and substitute for that order an order dismissing the application.

  2. LAYTON J:          I respectfully agree with the orders proposed by Kelly J and her reasons.

    KELLY J:

    Introduction

  3. This is an appeal against a decision of the Licensing Court to grant a Certificate of Approval under the provisions of s 59 of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (“the Act”) in respect of proposed premises at the Woodcroft Market Plaza Shopping Centre. 

  4. The respondent, J & B Development Investments Pty Ltd, was the applicant.  The appellant, Carleton Investments Pty Ltd, opposed the application in the Licensing Court.

  5. The effect of the order made by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carleton Investments Pty Ltd v J & B Development Investments... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Carleton Investments Pty Ltd v J & B Development Investments Pty Ltd involved an appeal against a decision of a judge of the Licensing Court, who had granted a certificate of approval under section 59 of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997. This certificate approved the respondent's plans to obtain a Retail Liquor Merchant's Licence and open a liquor outlet in a shopping complex. The appellant, which holds a hotel licence for a tavern near the proposed site, opposed the application in the Licensing Court. The appeal questioned whether the licensing judge had overlooked or ignored aspects of unchallenged evidence, whether there had been significant changes in the locality since the previous application, the reliability of the evidence of the need witnesses, the population increase, the adequacy of existing licensed premises, and whether the shopping centre had undergone substantial changes.

The court found that the evidence presented by the need witnesses, who largely resided in the northern part of the locality, was not sufficiently representative of the broader public demand for liquor. The witnesses' proximity to the proposed site and their regular travel habits indicated a subjective bias towards supporting the new outlet. The court emphasized the importance of considering objective features of the locality and the demographics of the population rather than relying solely on the subjective opinions of selected witnesses. The evidence of Mr. Brunning, the town planner, who noted the high mobility and vehicle ownership among residents, further supported the court's view that the demand for liquor was not adequately substantiated by the witnesses' testimonies.

The court also scrutinized the increase in turnover at the Woolworths supermarket and the changes in the shopping centre's design and layout. However, the court found that these changes did not sufficiently demonstrate a need for an additional liquor outlet. The existing licensed premises, particularly those at the Woodcroft Town Centre, were deemed adequate, albeit marginally so, in meeting the public demand for liquor. The court concluded that the appellant had not provided sufficient evidence to warrant the approval of the respondent's application. Therefore, the appeal was allowed, the Licensing Court judgment was set aside, and the respondent's application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is necessary to examine the evidence to ascertain whether the Judge’s conclusion was supported by the evidence. The cogency of the evidence of the need witnesses The Judge devoted some considerable portion of the reasons to the evidence given by six local witnesses. It is notable that all but one of the need witnesses reside in the northern half of the locality defined by the Judge. Two of them in fact resided just outside the locality, four were within a very short distance if not walking distance, from the proposed premises at the shopping centre. These witnesses were found by the Judge to be representative of those members of the public who seek to satisfy their demand for packaged liquor in the locality. Not surprisingly they all expressed a desire for a liquor outlet in close proximity if not walking distance from their respective residences. Notably each of the witnesses who gave evidence appear to have transport and drive regularly to other shopping outlets within and just outside the locality for one purpose or another. That is consistent with the evidence of the planner named Mr Brunning whose evidence the Judge accepted. Mr Brunning’s evidence confirmed that the population in the relevant locality remained a highly mobile one with residents having a high level of either ownership or access to private motor vehicles. Public demand, as King CJ said in Temple v Liquor Licensing Commissioner and Ors (1987) 138 LSJS 376 at 380, is not to be confused with individual desires. In Nuriootpa Vine Inn & Anor v Liquor Licensing Commissioner [1999] SASC 512 Perry J said at [15]:I have said before while sitting as a member of the Full Court, and I repeat, that there is a tendency in the Liquor Licensing jurisdiction to place too much emphasis on so-called need witnesses and lay evidence of demand. That type of evidence is relevant, but it tends to be very subjective and coloured by the natural leaning of many people to support any new facility however marginal the real case as to need might be. More important than evidence of that kind are the objective features of the locality and its demographics, coupled with the Licensing Court's own expertise as to what the reasonable requirements of contemporary demand may be, considered in the light of a very stringent test for the grant of a retail liquor licence which is still a feature of the legislation. More recently, Doyle CJ in Harding Hotels v Jatadd (2001) 81 SASR 222 at [21] said with reference to evidence of needs:This Court has previously referred to the desirability of the Licensing Court having regard to objective features of the locality, the makeup of the population and the Court's own expertise, when assessing the demand for liquor, and not paying undue regard to evidence of demand from witnesses. This is because of the way in which the witnesses can be hand-picked, and because of the subjective nature of their evidence: see, for example, Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd v Hurley's Arkaba Hotel Pty Ltd (2001) 80 SASR 59 at 74 [107]. On the other hand, the calling of witnesses from the locality is a permissible means of proving that the public demand for liquor is not adequately catered for by existing premises in the locality. Perhaps the main point to emphasise is the need to pay careful attention to the objective features of the locality, and to the makeup of the local population, when considering whether the need witnesses are representative of a significant part of the public in the locality.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In this case, the applicant had applied for a Certificate of Approval under s 59 of the Act. That section provides that a Certificate of Approval can be granted as an alternative to a licence in circumstances in which a licence would have been granted but for the fact that the applicant’s premises were not yet completed. Therefore an applicant for a Certificate of Approval under s 59 must satisfy the Licensing Court of the same matters as an applicant for a licence. In the case of an application for a Retail Liquor Merchant’s Licence, one of the requirements which must be satisfied is that set out in s 58(2). This was the matter in issue on this appeal.Judgment of the Licensing Court Judge The Judge commenced by referring to the unsuccessful application, noting that it had been made twelve years earlier. The Judge then referred to the principle established in a number of decisions of this Court that the Licensing Court should be slow to depart from a previous decision if a second application is made for a licence in respect of premises which are the same as those for which an earlier application has been refused. Observing that the Full Court in the Woolies Liquor Stores case placed reliance on the fact that at the time of the previous application the shopping centre was not capable of meeting all of the regular shopping needs of those residing nearby, the Judge went on to say that one of the issues he was required to address was whether the operations of the shopping centre have altered those shopping patterns. Having found that the respondent satisfied the requirements imposed by ss 56 and 57 of the Act, the Judge then turned to consider the test in s 58(2) of the Act. In reaching that conclusion, the Judge was influenced by the increase in turnover at the Woolworths supermarket from $13.6 million in 1998 to $22.76 million by June of 2006. He also referred to the scale, design and layout of the shopping centre, together with the tenancy mix which he noted attracted customers beyond the range which might normally be associated with neighbourhood shopping centres. He found that the locality for the purposes of the determination he had to make was the area bounded by Bains Road to the south, Reynell Road to the north, Panalatinga Road to the west and Pine Road to the east. None of the other licensed premises referred to, including the three objectors, fall within the locality as defined by the Judge. However, the Judge did refer to those other licensed premises and correctly identified the real issue for consideration, namely whether those other liquor outlets, in particular the two licensed premises at the Woodcroft Town Centre, can be said to adequately cater for the public demand for liquor consumption off licensed premises. With respect to those premises, the Judge concluded that the range of liquor available in those premises was adequate, if in some cases, barely adequate. The Judge took into account the opinion of a town planner, Mr Paul Brunning, as to the increasing population in the area in the period between 1996 and 2001. He also referred to a 2005 aerial photograph of the locality, which showed a considerable expansion of residential development within an area bounded by Panalatinga Road to the west, Sir James Hardy Way to the east and Bains Road to the south of the proposed premises. He took into account the opinion of Mr Brunning that despite that being a relatively mobile population, they were disadvantaged in terms of the cost of travel and because of the poor level of public transport in the area.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established