DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Happy Lounge Pty Ltd v Choi & Lee Pty Ltd and Anor [2020] QDC 184
PARTIES:
HAPPY LOUNGE PTY LTD ACN 628 766 361
(applicant)v
CHOI & LEE PTY LTD ACN 638 573 305 as
Trustee for CHOI & LEE FAMILY TRUST
(first respondent)And
MINKYU CHOI and TAE MUN CHOI
(second respondents)FILE NO:
1066 of 2020
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Trial
DELIVERED ON:
13 August 2020
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
15 June 2020
JUDGE:
Rosengren DCJ
ORDERS:
The originating application is dismissed.1.
It is declared that the contract was lawfully terminated by the first respondent on 25 March 2020.2.
It is declared that the first respondent is entitled to a refund of the deposit of $55,000 that it paid on 28 February 2020 pursuant to the contract.3.
Unless a party wishes to submit to the contrary within seven days, the applicant is to pay the respondents’ costs of the proceeding. 4.
The parties are given leave to make further submissions as to the form of the orders.5.
CATCHWORDS:
CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – FRUSTRATION – where the applicant entered into a contract with the first respondent for the sale of a bar and lounge – where the second respondents guaranteed performance of the first respondent’s obligations – whether government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic frustrated the contract
CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – where the respondents allege the applicant breached its obligations under the contract – whether the applicant breached its contractual obligations by failing to obtain the consent of the mortgagee to the assignment of the lease – whether the applicant breached its contractual obligations by failing to provide evidence of the value of the stock – whether the first respondent is entitled to a refund of the deposit paid
CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – ILLEGALITY – where the respondents allege the applicant breached its obligations under the contract to operate the bar and lounge as a going concern and in the usual way – where government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic made it illegal for the bar and lounge to continue operating – whether the applicant is liable for such breaches
Liquor Act 1992 (Qld)
Public Health Act 2005 (Qld) s 326B
Brisbane CC v Group Projects Pty Ltd (1979) 145 CLR 143, applied
Chapman v Taylor [2004] NSWCA 456, applied
Codelfa Constructions Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority (NSW) (1982) 149 CLR 337, applied
Gerraty v McGavin (1914) 18 CLR 152, applied
Scanlan’s New Neon Ltd v Tooheys Ltd (1943) 67 CLR 169, appliedTenants (Lancashire) Ltd v CS Wilson & Co Ltd [1917] AC 495, applied
Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 LCR 165, appliedCOUNSEL:
Michael de Waard for the applicant
Matt Black for the respondentsSOLICITORS:
Rostryn Carlyle Rojas Lawyers for the applicant
Sandstone Lawyers for the respondentsIntroduction
[1]…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Happy Lounge Pty Ltd v Choi and Lee Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] QDC 184
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic frustrated the contract. The court found that the contract was not frustrated as the pandemic did not render the contract impossible to perform. The court also found that Happy Lounge Pty Ltd had breached the contract by failing to obtain the consent of the mortgagee to the assignment of the lease. However, the court found that the respondents were not entitled to a refund of the deposit as the first respondent lawfully terminated the contract. The court also found that the government orders did not render it illegal for the bar and lounge to continue operating, and therefore, Happy Lounge Pty Ltd was not liable for breaches related to the operation of the bar and lounge.
The court dismissed the originating application and declared that the contract was lawfully terminated by the first respondent on 25 March 2020. The court also declared that the first respondent was entitled to a refund of the deposit of $55,000 that it paid on 28 February 2020 pursuant to the contract. Unless a party wishes to submit to the contrary within seven days, the applicant is to pay the respondents’ costs of the proceeding. The parties are given leave to make further submissions as to the form of the orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
The originating application is dismissed.1.
It is declared that the contract was lawfully terminated by the first respondent on 25 March 2020.2.
It is declared that the first respondent is entitled to a refund of the deposit of $55,000 that it paid on 28 February 2020 pursuant to the contract.3.
Unless a party wishes to submit to the contrary within seven days, the applicant is to pay the respondents’ costs of the proceeding. 4.
The parties are given leave to make further submissions as to the form of the orders.5.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic in Australia, the government issued orders that made it illegal for the bar and lounge to continue operating. The first respondent terminated the contract on 25 March 2020, and sought a refund of the deposit paid by the applicant. The applicant argued that the contract had been frustrated by the government orders, and that it was not liable for any breaches of the contract. The first respondent, on the other hand, argued that the applicant had breached its contractual obligations by failing to obtain the consent of the mortgagee to the assignment of the lease, and by failing to provide evidence of the value of the stock. The first respondent also argued that it was entitled to a refund of the deposit paid by the applicant.
The second respondents alleged that the applicant had breached its obligations under the contract to operate the bar and lounge as a going concern and in the usual way, and that it was liable for such breaches. The second respondents also argued that the applicant had breached its obligations under the contract by failing to obtain the consent of the mortgagee to the assignment of the lease, and by failing to provide evidence of the value of the stock. The second respondents argued that they were liable for any breaches of the contract by the first respondent, as they were guarantors of the first respondent's performance of the contract. The applicant denied all allegations of breach and liability, and argued that the contract had been lawfully terminated by the first respondent due to the government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic.
The case of Happy Lounge Pty Ltd v Choi and Lee Pty Ltd originates from a dispute between the applicant, Happy Lounge Pty Ltd, and the respondents, Choi and Lee Pty Ltd and the individual guarantors, regarding the sale of a bar and lounge. The matter came before the court following an originating application filed by the respondents seeking a declaration that the contract was lawfully terminated, an order for a refund of the deposit, and costs. This case represents an interlocutory application concerning the interpretation and enforcement of a contract, specifically addressing whether the contract was frustrated by government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic, and whether the applicant breached its contractual obligations. The application was brought after the contract was terminated by the first respondent on 25 March 2020, in response to government restrictions that made the operation of the bar and lounge illegal. Prior to this application, there were no other reported proceedings or decisions between the parties. Key procedural steps include the filing of the originating application, the respondents' allegations of breach of contract, and the applicant's defence, which centred on the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on the contractual obligations.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic frustrated the contract for the sale of the bar and lounge between the applicant and the first respondent.
2. Whether the applicant breached its contractual obligations by failing to obtain the consent of the mortgagee to the assignment of the lease.
3. Whether the applicant breached its contractual obligations by failing to provide evidence of the value of the stock.
4. Whether the first respondent is entitled to a refund of the deposit paid.
5. Whether the applicant is liable for breaches of the contract to operate the bar and lounge as a going concern and in the usual way, given that government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic made it illegal for the bar and lounge to continue operating.
Held
1. The court concluded that government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic frustrated the contract for the sale of the bar and lounge between the applicant and the first respondent. Result: Contract lawfully terminated.
2. The court found that the applicant breached its contractual obligations by failing to obtain the consent of the mortgagee to the assignment of the lease. Result: Breach of contract.
3. The court determined that the applicant breached its contractual obligations by failing to provide evidence of the value of the stock. Result: Breach of contract.
4. The court held that the first respondent is entitled to a refund of the deposit paid. Result: Refund of $55,000 declared.
5. The court found that the applicant is not liable for breaches of the contract to operate the bar and lounge as a going concern and in the usual way, given that government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic made it illegal for the bar and lounge to continue operating. Result: Applicant not liable for such breaches.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Happy Lounge Pty Ltd v Choi and Lee Pty Ltd, the court was tasked with determining whether government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic frustrated the contract for the sale of a bar and lounge between the applicant and the first respondent. The court found that the government orders did frustrate the contract, rendering it impossible to perform due to the prohibition on operating the bar and lounge, which was a central component of the contractual obligations. The court relied on established principles of frustration in contract law, emphasizing that when an unforeseen event makes performance of a contract impossible or radically different from what was contemplated, the contract may be frustrated. The court distinguished this case from situations where the impossibility was self-induced or where the parties could have reasonably anticipated the event, as neither applied here.
The court also considered whether the applicant breached its contractual obligations by failing to obtain the consent of the mortgagee to the assignment of the lease. The court held that the applicant did breach this specific obligation. The contractual terms explicitly required the applicant to obtain the mortgagee's consent, and the failure to do so constituted a clear breach. The court referenced established contract law principles regarding the strict enforcement of contractual obligations and relied on authorities that support the notion that failure to adhere to specific terms of a contract constitutes a breach. The court did not find any extenuating circumstances that would excuse the applicant's failure to meet this requirement.
Another issue addressed was whether the applicant breached its contractual obligations by failing to provide evidence of the value of the stock. The court concluded that the applicant did breach this obligation. The contract stipulated that the applicant must provide evidence of the stock's value, and the court found that the applicant's failure to do so was a material breach. The court emphasized that contractual obligations must be met with substantial compliance, and the lack of evidence regarding the stock's value was a clear departure from the contractual requirements. The court referenced case law that underscores the importance of fulfilling contractual obligations related to property included in a sale.
The court determined that the first respondent is entitled to a refund of the deposit paid. The court's decision was based on the principle that upon frustration of the contract, the parties are discharged from their future obligations, and any deposit paid should be refunded. The court found that the frustration of the contract by external events beyond the control of the parties justified the refund. The court cited relevant authorities that support the restitution of deposits in cases of frustration, reinforcing that the doctrine of frustration operates to release parties from their obligations and to restore them to the position they were in before the contract was formed.
Finally, the court addressed whether the applicant is liable for breaches of the contract to operate the bar and lounge as a going concern and in the usual way, given that government orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic made it illegal for the bar and lounge to continue operating. The court held that the applicant was not liable for these breaches. The court reasoned that the illegality introduced by the government orders constituted a supervening illegality that frustrated the contract, absolving the applicant from liability for failing to operate the bar and lounge as a going concern. The court relied on the principle that illegality, particularly when imposed by law, can frustrate a contract and absolve a party from liability for failing to perform contractual obligations that become impossible or illegal to execute. The court distinguished this case from scenarios where the illegality stems from the actions of the parties themselves, emphasizing that the illegality here was an external, unforeseen event.