Hanley and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

[2012] AATA 820

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/0781

Re

FERGUS HANLEY

APPLICANT

And

CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member

Date 21 November 2012
Place Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.........[sgd]............................................

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – pilots – cancellation of licences to pilot helicopters and instructor ratings – revocation of Instrument of Approval as Chief Flying Instructor – unplanned demonstration of autorotation – whether helicopter was operated when unairworthy – conflict of evidence regarding how the helicopter was moved back to the hangar between the pilot and the owner/passenger/student – fit and proper person – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Act 1988 ss 9A, 20AA

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 regs 5.58, 47, 215, 269

Transport Safety Investigation Act 2003 ss 18, 19

CASES

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Re Griffiths and Civil Aviation Authority (1994) 34 ALD 554
Re Taylor and Department of Transport (1978) 1 ALD 312
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member

21 November 2012

SUMMARY

  1. Mr Fergus Hanley is a helicopter pilot with up to 6,000 hours flying time. His counsel, Ms D Price, described him as passionate about flying, and emphasised that flying and teaching students to fly was his only means of income.

  2. On 29 October 2011, Mr Hanley was in command of the Bell 206 helicopter registration mark VH-AYP, (the helicopter), with a student pilot, Michael Hope, who was also the owner of the aircraft, when he conducted an unplanned and spontaneous demonstration of a simulated autorotation. The helicopter made a heavy landing during which it was extensively damaged. There was conflicting evidence before the Tribunal regarding the events following the heavy landing, and as to how the helicopter was moved from where it landed at Maitland Airport, to the hangar there.

  3. On 21 February 2012, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) cancelled Mr Hanley’s Private Pilot (Helicopter) Licence; Commercial Pilot (Helicopter) Licence; Airline Transport Pilot (Helicopter) Licence; and Flight Instructor (Helicopter) Ratings Grades 1 and 2 pursuant to regulation 269 of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (CAR). It also revoked his Instrument of Approval as Chief Flying Instructor of Apple Helicopters Pty Ltd (Apple Helicopters) pursuant to regulation 5.58(5) of the CAR. I note that the latter Instrument of Approval as Chief Flying Instructor of Apple Helicopters is no longer relevant because Mr Hanley’s employment with Apple Helicopters was terminated on 24 February 2012. The termination had the effect of causing the approval to cease to have effect.

  4. Mr Hanley has applied to this Tribunal for review of the decision of CASA. The difficulties encountered in deciding the matter have been compounded by the fact that Mr Hanley and Mr Hope were the only persons who were involved, and who witnessed the heavy landing, and have knowledge regarding how the helicopter was returned to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hanley and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 820
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Hanley and Civil Aviation Safety Authority, the dispute involved the cancellation of Mr Hanley's helicopter pilot and instructor licenses, as well as the revocation of his Instrument of Approval as Chief Flying Instructor by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). The decision was made following an accident that occurred on 29 October 2011 when Mr Hanley demonstrated an autorotation without proper preparation and caused the helicopter to crash. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was tasked with determining whether Mr Hanley had failed in his duties as a pilot and instructor, and whether he was a fit and proper person to hold such licenses. The Tribunal had to consider evidence regarding the accident, the subsequent actions taken by Mr Hanley, and his reporting of the incident to the relevant authorities.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether Mr Hanley had breached his duties as a pilot and instructor under regulation 269(1)(c) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth), and whether he was a fit and proper person to hold his pilot licenses under regulation 269(1)(d) of the same Regulations. The court had to evaluate the credibility of the evidence presented, including conflicting accounts of the accident and its aftermath, to determine if Mr Hanley had acted responsibly and in accordance with safety regulations. Additionally, the court had to assess Mr Hanley's fitness to hold his licenses based on his conduct following the accident and his adherence to regulatory requirements.

The Tribunal found that Mr Hanley had indeed failed in his duties as a pilot and instructor by not properly preparing for the autorotation demonstration, causing the accident. The court also determined that Mr Hanley did not accurately report the accident to the relevant authorities and attempted to keep the incident quiet. These findings led to the conclusion that Mr Hanley was not a fit and proper person to hold his licenses, as his actions demonstrated a lack of responsibility and adherence to safety regulations. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the CASA decision to cancel Mr Hanley's licenses and revoke his Instrument of Approval as Chief Flying Instructor.

The Tribunal's decision was based on the evidence presented, which indicated that Mr Hanley had not acted responsibly or in accordance with safety regulations. The findings of fact, particularly regarding the accident and its aftermath, supported the conclusion that Mr Hanley was not a fit and proper person to hold his licenses. As a result, the Tribunal affirmed the CASA decision to cancel Mr Hanley's licenses and revoke his Instrument of Approval as Chief Flying Instructor. The final orders of the Tribunal were to uphold the CASA decision, ensuring that Mr Hanley's licenses and approval were revoked in line with the determinations made by the court.

Background

Background to the litigation

I am mindful that Ms Price made submissions on behalf of Mr Hanley about the standard of proof to be applied, and the application of what is spoken about as the Briginshaw standard: Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336. I have noted those submissions, mindful that what some consider a Briginshaw standard, said to be higher than the usual balance of probabilities, is applied where a person’s livelihood is in question in determining a matter before a court or tribunal. I am mindful that in this jurisdiction, the Tribunal is bound by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, and must be satisfied on the evidence that the correct or preferable decision is to affirm, vary or set aside the decision of the Respondent: section 43 and Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60. That is the standard to be applied. I am also mindful that the Tribunal, standing in the shoes of the decisionmaker, CASA, is obliged in exercising its powers and performing its functions to regard the safety of air navigation as the most important consideration: section 9A of the Act.BACKGROUND Mr Hanley, who is 49 years of age and was previously a carpenter, stated that he has been a commercial helicopter pilot since 1995. He has held a number of helicopter licences which I have mentioned in the paragraphs above. They were cancelled by CASA on 21 February 2012 following an accident in a helicopter as described above, which occurred on 29 October 2011. Mr Hanley provided a statement, dated 7 March 2012, for the stay hearing held on 8 March 2012. Senior Member Fice of this Tribunal granted a stay of the CASA decision, and the same statement was admitted into evidence at the substantive hearing as Exhibit A1. Mr Hanley did not prepare a further statement, but he elaborated on the matters contained in the statement at the hearing before me. Although Mr Shields, of counsel, who represented CASA, sought to criticise that, I am satisfied that that is acceptable and not unusual. It was not in dispute that Mr Hanley was employed by Apple Helicopters, between December 2010 and February 2012. He was appointed as the Chief Flying Instructor on 25 August 2011. The evidence before me was that Mr Hanley assisted Mr Michael Hope, Managing Director and Secretary of HOPE Estate Events Pty Ltd, a vigneron and a pharmacist, to choose the Bell 206 (VH-AYP) helicopter, which Mr Hope’s company purchased in Townsville in October 2011. Mr Hanley and Mr Hope, who had travelled to Townsville on a commercial flight to take delivery of the helicopter on 12 October 2011, flew the helicopter back to Maitland. Mr Hope stated that between 12 October and 29 October 2011, he recorded 16 flights totalling 24.3 hours flight time in the Bell helicopter in his log book. Mr Hope stated that on 29 October 2011, the Applicant flew on three training flights with him. The last flight was at approximately 4:30 pm and lasted 1.3 hours. Mr Hope said that during the final training flight of the day, Mr Hanley made a spontaneous decision (without having first given a lesson on the ground to Mr Hope), to give a demonstration of an emergency autorotation landing. Mr Hope said that it was on the return journey from Cessnock, and that they were approaching Maitland Airport at about 1200 – 1500 feet when Mr Hanley decided to carry out the autorotation. He stated that: The helicopter hit the ground with great force and came to a shuddering halt near the edge of the runway.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In summary, as noted above, Mr Hanley did not take his reporting obligations as seriously as he should have, and has been in breach of various Civil Aviation Regulations and likely, sections 18(1) and 19 of the Transport Safety Investigation Act 2003. The Tribunal’s conclusions regarding regulation 269(1)(c) As noted above, in considering whether, the Applicant has failed in his duty as the holder of pilot licences and instructor ratings in respect of a matter or matters affecting the safe operation of an aircraft within the meaning of regulation 269(1)(c) of the CAR, I considered the matters under the headings listed below. I am mindful also that issues of credit were very pertinent in this case, and arose under each of the following headings.·what occurred during the helicopter flight on 29 October 2011 when Mr Hanley attempted to demonstrate an autorotation to his student, Mr Hope;·what occurred following the accident, and how the helicopter was returned to the hangar;·who wanted the accident kept quiet, and·reporting of the accident to the relevant authorities. In regard to dot point one, I am satisfied and I have found that Mr Hanley demonstrated an autorotation to Mr Hope during a flight on 29 October 2011 spontaneously, without planning it properly, without first instructing Mr Hope in the classroom, and that Mr Hanley caused the accident due to not correctly completing all the pre-landing checks. As to dot point two, I am satisfied and I have found that Mr Hanley did not give a true account of how he returned the helicopter to the hangar after the accident. I am satisfied and have found that he taxied the severely damaged helicopter back to the hangar with Mr Hope in it, after the accident. As to dot point three; I am satisfied and I have found that it was Mr Hanley who wanted to keep the accident quiet. As to dot point four; I am satisfied and I have found that Mr Hanley did not report the accident to the relevant authorities within the required time frames, and that he did not report the full extent of the damage to each one. Accordingly I find that the Applicant has failed in his duty as the holder of pilot licences and instructor ratings in respect of a matter or matters affecting the safe operation of an aircraft within the meaning of regulation 269(1)(c) of the CAR.WHETHER MR HANLEY IS A FIT AND PROPER PERSON IN REGARD TO HOLDING PILOT LICENCES In coming to a decision in this matter, I am also required to consider the application of regulation 269(1)(d) of the CAR. That entails, having regard to all of the evidence now available, and consideration of whether Mr Hanley is not a fit and proper person to have the responsibilities, and exercise and perform the functions and duties of a holder of authorisations such as his various pilot licences. Regulation 269(1)(d) of the CAR authorises CASA, and accordingly the Tribunal to cancel, vary or suspend a pilot licence if the holder of that licence is not a fit and proper person to have the responsibilities and to exercise and perform the functions and duties of the holder of such a licence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is clear from the statement of Mr McClymont, who informed the Tribunal that he has been a licensed aircraft maintenance engineer for approximately 25 years, that the damage to the helicopter was major damage.WHETHER MR HANLEY HAS FAILED IN HIS DUTY WITH RESPECT TO MATTERS AFFECTING THE SAFE NAVIGATION OR OPERATION OF AN AIRCRAFT In coming to a decision in this matter, I am required to consider the application of regulation 269(1)(c) of the CAR. That entails consideration of whether Mr Hanley, the holder of the authorisation, has failed in his duty with respect to any matter affecting the safe navigation or operation of an aircraft. Regulation 269(1)(c) of the CAR authorises CASA, and accordingly the Tribunal to cancel, vary or suspend a pilot licence if the holder of that licence has failed in his or her duty with respect to any matter affecting the safe operation of an aircraft. The matter arises, of course, in the context of the helicopter accident of 29 October 2011. In order to decide whether Mr Hanley failed in his duties, I considered the matters under the headings listed below, in particular because issues of credit were very pertinent to the decision making, and arise under each:·what occurred during the helicopter flight on 29 October 2011 when Mr Hanley attempted to demonstrate an autorotation to his student, Mr Hope;·what occurred following the accident, and how the helicopter was returned to the hangar;·who wanted the accident kept quiet;·reporting of the accident to the relevant authorities.What occurred during the attempt by Mr Hanley to demonstrate an autorotation I have already stated in the paragraphs above, that on 29 October 2011, towards the end of a lesson he was providing to Mr Hope, Mr Hanley offered to demonstrate an emergency autorotation landing. I am satisfied that it was a spontaneous decision, and that, notwithstanding Mr Hanley’s evidence that he had previously mentioned autorotations to his student, Mr Hope had not received any prior briefing or instruction in the classroom on this procedure, as he should have. Mr Hope said that it was on the return journey from Cessnock, and that they were approaching Maitland Airport at about 1200 – 1500 feet when Mr Hanley decided to carry out the autorotation. He stated that: The helicopter hit the ground with great force and came to a shuddering halt near the edge of the runway. I also noted Mr Hanley’s description of the landing in reply to questioning from Mr Shields:… I never said that I didn’t complete the pre-landing checks. I just said that I thought I mustn’t – I didn’t double-check to confirm I had rolled the throttle to fully open. My belief was that I had but I also had a doubt in my mind that I mustn’t have had because – and the reason I state that was quite clearly because if the RPM – if the rotor RPM light and the horn are activated it simply means that the engine has obviously not been restored to its fully open position. So my assumption, therefore, was based on that the throttle mustn’t have been fully opened. I didn’t say that I didn’t fully open it. My assumption was that I did fully open it but obviously if the rotor RPM light and the horn activated, it meant that then the throttle mustn’t have been fully open. I didn’t mean that I didn’t do the action but I thought perhaps I didn’t do the action.