Hammond Village Operations Pty Ltd v Richard Homans

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION:Hammond Village Operations Pty Ltd v Richard Homans & Ors [2023] QCATA 142

PARTIES: HAMMOND VILLAGE OPERATIONS PTY LTD

(applicant)

v

RICHARD HOMANS & ORS

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:     APL083-23

APPLICATION

ORIGINATING NO:       OCL050-20

MATTER TYPE:             Appeal

DELIVERED ON:           15 November 2023

HEARING DATE:           9 October 2023

HEARD AT:Brisbane

DECISION OF:               Member Matthews KC

ORDERS:1.      Appeal allowed

2.Remit the matter to the Tribunal for the purpose of making such orders as it considers appropriate pursuant to 70A(2) of the Act

3.Stay orders 4 and 5 made by the Tribunal on 23 January 2023 pending the outcome of the remitted hearing

CATCHWORDS:               APPEAL – FRESH EVIDENCVE - STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – MATTER OF LAW NOT RAISED OR NOT CONSIDERED BELOW

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld),
s 142(1), s 142(3)(b)
Manufactured Homes (Residential Parks) Act 2003 (Qld), s 69D, s 70A

APPEARANCES &

REPRESENTATION: 

Applicant:Mr Pitt (solicitor)

Respondent:  Mr Homans as lead respondent

REASONS FOR DECISION

Procedural Background

  1. On 23 January 2023, the Tribunal delivered reasons for decision upon an on the papers hearing of an application by Mr Richard Homans as lead applicant to set aside notices of increase in site rent dated 27 November 2019 given to occupants of the homeowners in a residential park governed by the Manufactured Homes (Residential Parks) Act 2003 (“the Act”).

  1. That decision, by order 4, set aside notices based upon a market review of site rent on the ground of want of consultation pursuant to s69D of the Act. It ordered, by order 5, that Hammond Village Operations Pty Ltd (“Hammon Village”) repay any overpayment of site rent to Mr Homans and four other nominated applicants and such other applicants who received the notices based on market review since any increase in rent had been paid.

  1. Otherwise, the Tribunal confirmed, by order 6, the increase of site rent set out in notices of increase dated 27 November 2019 which notices relied upon a CPI increase in accordance with the formulae in the homeowners’ individual site agreements.

  1. From that decision, Hammond Village has applied for leave to appeal (if necessary) or appeal filed 27 March 2023 (within 28 days of receipt of the written reasons) together with an application to stay orders 4 and 5 of the Tribunal’s decision filed the same date. The stay application was granted. Directions were given by a Senior Member of the Tribunal on 28 March 2023 for procedural steps to occur prior to the application for leave to appeal or appeal being heard.

    Factual Background

  2. At the commencement of the hearing of the application for leave to appeal or appeal, both Mr Pitt and Mr Homans on behalf of the respondents accepted that the matters articulated in the notice of appeal of appeal and Hammond Village’s submissions were a matter of law and that, accordingly, leave to appeal was not required.[1] Those submissions were, in my view, correct.

[1]That concession was in accordance with the written submissions of Hammond Village at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hammond Village Operations Pty Ltd v Richard Homans and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCATA 142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hammond Village Operations Pty Ltd has appealed against a decision of the Tribunal concerning a dispute regarding a rent increase for a market review site. The appeal focuses on whether the Tribunal was required to consider discretionary matters and procedural powers under section 70A of the Act once a finding was made under section 69D. The appeal was allowed, and the matter has been remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration in light of the appeal decision.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the Tribunal was required to engage with section 70A of the Act, which provides a caveat against the fatality of a market review site rent increase in certain discretionary circumstances, and whether the Tribunal should have considered fresh evidence presented by Mr Homans. The parties agreed that the appeal centred on questions of statutory interpretation and procedural fairness. Specifically, the issue was whether the absence of proper notice to the Homeowners Committee, as required by section 69D, mandated the engagement of section 70A, which was not considered by the Tribunal in its original decision.

In addressing these issues, the court found that once a finding was made under section 69D, it was incumbent upon the Tribunal to consider the discretionary matters and procedural powers under section 70A. The court held that the Tribunal’s failure to engage with section 70A was an error of law. Furthermore, the court ruled that Mr Homans could not rely on fresh evidence that was not presented to the Tribunal, as no application had been filed to rely on such material.

The appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration in light of the appeal decision. The Tribunal was directed to make such orders as it considers appropriate pursuant to section 70A(2) of the Act. The stay orders 4 and 5 made by the Tribunal on 23 January 2023 were to remain in place pending the outcome of the remitted hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed

2. Remit the matter to the Tribunal for the purpose of making such orders as it considers appropriate pursuant to 70A(2) of the Act

3. Stay orders 4 and 5 made by the Tribunal on 23 January 2023 pending the outcome of the remitted hearing

Background

Background to the litigation

From that decision, Hammond Village has applied for leave to appeal (if necessary) or appeal filed 27 March 2023 (within 28 days of receipt of the written reasons) together with an application to stay orders 4 and 5 of the Tribunal’s decision filed the same date. The stay application was granted. Directions were given by a Senior Member of the Tribunal on 28 March 2023 for procedural steps to occur prior to the application for leave to appeal or appeal being heard. Factual Background At the commencement of the hearing of the application for leave to appeal or appeal, both Mr Pitt and Mr Homans on behalf of the respondents accepted that the matters articulated in the notice of appeal of appeal and Hammond Village’s submissions were a matter of law and that, accordingly, leave to appeal was not required.[1] Those submissions were, in my view, correct. It was also accepted at the outset of the hearing that neither Hammond Village nor Mr Homans had in any way flagged or made submissions to the Tribunal concerning the engaging of s70A of the Act. Thus, the principal thrust of the appeal was an argument not raised below but, in my opinion, once the statutory threshold of a finding is made under s69D of the Act, it incumbent upon the Tribunal to thereafter consider the discretionary matters and procedural powers under the later section. Mr Homans’ written submissions included reference to further material and fresh evidence of matters subsequent to the relevant time frame. As no application had been filed to rely on such material, I held that Mr Homans could not rely upon that material on the appeal. It was confirmed by Mr Pitt of Hopgood & Ganim appearing for Hammond Village that as appeared in the applicant’s submissions,[2] that Hammond Village did not take issue with the Tribunal’s finding that it did not consult with the Homeowners Committee as required by s69D of the Act[3] and indicating that the issue was whether the consequence of that finding ought to have been the engaging of s70A of the Act which provides a caveat in certain discretionary circumstances against the fatality of a market review site rent increase. [2] At paragraph 5.[3] Those submissions referring to the Tribunal’s reasons for decision at [44]-[45]. It was accepted by both Mr Pitt and Mr Homans that the Tribunal’s decision included an accurate distillation of the background facts. For that reason I adopt those paragraphs[4] of the decision as accurately reflecting the background to the original application and the references to the Act as follows: Hammond Village’s written submissions set out the sections of the Act relevant to this appeal but in light of the concession that there was no challenge to the factual finding of a want of proper notice under s69D, it is not necessary to further consider that section noting, however, that absence of proper notice to the Committee renders it mandatory for the rent rise to be determined as invalid. That is by use of the word “must” as contained in s69D(2) of the Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established