Franklin & Ors v Burleigh Town Village Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read
CITATION: Franklin & Ors v Burleigh Town Village Pty Ltd [2014] QCATA 183
PARTIES: Leslie (Glen) Franklin 
Ronald James Caddell
Gai Hampson
Michael Hampson
Edwin Gunder
Rhelma Gunder
Marlene Barber
Lauri Neibling
David Noice
Kathy Noice
Sandra Hawkins
Douglas Pacholke
Margaret Pacholke
Josephine Saveall
David Rands-Trevor
Hazel Rands-Trevor
Ian Wiltshires
Isabella Wiltshire
Margaret L Farek
Mary Rose Whiffin
Margaret Clark
Cheryl Riley
Russell Staader
Karl Krepela
Marie Brown
Zofia Mazurkiewice
Witold Mazurkiewice
Maureen Randle
Daphne Sellwood
Jan Kollen
Wilma Kollen
Shirley Gailbraith
Brian Peterson
David Nichols
Mihaly Lukacs
Ivan Lukacs
John W F Damon
Rosemary Osborne
Gem Howe
Noela Lucht
Kath Gibson
Ann Hollingsworth
Alan Chauncy
John Warren
Marilyn Warren
Henk Koning
Ursula Koning
Brian McAulliffe
Shirley Houlihan
Millicent Ann Fraser
Judith Ethel Berg
Ernst A A de Vreede
Don Giddens
Sylvia Giddens
Jacoba Lupina de Klerk
Lynne Newport
Allan Arthy
Bette Arthy
Eileen E Smith
Kenneth Smith
Jan Westall
Judy King
Derek Waller
Maureen Waller
Lynette Baker
Barbara Pignatelli
Joseph Pignatelli
Allan Brown
Babette Davidson
Patricia Tierney
Julie Knight
Tony Van Krevel
Elaine Brass
Joan Cross
Marjorie Keepers
Dianne Caddell
Ronald Caddell
John Carthew
Carole McPherson
Ian McPherson
Shirley Bargeman
Beryl Sheedy
Faye Campbell
Anthony C Dodd
Cynthua Margaret Tomkinson
Don Iles
Helen Iles
Maureen Wood
Gregory McKenzie
Valma Spence
Margaret Ahrens
Vivienne Armstrong
Roberta Cava
Dian Buttress-Grove
Valma Briggs
Lynn Bull
Colin Milnes
Marie Milnes
Peter Malcolm Dunning
Sheila Dunning
Tamala Thornley
Evelyn Harper
Gail Deacon
Faye Feldbauer
Alan Dudley Wright
Anita Dawn Hall
Valda McPhee
Fay Towerton
Vladimir Hejduk
Geoffrey Parsons
Ellis Ivor
Shirley Semple
Nancy Kae Wright
Marilyn Williams
Elaine M Lyme
Marie Kathleen Buttenshaw
Diana Bourn
Phil Plews
Marg Plummer
Alan Scown
Valda Scown
Narelle Porthouse
Neville Hunter
Veronica Hunter
Marilyn Roland
John Cummins
Judy Cummins
Maureen Woolsey
Norma Wagland
Gael Patricia George
Sandra Allen
Maria Robel
Garry Scarlett
Susan Scarlett
Lily Randabel
Edith Betty Robertson
Noel Andrew Robertson
Kaye Vawser
Maureen Prosser
Judith Dewar
Ivan Harris
Jewell Harris
Fay Cross
Doreen Koniaras
Elaine Joy Laughlin
Joan Hall
John Hall
Phyllis Ahearn
Noelene Kay Sayer
Elisa Kaiser
Heinz Kaiser
Richard James Foulkes
Colleen Hardwick
Rachel Guarnieri
John Gillett
Pam Gillett
Frederick Jones
Susan Jones
Crystal O’Loan
Iris Shephard
Jan Collis
Neil Collis
Barry Gadsden
Norma Gadsden
Beverley Knight
Robyn Diane Phillips
Kathleen E Newman
T Soellaart
Claire Riera
Alex Kosorukson
Winsome Oost
Trevor Bartholomew
Hyacinth Davis
Francis Happ
Elsie Burnell
T E Syred
Diane Menso
B Sheehan
Lynn Smith
Norman Smith
Greg Smith
Marion Jones
Alan Moore
Jeanette Moore
Kevin McGarry
Lois McGarry
Frances Keyte
Ken Keyte
Jean Ann Moss
Yvonne Fitzgerald
Francis Fullerton
Valmae Fullerton
Edward Dyson
Verna Dyson
Leonie Barker
Deborah Landers
John Landers
Sharon Leabourne
Warwick Leabourne
Helen Watt
Roger Gathercole
Margery Gathercole
M Cooper
Ken Whiteman
Roseann Whiteman
Carol Whelan
William Mullen
Gladys Mullen
Beverley Elliott
William Elliott
David Melrose
Marie Melrose
Penny Carthew
Jack Gilbert
Janice Browett
Rita Worboys
Annette Gulliver
Norman Gulliver
Norma Forlonge
Delma J Bourke
Helen Gately
John Townsley
Elaine Arch-Rowe
Peter Arch-Rowe
Barry Hughes
Dianne Hughes
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Franklin & Ors v Burleigh Town Village Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QCATA 183
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Franklin & Ors v Burleigh Town Village Pty Ltd, the applicants, residents of a manufactured home park, appealed against the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal's (QCAT) decision regarding a site rent increase and the tribunal's refusal to allow additional applicants to join the proceedings. The court was required to determine whether the tribunal erred in its consideration of the evidence and whether it was appropriate to allow additional applicants to join the appeal.

The applicants argued that the tribunal ignored their evidence and accepted only the evidence of the respondent. The court noted that the tribunal Member considered all the evidence before him, including the valuer’s report, and gave it greater weight than the non-expert opinions of the homeowners. The tribunal also considered the difficult financial position in which the increased site rent placed homeowners, and the impact on their livelihood. The court concluded that the tribunal adequately articulated its reasons and considered the evidence as provided before it. Regarding the refusal to allow additional applicants to join the proceedings, the court found that the tribunal was correct in dismissing the application, as there was no explanation for the delay, and the prescribed time for filing the application had expired.

The appeal was dismissed for persons not entitled to be appellants, and an extension of time was granted for the proper appellants to file their application for leave to appeal and appeal. The appeal was allowed in respect of the identification of the original applicants, but leave to appeal was refused in relation to the grounds of appeal that did not relate to errors of law. The orders of 12 December 2012 were otherwise confirmed.

The final orders included dismissing the appeal for persons not entitled to be appellants, granting an extension of time for the proper appellants to file their application for leave to appeal and appeal, allowing the appeal in respect of the identification of the original applicants, refusing leave to appeal in relation to the grounds of appeal that did not relate to errors of law, and dismissing the appeal in respect of all other identified grounds of appeal. The orders of 12 December 2012 were confirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In respect of the persons named in Annexure B(3) attached, the application for leave to appeal and appeal is dismissed.

2. An extension of time is granted for the appellants named in Annexures B(1) (original applicants in OCL083-11 who are parties to the application for leave to appeal and appeal) and B(2) (applicants for joinder in OCL083-11 who are parties to the application for leave to appeal and appeal) to file their application for leave to appeal and appeal by 30 January 2013.

3. The appeal is allowed in respect of order 1 of the tribunal’s orders of 12 December 2012 as follows:

(i) Order 1 of 12 December 2012 is set aside in respect of all original applicants named in Annexure A(1);

(ii) It is declared that all original applicants named in Annexure A(1) were properly parties to the application pursuant to s 141 of the Manufactured Homes (Residential Parks) Act 2003 (Qld).

4. Leave to appeal is refused in relation to the grounds of appeal specified by the appellants in their application which do not relate to errors of law.

5. The appeal is otherwise dismissed and the orders of 12 December 2012 confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ground of appeal: The Member ignored the evidence of the applicants and accepted only the evidence of the respondent Although it is not entirely clear, the submissions suggest that the complaint made is largely that the tribunal accepted the valuer’s report over the assertions of the homeowners about comparable parks and locality; accepted Mr Beck’s evidence about increased costs to the park owner; and did not consider the difficult financial position in which the increased site rent placed home owners, and the impact on their livelihood. As part of reaching his decision, the learned Member was required to consider all of the material or evidence before him, and then form and articulate conclusions. The Member discussed the evidence. He explained that he gave less weight to the valuer’s report because it referred to the previous s 70(3) factors. However, he also made it clear that he gave it greater weight than the non-expert opinions of the homeowners about comparable parks. He adequately articulated his acceptance of the evidence about increased costs and rejects the home owners expressed concerns that site rent was subsidising other parts of the business.[56] [56]Reasons for decision, [57]. The joint applicants did not present specific evidence that any home owner/s could not afford the increase. Rather, what was provided was in the nature of general assertions to the effect that other items had also increased in cost, and that this site rent increase would make it difficult for pensioner home owners to manage. The tribunal said that it could only take into account the circumstances of Franklin and Caddell.[57] In light of our findings about the joint applicants, this was incorrect. It observed that Mr Franklin entered the park in 2010 with full knowledge of the site fees. That said, in paragraph [61], the tribunal discussed the applicants’ arguments about the impact of the financial burden and resultant hardship for residents. Therefore, the learned Member did consider the broader arguments as far as there was material about it before him.[57]Reasons for decision [59] – [60]. Further, the learned Member made it clear that he considered it significant that 14 new entrants, including 12 pensioners, had bought into the village since July 2011,[58] and that 47 residents were on a 5% agreement.[59] He observed that the site rent increase was ‘just above’ the amount assessed by Mr Hamilton as market rent.[60] It is in fact $2.10 per week over Mr Hamilton’s assessment of $162.50. Having regard to these and other matters he concluded that the increase was fair and reasonable.[58]Reasons for decision at [61]. [59]Reasons for decision at [65]. [60]Reasons for decision at [66]. We are of the view that the reasons are sufficiently clear and adequate to explain his conclusions. Although he says at some point that he can only consider the circumstances of Mr Franklin and Mr Caddell, he did go on to consider the evidence, as far as it was provided about the issue, about the broader position of residents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ground of appeal: The Member made an unprovoked personal attack upon the character of Mr Franklin in his decision which was false in every respect The submissions of the home owners, although alleging an attempt to ‘isolate Mr Franklin and teach him a lesson’, do not particularise the ‘unprovoked personal attack’ said to have been made. The park owner, in its submissions, points out that it can not identify what the home owners refer to. Despite providing submissions in reply to the park owner’s submissions, the home owners do not articulate what is said to be the ‘attack.’ We can not identify any personal attack on Mr Franklin in the reasons. In any event, the ground, which could only refer to an alleged mistake of fact, identifies no error by the tribunal, and we would refuse leave to appeal. In summary, orders are made dismissing the appeal as far as it is made by persons not entitled to be appellants; granting an extension of time to file the application for leave to appeal and appeal as far as the proper appellants as determined by us are concerned; allowing the appeal in respect of the identification of the original applicants; refusing leave to appeal the application for joinder by the joinder applicants; and otherwise refusing leave to appeal (where required); and dismissing the appeal in respect of all other identified grounds of appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established