| CITATION: | Franklin & Ors v Burleigh Town Village Pty Ltd [2014] QCATA 183 |
| PARTIES: | Leslie (Glen) Franklin Ronald James Caddell Gai Hampson Michael Hampson Edwin Gunder Rhelma Gunder Marlene Barber Lauri Neibling David Noice Kathy Noice Sandra Hawkins Douglas Pacholke Margaret Pacholke Josephine Saveall David Rands-Trevor Hazel Rands-Trevor Ian Wiltshires Isabella Wiltshire Margaret L Farek Mary Rose Whiffin Margaret Clark Cheryl Riley Russell Staader Karl Krepela Marie Brown Zofia Mazurkiewice Witold Mazurkiewice Maureen Randle Daphne Sellwood Jan Kollen Wilma Kollen Shirley Gailbraith Brian Peterson David Nichols Mihaly Lukacs Ivan Lukacs John W F Damon Rosemary Osborne Gem Howe Noela Lucht Kath Gibson Ann Hollingsworth Alan Chauncy John Warren Marilyn Warren Henk Koning Ursula Koning Brian McAulliffe Shirley Houlihan Millicent Ann Fraser Judith Ethel Berg Ernst A A de Vreede Don Giddens Sylvia Giddens Jacoba Lupina de Klerk Lynne Newport Allan Arthy Bette Arthy Eileen E Smith Kenneth Smith Jan Westall Judy King Derek Waller Maureen Waller Lynette Baker Barbara Pignatelli Joseph Pignatelli Allan Brown Babette Davidson Patricia Tierney Julie Knight Tony Van Krevel Elaine Brass Joan Cross Marjorie Keepers Dianne Caddell Ronald Caddell John Carthew Carole McPherson Ian McPherson Shirley Bargeman Beryl Sheedy Faye Campbell Anthony C Dodd Cynthua Margaret Tomkinson Don Iles Helen Iles Maureen Wood Gregory McKenzie Valma Spence Margaret Ahrens Vivienne Armstrong Roberta Cava Dian Buttress-Grove Valma Briggs Lynn Bull Colin Milnes Marie Milnes Peter Malcolm Dunning Sheila Dunning Tamala Thornley Evelyn Harper Gail Deacon Faye Feldbauer Alan Dudley Wright Anita Dawn Hall Valda McPhee Fay Towerton Vladimir Hejduk Geoffrey Parsons Ellis Ivor Shirley Semple Nancy Kae Wright Marilyn Williams Elaine M Lyme Marie Kathleen Buttenshaw Diana Bourn Phil Plews Marg Plummer Alan Scown Valda Scown Narelle Porthouse Neville Hunter Veronica Hunter Marilyn Roland John Cummins Judy Cummins Maureen Woolsey Norma Wagland Gael Patricia George Sandra Allen Maria Robel Garry Scarlett Susan Scarlett Lily Randabel Edith Betty Robertson Noel Andrew Robertson Kaye Vawser Maureen Prosser Judith Dewar Ivan Harris Jewell Harris Fay Cross Doreen Koniaras Elaine Joy Laughlin Joan Hall John Hall Phyllis Ahearn Noelene Kay Sayer Elisa Kaiser Heinz Kaiser Richard James Foulkes Colleen Hardwick Rachel Guarnieri John Gillett Pam Gillett Frederick Jones Susan Jones Crystal O’Loan Iris Shephard Jan Collis Neil Collis Barry Gadsden Norma Gadsden Beverley Knight Robyn Diane Phillips Kathleen E Newman T Soellaart Claire Riera Alex Kosorukson Winsome Oost Trevor Bartholomew Hyacinth Davis Francis Happ Elsie Burnell T E Syred Diane Menso B Sheehan Lynn Smith Norman Smith Greg Smith Marion Jones Alan Moore Jeanette Moore Kevin McGarry Lois McGarry Frances Keyte Ken Keyte Jean Ann Moss Yvonne Fitzgerald Francis Fullerton Valmae Fullerton Edward Dyson Verna Dyson Leonie Barker Deborah Landers John Landers Sharon Leabourne Warwick Leabourne Helen Watt Roger Gathercole Margery Gathercole M Cooper Ken Whiteman Roseann Whiteman Carol Whelan William Mullen Gladys Mullen Beverley Elliott William Elliott David Melrose Marie Melrose Penny Carthew Jack Gilbert Janice Browett Rita Worboys Annette Gulliver Norman Gulliver Norma Forlonge Delma J Bourke Helen Gately John Townsley Elaine Arch-Rowe Peter Arch-Rowe Barry Hughes Dianne Hughes |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Franklin & Ors v Burleigh Town Village Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] QCATA 183
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The applicants argued that the tribunal ignored their evidence and accepted only the evidence of the respondent. The court noted that the tribunal Member considered all the evidence before him, including the valuer’s report, and gave it greater weight than the non-expert opinions of the homeowners. The tribunal also considered the difficult financial position in which the increased site rent placed homeowners, and the impact on their livelihood. The court concluded that the tribunal adequately articulated its reasons and considered the evidence as provided before it. Regarding the refusal to allow additional applicants to join the proceedings, the court found that the tribunal was correct in dismissing the application, as there was no explanation for the delay, and the prescribed time for filing the application had expired.
The appeal was dismissed for persons not entitled to be appellants, and an extension of time was granted for the proper appellants to file their application for leave to appeal and appeal. The appeal was allowed in respect of the identification of the original applicants, but leave to appeal was refused in relation to the grounds of appeal that did not relate to errors of law. The orders of 12 December 2012 were otherwise confirmed.
The final orders included dismissing the appeal for persons not entitled to be appellants, granting an extension of time for the proper appellants to file their application for leave to appeal and appeal, allowing the appeal in respect of the identification of the original applicants, refusing leave to appeal in relation to the grounds of appeal that did not relate to errors of law, and dismissing the appeal in respect of all other identified grounds of appeal. The orders of 12 December 2012 were confirmed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. In respect of the persons named in Annexure B(3) attached, the application for leave to appeal and appeal is dismissed.
2. An extension of time is granted for the appellants named in Annexures B(1) (original applicants in OCL083-11 who are parties to the application for leave to appeal and appeal) and B(2) (applicants for joinder in OCL083-11 who are parties to the application for leave to appeal and appeal) to file their application for leave to appeal and appeal by 30 January 2013.
3. The appeal is allowed in respect of order 1 of the tribunal’s orders of 12 December 2012 as follows:
(i) Order 1 of 12 December 2012 is set aside in respect of all original applicants named in Annexure A(1);
(ii) It is declared that all original applicants named in Annexure A(1) were properly parties to the application pursuant to s 141 of the Manufactured Homes (Residential Parks) Act 2003 (Qld).
4. Leave to appeal is refused in relation to the grounds of appeal specified by the appellants in their application which do not relate to errors of law.
5. The appeal is otherwise dismissed and the orders of 12 December 2012 confirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi