Hamilton-Smith v George No. DCCIV-03-1444

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

Hamilton-Smith v George

[2003] SADC 157

Judge Herriman

Minor Civil Review

  1. This matter has had a somewhat unusual history and, in all the circumstances, it is appropriate that I describe it:

    (1)Nov./Dec. 2000 – the respondent asserts that she loaned the applicant the sum of $5,000, repayable in three weeks’ time, to enable the applicant “to pay out the loan for a blue Ford Probe”.  The applicant denies negotiating or receiving that loan, but says a financial arrangement was concluded between the respondent and the applicant’s former husband, Donald Osborne (“Osborne”).

    (2)12.1.01 – the applicant hands $1,000 to the respondent in part‑repayment of loan.  This payment is not denied by the applicant, but she says it was paid by her at the direction and on behalf of the borrower, Osborne, and from a company cheque book.

    (3)12.11.02 – the respondent issues the summons in this action seeking recovery from the applicant of $4,329.80, being the balance she says is due on the loan, with interest and costs.

    (4)4.12.02 – the applicant files a defence, denying she was a party to the loan.

    (5)4.2.03 – a directions hearing takes place in the matter in Mount Barker Magistrates Court.  The respondent says that during the course of mediation, the applicant walked out of court, that the court officer was asked to bring her back, that there was a scene of some kind and she was brought back.  For her part, the applicant says that the hearing had finished and that she was leaving when she was confronted out the front of the courthouse by a man who appeared to be a sheriff’s officer and who committed upon her “a very serious assault which lasted about five minutes”.  She said the assault was witnessed by the magistrate, who did not intervene.  As a result of it, she says, she suffered injuries, including cuts and bruises to her arms, throat and ankle, and was obliged to seek medical attention for her physical and mental injuries. 

    An order is later made transferring the hearing of the matter to Adelaide Magistrates Court and it is listed there on 17 June 2003.

    (6)13.6.03 – a specially returnable application is filed by the applicant to vacate the trial date of 17 June 2003 and fix a directions hearing for October 2003.  The application is supported by an affidavit of the applicant’s solicitor, Mr Viscariello, which asserts that the applicant is unable to attend at the trial and that she continues to receive medical treatment in consequence of the alleged assault, and it exhibits a report of a consulting psychologist, Dr Cayley, of 3 June 2003, who expresses the opinion that “Ms. Hamilton‑Smith is not well enough to attend court at this time”.  The report does not say when Ms Hamilton‑Smith might be able to attend.

    The application is heard that day, but the presiding magistrate is not satisfied that the application has been served on the respondent, the application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hamilton-Smith v George No. DCCIV-03-1444 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 157
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter concerns a dispute between the applicant, Tanya Hamilton-Smith, and the respondent, Heidi George, over a loan of $5,000. George claims that she lent the money to Hamilton-Smith, who repaid $1,000 before defaulting on the balance. Hamilton-Smith denies the loan and the subsequent repayment. The matter proceeded through the Magistrates Court, where the magistrate found in favour of George. Hamilton-Smith appealed to the District Court. The court was required to decide whether the magistrate erred in his procedural handling of the case, whether he erred in admitting certain evidence, and whether he properly assessed the credibility of the witnesses and evidence.

The court found that the magistrate was entitled to proceed with the hearing in the absence of Hamilton-Smith and to call and examine witnesses, consistent with the statutory regime for minor civil claims. The court found that the magistrate did not err in taking unsworn evidence from Osborne by telephone, as Osborne had provided his version of events in an affidavit and was not brought to court by either party. The court also found that the magistrate did not err in admitting a letter purportedly written by Osborne, as the applicant did not bring Osborne to court to deny or explain it, but instead sought to rely upon his affidavit. The court was satisfied that the magistrate properly assessed the credibility of the witnesses and evidence, particularly in light of Osborne's contradictory statements in his affidavit and during the telephone conversation.

The application to review the magistrate’s decision was refused, and the decision was affirmed.