FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE - CHILD WELFARE UNDER STATE OR TERRITORY JURISDICTION AND LEGISLATION - CHILDREN IN NEED OF PROTECTION - PROCEEDINGS RELATING TO CARE AND PROTECTION
FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE - CHILD WELFARE UNDER STATE OR TERRITORY JURISDICTION AND LEGISLATION - CUSTODY - APPEALS
Following an application by the Minister for Education and Child Development pursuant to sections 37 and 38, a trial was listed in the Youth Court to determine whether care and protection orders with respect to the two very young children of the appellant father should be made. These included orders placing each child under the guardianship of the Minister and orders in relation to parental access with the children. After the trial commenced, the appellant expressed a wish to take no further part in the trial and removed himself. The mother (the second respondent) and her counsel remained present. Following the appellant’s departure, final orders in terms that differed, in part, from those sought in the application were made by consent of all parties present including an order that the appellant refrain from having any contact at all with the children. The appellant has appealed against all of the orders made.
Held:
1. There has been no error on the part of the Magistrate that could be said to have given rise to a miscarriage of justice.
H, JR v DEPARTMENT FOR CHILD PROTECTION & ANOR [2017] SASC 121
Youth Court Appeal
NICHOLSON J.
Introduction
JH (the appellant) has appealed against care and protection orders with respect to his two children made by a Magistrate, sitting in the Youth Court of South Australia, on 24 January 2017.
On 26 October 2016, the Minister for Education and Child Development (the Minister and first respondent to the appeal and the Department, respectively) instituted a care and protection application pursuant to sections 37 and 38 of the Children’s Protection Act 1993 (the Act). Orders to the effect that the two children, LH (a male child, approximately 18 months old as at the time of the application) and EH (a female…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read H, JR v Department for Child Protection & Anor and more:
The case of H, JR v Department for Child Protection & Anor involves the appellant, H, JR, who is challenging the decisions made by the Magistrate in the Youth Court regarding the welfare of his children. The primary concern revolves around the Magistrate's decision to grant long-term Guardianship Orders for his children, which was upheld by the Family Court. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the appellant sought to set aside the Magistrate's decision.
The legal issues before the court centered on whether the Magistrate's decision to impose a refraining order was appropriate and whether there was any procedural unfairness that resulted in a miscarriage of justice. The court had to determine if the Magistrate's decision was justified based on the evidence and submissions presented, and whether the appellant's rights were adequately considered in the proceedings.
The court found that the Magistrate's decision was well-founded, given the extensive evidence of the father's volatile behavior, criminal history, mental health issues, and lack of engagement with child protection services. The court was satisfied that the Minister's case was overwhelming and that the Guardianship Orders were necessary to ensure the safety and wellbeing of the children. The court also concluded that any procedural unfairness did not result in a miscarriage of justice, as the appellant's attitude and approach to the trial would not have changed even if the refraining order had been included in the application. The court dismissed the appeal, noting that the Youth Court remained the most appropriate forum for any future proceedings regarding the children's welfare.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Section 45(1) of the Act provides that in any proceedings under the Act, the court is not bound by the rules of evidence, may inform itself as it thinks fit and must act according to equity, good conscience and the substantial merits of the case without regard to technicalities and legal forms.The factual background to the application as alleged by the Minister The particulars of the factual allegations in support of the grounds of the Minister’s application and as set out in the application are as follows:• The child, [LH], was removed from the care of his parents at birth due to concerns relating to the father’s volatile behaviour, criminal offending, history of substance misuse and unstable mental health; and concerns around the impact of the mother’s intellectual functioning upon her parenting capacity and her unstable mental health.• Following her birth, the child, [EH], was subject to an Investigation and Assessment (Custody) Order, however [EH] was placed with the mother, at the maternal grandmother’s house. A subsequent Supervision Order was granted, requiring the mother to sign Undertakings to ensure [EH’s] safety. The mother has since breached a number of these Undertakings.• The father’s eldest daughter [B] was removed from the care of the father and her mother [AH] and placed under long term Orders in 2005. The concerns were related to neglect, emotional and physical abuse, substance misuse and exposure to significant domestic violence between the parents.• The father has a significant criminal history, namely for offences of violence. Such offences, include threatening to kill both a local Member of Parliament and a Families SA worker. The father has spent significant periods of time in prison as a result of his offending.• The father has a significant and long-standing history of mental illness, with a diagnosis of Bipolar Disorder and at times presents with psychotic symptoms. The father’s mental health issues impact significantly upon his ability to provide a safe and stable environment for the children. The father has been hospitalised on multiple occasions as a result of his unstable mental health. The father is adamant that authorities and Government departments are conspiring against him. • Whilst the father was detained at James Nash House in 2006, his former wife [AH] passed away due to post seizure complications connected to her diagnosis of Lennox Gestaut Syndrome, which is an incurable severe form of Epilepsy. The father believes his arrests and past Court interventions are a conspiracy to cover up mistakes made by medical practitioners in relation to the death of [AH] and of his second child [A] .• The father has not been able to demonstrate any meaningful engagement with the Department or other involved services and further, has been hostile, threatening and verbally aggressive towards Families SA workers.• The father has been unable to demonstrate an awareness of the impact and associated risks of his volatile behaviour on a child.• The father’s previous relationship with his first wife [AH] was characterised by domestic violence perpetrated by the father, to which violence the child [B] was exposed. The father has subsequently displayed controlling behaviour toward the mother, [JD-P], hence Families SA hold concerns about the safety of the mother and the children in the presence of the father.• The father has demonstrated an inability to relate appropriately to a child, or to understand a child’s developmental needs. For example, the father has expressed a strong desire for [LH] to be exposed to punk heavy metal music, as opposed to The Wiggles.• The father has a past history of illicit substance misuse. The father has self-reported that he frequently exposed his eldest daughter [B] to a high level of Marijuana in the family home environment, whilst she was a toddler.• The mother has an intellectual disability, which causes delays in processing and retaining information and which subsequently impacts upon her parenting capacity. Families SA consider that the mother, of her own accord, is unable to effectively meet the needs of either of her young children and has been observed to lack understanding of a child’s cues and needs, thus is unable to respond accurately.• The mother has been diagnosed with Epilepsy. Families SA are unsure whether the mother could relapse in times of high stress and are subsequently unsure about whether the mother’s Epilepsy places a risk to the children if alone in her care.• The mother has long standing mental health issues, including suicide ideation, anxiety, depression and anxiety, which impact upon her ability to provide safe and stable care for the children. In 2015 the mother claimed she has multiple (8) personalities, including a 150 year old vampire and a 12 year old girl.• The mother has demonstrated an inability to prioritise the needs of the children above her relationship with the father. The mother continuously denies that the father’s offensive behaviours are an issue. Families SA do not consider that the mother has the requisite protective capacity in order to protect the children from the father’s volatile behaviour and impact of same.• The mother has not been able to demonstrate any meaningful engagement with the Department or other involved services and further, has been hostile and verbally aggressive toward Families SA workers.• The child, [LH], has exhibited concerning responses towards the mother’s presence during access, despite having had regular and frequent access visits with the mother since the time of his birth.• Families SA do not consider that the mother, nor the maternal grandmother [RP] possess the requisite protective capacity to effectively protect the children from the father’s volatile behaviours.• In 2001, Families SA received information that the mother had disclosed that she had been sexually abused by her maternal grandfather at the age of 6 years. The maternal grandmother [RP] refused to allow the mother to be interviewed by Child Protection Services to confirm these allegations. Concerns were subsequently raised that [RP] may not be protective of her daughter.• Families SA consider that a long-term Guardianship Order is necessary and in the best interests of both children, in order to ensure their ongoing safety and wellbeing, and to enable them to reach their full potential.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
NICHOLSON J
I have given anxious consideration to whether or not the refraining order should be set aside on this basis. In my view, it would be inappropriate to do so. The Minister’s case before the Magistrate, considered on a prima facie basis, was quite overwhelming. Further, having considered the material tendered by the Minister in exhibit M2, the transcript of the exchanges between the appellant and the Magistrate, the written submissions in their various forms provided by the appellant on appeal, as to their content and as to their tone insofar as the latter can be discerned from the written word[15] and the appellant’s presentation before me during the appeal, I am satisfied that the case for a refraining order was overwhelming. I am also satisfied that had the order been included in the application it would have made absolutely no difference to the appellant’s attitude and approach to the trial. In other words, I am not satisfied that, to the extent that there may have been an element of procedural unfairness in this respect, such has resulted in any miscarriage of justice. [15] I agree with the first respondent’s submission that the appellant’s summary of argument is “incongruent, illogical, largely contains irrelevant material and is threatening and inappropriate”.Conclusion I am satisfied that there has been no error on the part of the Magistrate such as could be said to have given rise to a miscarriage of justice in this matter. I dismiss the appeal. In doing so, I am fortified by the fact that pursuant to section 40 of the Act, an order made by the Court under Part 5, Division 2 of the Act (which includes section 38) may be varied or revoked at any time on application by a party to the proceedings. Because of the manner by which this matter proceeded in the Youth Court, there has been no complete exploration on the merits. There has not been a trial during which the appellant has presented his case. The Youth Court is a specialist court and the most appropriate forum for such a trial to be conducted. It is undesirable that any such trial should take place in this Court through the appellant process. It is always open to the appellant to bring an application in the Youth Court pursuant to section 40 seeking revocation or variation of any of the orders that have been made and, through such a process, to have the opportunity to present his case.